AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 522, 523, 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003 for contravention of Section 16(1)(a) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.read with Section 68 Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973,
  • SECTION 68 FOREIGN EXCHANGE REGULATION ACT 1973
  • 522, 523, 524, 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003 for contravention of Section 9(1)(c) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.(c)
  • provisions of Section 9(1)(c) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973,
  • Section 18(2) r/w Section 18(3) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.(b)
  • Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977,
  • Adulteration Act; or (3) violation of Cosmetic and Drugs Act
  • Section 16(1)(a) of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act., 1973
  • Section 16(1)(a) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.25.
  • Section 48 of Insolvency Act, 1986.On February 28, 1997,
  • Section 18(3) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act,
  • provisions of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1974.
  • Section 9(1)(c) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973
  • SECTION 291 COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Section 9(1)(c) of the FERA Act, 1973
  • Section 68 of the FERA Act, 1973,
  • Section 18(2) and Section 18(3)
  • NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
  • provisions of Section 16(1)(a)
  • 9(1)(c) of the FERA Act, 1973
  • FERA Act, 1973 [rule 9(1)(c)]
  • Section 9(1)(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • 522, 523, 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003 for contravention of Section 16(1)(a) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.read with Section 68 Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973,
  • SECTION 68 FOREIGN EXCHANGE REGULATION ACT 1973
  • 522, 523, 524, 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003 for contravention of Section 9(1)(c) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.(c)
  • provisions of Section 9(1)(c) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973,
  • Section 18(2) r/w Section 18(3) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.(b)
  • Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977,
  • Adulteration Act; or (3) violation of Cosmetic and Drugs Act
  • Section 16(1)(a) of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act., 1973
  • Section 16(1)(a) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.25.
  • Section 48 of Insolvency Act, 1986.On February 28, 1997,
  • Section 18(3) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act,
  • provisions of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1974.
  • Section 9(1)(c) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973
  • SECTION 291 COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Section 9(1)(c) of the FERA Act, 1973
  • Section 68 of the FERA Act, 1973,
  • Section 18(2) and Section 18(3)
  • NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
  • provisions of Section 16(1)(a)
  • 9(1)(c) of the FERA Act, 1973
  • FERA Act, 1973 [rule 9(1)(c)]
  • Section 9(1)(c)

    M/S Swil Ltd. v. The Special Director, Enforcement Directorate, New Delhi

    Pinaki Chandra Ghose, J.:— These appeals are directed against an order dated February 18, 2008, passed by the Appellate Tribunal for Foreign Exchange, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as “the learned Tribunal”). It appears that these nine appeals were filed before the learned Tribunal against a common Adjudication Order No. SDE(SSB)II/22 to 24/2003 dated 26th September, 2003, passed by Special Director, Enforcement Directorate, imposing different penalties against three Show Cause Notices as described below :-

    (a) a penalty of Rs. 25 lacs on the allegations contained in Show Cause Notice No. T-4/2-C/2000 dated 07.01.2000 against appellant-company and Rs. 5 lacs each against other four appellants in Appeal Nos. 522, 523 524/2003 & 1204/2004 for contravention of Section 18(2) r/w Section 18(3) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.

    (b) a penalty of Rs. 2 lacs on the allegations contained in Show Cause Notice No. 28-36/98.SCN/DD dated 17.04.1998 against appellant-company and Rs. 20,000/- each against other appellants in Appeal Nos. 522, 523, 524, 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003 for contravention of Section 9(1)(c) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.

    (c) a penalty of Rs. 40,000/- on the allegations contained in Show Cause Notice No. 37-45/98.SCN/DD dated 17.04.1998 against appellant-company and Rs. 4,000/- each against appellants in Appeal Nos. 522, 523, 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003 for contravention of Section 16(1)(a) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.

    read with Section 68 Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973, on the reasons that the appellants failed to take reasonable steps for repatriation of the export proceeds of UK Pound 422071.10 of the goods exported through 18 GRIs and for acknowledging a debt of UK Pound 22000 in favour of non-resident person and further not doing or refraining from doing anything which had the effect of not receiving foreign currency of UK Pound 7500. While disposing of application for dispensation of pre-deposit, this Tribunal allowed by order dated 11.05.2004 appellant in Appeal No. 521/2003 to make pre-deposit of Rs. 5 lacs which the appellant in Appeal No. 521/2003 has complied. Further, in Appeal Nos. 522, 523 & 524/2003, this Tribunal by order dated 11.05.2004 allowed the appellants to make pre-deposit of Rs. 1 lac each. Similarly, the appellants in Appeal Nos. 525, 526, 527 & 528/2003, each appellants were allowed to make pre-deposit of Rs. 5,000/-. However, in Appeal No. 1204/2004, the appellant was allowed full dispensation by order dated 19.05.2005 It is stated at Bar that the appellants have complied with the aforesaid different pre-deposit orders. Presently, these appeals are taken up for final disposal on merits.

    These appeals have arisen from a common order passed by the learned Tribunal for disposing of the appeals by a common order.

    After hearing the parties the learned Tribunal with regard to legal obligations of an exporter under Section 18(2) and Section 18(3) held that an exporter cannot do anything or refrain from doing anything which has the effect of not securing or delaying recovery of export proceeds except with the permission of Reserve Bank of India. If such permission is sought and given by the Reserve Bank of India there would be no contravention of Section 18(2) even if export proceeds are not realized. But if such permission is not sought at all or if sought but refused, the exporter will be guilty of the contravention in Section 18(2). In the instant case, the learned Tribunal also held that no reasonable or effective steps were taken by the appellants. On other point in respect of show-cause notice, the appellants agreed to allow a discount claim of U.K Pound 19046 in favour of foreign buyer M/s Bruce Clothing Ltd.

    The other show-cause Notice discussed in Para 2(c) above, has alleged non-receipt of U.S Dollars 7500 due to act or omission of the appellants and the appellants written to M/s Wellbred Asset Management (Bahamos) Ltd., requesting refund of U.S Dollars 7500 given for placement of preferential shares which later were not issued by the appellants.

    After analyzing the facts and the provisions the learned Tribunal in its order at Para 23, 24 & 25, held as follows :

    “23. The facts are admitted in these appeals so far as they relate to admittance of the claim of U.K Pound 19046 and Pound 22000. The letter dated 24.10.1996 from Shri Iqbal Singh of M/s Bruce Clothing Ltd. and another letter dated 5.12.1996 from the same person clearly describe admittance of the claim of reduction of price of the exported goods as well as the amount of reduced price described above. Thereafter, the appellants made a settlement in the recovery proceedings before Court in London foregoing amount identified by Shri Iqbal Singh of M/s Bruce Clothing Ltd. Here, not only the debt is acknowledged in favour of the non-resident but that debt is also paid by arrival of a settlement. If that is so, the appellants have no reason to say that acknowledgement has not been made in favour of non-resident person in violation of Section 9(1)(c) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 without permission of RBI. This is an admitted position that RBI was neither approached nor granted any permission to acknowledgement of debt claimed in the nature of reduction of the price of exported goods due to late shipment or quality of the goods. The actionable claim not only is acknowledged so that amount can be recovered in future but the incidence has come to the light after the payment had already been made. Therefore, the impugned order cannot be faulted with this arrival of guilt and there is no error found in the adjudication order.

    24. Lastly, we come to the third show-cause Notice discussed in Para 2(c) above. According to this Show-cause Notice, U.S Dollar 7500 was paid to M/s Wellbred Asset Management (Bahamas) Ltd. for processing the listing of preferential shares. This listing of preferential shares never occurred but the amount was neither refunded. The appellants have sent letter also to claim this amount but thereafter failed to do anything. As per Section 16(1)(a), the obligation on an individual who has right to receive foreign exchange from person resident outside India is to do a particular thing or refrain from doing anything whereby receipt of foreign exchange is delayed or lost. This is an admitted fact that U.S Dollar 7500 has not been received as yet which depicts act or omission on behalf of the appellants. Merely saying that the amount is too small and recovery was not possible can hardly absolve the appellants from their liability without permission from RBI. Though RBI has not given any directions under Section 16(2) to the appellants, but even without such directions the appellants are duty bound to refrain from any act or omission which has the effect of delayed receipt of the foreign exchange or foreign exchange is never received at all. Therefore, it is not possible to draw a conclusion in favour of the appellants as argued by Ld. Counsel that the appellants are required to be absolved from allegations of any act or omission in violation of Section 16(1)(a) Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.

    25. Lastly, this is an admitted fact that the appellant-company is a well recognized export house whose management resides, as per Section 291 Companies Act, 1956, in the Board of Directors. The other appellants, except appellant-company, are members of Board of Directors. However, the appellant in Appeal No. 524/2004 had been Vice-President. The provisions of Section 291 Companies Act, 1956 has specifically incorporated that except anything provided in the statute, the management of the company resides in and will be handled by the Board of Directors. As an established export house, the appellants are consistently making export and receiving payments in lieu thereof. Therefore, in this factual situation, the citations relied upon by the appellants which pertain to (1) issuance of cheque under Negotiable Instruments Act, (2) sale of an adulterated food under Food Adulteration Act; or (3) violation of Cosmetic and Drugs Act by sale of spurious drugs are generally individual acts not falling under concerted action of corporate management. Therefore, these judgments need no further discussion because all these judgments are distinguishable on facts.”

    The learned Tribunal held that these appeals have no merits and thus dismissed.

    Being aggrieved, these appeals have been filed.

    The Special Director of Enforcement, being the adjudicating officer imposed a penalty under Section 18(2) and Section 18(3) read with Section 68 of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act., 1973 (hereinafter referred to as the “FERA Act, 1973”) for a sum of Rs. 5 lacs for contravention of the said Sections and the subject matter of show cause notice bearing No. T-4/2-C/2000 dated January 7, 2000 and further imposed a penalty of Rs. 20,000/- in contravention of Section 9(1)(c) of the Act and the subject matter in relation to the show-cause notice bearing No. 28-36/98.SCN/DD dated April 17, 1998 and a penalty of Rs. 4,000/- for contravention of Section 16(1)(a) of the Act in relation to show-cause bearing No. 37-45/98.SCN/DD dated April 17, 1998.

    The facts of the case briefly are as follows :

    The company was a recognized export house. During April 1994 to March 1997, the company exported goods worth Rs. 63.56 crores. The company realized export bills excepting the bills which are subject matter of these appeals. The foreign buyer M/s. Bruce Clothing Ltd. of U.K had transactions earlier with the company and paid the full amount in respect of the export invoices. It appears that towards the end of 1995 the Company found that payments were not forthcoming from the U.K Company.

    The representatives of the Company duly met the Director of the U.K Company on number of occasions and the U.K Company agreed to make payments in due time which is a product of such meetings. The bills of exchange were also accepted by the U.K Company in favour of the Company but it appears that only one bill of exchange was honoured and nine bills of exchange of the aggregate value of U.K Pounds 2,87,519.76 stood dishonoured. The remaining bills of exchange of the value of U.K Pounds 2,09,551.34 had due dates falling on November 18, 1996 and thereafter. Therefore, the aggregate outstanding thus amounted to U.K Pounds 4,97,071.10.

    The company initiated legal proceedings in the High Court at U.K and the U.K Company claimed that after initiation of the proceedings, it was entitled to deduct 1,73,763.90 U.K Pounds on account of late delivery, quality, quantity, price difference etc. However, the Company agreed to give a discount of 22,000 U.K Pounds and the rest of the claim of the U.K Company was given up by the said Company and U.K Company agreed to pay 4,75,000 U.K Pounds in installments to the Company.

    On the basis of the negotiation which was reached between the parties, the U.K Company paid 60,000 U.K Pounds to the Indian Company and the Indian Company withdrew the proceeding which was pending before the U.K Court. The other installments as it appears that the U.K Company only paid 15,000 U.K Pounds and leaving an outstanding of 4,00,000 U.K Pounds subsequent thereto. The U.K Company went into administrative receivership convened pursuant to Section 48 of Insolvency Act, 1986.

    On February 28, 1997, the Company lodged its claim for the outstanding amount of 4,00,000 U.K Pounds before the Joint Administrative Receivers, but without any result. In March 1997, the Indian Company instituted another proceedings in the High Court at U.K for the said amount. On advice, the Company thought that it would not be fulfilled to incur any further expenditure towards litigation. In the meantime on November, 1999 the U.K Company was directed to be wound up. The company duly applied before the Reserve Bank of India from time to time for extension of time for realization of the export proceeds stated on the facts and circumstances and the developments of the said case and the time was extended by the Reserve Bank of India till 31st December, 1998. The Reserve Bank of India further pointed out that no further extension should be granted unless there was any substantial improvement in realization or investigation undertaken by the Enforcement Directorate. The company also applied for writing off the said outstanding before the Reserve Bank of India which is still pending.

    The Show-cause notice was issued to the Company on January 7, 2000 and the reply was also addressed by the company on 12 February, 2000. After taking into account all the facts as placed before the Special Directorate an adjudication order dated September 26, 2003 was made by the Special Directorate holding that the company had contravened the provisions of Sections 18(2) and 18(3) of the Act and imposed a penalty of Rs. 25 lacs.

    It was further held that the petitioner/company is liable for contravention of the said Sections, and, therefore, penalized the petitioner under Section 68 of the FERA Act, 1973, by imposing a penalty of Rs. 5 lacs. Then, an appeal was filed before the learned Tribunal and the learned Tribunal upheld the penalty awarded by the Special Director in respect of the alleged contravention of Section 9(1)(c) of the said Act.

    It is further submitted that in respect of the discount of 22,000 U.K Pounds, the said amount was allowed by the Company to the U.K Company on account of its claim while settling the proceedings initiated by the Company. It was a case of the Enforcement Directorate that the Company had thereby acknowledged a debt in favour of the U.K Company without the approval of the Reserve Bank of India which is in violation of Section 9(1)(c) of the said Act.

    The company contended that a discount allowed to the U.K Company cannot be treated to be an acknowledgment of any debt. However, on this ground the Special Directorate upheld the charge made in the Show-cause notice and imposed a penalty of Rs. 2 lacs on the Company. The company/petitioner was on such ground also found guilty under the provisions of Section 68 of the said Act and was penalized with a penalty of Rs. 20,000/-.

    The company further stated that it had paid 7,500 U.S Dollars by the name of Wellbred Asset Management (Bahamas) Limited as refundable processing and documentation cost for providing service by way of an arrangement of funds for the copper project proposed to be undertaken by the Company. The said payment was made in the normal and usual course of business. However, the said overseas company could not arrange the funds and, as such, the company requested for refund of the said amount. The company did not receive any refund since the costs initiating legal proceedings for recovery of the said amount were estimated to be more than the refund claimed and for such reason the company did not consider it prudent to pursue the said claim.

    In respect of the said claim, the show-cause notice was also issued on this ground for violation of Section 16(1)(a) and Section 16(1)(b) of the Act. It appears from the fact that without the permission of the Reserve Bank of India, the company refrained from doing anything which amounts to contravention of Section 16(1)(b) of the Act. As a result, whereof, the Special Director imposed a penalty of Rs. 40,000/- on that ground also.

    The Tribunal by its order dated February 18, 2008 wrongfully and illegally upheld the said penalties imposed by the Special Director and according to Mr. Chatterjee, learned Senior Advocate, appearing in support of these applications, submitted that the imposition of the said penalties upholding the findings of the Special Director that the Company had contravened the provisions of Sections 18(2) and 18(3) of the said Act and upheld the penalty of Rs. 25 lacs are arbitrary, unreasonable and perverse.

    It is further submitted that the learned Tribunal failed to consider the facts and materials on record that the Company took various steps in the matter of recovery of the said dues from the U.K Company. The learned Tribunal failed to consider that the Company had bona fide and diligently pursued the claim and had taken all reasonable steps to secure the realization of the outstanding amount and incurred huge expenditure for the said purpose.

    It is further submitted by Mr. Chatterjee that the learned Tribunal failed to consider the facts of the case and did not consider that all possible steps were taken by the Company for realization of the amounts in question. It is further submitted that the learned Tribunal failed to consider that the entire proceedings including the imposition of penalty were arbitrary inasmuch as the Company's application for writing off the amount outstanding by the U.K Company was pending with the Reserve Bank of India for adjudication.

    Hence, he submitted that on this ground alone the order should be set aside.

    He further submitted that the settlement cannot be treated as an acknowledgement of any debt within the meaning of Section 9(1)(c) of the Act in question. Therefore, there was no contravention of the said provisions by the Company.

    Mr. Chatterjee further submitted that it cannot be said that by not obtaining refund of the sum of 7,500 U.S Dollars paid for services in the matter of arrangement of funds can be treated as contravention of the provisions of Section 16(1)(a) of the said Act.

    He further relied on the decision in the case of Director of Enforcement v. New Central Jute Mills Co. Ltd., reported in AIR 1991 Supreme Court 719, where the Court held that the High Court has jurisdiction even to examine the justification for the quantum of penalty.

    He also relied upon the decision in the case of Commissioner of Income-Tax (Central), Calcutta v. Daulat Ram Rawaatmull, reported in ITR (1973) page 349 Vol. 87 page 349 and submitted that when a Court of fact deals with acts on material partly relevant and partly irrelevant, it is impossible to say that to what extent the mind of the Court was affected by the irrelevant material used by it in arriving at its finding. Such a finding is vitiated because of the use of inadmissible material and thereby an issue of law arises. Likewise, if the Court of fact bases its decision partly on conjecture, surmises and suspicions and partly on evidence, in such a situation an issue of law arises.

    On the contrary, Mr. Pradeep Tarafdar, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent drew our attention to Sections 18(2) and 18(3) of the said Act which are reproduced hereunder :

    “18. Payment for exported goods :

    (1) ………………………………………………………

    18(2) : Where any export of goods to which a notification under clause (a) of subsection (1) applies, has been made, no person shall, except with the permission of the Reserve Bank, do or refrain from doing anything, or take or refrain from taking any action, which has the effect of securing -

    (A) in a case falling under sub-clause (i) or sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) of sub section (1),

    (a) that payment for the goods -

    (i) is made otherwise than in the prescribed manner, or

    (ii) is delayed beyond the period prescribed under clause (a) of subsection (1), or

    (b) that the proceeds of sale of the goods exported do not represent the full export value of the goods subject to such deductions, if any, as may be allowed by the Reserve Bank; and

    (B) in a case falling under sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) of sub-section (1), also that the sale of the goods is delayed to an extent which is unreasonable having regard to the ordinary course of trade;

    Provided that no proceedings in respect of any contravention of the provisions of this sub-section shall be instituted unless the prescribed period has expired and payment for the goods representing the full export value has not been made in the prescribed period.

    18(3) : Where in relation to any goods to which a notification under clause (a) of sub-section (1) applies the prescribed period has expired and payment therefore has not been made as aforesaid, it shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved by the person who has sold or is entitled to sell the goods or to procure the sale thereof, that such person has not taken all reasonable steps to received or recover the payment for the goods as aforesaid and he shall accordingly be presumed to have contravened the provisions of sub-section (2).”

    He further submitted that an exporter cannot do anything or refrain from doing anything which has the effect of not securing or delaying recovery of export proceeds except with the permission from the Reserve Bank of India. He further submitted that if a person asks for any permission from the Reserve Bank of India to do something or restrain from doing anything and if such permission is granted then there cannot be any contravention of Section 18(2) of the said Act, even if export proceeds are not realized. He further submitted that if such permission is not sought either, or if sought but refused the exporter must be held as guilty of contravention of Section 18(2) of the said Act if he fails to prove that he had taken the effective or reasonable steps as in the circumstances of this case would have been reasonably taken by a prudent man dealing in export business.

    Therefore, according to him, the charges as against the Company that they have not taken any reasonable steps in the matter which ought to have been taken by a prudent exporter are not maintainable. He further contended that it is an admitted fact that the exporter could not bring the export price even within the extended period which was granted by the Reserve Bank of India. Therefore, it would attract Section 18(3) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973.

    He further contended that the most important thing is that reasonable steps have to be taken by an exporter. The meaning of ‘reasonable’ has been given in the legal dictionary, even in the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of E.S.I Corporation v. C.C Santhakumar, reported in JT 2006 (10) SC 549, where the Supreme Court held as follows :

    “35. A reasonable period would depend upon the factual circumstances of the case concerned. There can not be any empirical formula to determine that question. The Court/authority considering the question whether the period is reasonable or not has to take into account the surrounding circumstances and relevant factors to decide that question.

    36. In Sate of Gujrat v. Patel Raghav Natha 1969 (2) SCC 187 it was observed that when even no period of limitation was prescribed, the power is to be exercised within a reasonable time and the limit of the reasonable time must be determined by the facts of the case and nature of the order which was sought to be varied. This aspect does not appear to have been specifically kept in view by the Division Bench. Additionally, the points relating to applicability of the Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977, and even if it is held that the Act was applicable, the reasonableness of the time during which action should have been initiated were also not considered. It would be hard to give an exact definition of the work “reasonable” Reason varies in its conclusions according to the idiosyncrasy of the individual and the times and circumstances in which he thinks. The reasoning which built up the old scholastic logic stands now like the jingling of a child's joy. But mankind must be satisfied with the reasonableness within reach; and in cases not covered by authority, the decision of the Judge usually determines what is “reasonable” in each particular case; but frequently reasonableness “belongs to the knowledge of the law, and therefore to be decided by the courts”. It was illuminatingly stated by a learned author that an attempt to give a specific meaning to the word “reasonable” is trying to count what is not a number and measure what is of space. It means prima facie in law reasonable in regard to those circumstances of which the actor, called upon to act reasonably, knows or ought to know. (See: Municipal Corpn, of Delhi v. Jagan Nath Ashok Kumar 1987 (4) SCC 497 and Gujrat Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. Unique Erectors (Gujrat) (P) Ltd. 1989 (1) SCC 532. As observed by Lord Romilly, M.R In Labouchere v. Dawson 41 LJ Ch 472 it is impossible a priori to state what is reasonable as such in all cases. You must have the particular facts of each case established before you can ascertain what is reasonable under the circumstances. Reasonable, being a relative term is essentially what is national according to the dictates of reason and not excessive or immoderate on the facts and circumstances of the particular case”.

    He also drew our attention to paragraph 11 of the decision of the learned Tribunal where the learned Tribunal has correctly held that the “reasonable steps” always depends on the circumstances of each case and there cannot be any fixed or right formula for the same.

    He further drew our attention to the Show-cause notice which was issued to the petitioner/company and he submitted that the steps which were taken by the Company and the proceedings initiated before the Court would show that the amount claimed as export proceeds by the company is higher than that of the claim made in the suit by the appellant.

    He also submitted that the export proceeds were 4,22,071.10 U.K Pound, whereas the suit was filed for 2,87,519.76 U.K Pound. He further pointed out that the settlement which was reached between the appellant Company and the U.K Company and the settlement arrived at only for 60,000 U.K Pound and the Company agreed to reduce its claim to 20,000 U.K Pound. Therefore, from such fact it would be evident that the amount so received by the company are far less than the amount claimed in the suit and further the petitioner/company after the settlement received 20,000 U.K Pound and withdrew the suit but the remaining 40,000 U.K Pound was not received since it is admittedly received by the appellant themselves that only 15,000 U.K Pound was substantially reduced.

    The facts also stated that the U.K Company gone into liquidation but, it is to be noted that the said order so passed only on 19 of January, 1998 till then no proper steps were taken by the Company to realize its claim. Therefore, he submitted that the Company did not take any steps reasonably which ought to have been taken by them. Therefore, on this ground he submitted that the learned Tribunal correctly explained the decision in its order and held against the appellant in respect of the violation of Section 9(1)(c) of the said Act.

    He submitted that an acknowledgment of a debt in favour of non-resident person without the permission of the Reserve Bank of India, attracts Section 9(1)(c) of the said Act and the learned Tribunal has correctly came to the conclusion. So far the show-cause notice issued in terms of Section 16(1)(a), the Company had no right to write off the claim without due permission from the Reserve Bank of India. Hence, the question of giving any relief to the appellant with regard to the violation of Section 16(1)(a) of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act., 1973 also cannot be accepted. The penalty amount which has been imposed cannot be said to be excessive and he contended that there is no ground as made out by the petitioner/company to admit this appeal.

    After hearing the learned Advocates for the parties and after analyzing the facts of this case, it appears to us that there is no dispute that the appellant company failed to repatriate export proceeds within six months. This period has specifically mentioned under Rule 8 framed under the provisions of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1974. It appears to us that adjudicating authority and the learned Tribunal both came to the conclusion on the basis of the evidence and the materials placed before them.

    Therefore, the said rules are binding on every exporter. It is also admitted that the payments were made by M/s Bruce Clothing Ltd. of U.K for the sum of 37,350 U.K Pound which was admittedly received by the appellant in September, 1996. Therefore, within six months it appears that the appellant inspite of the undertaking given before the authority only brought the part of the amount in the country.

    It further appears that the appellants filed a recovery suit in the High Court at U.K claiming the amount of 2,87,519.76 U.K Pound but it cannot be brushed aside the fact that the total amount of export proceeds is much more than the said amount and in fact the said export proceeds were 4,22,071.10 U.K Pound. No answer was given by the petitioner/company that why the recovery suit was filed only for 287519.76 U.K Pound and not for the whole amount. No documents in support of the said suit were disclosed before the Tribunal nor even the date of filing of the recovery suit was provided to the Tribunal which was specifically recorded by the learned Tribunal in its judgment. We also do not find any reason why the exporter did not disclose this material before the authority when it is an obligation on the part of the exporter under Section 18(1)(a) of the said Act to disclose all material particulars including full export value of the accounts as well as the total period during which the export value is likely to be repatriated.

    The appellant has stated that reasonable steps were taken but, after analyzing the facts and the steps which were taken by the appellant, we have come to the conclusion and accept the opinion expressed by the learned Tribunal. The appellant did not take reasonable steps in the matter which, in fact, the appellant was duty bound under the provisions of law. It appears to us that the appellant has failed to take proper steps in the matter in question. We have not been able to find out any reason and also the other fact which is being admitted that why the appellant when reached in the settlement only received a part thereof and withdrew the suit.

    In the case of Union of India v. Bata India Ltd., reported in AIR 1991 Cal. 365 (Para 16) where the Court observed as follows :

    “In our view, on the facts and in the circumstances of this case, the provisions of Section 9(1)(c) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973, cannot be pressed into service. This section provides that no person in, or resident in India, shall draw, issue or negotiate any Bill of Exchange or Promissory Note to acknowledge any debt so that a right to receive payment is created or transferred in favour of any person resident outside India. Unless the conditions as enumerated in Section 9(1)(c) of the Act co-exist, no liability can be fastened on the respondent company. Section 9(1)(c) of the act stipulates that there should be a debt and lastly such acknowledgment must give right to the foreign company to claim the amount so that it can be recovered”.

    Hon'ble Court further observed in Para 17 of the said case as under :

    “Thus there must be an actionable claim on the basis of which either party cannot only lay its claim but also withdraw the amount. Debt is therefore a sum payable in respect of a liquidated money demand recoverable by action.”

    It is necessary for us to quote 9(1)(c) of the FERA Act, 1973 which reads as follows :

    “9. Restrictions on payments (1) Save as may be provided in, an in accordance with any general or special exemption from the provisions of this sub-section which may be granted conditionally or unconditionally be the Reserve Bank, no person in, or resident in, India shall -

    (a) ………………………………………………………………………………

    (b) ………………………………………………………………………………

    (c) Draw, issue or negotiate any bill or exchange or promissory note or acknowledge any debt, so that a right (whether actual or contingent) to receive a payment is created or transferred in favour of any person resident outside India”.

    From the above provisions, it is clear that no person in, or resident in, India shall draw, issue or negotiate any bill of exchange or promissory note so that a right to receive payment is created or transferred in favour of any person resides outside India. Further, an acknowledgment of a debt in favour of a non-resident person is prohibited in absence of any permission from Reserve Bank of India.

    We do not have any hesitation to hold that the acknowledgment has not been made in favour of non-resident person for violation of Section 9(1)(c) of the said Act without permission of the Reserve Bank of India. From the facts it appears that at no point of time the Reserve Bank of India was neither approached nor any permission was granted to the appellants to acknowledge a debt claim in the nature of rejection of the price exported goods due to delay shipment or quality of the goods. Therefore, we do not find that there is any reason to accept the contention of the appellants.

    It appears to us that in terms of Section 16(1)(a) of the said Act there is an obligation on a person who has the right to receive the Foreign Exchange from person resides outside India has to do a particular thing or refrain from doing anything whereby the receipt of Foreign Exchange is delayed or lost.

    Admittedly, it appears to us that an exporter cannot do anything or refrain from doing anything which has the effect of not securing or delaying recovery of export proceeds except with the permission from the Reserve Bank of India. Admittedly, in the instant case, the exporter has failed to comply in accordance with the provisions of law. He further submitted that if a person asks for any permission from the Reserve Bank of India to do something or restrain from doing anything and if such permission is granted then there cannot be any contravention of Section 18(2) even if export proceeds are not realized. Admittedly, in the instant case, the exporter has failed to comply with the provisions of FERA Act, 1973. It appears that the Reserve Bank of India has extended the time and thereafter did not accede to the prayer made by the petitioner. The moot question in this matter as it appears from the fact that the appellant/petitioner failed to take reasonable steps for repatriation of export proceeds. The Supreme Court on the question of reasonable time has specifically stated in E.S.I Corporation v. C.C Santhakumar (Supra), it appears to us that on the given facts the petitioners cannot get any benefit or can be said to be fulfilled the meaning of reasonable steps which have been taken by them. It is true that there is no fixed or rigid formula which can the meaning of reasonable steps depends upon the facts and the circumstances of each case. Therefore, taking into account the facts of this case, in our considered opinion, the petitioner has failed to take reasonable steps for repatriation of the FERA Act, 1973. It is also a fact that there is no explanation given by the appellant/petitioner that when the claim on export proceeds is much more higher i.e U.K Pound 422071.10, then why the appellants filed recovery suit only of U.K Pound 287519.76

    Mere filing of recovery suit would not show the efforts on behalf of the petitioner/appellant to pursue the litigation or the same cannot be termed as reasonable steps. It further appears from the FERA Act, 1973 [rule 9(1)(c)] that no person can draw, issue or negotiate any bill or exchange or promissory note or acknowledge any debt, so that a right to receive a payment is created or transferred in favour of any person resident outside India. Furthermore, an acknowledgment of debt in favour of non-resident person is prohibited in absence of any permission from Reserve Bank of India. From the facts it is admitted that claim of reduction of price of the exported goods as well as amount of reduced price has been made in favour of non-resident person in violation of Section 9(1)(c) of the FERA Act, 1973 without permission of Reserve Bank of India.

    This is an admitted position that the Reserve Bank of India was neither approached nor granted any permission to acknowledgement of debt claimed in the nature of reduction of the price of exported goods due to late shipment or quality of the goods. The obligation of an individual who has right to receive foreign exchange from person resident outside India is to do a particular thing in accordance with the provisions of Section 16(1)(a) of the said Act and it is an admitted fact that U.S Dollar 7500 has not been received and therefore, the appellant is liable for contravention of the said Section. Consequently, under Section 16(2) of the said Act the appellants are duty bound to refrain from any act or omission which is the effect of delayed receipt of the foreign exchange. Therefore, it comes within the four corners of Section 16(1)(a) of the said Act.

    In these circumstances, we cannot find any reason to hold that the order so passed by the learned Tribunal suffers from any illegality or irregularity.

    In this factual matrix we have to come to the conclusion that there is no merit in these appeals and we also do not find any illegality or irregularity in respect of the order so passed by the learned Tribunal.

    Hence, all the these appeals are dismissed and the order so passed by the learned Tribunal, is affirmed.

    Urgent Xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties subject to compliance with all requisite formalities.

    SANKAR PRASAD MITRA, J.

    I agree.

    LATER :

    Mr. Ritobrato Mitra, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant has prayed for stay of operation of this judgment. Such prayer is granted and stay is allowed for eight weeks.

    SANKAR PRASAD MITRA, J.

    I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S Swil Ltd. v. The Special Director, Enforcement Directorate, New Delhi
    (Jul 29, 2009)