Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 364, 302, 201 IPC r/w. Section 34 IPC.127.
  • Sections 342, 365, 384, 447, 448, 427 and 506 IPC
  • sections 364, 306, 302, 201 r/w 34 IPC.2.
  • sections 364, 302, 201 r/w 34 IPC.
  • SECTION 24 EVIDENCE ACT
  • section 306 r/w 34 IPC.3.
  • Section 313 of the Code
  • Section 233(2) Cr.P.C
  • section 313 Cr.P.C,
  • section 161 Cr.P.C,
  • section 174 Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 364, 302, 201 IPC r/w. Section 34 IPC.127.
  • Sections 342, 365, 384, 447, 448, 427 and 506 IPC
  • sections 364, 306, 302, 201 r/w 34 IPC.2.
  • sections 364, 302, 201 r/w 34 IPC.
  • SECTION 24 EVIDENCE ACT
  • section 306 r/w 34 IPC.3.
  • Section 313 of the Code
  • Section 233(2) Cr.P.C
  • section 313 Cr.P.C,
  • section 161 Cr.P.C,
  • section 174 Cr.P.C

    R. Rachaiah v. Station House Officer

    JUDGEMENT

    1. The appellants 1 to 3 (hereinafter referred as accused 1 to 3) were tried for offences punishable under sections 364, 306, 302, 201 r/w 34 IPC.

    2. The learned sessions Judge has convicted accused 1 to 3 for offences punishable under sections 364, 302, 201 r/w 34 IPC. Therefore, accused 1 to 3 have filed this appeal. The State has not filed any appeal against acquittal of accused 1 to 3 of offences punishable under section 306 r/w 34 IPC.

    3. This being an appeal against judgment of conviction, it is necessary for us to denova appreciate evidence to decide the guilt or innocence of accused 1 to 3.

    4. At the out set, it is necessary to state that the case of prosecution rests upon circumstantial evidence. Before adverting to appreciation of evidence, we would narrate the case of prosecution, inter se relationship of accused 1 to 3 with deceased and relationship of deceased with PW3 to PW6.

    5. The first informant - Nanjappa was the father of Dr. N. Shivakumar (deceased), PW3-Mahadevamma is the mother of Dr. N. Shivakumar, PW4-Hirannaiah is the younger brother of Dr. N. Shivakumar, PW5-Rudraiah is the elder brother of Dr. N. Shivakumar, PW6-Rajamma is the elder sister of Dr. N. Shivakumar. Accused No. 1-R. Rachaiah is the father of Prabhavathi and she was married to Dr. N. Shivakumar. Accused No. 2-C.P. Mahesh is the son of elder sister of accused No. 1 and accused No. 3-K.M. Neelakanta is the son-in-law of elder brother of accused No. 1.

    6. At the relevant time, accused No. 1 was working as the Inspector of Police of Devaraja Police Station (Traffic Division). The deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar, B.A.M.S, M.D, was the son of CW1-Nanjappa, (who died during pendency of trial). The daughter of I-accused namely Prabhavathi was given in marriage to Dr. N. Shivakumar. The I-accused performed the marriage of his daughter - Prabhavathi with Dr. N. Shivakumar on 28.05.2000 in a choultry at Mysore. After the marriage, during evening of 28.05.2000, the newly wed couple came to the house of CW1 - Nanjappa at Bangalore.

    7. On 30.05.2000, CW1-Nanjappa had arranged customary dinner, colloquially called as ‘Bigara Oota’ at Bangalore. The newly wed couple, accused 1 to 3 and other relatives of accused No. 1 had come to Bangalore. After dinner, at about 4.30 p.m, or 5 p.m, newly wed couple and accused 1 to 3 and other relatives of accused No. 1 returned to Mysore. During night of 30.05.2000, things went terribly wrong in the house of accused No. 1, situate at Vijayanagar, Mysore. Prabhavathi, wife of Dr. N. Shivakumar had consumed poison (Begon Spray). The reasons are not too far to seek. Dr. N. Shivakumar had suspected that before the marriage, his wife had illicit relationship with her maternal uncle - Chandrashekar. After first aid treatment, Prabhavathi was admitted in B.M Hospital at Mysore. Accused No. 1 suspected that Dr. N. Shivakumar had administered poison to his wife Prabhavathi. Dr. N. Shivakumar, sensing impending danger, reached Bangalore during intervening night of 30/31.5.2000.

    8. On 31.05.2000, at the instigation of accused No. 1, accused No. 3 and two of his associates came to the house of CW1 at Bangalore. Accused No. 3 and his associates ransacked the house and assaulted PW4. The matter was reported to Chamarajpet Police. Apart from registering the case, Chamarajpet police did not evince interest On the other hand, they had advised both parties to sort out their differences. Accused No. 3 insisted that PW3 and PW4 should go over to Mysore. Accused No. 3 and his associates took PW3 and PW4 in a Tata Sumo driven by PW7 to Mysore. They were taken to B.M Hospital at Mysore, wherein Prabhavathi was being treated. Soon alter PW3 and PW4 got down from car, accused. No. 1 and others assaulted PW2 and PW3 and confined PW3 & PW4 in a room situate in the third floor of B.M Hospital. PW3 and PW4 were under the surveillance of accused No. 1 and his henchmen.

    9. On 31.05.2000, accused No. 1 insisted that his son-in-law - Dr. N. Shivakumar, should go over to Mysore to meet him. On the same day, during evening Dr. N. Shivakumar, his uncle Andanaiah and PW5 were travelling in a car to go to Mysore. As instructed by Dr. N. Shivakumar, car was stopped near Bidadi (which is at a distance of 30 kms from Bangalore). Dr. N. Shivakumar went to a S.T.D booth and contacted relatives of accused No. 1 to know, the condition of his wife - Prabhavathi, Dr. N. Shivakumar was informed from the other end that his wife is dead. Dr. N. Shivakumar after sitting in the car attempted to commit suicide by slitting his throat with a blade. Dr. N. Shivakumar was shifted to General Hospital at Bidadi and jurisdictional police registered a case under section 309 IPC. Later, Dr. N. Shivakumar was admitted in Shekar Hospital, Basavanagudi at Bangalore. Dr. N. Shivakumar had inflicted two cut injuries on his throat. He was shifted to intensive care unit in Shekar Hospital.

    10. At this juncture, we would like to clarify that Prabhavathi is alive and information given to Dr. N. Shivakumar over phone was false.

    11. In the meanwhile, PW2 & PW3 were let off by accused No. 1, however, with a condition that CW1 and PW5 should go over to Mysore to meet accused No. 1. CW1, PW5 and others reached Mysore and they were taken to the house of I accused. The I-accused demanded CW1 to pay him a sum of Rupees Ten Lakhs towards the expenditure incurred by him to perform the marriage of his daughter-Prabhavathi with Dr. N. Shivakumar. There were negotiations and CW1 agreed to pay to accused No. 1 a sum of Rupees Eight Lakhs. Accused No. 1 wanted immediate payment to which CW1 pleaded his inability. Accused No. 1 got prepared an agreement of sale, purported to be executed by CW1 and PW5, agreeing to sell two sites belonging to CW1 for alleged consideration of Rupees Six Lakhs to accused No. 1. This document was signed by CW1 and PW5. Apart from this document, accused No. 1 also obtained an acknowledgment of debt from CW1 for payment of remaining sum of Rs. Two Lakhs. Accused No. 1 told CW1 and PW5 that he would return the agreement of sale after a sum of Rupees Eight Lakhs is paid to him by CW1. Accused No. 1 had threatened CW1 and PW5 not to disclose the transaction to any one. CW1 and PW5 returned to Bangalore. The situation near Shekar Hospital was rather strange. None of the family members of CW1 was allowed to see Dr. N. Shivakumar. The henchmen of accused No. 1 were preventing family members of CW1 to see Dr. N. Shivakumar. However, PW6 was allowed to stay in Shekar Hospital.

    12. On 07.06.2000, Prabhavathi gave a statement in B.M Hospital, alleging that on 30.05.2000, at 10 p.m, her husband Dr. N. Shivakumar had administered poison to her as he had suspected that she had illicit relationship with her maternal uncle. The jurisdictional police had registered a crime against Dr. N. Shivakumar for offences punishable under sections 498-A and 307 IPC.

    13. On 08.06.2000, Dr. N. Shivakumar made II attempt to commit suicide by cutting veins of his wrists in a toilet attached to ICU of Shekar Hospital and he was treated for the same. On 09.06.2000, at 8 p.m, PW6-Rajamma had visited Shekar Hospital. At that time, accused 1 to 3 were present in Shekar Hospital. On that night, at about 9.30 p.m, or 10 p.m, accused 1 to 3 got Dr. N. Shivakumar discharged against medical advice from Shekar Hospital. The protests made by PW6 and deceased fell into deaf ears of accused No. 1. Thereafter, accused 1 to 3 took Dr. N. Shivakumar in a car to Mysore. PW6 informed this to her father CW1, who sent telegrams to the Commissioner of Police at Mysore.

    14. On 10.06.2000 at 7 a.m, PW22 found the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar on the railway track near Naguvanahalli, which is at a distance of 13 kms from Mysore. The body was cut and severed into two pieces just below the rib cage, obviously, due to train running over the body of Dr. N. Shivakumar. The Mysore Railway Police registered a case under section 174 Cr.P.C The inquest was held between 11 a.m and 1 p.m on 10.06.2000 After inquest, the deadbody was shifted to mortuary of K.R Hospital at Mysore.

    15. On 10.06.2000 at 2.30 p.m, accused No. 1 lodged a missing complaint with Jayalakshmipuram Police at Mysore, wherein accused No. 1 has stated;- that on 31.05.2000 at 9 or 10 p.m, he along with accused No. 2 got his son-in-law Dr. N. Shivakumar, discharged from Shekar Hospital and brought Dr. N. Shivakumar in a car to the house of accused No. 1 in Vijayanagar at Mysore. They reached the house of accused No. 1 at 2.30 a.m, on 10.06.2000 Accused No. 1 had brought Dr. N. Shivakumar to his house as his daughter Prabhavathi wanted to see her husband to plead excuses for she had done. Accused No. 1 was also anxious to know train his son-in-law - Dr. N. Shivakumar, as to why his marital life with Prabhavathi had run into rough weather. Dr. N. Shivakumar slept in the hail of house of accused No. 1. However, during morning of 10.06.2000 Dr. N. Shivakumar was not found in. the house of accused No. 1. Thereafter, accused No. 1 and his relatives searched for Dr. N. Shivakumar but could not trace him.

    16. This missing complaint was lodged at 2.30 p.m, on 10.06.2000 On the basis of this report, Jayalakshmipuram police had registered Crime No. 84/2000. On 11.06.2000 at 10.00 a.m, accused No. 1 lodged II report with Jayalakshmipuram police that he had seen the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar in the mortuary of K.R Hospital and he had identified the deadbody. Accused No. 1 lodged a written report that he had seen the deadbody of his son-in-law in the mortuary, presumably to stop the police from searching for the deceased.

    17. CW1 and other family members of CW1 were informed about the occurrence on 12.06.2000 They came to mortuary and identified the deadbody.

    18. On 12.06.2000, PW11 - Dr. P.K Devadas conducted post-mortem examination on the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar and opined that the deceased had suffered injuries as he was run over by a train.

    19. CW1 suspected, that his son - Dr. N. Shivakumar was assaulted by accused 1 to 3 and he was rendered unconscious. Thereafter, his body was kept on railway track for being run over by a train by accused 1 to 3, to make it appear as a case of suicide. Therefore, CW1 brought the dead body of Dr. N. Shivakumar to Bangalore and laid it in front of the Office of Commissioner of Police as a mark of protest and demanded for investigation of case. The Commissioner of Police assured CW1 to take necessary action, thereafter deadbody was buried in Padarayanapura grave yard at Bangalore.

    20. CW1 was repeatedly requesting the police higher-ups to take up investigation, but there was no response. On 22.06.2000, CW1 gave a written complaint to the Secretary, Home Department, Government of Karnataka. The Secretary to Home Department directed the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Mysore to take up investigation, consequent to which missing complaint registered as Crime No. 84/2000 and UDR No. 34/2000 registered by Mysore Police were revived and the investigation was handed over to CoD.

    21. During investigation, the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar was exhumed and subjected to II post-mortem examination. PW14-Dr. K.H Manjunath, who conducted II post-mortem examination opined that deceased suffered injuries as he was ran over by a train.

    22. Thereafter, an Expert Committee was constituted to give opinion as to nature of injuries and cause of death of Dr. N. Shivakumar. The Committee on examination of I and II post-mortem examination reports gave opinion that deceased had suffered depressed fracture of skull bones. The committee had opined it was possible that deceased had been rendered unconscious by hitting on his head with a blunt object and thereafter his body was laid on the railway track. The Investigation Officer seized records from Shekar Hospital and recorded statements of witnesses, The seized incriminating articles including car used by accused No. 1 during the night of 09.06.2000 to take the deceased from Shekar Hospital to Mysore were seized and they were sent to Forensic Science laboratory.

    23. During investigation, accused Nos. 1 to 3, Prabhavathi and wife of accused No. 1 were subjected to Polygraph and Brain Mapping tests. CW1 had filed writ petition to hand over the investigation to C.B.I This Court, taking note of the fact that investigation was taken over by Deputy Superintendent of Police of CoD, dismissed the writ petition. The Deputy Superintendent of Police (CoD) on completion of investigation, submitted chargesheet on 23.01.2002

    24. We notice from records, accused 2 & 3 were arrested during investigation and released on bail. However, accused No. 1 was arrested on the date of submission of chargesheet and he was remanded to judicial custody. It is obvious though investigation was spread over for a period of one year and six months, accused No. 1 had not been arrested and interrogated during investigation. We find accused 2 and 3 were also not subjected to interrogation.

    25. We have narrated the above facts put forth by the prosecution, to show various events that had preceded death of Dr. N. Shivakumar and various turns and twists in the investigation.

    26. We have heard Sri. S.K Venkatareddy, learned Counsel for accused and Sri. S.B Pavin, learned State Public Prosecutor. The prosecution has relied on circumstantial evidence.

    27. Before adverting to appreciation of evidence, we remind ourselves of settled principles of law relating to appreciation of circumstantial evidence and the approach of Courts to the cases resting upon circumstantial evidence.

    28. We deem it necessary to refer to a decision of Supreme Court, reported in (2008) 3 SCC 210 (in the case of Sattatiya Alias Satish Rajanna Kartalla v. State Of Maharashtra), wherein settled principles of law relating to appreciation of circumstantial evidence and approach of courts have been laid down by the Supreme Court. The relevant paragraphs would read thus:-

    “10. We have thoughtfully considered the entire matter. It is settled law that an offence can be proved not only by direct evidence but also by circumstantial evidence where there is no direct evidence. The court can draw an inference of guilt when all the incriminating facts and circumstances are found to be totally incompatible with the innocence of the accused. Of course, the circumstances from which an inference as to the guilt is drawn have to be proved beyond reasonable doubt and have to be shown, to be closely connected with the principal fact sought to be inferred from those circumstances.

    11. In Hanumant, Son Of Govind Nargundkar v. State Of Madhya Pradesh, which is one of the earliest decisions on the subject, this Court observed as under:

    “10. It is well to remember that in cases where the evidence is of a circumstantial nature, the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should in the first instance be fully established, and all the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. Again, the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency and they should be such as to exclude every hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other words, there must be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and it must be such as to show that within all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.”

    12. In Padala Veera Reddy v. State of A.P, this Court held that when a case rests upon circumstantial evidence, the following tests must be satisfied:

    (1) the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn, must be cogently and firmly established;

    (2) those circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards guilt of the accused;

    (3) the circumstances taken cumulatively, should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusions that within all human probability the crime was committed by the accused and none else; and

    (4) the circumstantial evidence in order to sustain conviction must be complete and incapable of explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the guilt of the accused and such evidence should not only be consistent with the guilt of the accused but should be inconsistent with his innocence.”

    13. In Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, it was held that the onus was on the prosecution to prove that the chain is complete and falsity or untenabiliry of the defence set up by the accused cannot be made basis for ignoring serious infirmity or lacuna in the prosecution case. The Court then proceeded to indicate the conditions which must be fully established before conviction can be based on circumstantial evidence. These are: (SCC P. 185, para 153)

    (1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established. The circumstances concerned ‘must’ or ‘should’ and not ‘may be’ established;

    (2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty;

    (3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency;

    (4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved; and

    (5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.

    14. In State of U.P v. Ashok Kumar Srivastava it was pointed out that great care must be taken in evaluating circumstantial evidence and if the evidence relied on is reasonably capable of two inferences, the out in favour of the accused must be accepted. It was also pointed out that the circumstances relied upon must be found to have been fully established and the cumulative effect of all the facts so established must be consistent only with the hypothesis of guilt.

    15. The above noted propositions have been reiterated in Bodhraj v. State of J & K, Bharat v. State of M.P, Jaswant Gir v. State of Punjab, Reddy Sampath Kumar v. State of A.P, Deepak Chandrakant Patil v. State of Maharashtra; Ramreddy Rajesh Khanna Reddy v. State of A.P and State of Goa v. Sanjay Thakran.

    16. In Ramreddy Rajesh Khanna Reddy v. State of A.P, this Court while reiterating the settled legal position, observed: (SCC p. 181, para 26)

    “26. It is now well settled that with a view to base conviction on circumstantial evidence, the prosecution must establish all the pieces of incriminating circumstances by reliable and clinching evidence and the circumstances so proved must form such a chain of events as would permit no conclusion other than one of guilt of the accused. The circumstances cannot be on any other hypothesis. It is also well settled that suspicion, however grave it may be, cannot be a substitute for a proof and the courts shall take utmost precaution in finding an accused guilty only on the basis of the circumstantial evidence.”

    29. In the case on hand, as could be seen from the case put forth by prosecution and evidence adduced by prosecution, we find the prosecution has relied on the following circumstances:-

    1) Motive

    2) Accused 1 to 3 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar at 10 p.m, on 09.06.2000 from Shekar Hospital and discharge was against medical advice.

    3) Accused 1 to 3 took the deceased in a car towards Mysore

    4) Deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused 1 to 3

    5) Homicidal death of Dr. N. Shivakumar

    6) Conduct of accused Nos. 1 to 3 prior and subsequent to occurrence

    Motive:-

    30. PW3 to PW6 have deposed that accused No. 1 had suspected that on 30.05.2000, Dr. N. Shivakumar suspecting fidelity of his wife - Prabhavathi had administered poison to her. During night of 30.5.2000 Prabhavathi was admitted in B.M Hospital at Mysore. The evidence of PW3 to PW6, finds corroboration from the statement given by Prabhavathi on 7.6.2000 and missing report lodged by accused No. 1 on 10.6.2000 PW3 and PW4 have deposed that Dr. N. Shivakumar, sensing danger at the hands of accused No. 1, over night reached Bangalore. PW3 to PW5 have deposed on 31.05.2000, at the instigation of accused No. 1, accused No. 3 and his associates about 3 to 4 in number had ransacked the house of CW1 and assaulted PW4. CW1 had reported the matter to the Chamarajapet Police, Bangalore. Though the prosecution has not produced first information report and chargesheet we find from records, a copy of the order dated 29.8.2001 in Cr. No. 159/2000 on the file of 1 Additional CMM Court at Bangalore. It is seen front copy of order dated 29.8.2001, Chamarajpet Police had registered Crime No. 159/2000 against accused 1, 2 and two others for committing aforestated offences. PW3 and PW4 have deposed;- that at the instigation of accused No. 1, accused No. 3 and his associates took PW3 and PW4 in Tata Sumo car to B.M Hospital at Mysore (wherein Prabhavathi was being treated). PW3 and PW4 were assaulted and confined in a room. Accused No. 1 had threatened PW3 and PW4 that they would be shot dead if his daughter Prabhavathi does not survive.

    31. PW3 is the mother of deceased. PW3 was not aware of location of B.M Hospital at Mysore. PW3 had no motives to make wild allegations against accused No. 1. The evidence of PW4 (younger brother of Dr. N. Shivakumar) does not suffer from major discrepancies. PW7-Marisoose, Driver of Tata Sumo has deposed that PW3 and PW4 and three persons had travelled in his car from Bangalore to B.M Hospital at Mysore. Though PW7 had not identified accused No. 3, his evidence that PW3 and PW4 had travelled in his car from Bangalore to B.M Hospital at Mysore, lends corroboration to evidence of PW3 and PW4. The possibility of PW3 and PW4 visiting B.M Hospital to see the condition of Prabhavathi can safely be ruled out in view of the fact that during morning of 31.05.2000, accused No. 3 and his associates had ransacked house of CW1; they had also assaulted PW4.

    32. PW3 during examination-in-chief has deposed that she was not allowed to see her daughter-in-law - Prabhavathi or to ascertain her condition from the doctors at B.M Hospital. During cross-examination, PW3 has admitted that she had gone near I.C.U, wherein Prabhavathi was being treated. PW3 has admitted that she had enquired doctors about the condition of Prabhavathi. However, this statement would not belie substratum of her evidence that PW3 and PW4 were under the surveillance of accused 1, 3 and their henchmen.

    33. PW3 and PW4 have deposed that they were allowed to go to Bangalore only after accused No. 1 learnt about admission of Dr. N. Shivakumar to Shekar Hospital for treatment of injuries inflicted by him in an attempt to commit suicide. During cross examination by learned counsel for accused it was suggested to PW3 that on 07.06.2000, Prabhavathi gave a statement before jurisdictional Police, alleging that her husband Dr. N. Shivakumar had administered poison to kill her, on the basis of this statement, Crime No. 82/2000 was registered for offences punishable under sections 498-A and 307 IPC, against Dr. N. Shivakumar. We find from records the statement given by Prabhavathi on 7.6.2000 which would prove the above suggestion. Thus, it is proved that accused No. 1 had suspected that Dr. N. Shivakumar had administered poison to his wife - Prabhavathi at about 10.00 p.m on 30.5.2000

    34. PW4 has deposed that I accused after learning about admission of Dr. N. Shivakumar let off PW3 and PW4 to go to Bangalore. PW3 and PW4 returned to Bangalore. On the following day, CW1 and PW5 visited Mysore.

    35. PW5 has deposed the events that occurred on 30.5.2000 and 31.5.2000 PW5 has deposed on 31.5.2000 he contacted accused No. 1 and requested him to send back PW3 and PW4. Accused No. 1 insisted that Dr. N. Shivakumar shall be brought to Mysore. Dr. N. Shivakumar was reluctant to visit Mysore.

    36. On 1.6.2000 PW5, his maternal uncle - Andanaiah and three others pursued Dr. N. Shivakumar to accompany them to Mysore and also told him that he could meet and talk to accused No. 1 in their presence and nothing untoward would happen, Dr. N. Shivakumar agreed thereafter; during evening of 1.6.2000 PW5, his maternal uncle - Andanaiah took Dr. N. Shivakumar in a car to go to Mysore. On the way near Bidadi, Dr. N. Shivakumar wanted to know the condition of his wife. The car was stopped. Dr. N. Shivakumar contacted relatives of accused No. 1 over phone and he was given false information that his wife (Prabhavathi) is dead. Dr. N. Shivakumar sat in the car. He was terribly afraid of accused No. 1. Dr. N. Shivakumar attempted to commit suicide by slitting his throat with a blade. PW5 and others shifted him to general hospital at Bidadi and informed the occurrence to Bidadi Police who visited hospital and recorded statement of Dr. N. Shivakuamar. The doctors in general Hospital advised them for shifting Dr. N. Shivakumar to a major hospital at Bangalore. Therefore PW5 and Others admitted Dr. N. Shivakumar in Shekar Hospital at Bangalore. During that night around 12.30 a.m accused No. 3 and two of his associates who had ransacked house of CW1 on 31.5.2000 came near Shekar Hospital and forced the hospital staff to open the gates of Shekar Hospital. PW5 told hospital staff that accused No. 3 and his associates had come to hospital to quarrel with PW5. Thereafter matter was informed to Hanumanthanagar Police. Accused No. 3 and two others (associates of accused No. 3) left that place.

    37. On the following day PW5 contacted accused No. 1 over phone and informed him of admission of Dr. N. Shivakuamr to Shekar Hospital and row created by accused No. 3 and his associates. Accused No. 1 told PW5 that it was at his instance, accused No. 1 had sent accused No. 3 and two others to forcibly bring Dr. N. Shivakumar to Mysore. Accused No. 1 also threatened if Dr. N. Shivakuamar is not brought to Mysore all of the family members of CW1 would be shot dead. On the following day PW5 along with his maternal uncle - Andanaiah, three of his friends an advocate by name Ahmed visited Mysore and met police commissioner by name Poovaiah, who contacted accused No. 1 over phone and later instructed PW5 and his companions to meet accused No. 1 near B.M Hospital at Mysore. PW5 and his companions came to B.M Hospital. In the meanwhile, father of PW5, namely CW1 - Nanjappa and PW-3 had come to B.M hospital. PW3, PW5, CW1 and others wanted to see Prabhavathi who was being treated in B.M Hospital. Accused No. 1 told them visiting hour would be during evening. Accused No. 1 told them to visit his house and take food. PW3, PW5, CW1 and others visited the house of accused No. 1. At that time, Advocate by name Ahmed (who had accompanied PW5 from Bangalore) suggested to accused No. 1 to sort out differences between Dr. N. Shivakumar and wife - Prabhavathi after they are discharged from Hospital. Accused No. 1 retorted that marital relationship between his daughter - Prabhavathi and Dr. N. Shivakumar has come to an end. Accused No. 1 demanded CW1 to pay him a sum of Rupees Ten Lakhs towards expenditure incurred by-accused No. 1 to perform marriage of his daughter - Prabhavathi with Dr. N. Shivakumar. After negotiations, CW1 agreed to pay to accused No. 1, a sum of Rupees Eight Lakhs. Accused No. 1 wanted immediate payment to which CW1 pleaded his inability. Accused No. 1 insisted that CW1 and PW5 should execute an agreement of sale in respect of two sites held by them. Accused No. 1 demanded immediate payment of rupees two lakhs and insisted that CW1 should execute an agreement of sale in his favour in respect of two sites held by CW1 at Bangalore. Accused No. 1 told CW1 and PW5 that he would return agreement of sale after remaining sum of Rs. six lakhs was paid to him by CW1. CW1 and PW5 were forced to agree for such arrangement Accused No. 1 took CW1 and PW5 to a stamp vendor and got executed an agreement of sale. Regarding remaining sum of Rupees Two Lakhs as insisted by accused No. 1, CW1 executed acknowledgment of debt in favour of accused No. 1.

    38. In order to test the veracity of evidence of PW5, we have verified records. The Investigation Officer had neither interrogated accused No. 1 on this aspect, nor made any efforts to seize the documents. However, we find from records, a photostat copy of this agreement. Accused No. 1 when examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C, has admitted this fact, however he has stated that CW1 and PW5 on their volition, without there being insistence from accused No. 1, executed agreement of sale in favour of accused No. 1.

    39. PW5 has deposed that accused No. 1 had alleged that on 30.05.2000, his son-in-law Dr. N. Shivakumar suspecting fidelity of his wife - Prabhavathi, had administered poison to her in a bid to kill her.

    40. In the discussion made supra, we have referred to evidence of PW3 and contents of copy of statement of Prabhavathi given on 07.06.2000 and registration of Cr. No. 82/2000 for offences punishable under Sections 498-A and 307 IPC against Dr. N. Shivakumar by Jayalakshmipuram police. Accused No. 1 in the missing complaint lodged by him on 10.06.2000 has stated that Dr. N. Shivakumar had administered poison to his wife-Prabhavathi and he had lodged a complaint. Thus, from evidence of PW3 to PW5 and also from contents of Ex.P.57 (missing complaint lodged by accused No. 1 at 2.30 p.m on 10.06.2000), we find that accused Nos. 1 and 3 had grudge against Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    41. The learned Counsel for accused has submitted that motive suggested by prosecution is false. The learned Counsel would submit as per evidence of PW4, the intention of accused No. 1 was to recover from CW1, the marriage expenditure incurred by accused Nos. 1. Therefore, the case of prosecution that accused Nos. 1 to 3 had motive to kill the deceased is apparently false.

    42. In the discussion made supra, we have narrated events that had taken place between 30.05.2000 and 07.06.2000 with reference to evidence of PW3 to PW5. We have also referred to documentary evidence, in particular the missing complaint lodged by accused No. 1 on 10.06.2000, statement made by Prabhavathi on 7.6.2000 and registration of case in Crime No. 82/2000 for offences punishable under Sections 498-A and 307 IPC against Dr. N. Shivakumar. The evidence of PW3 to PW5 is clinching and it is of conclusive tendency. Accused No. 1 had grudge against Dr. N. Shivakumar and accused Nos. 2 and 3 being close relatives of accused No. 1 were acting at the behest of accused No. 1. It may be that an unsuccessful attempt was made by accused No. 3 to recover from CW1 the marriage expenditure. However, it does not mean that after getting agreement of sale, accused No. 1 was satisfied and he had treated the matter as closed. The presence of accused 1 to 3 in Shekar Hospital on 9.06.2000 and contents of missing complaint lodged by accused No. 1 on 10.06.2000 would conclusively prove that accused No. 1 had ill-will against Dr. N. Shivakumar and his family members. Therefore, we held that prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that accused 1 to 3 had ill-will against deceased.

    43. The other circumstance relied upon by prosecution are:- that on 09.06.2000, at about 10 p.m, accused 1 to 3 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar Hospital against medical advice; accused Nos. 1 to 3 took the deceased in a car; deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused; on 10.06.2000, at 7 a.m, deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar was found on the railway track near Naganahally which is at a distance of 13 kms. from Mysore; conduct of accused No. 1 prior and subsequent to occurrence, and death of Dr. N. Shivakumar was homicidal. These circumstances would form a chain of events and cumulative effect of facts established from the evidence adduced by the prosecution would be decisive on innocence or guilt of accused Nos. 1 to 3. Therefore, we take up the evidence adduced to prove above circumstances together to avoid unnecessary discussion and repetition of evidence and overlapping of facts.

    44. The fact that on 09.06.2000 at 10 p.m, Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged from Shekar Hospital is not disputed. The disputed facts are whether Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged against medical advice and he was got discharged by accused 1 to 3. The proof of these facts provide ample proof of vital links in the chain of circumstances put forth by prosecution. The evidence of PW1 - Dr. Ravikoushik of Shekar hospital and contemporaneous records viz., case sheet and discharge certificate and physical and mental condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar would provide conclusive proof of the fact Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged against medical advice. The evidence of PW1 that the deceased - Dr. N. Shivakumar had inflicted two cut injuries in an attempt to commit suicide has not been controverted PW1 has deposed that on 31.05.2000, during night Dr. N. Shivakumar was admitted in Shekar Hospital. On examination, PW1 found that Dr. N. Shivakumar had following injuries on his neck:-

    (1) Incised wound measuring 15 cms. × inch clip from anterior border of (M) 5 cms × 1 cm. anterior to (R) 5 cms. anterior borel.

    45. PW1 has deposed that PW1 and Dr. M.S Venkatesh sutured cut injuries found on the neck of Dr. N. Shivakumar. These facts are mentioned in case sheet marked as exhibit P12. During cross-examination, PW1 has deposed that he learnt on 08.06.2000, Dr. N. Shivakumar had cut veins of his both wrists in a toilet attached to I.C.U of Shekar Hospital. PW1 has deposed that he learnt on 9.6.2000 Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged against medical advice. These facts are mentioned in case sheet and discharge summary.

    46. PW1 has deposed that Dr. N. Shivakumar had suicidal tendency. The evidence of PW1 finds corroboration from evidence of PW8 - Sridhar (Manager of Shekar Hospital) and PW9 Dr. Srinivasulu Naidu. From evidence of PW9 we find Dr. N. Shivakumar was treated by PW9 - Dr. Srinivasulu Naidu. PW9 has deposed that Dr. N. Shivakumar was treated in intensive care unit from 1.6.2000 to 9.6.2000 PW9 has deposed that patient's whose condition is critical would be treated mintensive care unit. After progress in treatment patient would be shifted to General Ward. PW9 has deposed that Dr. N. Shivakumar had suicidal tendency.

    47. The evidence of PW1, PW8 and PW9, condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar at the time of discharge would conclusively prove that on 09.06.2000 at 10 p.m, Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged from Shaker Hospital against medical advice.

    48. The next point for consideration is:-

    “Whether accused 1 to 3 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar Hospital?”

    49. The prosecution has relied on evidence of PW6. The fact PW6 was frequently visiting Shekar Hospital has not been disputed. The presence of PW6 at the time of discharge has not been disputed. The defence has put forth positive suggestion to PW6 that Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged by PW6. However, PW6 has denied this suggestion. We do not find any reasons for PW6 to get her younger brother Dr. N. Shivakumar discharged from Shekar Hospital against medical advice. We have no reasons to suspect evidence of PW6. The discharge sheet bears signature of accused No. 2-Neelkanta. Accused No. 2 when questioned under Section 313 Cr.P.C, has admitted this fact but he has added accused 2 and PW6 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar Hospital. PW6 being the elder sister of deceased was much interested in health condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    50. It is established from evidence on record that Dr. N. Shivakumar was being treated in I.C.U from the date of his admission till he was discharged from Shekar Hospital. PW6 has deposed that she had protested discharge against medical advice, her protest fell into deaf ears of accused 1 to 3. Dr. N. Shivakumar himself being a doctor was not in a condition to take any decision. There is nothing on record to hold that Dr. N. Shivakumar had consented for his discharge from Shekar Hospital.

    51. In the missing complaint (Ex.P.57), lodged by accused No. 2 on 10.06.2000, accused No. 1 has categorically stated that on 09.06.2000 at 10 p.m, accused Nos. 1 & 2 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar Hospital and brought him in a car to the house of accused No. 1 at Vijaynagar in Mysore. The missing complaint was lodged by accused No. 1 at 2.30 p.m on 10.06.2000 Accused No. 1 has not denied the contents of missing complaint. Accused No. 1 has stated in the missing complaint that he got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar and brought him to his house at Mysore to reconcile differences between Dr. N. Shivakumar and his wife-Prabhavathi, who had expressed strong desire to see her husband - Dr. N. Shivakumar, besides accused No. 1 was anxious to know from Dr. N. Shivakumar the reasons for what had happened to his daughter-Prabhavathi.

    52. We find from evidence of PW6, that soon after Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged from Shekar Hospital, she informed the same to her father-CW1, who in turn had sent a telegram to the Commissioner of Police. CW1 was not alive to speak these facts. Therefore, on appreciation of evidence referred to supra, we hold that prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that on 09.06.2000 at 10 p.m, Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged from Shekar Hospital by accused 1 to 3 and discharge of Dr. N. Shivakumar was against medical advice.

    53. The learned Counsel for accused has submitted that doctors of Shekar Hospital have not stated that accused 1 to 3 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar hospital. The evidence of PW6 is highly discrepant. The statement of PW6 under Section 161 Cr.P.C, was belatedly recorded. The interested evidence of PW6 (elder sister of Dr. N. Shivakumar) does not find corroboration from other evidence. The learned counsel for accused has placed reliance on a decision reported in 1979 SCC (Cri) 1, wherein the Supreme Court has held:-

    “15. Delay of a few hours, simpliciter, in recording the statements of eye-witnesses may not, be itself, amount to a serious infirmity in the prosecution case. But it may assume such a character if there are concomitant circumstances to suggest that the investigator was deliberately marking time with a view to decide about the shape to be given to the case and the eye-witnesses to be introduced.”

    54. In the discussion made supra, we have held that Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged against medical advice. PW6 had protested this. We have held that PW6 being elder sister of Dr. N. Shivakumar was very much interested in health condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar. We do not find any reasons to suspect her evidence. If PW6 got Dr. N. Shivakumar discharged, it is not made clear as to how accused No. 1 was able to take the deceased to his house at Mysore. Regarding delay in recording statement of PW6 under Section 161 Cr.P.C, we would like to observe, the case on hand has survived tardy and faulty investigation. The defence has no case that PW6 is a planted witness to prove these vital links in the chain of circumstances put forth by prosecution.

    55. Regarding interest testimony of PW6, it is necessary to state that PW6 being the eider sister of Dr. N. Shivakumar would be least deposed to implicate accused by sparing real culprits. In any event, relationship of PW6 with deceased is not a factor to affect her evidence, which we have found credible.

    56. In a decision reported in (2002) 8 SCC 381 (in the case of Gangadhar Behera v. State of Orissa), it is held that relationship is not a factor to affect credibility of a witness.

    57. Therefore, we disagree with the submissions of learned Counsel for accused. Thus, we hold that prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that accused 1 to 3 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar Hospital at 10 p.m, on 09.06.2000 and the condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar was not stable and such discharge was not only against medical advise but also it was detrimental to health condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    58. The next crucial point for determination is to what happened to Dr. N. Shivakumar after he was got discharged from Shekar Hospital by accused Nos. 1 to 3. The answer to this point is entirely inferential and such inference has to be drawn on appreciation of evidence and other facts established from evidence on record and the facts which are not disputed by accused Nos. 1 to 3. This point has to be considered bearing in mind that on 10.6.2000 at 7.00 a.m, deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar was found near the railway track between Srirangapatna and Naguvanahalli. We notice the place of occurrence (railway track near Naguvanahalli is at a distance of about 115 kms from Bangalore and at a distance of about 13 kms from Mysore. According to the case of prosecution, Dr. N. Shivakumar had not reached the house of accused No. 1 at Mysore. Contrary to this, accused No. 1 has come out with a specific defence that accused 1 and 2 had taken Dr. N. Shivakumar in a car to the house of accused No. 1 and they reached the house of accused No. 1 at 2.30 a.m (during intervening night of 9/10.6.2000). The deceased slept in the bail of house of accused No. 1. During early hours of 10.6.2000 deceased was found missing from house of accused No. 1. Accused No. 1 and his relatives searched for him, but could not trace him. Therefore on 10.6.2000 at 2.30 p.m accused No. 1 lodged a missing complaint as per Ex.P57 by narrating the above facts. Thus from the evidence of PW6 and contents of missing report it is proved beyond reasonable doubt, accused Nos. 1 to 3 took deceased in a car from Bangalore towards Mysore during intervening night of 9/10.6.2000.

    59. At this juncture it is necessary to find out reasons for accused Nos. 1 to 3 to take over night journey with Dr. N. Shivakumar who was physically unfit that too after getting him discharged from hospital against medical advice. Accused No. 1 in the missing complaint (Ex.P57) has stated that he took Dr. N. Shivakumar as his daughter - Prabhavathi wanted to see her husband, besides accused No. 1 was anxious to know from Dr. N. Shivakimar the reasons for untoward events that had occurred between 30.5.2000 and 9.6.2000 PW6 was very much present when accused Nos. 1 to 3 took the deceased from hospital. Accused No. 1 did not inform PW6 the reasons for taking Dr. N. Shivakumar with him. Accused No. 1 did not inform this fact to the parents of Dr. N. Shivakumar. Above all, accused Nos. 1 to 3 did not ascertain willingness of Dr. N. Shivakumar to accompany them to Mysore. Accused 1 to 3 did not have slightest regard or botheration to the health condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar. The reasons put forth by accused No. 1 in missing complaint (Ex.P57) are hardly capable of acceptance for the following reasons;- on 7.6.2000 Prabhavathi had made a statement before Jayalakshmipuram police on the basis of which a crime had been registered against Dr. N. Shivakumar for offences punishable under Sections 498A and 307 IPC. Few days prior to 7.6.2000 accused No. 1 had demanded and got executed an agreement of sale from CW1 and PW4 as a guarantee for repayment of marriage expenditure incurred by accused No. 1. Accused No. 1 had held Dr. N. Shivakumar entirely responsible for the miserable condition of Prabhavathi.

    60. In the discussion made supra, we have referred to various acts committed by accused Nos. 1 to 3 after Prabhavathi was admitted in B.M Hospital for treatment of consumption of poison on 30.5.2000 From these facts established from evidence on record, it is crystal clear that accused No. 1 had treated that marriage of Dr. N. Shivakumar with his daughter was irretrievably broken. PW5 has deposed that when his advocate has suggested to accused No. 1 to sort out differences after Prabhavathi and Dr. N. Shivakumar were discharged from hospitals, accused No. 1 had retorted that he had put an end to the marriage between Dr. N. Shivakumar and Prabhavathi and demanded CW1 and PW5 to pay the marriage expenditure and leave the place without further more. Neither 1 accused nor his daughter was in reconciliatory mood. The parents of Dr. N. Shivakumar were never informed of the intention of accused No. 1 to reconcile differences between Dr. N. Shivakumar and his wife - Prabhavathi. Above all health condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar was not stable. From the facts established by evidence on record, we find during period between 30.5.2000 and 9.6.2000 accused 1 and 3 had committed several aggressive acts on Dr. N. Shivakumar and his family members.

    61. We also see from records on 7.6.2000 daughter of accused No. 1 has made a false statement that accused No. 1 had administered poison to her. The contents of copy of statement dated 7.6.2000 would reveal;- on 30.5.2000 Dr. N. Shivakumar and his wife along with accused No. 1 and his relatives after completing dinner at Bangalore left to Mysore and reached the house of accused No. 1. Dr. N. Shivakumar had suspected fidelity of his wife-Prabhavathi and scolded her; Dr. N. Shivakumar asked her to bring Begon Spray as he had found cockroaches in a room of house of accused No. 1; Prabhavathi brought Bagon Spray and gave to him; he ordered her to bring a cup of tea; she prepared and brought a cup of tea and went to kitchen; when she was in kitchen Dr. N. Shivakumar called and scolded her that tea was not tasty and asked her to drink tea; she obediently drank tea and fell soon and later she was shifted to hospital; Dr. N. Shivakumar after clandestinely mixing Begon Spray with tea had instigated Prabhavathi to drink tea with an intention to kill her.

    62. In order to appreciate the truth of this statement it is necessary for us to analyse sequence of events narrated in the statement in the background of relationship of parties. The legitimate queries that would arise of statement of Prabhavathi are; Dr. N. Shivakumar had visited the house of his father-in-law on the third day of his marriage; whether the house of accused was dirty and there were number of cockroaches; even if so, the new bridegroom had taken the task of cleaning house by using Begon Spray; was there any reason for Prabhavathi to bring Begon Spray and give to her husband so that he could clean the house. Even there was cockroach menace, whether accused No. 1 would have allowed Dr. N. Shivakumar (his doctor son-in-law) to clean the room in the house of accused No. 1. If Dr. N. Shivakumar had clandestinely mixed Begon Spray with tea, it would have naturally emanated foul smell; how could Prabhavathi consume foul smelling tea. If the things had happened in the manner stated by Prabhavathi in her statement dated 07.06.2000 why accused No. 1 had kept quite till 7.6.2000 Be it a case of attempt to commit murder or attempt to commit suicide, was it not the duty of accused No. 1 (Police Officer of the rank of Circle Inspector) to inform the matter to police: the statement given by Prabhavathi on 7.6.2000 was obviously at the instance of accused No. 1. PW17 S.L Madhava Rao (the then Sub-inspector of Jayalaskhmipuram Police Station) has deposed about the statement given by Prabhavathi on 7.6.2000 and registration of Cr. No. 82/2000 for offences punishable under Sections 498A and 307 IPC against Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    63. On critical analysis of facts and circumstances, we hold that accused No. 1 had instigated his daughter to give such a statement and accused No. 1 was instrumental for registration of criminal case against. Dr. N. Shivakumar. Accused No. 1 committed these acts to create a situation of a democlus sword hanging over the head of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    64. Therefore the reason given by accused No. 1 in the missing report (Ex.P57) that he had brought Dr. N. Shivakumar to reconcile differences is a false and misleading statement.

    65. The next question for determination is whether Dr. N. Shivakumar was done to death by accused Nos. 1 to 3 or Dr. N. Shivakumar had overnight reached railway track (place of occurrence) and he had laid down across railway track to commit suicide. The determination of this question involves appreciation of evidence of prosecution, conduct of accused Nos. 1 to 3 and medical evidence relating to cause of death.

    66. At the time of discharge the condition of Dr. N. Shivakumar was not normal. He was being treated in intensive care unit. He had suffered hemorrhage due to self inflicted injuries on his neck on 31.5.2000 near Bidadi. He had also cut veins of his both wrists on 8.6.2000 These facts are established from the evidence of PW1 Dr. Ravikoushik, PW9 - Dr. Srinivasalunaidu and medical records of Shekar Hospital. We also notice these injuries from the postmortem examination report marked as Ex.P13 and evidence of PW11 - Dr. P.K Devadas. These injuries are described as ante mortem external injuries at Sl. Nos. 2 to 5 of I postmortem examination report.

    67. The defence has not disputed the contents of I post-mortem examination report. On the other hand, defence has strongly contended that Dr. N. Shivakumar had suicidal tendency and he was unsuccessful in his attempts to commit suicide on 31.5.2000 and 8.6.2000

    68. In the discussion made supra we have held accused Nos. 1 and 3 got Dr. N. Shivakumar discharged against medical advice from Shekar Hospital. Even at the time of discharge Dr. N. Shivakumar was being treated in intensive care unit of Shekar Hospital. It is seen from the evidence of PW20 - A.S Hanumantharayappa (the then police Inspector of Mysore, Railway police station), after the occurrence a shirt, a collar bandage cloth, a katcha (under garment) and a bedspread were found on deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar. It is not the case of defence that when deceased was discharged from hospital he was wearing only a shirt and katcha and he had covered his body with a bed spread. The conduct of accused No. 1 and contents of missing report as per Ex.P57 lodged by accused No. 1 at 2.45 p.m on 10.6.2000 and subsequent report lodged by accused No. 1 on 11.6.2000 at 10.00 p.m would provide proof of the above circumstance.

    69. PW17 - S.L Mahadevarao has deposed that on 10.6.2000 at 2.45 p.m accused No. 1 lodged report (as per Ex.P.57) relating to missing of Dr. N. Shivakumar with PW17 upon which Crime No. 84/2000 was registered. PW17 has deposed that on 11.6.2000 at 10.00 p.m accused No. 1 lodged another report stating that he had seen deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar in the Mortuary of K.R Hospital. The I accused had lodged this report obviously to persuade PW17 to treat the missing report (Ex.P57) as closed.

    70. PW17 has not been cross examined by learned counsel for accused. There is no denial of contents of Ex.P57 and Ex.P39, which were admittedly lodged by accused No. 1. These documents have come into existence before the crime was registered against accused No. 1. In other words vhen Ex.P57 and P39 were brought into existence no cognizable offence in relation to death of Dr. N. Shivakumar had been registered against accused Nos. 1 to 3. The missing report as per Ex.P57 and II report marked as Ex.P39 do not fall under Section 24 of the Evidence Act and they cannot be treated in statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C recorded during investigation of crime in relation to death of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    71. The evidence of PW22 - Shivaramaiah (ASI of Mysore Railway police station) that on 10.6.2000 at 7.00 p.m deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar was found near railway track near Pashchimavahini railway gate has not been controverted, so also evidence of PW22 that a train from Bangalore to Mysore had passed on that track around 3.15 a.m on 10.6.2000 and another train from Mysore to Bangalore had passed on that track at about 6.15 a.m on 10.6.2000 has not been controverted by the defence. This witness was not cross examined by the learned counsel for accused.

    72. The evidence of PW22 - Shivaramaiah, the then ASI of Mysore railway police station, that place of occurrence is at a distance of 12 kms. from Mysore has not been controverted. The evidence of PW22, inquest on the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar was held by him between 11.00 a.m and 1.00 p.m on 10.6.2000 he sent the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar to mortuary of K.R Hospital after 1 00 p.m on 10.6.2000 has not been controverted. From the contents of inquest report marked as Ex.P53 we find inquest was held between 11.00 a.m and 1.00 p.m on 10.6.2000 and after the inquest deadbody was sent to mortuary of K.R Hospital at Mysore.

    73. At this juncture we reiterate the fact that on 10.6.2000 at 2.45 p.m accused No. 1 had lodged a missing complaint as per Ex.P57 with Jayalakshmipuram Police. We have already referred to contents of missing report marked as Ex.P57 We notice from the contents of inquest report marked as Ex.P53 there was none to identify the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar. It was treated as an unidentified deadbody.

    74. Now the crucial question is whether lodging of missing complaint by accused No. 1 at 2.45 p.m on 10.6.2000 soon after the inquest was concluded at 1.00 p.m on 10.6.2000 was a mere coincidence or a deliberate act on the part of accused No. 1 to mislead the investigation.

    75. In order to answer this question we refer to the contents of II report (Ex.P39) lodged by accused No. 1 at 10.00 a.m on 11.6.2000 with PW17 the then PSI of Jayalakshmipuram police station. The evidence of PW17 relating to this fact has not been controverted. In Ex.P39 accused No. 1 has stated;- that on 10.6.2000 accused No. 1 had lodged report about the missing of his son-in-law Dr. N. Shivakumar, on 11.6.2000 during morning Assistant Commissioner of Police informed accused No. 1 that an unidentified deadbody was lying in the mortuary of Mysore Medical college; accused No. 1 visited the mortuary and saw the deadbody of his son-in-law Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    76. As already stated, Ex.P39 was lodged by accused No. 1 to persuade investigation officer - PW17 to treat the missing complaint (Ex.P57) as closed.

    77. Now the crucial question is whether accused No. 1 did not know about the death of his son-in-law (Dr. N. Shivakumar) till he saw the deadbody of his son-in-law (Dr. N. Shivakumar) in the mortuary before 10.00 a.m on 11.6.2000

    78. The accused No. 1 after his examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C had filed his written statement which has been treated as a part of the record, in terms of Section 233(2) Cr.P.C In his written statement, accused No. 1 has asserted the following facts;- During intervening night of 9/30.6.2000 Dr. N. Shivakumar had stayed in the house of accused No. 1. On the following day morning Dr. N. Shivakumar was missing from his house. Therefore accused No. 1 lodged a missing complaint. Thereafter he learnt about deadbody lying near place of occurrence. Accused No. 1 immediately rushed to place of occurrence and identified the deadbody as that of Dr. N. Shivakumar, contacted parents of deceased over phone and informed them of occurrence. The parents of deceased came to place of occurrence and insisted for removal of deadbody. Accused No. 1 used his car to shift the deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar in the process a part of rubber mat of his car was stained with blood.

    79. Thus from the combined reading Ex.P57, Ex.P39 and written statement filed by accused No. 1 under Section 233(2) Cr.P.C, we find that missing complaint as per Ex.P57 was lodged by accused No. 1 at 2.45 p.m on 10.6.2000 to deliberately mislead the investigation and misdirect the investigation. The accused had visited place of occurrence much before he lodged missing complaint as per Ex.P57

    80. The learned counsel for accused has submitted that answers given by accused in examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C cannot be made basis to draw an inference of guilt of accused.

    81. In the discussion made supra, we have referred to evidence of PW 21 and PW22 and contents of inquest report. We have also referred to contents of missing complaint as per Ex.P57 and subsequent report as per Ex.P39

    82. On appreciation of evidence of PW6 and circumstances under which deceased was discharged from Shekar Hospital we have held that deceased was seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3, we take notice of fact as established from evidence on record that place of occurrence is at a distance of 12 kms. from Mysore railway station and about 100 kms. away from Bangalore. The deceased was got discharged around 10.00 p.m on 9.6.2000 Therefore, the contention of defence that the deceased had left the house of accused No. 1 at Mysore and reached the place of occurrence near Srirangapatna between 2.30 a.m and 6.00 a.m on 10.6.2000 and committed suicide by lying across railway track cannot be accepted.

    83. In a decision reported in 1996 (4) Crime 282 SC (in the case of RATTAN SINGH v. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH), it is held:-

    “Examination of the accused under Section 313 of the Code is not a mere formality. Answers given by the accused to the questions put to him during such examination have a practical utility for criminal courts. Apart from affording an opportunity to the delinquent to explain incriminating circumstances against him, they would help the Court in appreciating the entire evidence adduced in the court during trial.”

    84. In a decision reported in (2002) 10 SCC 236 (in the case of MOHAN SINGH v. PPEM SINGH), the Supreme Court has held;-

    The statement made in defence by the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C can certainly be taken aid of to lend credence to the evidence led by the prosecution, but only a part of such statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C cannot be made the sole basis of his conviction. The law on the subject is almost settled that statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C of the accused can either be relied on in whole or in part. It may also be possible to rely on the inculpatory part of the statement of the accused if the exculpatory part is found to be false on the basis of the evidence led by the prosecution. The statement of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C is not a substantive piece of evidence. It can be used for appreciating evidence led by the prosecution to accept or reject it. It is, however, not a substitute for the evidence of the prosecution. If the exculpatory part of the statement of the accused is found to be false and the evidence led by the prosecution is reliable, the inculpatory part of his statement can be taken aid of to lend assurance to the evidence of the prosecution. If the prosecution evidence does not inspire confidence to sustain the conviction of the accused, the inculpatory part of his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C cannot be made the sole basis of his conviction.”

    85. We have referred to aforestated decisions to state in the case on hand incriminating evidence brought on record when put to accused during examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C does not find any acceptable explanation from accused No. 1. On the other hand, the explanation given by accused No. 1 in his written statement would help the court in appreciating the entire evidence adduced in the court during trial.

    86. Therefore we reject the submission of learned counsel for accused that during intervening night of 9/10.6,2000 deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar on his volition had reached the place of occurrence either from Bangalore or Mysore.

    87. The next point for determination is whether death of Dr. N. Shivakumar was suicidal or homicidal.

    88. It is the case of prosecution that accused Nos. 1 to 3 after getting Dr. N. Shivakumar discharged against medical advice took him in car bearing No. KA-34.M-962 towards Mysore. On the way to Mysore accused Nos. 1 to 3 hit on the head of decreased with a blunt object and rendered him unconscious. Thereafter accused Nos. 1 to 3 laid Dr. N. Shivakumar in unconscious state on the railway track for being run over by a train to make it appear as a case of suicide.

    89. Contrary to this, learned counsel for accused has contended that prosecution has adduced positive evidence to prove that accused attempted to commit suicide on 31.5.2000 and 8.6.2000 PW1 - Dr. Ravikoushik and PW9 - Dr. Srinivasalu Naidu have opined deceased had suicidal tendency. The learned counsel for accused would submit that deceased was a scizopernic.

    90. In order to appreciate these rival contentions we have to refer to several admitted and proved facts. Deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar was an ayurvedic doctor and his qualification was B.A.M.S M.D He was pursuing his studies till one or two years before his marriage. There is no evidence on record that prior to 31.5.2000 he had attempted to commit suicide at any point of time. Dr. N. Shivakumar had married Prabhavathi on 28.5.2000 On 30.5.2000 Prabhavathi had consumed poison and she was admitted in B.M Hospital at Mysore. Accused No. 1 had made wild allegations that Dr. N. Shivakumar had administered poison to Prabhavathi with an intention to kill her. Accused No. 1 had also alleged that Dr. N. Shivakumar had suspected chastity of Prabhavathi.

    91. In the discussion made in the earlier part of this judgment we have referred to statement of Prabhavathi to hold that accusation made against Dr. N. Shivakumar was palpably false. Accused No. 1 had become aggressive. On 31.5.2000 during morning at the instance of accused No. 1, accused No. 3 and his associates had ransacked the house of Dr. N. Shivakumar and they had assaulted the younger brother of Dr. N. Shivakumar. The jurisdictional police apart from registering crime did not take any action against accused No. 3 and his associates. Accused No. 3 and his associates had intimidated and taken the mother (PW-3) and younger brother of Dr. N. Shivakumar (PW4) to Mysore to meet accused No. 1. During evening of 31.5.2000 as demanded by accused No. 1, Dr. N. Shivakumar was being taken in a car to Mysore. On the way near Bidadi when Dr. N. Shivakumar contacted relatives of accused No. 1 over phone to know the condition of his wife Prabhavathi, he was given false information that she is dead. Soon after hearing the same deceased attempted to commit suicide. From the above events we infer that Dr. N. Shivakumar was under fear psychosis. Dr. N. Shivakumar was afraid of consequences which would follow due to aggressive attitude of accused No. 1 and the powerful post held by accused No. 1.

    92. On 7.6.2000 Prabhavathi - wife of Dr. N. Shivakumar had made a statement accusing Dr. N. Shivakuamar of subjecting her to cruelty and making an attempt on her life by administering poison. In the meanwhile I accused had demanded a sum of rupees ten lakhs from the father of Dr. N. Shivakumar towards marriage expenses and had obtained an agreement of sale from the father and elder brother of Dr. N. Shivakumar. After Dr. N. Shivakumar was admitted in Shekar Hospital during period of treatment he was under surveillance of accused No. 1 and his bench men.

    93. Thus, marital life and future of accused was shattered. During period between 30.5.2000 and 8.6.2000 series of catamites had befallen the deceased. In other words, troubles had come in floods to him. In these circumstances deceased was disgusted in life and attempted to commit suicide.

    94. PW 1 and PW9 had not examined the deceased to diagnose if he had suicidal tendency or any other mental disorder tending to commit suicide. Therefore it is not possible to hold that deceased had suicidal tendency.

    95. We have voluminous medical evidence relating to cause of death of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    96. P.W11 - Dr. P.K Devdas conducted I postmortem examination on 12.6.2000 and noticed following ante-mortem injuries:

    The body is crushed below the level of nipples and divided into two halves. Both the wrists are covered with hospital bandages which show blood stains. Both the dorsum of hands swollen, dorsum of left foot swollen. The body is stained with oil and grease. The front of neck shows oblique incised injury measuring 10.05 cm. × 2 cm. × muscle deep; broad on the right side tailing on the left side. The edges show partial healing and it places bits of suture material thread is found. The injury is 6 cm, below left angle of mandible, 8 cms., below chin, 9.5 cms gaping. There is another incised injury parallel 2.5 cm below the above mentioned injury measuring 5.0 cms., in length, superficial having one black suture on removal of the bandage of right wrist. There is a transverse cut injury found sutured ………… (words not visible) of suture it is 5 cm. × 1 cm. Though the injury tendons are seen and they are intact Edges are clean cut. Injury is placed 2 cm. above the wrist crease. On removal of bandage of left wrist, there is a superficial cut injury measuring 4 cms. × 0.5 cm. situated 2.5 cm. above the wrist crease. Three cm. above the outer end of this injury there are two lacerations measuring 1 × 0.5 cm and 0.5 × 0.5 × 0.5 cms There is a linear superficial vertical, cut injury 3.5 cm. present over palmar surface of left thumb.

    Other injuries are:

    1. There is abrasion measuring 4 cm. × 2.5 cm. situated 3 cm. above the inner end of left eve brow.

    2. Abrasion measuring 2.5 cm. × 1 cm. situated by the outer side of injury number 1.

    3. Laceration measuring 3 cm. × 2 cm. bone dep situated on the outer third of left eyebrow. Though injury fractured frontal bone is visible.

    4. Abrasion measuring 4 cm. × 2.5 cm situated by the outer end of right eyebrow.

    5. Abrasion measuring 3 cms. × 0.5 cm. situated on the upper part of nose.

    6. Abrasion 8 cm. × 6 cm. present over left cheek.

    7. Abrasion measuring 4 cm. × 0.5 cm. on right edge of lower lip.

    8. Abrasion measuring 7 cm. × 2 cm and 5 cm. × 1 cm. are present over front and outer side of right arm at its lower third.

    9. Abrasion measuring 10 cm. × 9 cm. present over right side front chest.

    10. Abrasion 4 cm. × 2 cm, 6 cm. × 2 cm., 5 cm. × 3 cm. are present over front of left shoulder.

    11. Abrasion measuring 22 cm. × 10 cm. is present over back of left arm, elbow and forearm. The left elbow joint is dislocated.

    12. There is lacerated injury 2.5 cm. × 0.5 cm situated 1 cm below the root of right fore finger over the dorsum underneath the second metacarpal bone is seen and is fractured.

    13. The large part of thorax 14 cm. below right, 11 cm below the left nipple is found crushed separate the lower half of body. Through the crushed injury the lacerated abdominal organs like liver, spleen, intestiner, crushed vertebrae are seen.

    14. Abrasion measuring 33 cm. × 25 cm. present over left side front of abdomen

    15. Abrasion measuring 50 cm. × 24 cm. present over outer side to back of light thigh.

    16. Laceration measuring 8 cm. × 4 cm. × 2 cm. present in the right inguinal region.

    17. The right leg is crushed at its lower third. The skin over the leg from patella downwards is stripped which shows extravasation of blood. The bones, muscles, vessels and nerves are crushed and exposed. The right foot is separated.

    18. Laceration measuring 10 cm. × 2.5 cm. × 2 5 cm. and 8 cm. × 3 cm. × 2.5 cm. are present in the premium over front and back of anus.

    19. Multiple abrasions measuring 2 cm. × 1 cm. × 4 cm, × 1 cm. over front, 1 × 1 cm. 4 × 2 cm. over the side and 2 × 2 cm. over the back of left knee, extravasation of blood is present at the fractured ends and under the abrasion.

    On dissection of scalp and skull PW11 noticed extravasation of blood present over left parieto occipital region, skull shows depressed fracture measuring 6 × 3.5 cm and sinus deep present over left part of forehead just above supraciatry arch. Left roof of orbit shows ‘V’ shaped fissued fracture connecting it to sinus. Dura lacerated at-fractured site. Brain-pale, covered with thin layer of hemorrhage over left frontal lobe upto parietal and lower part of the lobe, corresponding to the external injury. On dissection of thorax PW11 noticed left side of 2nd, 3rd and 4 ribs are fractured at middle 5 to 8 ribs near verterbra, right side 9 to 12 are fractured with extravasation of blood with thin layer, pleura and cavity was lacerated and pale. Larynx and traches intact and pale. Both the lungs are lacerated and pale, pericardium lacerated, heart intact and pale, large vessels lacerated. On dissection of abdomen PW11 noticed, peritoneum lacerated, mouth, pharynx and pesophagus intact pale, stomach was containing biscuit coloured fluid measuring 200m.1 and mucosa was normal, the small and large intestines lacerated pale, liver and splen were lacerated. On dissection of genitos urinary system PW11 noticed that kidney were lacerated and pale and organs of generation external and internal penis and soroturn intact PW11 further noticed that the left pelvic bone, right public part of pelvic are fractured into multiple pieces, lower thorasic vertebra are crushed, lumbar verterbra dislocated from sacrum, spinal card was lacerated at fractured site.

    97. PW11 - Dr. P.K Devdsas has opined that death of Dr. N. Shivakumar was as a result of traumatic shock due to train running over his chest and abdomen.

    98. PW14 - Dr. K.H Manjunath conducted II postmortem examination on 30.7.2000 after the deadbody was exhumed. Dr. K.H Manjunath had noticed the following ante-mortem injuries.

    “1. On removal of above sutures, it is observed that the body is transacted at the level of 14 cms. below right nipple and 11 cms. below left nipple. Margins are dark stained all round-crushed injury.

    2. Lower third of right leg shows crushed injury with separate margins shows dark, spots. Exposing fracturedends of both leg bones fractured crevices shows dark spot.

    On dissection of scalp. PW14 Dr. K.H Manjunath noticed that the skull shows sawing of the vaust of the previous autopsy and that the skull shows depressed fracture over left side frontal bone, root of left orbit, left side of zygomatic arch and left maxilla over an area of 9 cms. × 4 cms. crevices shows dark spots skull cavity contains cloth pieces which are soiled and lower two thoracic vertebrae and upper two lumbar vertebrae were missing. On dissection of thorax PW14 Dr. K.H Manjunath noticed that right 9 to 12 ribs fractured at their middle, left 2 to 4 ribs fractured attaic middle and 9 to 12 ribs fractured near vertebrae ends fractured ends fractured end shows dark spots and the rest of the organs in the rorax were decomposed. On dissection of abdomen and urinary organs PW14 Dr. K.H Manjunath noticed that all the said organs were decomposed. PW14 Dr. K.H Manjunath noticed that the left collar bone fractured at the junction of inner two third and outer third, right thigh bone fractured at its middle, sacrum irregularly fractured and lower parts of both hip bones fractured and that fractured cervices of the bones shows dark spots.”

    99. PW14 - Dr. K.H Manjunath has opined that injuries were ante-mortem in nature and death was due to train running over the deceased.

    100. We find the evidence of PW 11 and PW14 that both of them had noticed fractures of skull bones.

    101. The investigation officer noticing the circumstances which had led to death of Dr. N. Shivakumar requested director of Health and Family Planning for further opinion. The Director of Health and Family Planning constituted an expert committee to give opinion relating to cause of death of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    102. At the relevant time, PW16-Dr. G.V Nagaraju was working as the Director of Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Karnataka. As per instructions given by the Commissioner of Health and Family Welfare Department, a Committee of five doctors was constituted to re-examine the post-mortem examination reports relating to deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar and furnish opinion as to the cause of his death. The Committee submitted the report as per Ex.P.36

    103. PW23-Dr. Mallikarjunaiah has deposed that from the year 1999 to 2003, he was working as the Deputy Director of Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Karnataka. At the relevant time, Dr. Chandrashekar was working as the Superintendent of Victoria Hospital. Dr. S.B Patil was working as a Professor in the Department of Forensic Medicine and Dr. Chandramma was working as the Superintendent of Bowring Hospital. At the relevant time, one Mr. Jahagirdhar was working as the Joint Director of Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Karnataka. The Commissioner for Health and Family Welfare Department had constituted a Committee consisting of Dr. Mallikarjunaiah, Dr. Chandrashekar, Dr. S.B Patil, Dr. Chandramma and Dr. Jahagirdhar. Apart from the above members, the Resident Medical Officer of Bowring Hospital and the Resident Medical Officer of Victoria Hospital were special invitees of the Committee.

    104. The members of the Committee and Special Invitees examined I & II post-mortem examination reports relating to deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar and furnished following opinion:-

    I. Injuries found in post-mortem examination report were properly described;

    II. Injuries found on deadbody of Dr. N. Shivakumar were of ante-mortem injuries and some of them were of different ages;

    III. Head injury (fracture of skull bone) could be caused in a railway accident, it could be caused by hitting the head with a blunt object:

    IV. Injury found on the head could be caused by hitting with a blunt object;

    V. Head injury was sufficient to render a person unconscious;

    VI. The other injuries found in I & II post-mortem examination reports could be caused if a person in an unconscious state is laid on railway track and run over by a train;

    VII. There was no histochemical examination. Therefore, Committee was not able to furnish exact time at which injuries were suffered.

    105. During cross-examination, PW23 has admitted injuries found in I & II post-mortem examination reports could be caused if a person is run over by a train.

    106. In the discussion made supra, we have narrated proved circumstances leading to death of Dr. N. Shivakumar. We have ruled out the possibility of deceased on his volition reaching the place of occurrence either from Bangalore or Mysore during intervening night of 9/10.6.2000. We have also taken into consideration gap between the point of time when deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3 and deceased was found dead. We have also taken into consideration location of place of occurrence and its distance from Mysore and Bangalore. Therefore, intervention of persons other than accused Nos. 1 to 3 and other intervening factors during the interregnum can safely be ruled out.

    107. The learned counsel for accused relying on a decision reported in 2005 ACR SCW 2394 has contended that if on same evidence two views are reasonably possible, the one in favour of accused must be preferred.

    108. In the discussion made supra, we have accepted evidence of prosecution that deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3. Considering the time gap between point of time when deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3 and point of time at which deceased was found dead we have ruled out the possibility of intervention of other persons. We have also ruled out the possibility of deceased on his volition reaching place of occurrence either from Bangalore or Mysore. We have rejected the contention of defence that deceased had suicidal tendency. Therefore the case on hand does not admit two reasonable views much less any reasonable view in favour of accused. Therefore we accept the opinion furnished by committee of doctors that deceased had been rendered unconscious by hitting him on his head with a blunt object and thereafter he was laid on the railway track for being run over by a train. We hold that prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that death of Dr. N. Shivakumar was homicidal in nature.

    109. We hold accused Nos. 1 to 3 committed these acts with an intention to kill the deceased and make it appear as a case of suicide.

    110. The prosecution has relied on evidence of PW15 Dr. Malini and scientific reports to prove that when accused Nos. 1 and 2 were subjected to polygraph and brain mapping tests their answers to incriminating questions were found deceptive.

    111. The learned counsel for accused relying on judgment of the Supreme Court reported in (1) Supreme Court of India Page 1009 (in the case of RANJITSING BRAHAMAJEETSING SHARMA v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA) has contended that when the prosecution has failed to establish that brain mapping test and polygraph tests are so developed the court cannot place reliance on evidence of PW15 and reports of polygraph and brain mapping tests.

    112. In the RANJIT SINGH's case the Supreme Court has held the question whether brain mapping test is so developed that report will have probative value so as to enable court to place reliance thereupon has been left undecided. Therefore, it is not necessary for us to lay emphasis on this aspect.

    113. The learned counsel for accused has submitted that prosecution has invoked Section 34 IPC. Therefore it is necessary for the prosecution to prove that accused Nos. 1 to 3 had shared common intention and prosecution has to prove involvement of each of the accused. There is no evidence on record to prove motive for accused Nos. 2 and 3. The evidence of prosecution to prove that deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3 is not credible. There is no evidence on record to infer prior meeting of minds of accused Nos. 1 to 3 to invoke Section 34 IPC.

    114. In the discussion made supra, we have referred to evidence of PW3 to PW6. PW3 to PW5 have deposed, that from the incesption viz., from 31.5.2000 accused No. 3 was acting at the behest of accused No. 1. Accused No. 3 and his associates had ransacked house of CW1 - Nanjappa during morning of 31.5.2000 The jurisdictional police-Chamarajapet police, had registered Crime No. 559/2000 against accused No. 1 - Rachaiah, accused No. 3 - Neelakant and two others for offences punishable under Sections 342, 365, 384, 447, 448, 427 and 506 IPC in relation to the occurrence that took place on 31.5.2000 in the house of deceased Nanjappa (father of Dr. N. Shivakumar), Accused No. 3 - Neelakant and two others were released on bail by I Addl. CMM by order dated 29.8.2001 The copy of order is available in records.

    115. We also find from evidence of PW6 that accused No. 3 was present and he had joined hands with accused Nos. 1 and 2 for getting discharge of Dr. N. Shivakumar against medical advice. Accused No. 3 - Neelakant and his associates had forcibly taken PW3 and PW4 from Bangalore to Mysore.

    116. PW6 has deposed that on 9.6.2000 at about 8.00 p.m accused No. 3 told her that accused Nos. 1 to 3 would take Dr. N. Shivakumar to Mysore and for that purpose they would get him discharged from hospital (Shekar Hospital). We find from records that accused No. 3 has affixed his signature to memo relating to discharge of Dr. N. Shivakumar against medical advice. Accused No. 3 was all along present with accused Nos. 1 and 2. If accused No. 3 had not shared common intention with accused Nos. 1 and 2 he would not have joined accused Nos. 1 and 2 in getting Dr. N. Shivakumar disharged from Shekar Hospital.

    117. When questioned under Section 313 Cr.P.C accused No. 3 admits to have got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar, however with consent of doctors. He had stated, PW6 had consented for the same. Accused No. 3 had paid a sum of Rs. 7,500/- towards hospital bill. He admits to have signed discharge memo. He admits that Dr. N. Shivakumar was being treated in intensive care unit from 1.6.2000 to 9.6.2000 He has stated that Dr. N. Shivakumar committed suicide. Thus evidence of PW 3 to PW6 proves beyond reasonable doubt that accused No. 3 was involved from the inception till the homicidal death of Dr. N. Shivakumar during intervening night of 9/10.6.2000.

    118. Now adverting to presence of accused No. 2 on 9.6.2000 in the company of accused Nos. 1 and 3 we have the positive evidence of PW6. In the missing report lodged by accused No. 1 on 10.6.2000 accused No. 1 has stated that accused Nos. 1 and 2 got discharged Dr. N. Shivakumar and brought him to the house of accused No. 1 at Mysore during intervening night of 9/10.6.2000.

    119. During investigation Maruthi car bearing No. KA-34.M-962 was seized from possession of accused No. 2. The evidence of PW27 - investigation Officer on this fact has not been controverted. The door mat of car showed presence of human blood stains as per FSL report marked as (Ex.P46). PW18 - N. Gundachandran, the then Asst. Director of Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Ramanathapuram, Tamilnadu, was examined to prove the contents of FSL report marked as Ex.P46 PW18 has deposed that door mat of car revealed presence of human blood. The evidence of PW18 and contents of Ex.P46 have not been controverted.

    120. The photographs of car bearing No. KA-34.M-962 are marked as Ex.P40 to Ex.P45

    121. When questioned under Section 313 Cr.P.C, Accused No. 2 has admitted (186 & 187) that PW27 - investigation officer, had seized car from his possession. Accused No. 2 has stated that Dr. N. Shivakumar committed suicide.

    122. The prosecution has proved that deceased was taken by accused Nos. 1 to 3 in maruthi car bearing No. KA-34.M-962 from Bangalore towards Mysore. The deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3. Therefore we hold that accused Nos. 1 to 3 had acted with pre-concert and they had shared common intention to commit the murder of Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    123. The learned counsel for accused has submitted that trial court had not framed charges against accused Nos. 1 to 3 for offences punishable under Sections 364 and 201 IPC. Therefore, conviction of accused 1 to 3 is vitiated.

    124. We see from records that trial court had framed charges on 19.2.2004 and additional charge on 30.9.2006 From the combined reading of charges framed on 19.2.2004 and 30.9.2006 it is clear that accused Nos. 1 to 3 were charged for an offence of abducting Dr. N. Shivakumar with an intention to commit his murder and that accused Nos. 1 to 3 were charged with an offence of causing disappearance of evidence in relation to commission of capital offence by laying body of Dr. N. Shivakumar on the railway track. Therefore, we reject the submission of learned counsel for accused.

    125. Thus to sum up, the prosecution has proved the following beyond reasonable doubt:

    (i) Accused Nos. 1 to 3 had motive to commit murder of deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar.

    (ii) On 9.6.2000 at about 10.00 p.m deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar was got discharged from Shekar Hospital against medical advice by accused Nos. 1 to 3.

    (iii) Accused Nos. 1 to 3 had forcibly taken deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar from Shekar Hospital.

    (iv) During intervening night of 9/10.6.2000 accused Nos. 1 to 3 forcibly took the deceased in car bearing No. KA-34.M-962 from Bangalore towards Mysore.

    (v) Deceased was last seen alive in the company of accused Nos. 1 to 3.

    (vi) That during intervening night of 9/10.6.2000 accused Nos. 1 to 3 had hit on the head of deceased with a blunt object and rendered him unconscious. Accused Nos. 1 to 3 with the intention of committing murder of Dr. N. Shivakumar and causing disappearance of evidence had laid body of deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar in unconscious state across railway track between Srirangapatna and Naguvanahally for being run over by a train. Deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar was run over by a train, and death of Dr. N. Shivakumar was homicidal.

    (vii) The conduct of accused Nos. 1 to 3 prior and subsequent to occurrence is entirely inconsistent with their innocence.

    (viii) Accused Nos. 1 to 3 being closely related to deceased Dr. N. Shivakumar had projected false theory of suicide.

    126. The evidence of prosecution in proof of above chain of circumstances is of conclusive tendency. The chain of circumstances proved by the prosecution is entirely consistent with guilt of accused Nos. 1 to 3 and inconsistent with the innocence of accused Nos. 1 to 3. All the aforestated incriminating circumstances have been fully established from evidence on record and only inference that could be drawn from the established circumstances is that accused Nos. 1 to 3 are guilty of offences punishable under Sections 364, 302, 201 IPC r/w. Section 34 IPC.

    127. Even though the learned trial judge has emphasised much on the evidence of PW15 and reports of polygraph and brain mapping tests yet the appreciation of evidence and conclusions arrived at on the circumstances stated supra by the learned sessions judge do not call for interference.

    128. In view of the foregoing discussion and for the reasons stated hereinbefore, we pass the following:

    129. The appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R. Rachaiah v. Station House Officer
    (Apr 22, 2009)