S.U Khan, J.:— Heard learned Counsel for the parties.
2. It is very fortunate that the landlord has not been impleaded in this writ petition.
3. Petitioner is sitting tenant and the only contesting respondent i.e Radhey Shyam Agarwal, respondent No. 3, is the allottee. Possession is still with the petitioner by virtue of the interim order passed by this Court.
4. Property in dispute consists of three rooms on second floor and two tin sheds on 3rd floor forming part of House No. CK-37/8 Mohalla Kotwalpura, Varanasi. The property belongs to a trust known as “Satya Narain Trust”. Local manager of the Trust at the relevant time was Shiv Kumar. Learned Counsel for the petitioner states that respondent No. 3 himself is tenant of ground floor as well as first floor of the same building. This fact is not denied by learned Counsel for respondent No. 3. Proceedings started on the application of respondent No. 3 for allotment. Rent Control and Eviction Officer, Varanasi through order dated 24.5.1978, copy of which is Annexure ‘F’ to the counter affidavit, declared the accommodation in dispute to be vacant holding that initially it was in the tenancy occupation of one Pooran Mal and after July, 1976 it was occupied by petitioner Ram Autar Sharma, hence legally the building was vacant. It has also been mentioned therein that the Manager of the Trust Sheo Kumar filed affidavit stating that recently it had come to his knowledge that Pooran Mal was sub let the accommodation to Gauri Shanker Sharma, father of the petitioner. Thereafter Rent Control and Eviction Officer/City Magistrate, Varanasi through order dated 31.3.1982 passed in Case No. 251 of 1976 allotted the building in dispute to respondent No. 3. Against the order of allotment dated 31.3.1982 petitioner filed Civil Revision No. 147 of 1982, which was dismissed by First Additional District Judge, Varanasi through order dated 17.8.1983, hence this writ petition.
5. It appears that the petitioner had applied for regularization of his tenancy under section 14 of the Act on the basis of application filed by Jag Mohan Bagla, one of the trustees, copy of which its Annexure ‘5’ to the writ petition.
6. The only ground of allotment in favour of respondent No. 3 was that apart from him no other applicant for allotment was appearing for several dates in the case.
7. Sri Jag Mohan Balga in his application had stated that he was nominating the petitioner for allotment. Absolutely nothing was said by Rent Control and Eviction Officer for ignoring the said nomination. Learned Counsel for the respondent has argued that Sri Bagla resided at Calcutta hence his nomination was of not much value. The right of nomination, which may be exercised by the landlord in certain circumstances does not depend upon the fact of residence of the landlord. Whether the landlord resides in the same city, where the building in dispute is situate or in some other city, the right to nominate remains there.
8. Learned Counsel for the respondent has further argued that the nomination was beyond time. Even if this argument is correct, the nomination could not be binding upon the Rent Control and Eviction Officer, still it should have been given due consideration. Moreover, Rent Control and Eviction Officer did not at all consider that respondent No. 3 was already residing in part of the accommodation in dispute and nothing was stated by him regarding his need for additional accommodation. In the allotment order even rent was not fixed. By virtue of Section 16(9) of U.P Act No. 13 of 1972 it is absolutely essential to fix the rent otherwise allotment order will be void ab initio. By virtue of section 105 Transfer of Property Act there cannot be any lease/tenancy without rent.
9. It has been held by the Supreme Court in R.K Parashar v. Dinesh Kumar . 2000 39 ALR 248., that a tenant inducted by landlord after July, 1976 without allotment order may be allotted the tenanted building. The application of regularization of tenancy filed by petitioner/tenant may very well be taken as allotment application. The application of landlord/trustee giving his choice of allotment to the petitioner fully proves that petitioner is tenant with consent of landlord, hence building may be allotted to him.
10. Accordingly writ petition is allowed. Impugned orders are set aside. Building in dispute stands allotted in favour of the petitioner on a monthly rent of Rs. 1,200/- payable with effect from January, 2007 onward. The current rent of the building in question may not be less than Rs. 2,000/- to 3,000/- per month.
Petition Allowed.