Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged the order dated 28.11.2003 passed by the first Additional Sessions Judge, Kannod, District Dewas, which upheld the conviction of the accused Raees Khan under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959. The accused was sentenced to one year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 200/-. The incident occurred on 15.1.1985 at around 15:20 p.m. at the bus stand Khategaon, where the accused was found in possession of a spring knife and a 12 bore country made revolver (katta) without a licence, violating section 25 of the Arms Act and a State Government notification. The investigation was conducted by the Thana Incharge Shri S.N. Pandey, who recovered the weapons in the presence of panch witnesses. The accused denied the charges, claiming false implication and challenged the legality of the seizure and sanction obtained for prosecution. The trial court convicted the accused, and the appellate court upheld the conviction, leading to this revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the seizure and recovery of the arms and weapons were conducted in accordance with the provisions of the Arms Act, particularly whether the sanction of the District Magistrate under section 39 of the Arms Act was validly obtained.
  2. Whether the conviction under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act is sustainable in the absence of proper sanction and lawful recovery procedures.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The seizure and recovery of the weapons were not in accordance with the Arms Act.
  • The sanction from the District Magistrate under section 39 of the Arms Act was not properly obtained as the weapons were not produced before the Magistrate for inspection.
  • Reliance on precedent cases such as Raju Dube v. State of M.P and Prabhudayal Ahirwar v. State of M.P to argue that sanction must be obtained after the Magistrate inspects the weapons and applies his mind, which was not done here.
  • The accused was falsely implicated and independent witnesses did not support the prosecution.
  • The accused could not be convicted under section 25/21 of the Arms Act due to procedural irregularities.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The offence was proved as witnesses, although declared hostile, admitted their signatures on the recovery memo.
  • Testimonies of P.W 5 (Sub-Inspector Shivnarayan) and P.W 6 (Balmukund Joshi) corroborated that sanction was properly obtained from the District Magistrate.
  • There was a presumption that the weapon was duly sealed and sent for examination under the law.
  • The minimum sentence was imposed, and there was no need for interference with the orders of the lower courts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Raju Dube v. State of M.P, 1998 (1) JLJ 236 Sanction under section 39 of the Arms Act must be obtained after the weapon is produced before and inspected by the District Magistrate; mere signature examination is insufficient. The court relied on this precedent to question the validity of sanction obtained without producing the weapon before the Magistrate.
Prabhudayal Ahirwar v. State of M.P, 2002 Cr LR (MP) 192 Sanction under section 39 is invalid if District Magistrate grants it without inspecting the weapon and applying his mind. The court referred to this case to emphasize the necessity of proper sanction and set aside conviction where sanction was improperly obtained.
Chunta S/o Kishori Lai v. State of M.P, 1999 Cr LJ 80 (MP) Sanction under section 39 is invalid if the weapon was not produced before the District Magistrate and sanction was granted routinely without application of mind. The court used this precedent to support the argument that the sanction in the present case was not valid.
Bapu v. State of M.P, 2005 MPW Vol. 1, 84 Sanction under section 39 not properly proved if there is no evidence that the weapon was sealed on the spot or produced before the District Magistrate; creates doubt about seizure. The court found this precedent identical in circumstances and relied on it to conclude that sanction was not validly obtained in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined whether the sanction under section 39 of the Arms Act was validly obtained. Although the sanction order from the District Magistrate was on record, the court found no evidence that the weapon was produced before the Magistrate for inspection at the time of sanction. Reliance was placed on precedents which established that proper sanction requires the Magistrate to apply his mind after inspecting the weapon. The court noted testimony indicating the weapon was not sent to the Magistrate along with the case records, and that the weapon was incapable of firing, raising doubts about the seizure. The court further observed that neither the investigating officer nor the prosecution proved that the weapon was produced before the Magistrate, rendering the sanction defective. Consequently, the conviction under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act was found unsustainable due to the invalid sanction and procedural lapses.

Holding and Implications

Petition Allowed.

The court set aside the conviction and sentence imposed on the accused under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act and acquitted him of the charge. The petitioner’s bail and surety bonds were discharged. No broader precedent was established beyond the direct effect of acquitting the accused due to the defective sanction under section 39 of the Arms Act and procedural irregularities in the seizure and prosecution process.

    Raees Khan v. State Of Madhya Pradesh

    Mrs. S.R Waghmare, J.:— Shri Zishan Ali, learned Counsel for the petitioner.

    2. Shri G.S Chauhan, Government Advocate for the respondent/State. By this present petition, the petitioner has challenged the order dated 28.11.2003 passed by the first Additional Sessions Judge, Kannod, District Dewas in Criminal Appeal No. 071/2001 upholding the conviction of the accused Raees Khan for offence under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959 and sentencing him to one year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 200/-.

    3. The brief facts of the necessary for the elucidation of the controversy are that on the date of incident dated 15.1.1985 at around 15.20 p.m at bus stand Khategaon the accused was found in possession of a spring knife and a 12 bore country made revolver (katta) without having a licence in contravention to the section 25 of the Aims Act as well as the notification of the State Government bearing No. 631/6552-II-D and (I) dated 12.11.1974 The offence was registered under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act; he stated to have purchased the said gun from Ram Vijayavargyia for Rs. 450/- from Sarangpur. The entire investigation was carried out by Thana Incharge Shri S.N Pandey on receiving information from an informant. The Thana Incharge has stated that on information he had gone along with the panch witnesses Subhash Chandra Dubey and Gopal Dhankar of Khategaon and taken the search at the bus-stand and the accused being identified as Raees Khan R/o Asthta, the revolver and a knife were recovered from the accused. And he was duly charged under section 25 of the Arms Act and crime registered at No. 12/85.

    4. The statements of the witnesses were recorded and the investigation launched. According to the statement of accused, the said revolver was purchased by Raees Khan from Babu Khan and Babu Khan purchased the same from his relative of Sarangpur. However, co-accused Munna could not be apprehended. Co-accused Munna and Salim were arrested later for the offence under section 25 of the Arms Act. However, they were Page: 456acquitted on 30.4.2001 whereas accused Raees Khan was convicted on trial. The accused however, had abjured his guilt stated that he was falsely implicated in the matter. He stated that independent witnesses Gopal and Subhash have not supported the prosecution and that the recovery of the seizure was not in accordance with the law; despite which the Trail Court convicted and sentenced the accused as herein below. The Appellate Court has also upheld the conviction and hence this revision petition.

    5. The main objection of the Counsel for the petitioner is that the seizure and recovery of the alleged arms and weapons are not in accordance to the provisions of the Act. Even if it is admitted that the arm i.e the country made 12 bore revolver (katta) and a knife were seized from the accused due sanction has not been obtained from the District Magistrate as required under section 39 of the Arms Act.

    6. Placing his reliance on Raju Dube v. State of M.P, 1998 (1) JLJ 236 whereby it was held that the weapons recovered from the accused along with the records to the District Magistrate for obtaining his sanction under section 39 of the Arms Act is mandatory and merely examining the clerk to prove the signature of the sanctioning authority would not be satisfactory to prove that the sanction was in accordance with the law. The weapons must also be placed for his inspection which had not been done and the Court held that recovery of arms is doubtful since the sanction of the District Magistrate was not proved. The learned Counsel for petitioner has stated that in the present case also sanction by the District Magistrate has been acquired however, learned Counsel for the petitioner states that the recovery of arms is doubtful since the revolver was not placed before him and the sanction was not in accordance with section 39 of the Act and that the accused could not be convicted under section 25/21 of the Arms Act.

    7. To bolster his submissions Counsel for the petitioner also relied on Prabhudayal Ahirwar… v. State Of M.P…. 2002 Cr LR (MP) 192 whereby this Court after going through several judgment and relying on Raju Dube v. State of M.P 1998 (1) JLJ 236 has also relied on Cr. L.R (M.P) 80 Chunta S/o Kishori Lai v. State of M.P wherein the revolver alleged to have been recovered from the possession of the appellant was not sent to the District Magistrate and District Magistrate without inspecting the weapon and without applying his mind, in routine course, gave sanction under section 39 of the Arms Act for prosecution of the appellant then the sanction is bad. In the matter of Raju Dube (supra), the Court had held that the investigating officer himself should take the instrument before the sanctioning authority for obtaining the sanction and sanctioning authority must give the sanction after applying its mind. The Court therefore, held that the sanction in the said case has not been proved and the document Ex, P-3 could not be said to be a proper sanction in the said cicumstances.

    8. In the case of Prabhudayal (supra) the Court had also set aside the conviction under section 307 of the I.P.C besides acquitted the accused of the offence under section 27 of the Arms Act. In the instant case on perused of the record it is found that there is no evidence on record to prove that the investigating officer had produced the alleged weapons along with the record before the District Magistrate at the time of obtaining sanction vide Ex. P/8 under section 39 of the Arms Act for prosecution of the appellant. The sanction has been obtained from the District Magistrate, Dewas on 9.4.1985 and at the time of taking sanction the Page: 457weapons do not seem to be produced under section 39 of the Arms Act. The sanction Ex. P/8 reads as follows:—

    “Whereas it has been made to appear to me that Rahish S/o Kullu Khan Mewate, R/o Amali, P.S Khategaon was already found to be in possession of one deshi katta.

    Fire arms—one deshi katta without licence on 15.1.1985 and that the said act of Shri Rahish S/o Kallu Khan Mewati, R/o Amali, constitutes an offence under section 25(a) of the Arms Act.

    Therefore, I, P. Joy Oomman, District Magistrate, Dewas, hereby accord sanction under section 39 of the said Act for the institution of proceeding against Rahish S/o Kallu Khan Maweti, R/o Amali for having committed that alleged offence and order that he be tried in a Court of law of competent jurisdiction.

    District Magistrate,

    District Dewas, M.P”

    9. Counsel for the petitioner prayed for setting aside the judgment of the Appellate Court.

    10. Counsel for the respondent on the other hand has fully supported the judgment stating that the offence has been proved since both the witnesses Gopal P.W 1 and Subhash P.W 2 although declared hostile have admitted their signatures on the recovery memo. However, they could not be doubted for the seizure of the weapons. The testimony of P.W 5 Sub-Inspector Shivnarayan and P.W 6 Balmukund Joshi duly corroborated the fact that the sanction has been properly obtained from the District Magistrate and there was no evidence to the contrary and under the law there must be a presumption that the weapon was duly sealed and sent for its examination. Moreover, by the impugned order minimum sentence has been imposed and therefore, there was no requirement for interference in the orders passed by both the Courts below.

    11. On considering the above and placing my reliance on Prabhudayal (supra) for considering whether proper and due sanction for prosecution in the present case under section 39 of the Arms Act has been obtained. I find that as already quoted above the sanction has been obtained from the District Magistrate vide Ex. P/8. Moreover, I did not find any categorical requirement under section 39 of the Arms Act requiring that the weapon ought to be produced before the District Magistrate. However, then relying on Bapu v. State of M.P 2005 MPW Vol. 1, 84 which is more identical to the circumstances of the present case and has also been relied on by Counsel for the petitioner; I find that in the said case this Court while considering the question whether sanction under section 39 was not proved in accordance with law stated thus:

    “R.S Jhala (P.W 7) has not jeposed in his testimony that pistol (katta) was sealed on the spot itself. There is no other evidence also to the effect. The prosecution has also not led evidence as to where and how the seized katta was kept after seizure. This creates a doubt about the very fact of seizure of katta. Sanction under section 39 of the Arms Act has also not been properly proved.” Even the concerning Arms Clerk has not been produced to prove the signatures of District Magistrate. Even if, the sanction (Exp. P-12) be taken to be proved, there is no evidence to the effect as to whether the katta or the arms concerned was produced at the time of obtaining sanction and District Magistrate has seen it before granting the sanction. In the Page: 458absence of any positive evidence, the above fact cannot be taken as proved and in the absence of such proof, sanction cannot be said to be valid sanction. Perused of endorsement made on the sanction order (Ex. P-12) reveals that only the case diary of the case might have been sent and at the time of granting sanction concerning weapon was not seen by the authority. R.S Jhala (P.W 7) has merely stated in his testimony that sanction order (Ex. P-12) was obtained from the District Magistrate, Mandsaur to launch prosecution under Arms Act. He has not made a bare assertion even in regard of producing the katta before the sanctioning authority.

    From the above discussion, it emerges from the perusal of the entire evidence that neither sanction (Ex. P-12) has been proved nor it is the valid sanction, as required by the law. In the light of the pronouncement made in the case of Prabhudayal Ahirwar… v. State Of M.P…. 2002 Cri LR (MP) 192 and Chunta S/o Kishori Lal v. State of M.P, 1999 Cr LJ 80 (MP) the conviction of the appellant is not sustainable in law.

    Consequently, appeal is allowed and the appellant is acquitted of the charge under section 25(1)(a) of Arms Act. He be set at liberty, if not required in any other case.”

    12. In instance case also P.W 5 Shivnarayan has been examined and his testimony is considered. He has stated that on 16.1.1985 he had recorded the statement of the accused that he had purchased the seized country made revolver from one Babu Khan in Rs. 300/- and Babu Khan was purchased from his relation of Sarangpur. Thereafter the seizure memo has already been prepared at the bus-stand itself. He had no knowledge whatever whether the country made revolver was sent to the District Magistrate, Dewas. He has stated in his cross-examination that Article (1) was the fire arm and its trigger was jammed and it had not been cleaned and he was unable to fire the same. When this Testimony is considered along with that of P.W 6 Shri B.M Joshi, the tehsildar who was also examined; he was the arms clerk of the District Magistrate Shri P. Joy Oomman and he had in para 4 of the deposition categorically discussed that the seized fire arm above was not sent to the District Magistrate along with the first information report and the record of the case.

    13. Then considering this fact in the light of 2005 M.P.W Vol. 1, 84 (supra) the petitioner deserves to be acquitted since both the Court below have not considered the question that the sanction was not obtained in accordance with the law under section 39 of the Arms Act at all. It has to be considered that looking to the condition of the weapon and the fact that it was not fired and was incapable of firing. Thus, the petitioner must be given the benefit of doubt since the country made revolver was not sent to the District Magistrate along with the record and hence the sanction from the District Magistrate was not duly obtained. The sentence and conviction of the accused for offence under section 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act thus, set aside and he is acquitted of the same. In view of the above, the petition is allowed. The petitioner is on bail, his bail bonds and surety bonds are discharged hereby.

    14. Petition Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raees Khan v. State Of Madhya Pradesh
    (Mar 13, 2008)