Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 28 of the Rules of 1971
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 28 of the Rules of 1971
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Dr. Vineet Kothari, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions concern persons engaged as "Vidhyarthi Mitra" on contract to undertake teaching work in schools under a State scheme. The petitioners challenged the termination/non-continuation of their contractual engagements and sought continuation of service. Several related writ petitions involving Vidhyarthi Mitras had been decided earlier by Single Bench and Division Bench orders of this Court, and those precedents were invoked by the petitioners' counsel.

Administrative communications from the State are central to the factual matrix: a letter dated 4.6.2010 from the Deputy Secretary, Elementary Education Department communicated that Vidhyarthi Mitras employed for the 2009-2010 academic session shall be continued for the 2010-2011 session; a subsequent letter dated 26.6.2010 from the Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner sought guidance on adding language to facilitate transfer and absorption of such Vidhyarthi Mitras under the State's Rationalisation and Equalisation policy. The respondent's counsel did not dispute the existence of these communications.

Procedurally, the learned Single Judge heard learned counsels, considered prior Single Bench and Division Bench decisions (including an extract from a decision dated 25.5.2010 in SBCWP No. 8987/2009), and referred to a Division Bench judgment in D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 580/2009 (SBCWP No. 4187/2009). The present writ petitions were disposed of by reference to those judicial decisions and the State communications of 4.6.2010 and 26.6.2010.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked in the Academic Session 2009-2010 should have their contractual engagement continued until the end of Academic Session 2010-2011.
  2. Whether such Vidhyarthi Mitras should be considered for transfer and absorption under the State's Rationalisation and Equalisation Policy (including transfers to other Blocks/Tehsils/Districts) as requested by the Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner.
  3. Whether Vidhyarthi Mitras engaged on a contractual basis are entitled to salary for vacation periods (i.e., when schools are closed).
  4. Whether contractual Vidhyarthi Mitras can claim regularization of service, equal pay, or other rights applicable to regularly appointed teachers (as addressed in prior decisions).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rekha Ram v. State of Rajasthan (SBCWP No. 8987/2009) — judgment dated 25.5.2010 Disposition of writ petitions of Vidhyarthi Mitras in specific terms; incorporation of directions given in earlier connected writ petitions. The Court relied on this decision and quoted an excerpt to dispose of the present writ petitions in the same terms, adopting the directions contained therein.
Sandroop v. State of Rajasthan (SBCWP No. 9173/2009) — decided 19.3.2010 Earlier coordinate decision on similar issues concerning Vidhyarthi Mitras (referential authority). The Single Judge noted that Rekha Ram followed Sandroop and treated these authorities as governing the present petitions.
D.B. Civil Special Appeal No. 580/2009 (in SBCWP No. 4187/2009) — Division Bench decision Division Bench consideration of identical issues; dismissal of similar appeals referencing contractual nature of posts and related reliefs. The Division Bench's conclusions were cited and the Single Judge expressed no reason to differ; its approach influenced dismissal of identical appeals and supported the directions given.
Devendra Kumar v. State (S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2578/09) — decided 15.5.2009 Directions that respondents consider continuation of petitioners in service until regularly selected candidates are available; clarification regarding genuineness of documents and continuity of working. The directions from Devendra Kumar were incorporated into the reasoning and used as a basis for ordering continuation of service subject to the conditions identified in that decision.
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 4652/09 and connected matters — decided 8.5.2009 Further directions on continuation in service and related clarifications for similarly situated contractual employees. The Single Judge incorporated the directions of the 8.5.2009 decision into the present dispositional order and relied on those principles in granting relief to the petitioners.
Rajendra Kumar Saini v. State of Rajasthan — reported in 2010 (1) WLC (Raj.) 171 Holding that appellants engaged on contractual basis are not entitled to claim regularization, equal pay, or salary during summer vacations. The Division Bench's treatment of similar appeals in Rajendra Kumar Saini was noted; its holdings (no claim to regularization/equal pay/salary during vacations) were accepted and applied by the Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeded primarily by reference to earlier Single Bench and Division Bench authorities dealing with identical or closely similar questions concerning contractual Vidhyarthi Mitras. The judge accepted the principle established in those precedents that, while contractual incumbents engaged as Vidhyarthi Mitras are not entitled to regularization or equal pay and are not entitled to salary during vacation periods, equitable administrative directions may be issued to preserve continuity of education until regularly selected candidates are available.

Concretely, the Court relied on:

  • Previously issued directions (as set out in Devendra Kumar and connected matters) that respondents should consider continuation of contractual employees until regularly selected candidates from RPSC/DPC become available, subject to verification of genuineness of documents and continuity of work.
  • Division Bench precedent holding contractual appointees cannot claim regularization, equal pay, or wage entitlement for vacations (as noted in Rajendra Kumar Saini and related orders), which the Court accepted as not distinguishable.
  • Recent administrative communications from the Deputy Secretary (4.6.2010) and the Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner (26.6.2010), which indicated administrative intent to continue Vidhyarthi Mitras of the 2009-2010 session into 2010-2011 and suggested facilitation of transfer and absorption under the Rationalisation and Equalisation policy.

On that combined basis (judicial precedents + State communications), the Court ordered respondents to continue the contracts of those Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked for Academic Session 2009-2010 until the end of Academic Session 2010-2011 and to consider their cases for transfer and absorption under the Rationalisation and Equalisation Policy. The Court explicitly limited the relief: continuation until the end of 2010-2011 only, with no automatic right to continue thereafter unless the State decides otherwise. The Court also clarified that the portion of earlier directions concerning preparation of a State-level seniority list remained stayed in light of a Division Bench order.

Finally, the Court extended the administrative relief to all similarly situated Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked in 2009-2010, even if they had not filed writ petitions, obliging respondents to treat them uniformly. By contrast, Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked only in 2008-2009 (or before) but not in 2009-2010 were held not to be entitled to the same relief unless representations are made and vacancies are available; in that event their cases may be considered or a common order may be passed by the Principal Secretary.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were disposed of by directing that the respondents shall continue the contract employment of Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked for Academic Session 2009-2010 up to the end of Academic Session 2010-2011, and shall consider their transfer and absorption under the Rationalisation and Equalisation Policy, in accordance with the State communications dated 4.6.2010 and 26.6.2010 and the judicial precedents cited.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: Petitioners (Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked in 2009-2010) receive continuation of contractual engagement through the 2010-2011 academic year and consideration for transfer/absorption under the State policy.
  • Scope and limitation: The Court expressly limited the relief to continuation until the end of Academic Session 2010-2011. The decision does not confer any automatic right to continue beyond that date; continuation thereafter depends solely on any subsequent decision by the State Government.
  • Uniform application: The directions apply to all similarly situated Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked in 2009-2010, whether or not they individually approached the Court.
  • Those who worked only in 2008-2009 (or earlier) but not in 2009-2010 are not entitled to the same relief, though representation and consideration are permitted where vacancies remain.
  • Relation to precedent: The Court disposed of the petitions by following earlier Single Bench and Division Bench decisions and by applying the State administrative communications; it did not purport to overrule or create a novel legal principle distinct from those prior rulings.

Administrative note in the order: Petitioners' counsel were directed to submit court fees of Rs. 25 per petitioner where applicable, and certified copy of the order may be issued only upon payment.

    Prahalad Kumar Sharma v. State Of Rajasthan & Ors.

    Dr. Vineet Kothari, J.:— Heard the learned counsels.

    2. The learned counsels for the petitioners submitted that the controversy involved in these cases are squarely covered by the decision of this Court dtd. 25.5.2010 rendered in SBCWP No. 8987/2009 Rekha Ram v. State Of Rajasthan (99) by which this Court following earlier decision in the case of Sandroop v. State of Rajasthan - SBCWP No. 9173/2009 decided on 19.3.2010 and the Division Bench judgment in DBSAW No. 580/2009 decided on 15.2.2010, disposed of the writ petitions of Vidhyarthi Mitras in same terms. The Relevant extract of the said judgment is quoted below for ready reference:

    “The learned counsel for the parties submit that part of Condition No. 4 has been stayed by the Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court Bench, Jaipur, however, that will not affect the fate of these writ petitions and both the counsel submit that similar directions, subject to the effect of the interim order as passed by the Division Bench of the Jaipur Bench of the High Court, may be passed in these matters also.

    In view of the above reasons, all these writ petitions are disposed of in the light of the directions issued in the S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 2578/09 Devendra Kumar v. State and connected matters decided vide judgment dated 15.5.2009 and in the light of the decision given in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 4652/09 and connected matters decided on 8.5.2009 with further clarification that the petitioners may satisfy the competent authority, who may be District Education Officer or the Block Elementary Education Officer about the genuineness of the documents as well as continuity of their working in the year 2008-2009.

    The directions given in the above writ petitions are incorporated in these writ petitions which are as under:—

    I. During continuation of the work, as detailed out hereinabove, the invocation of the last extension is arbitrary and illegal; and the consequential automatic termination orders of the petitioners are set aside.

    II. The RPSC/DPC selected candidates/employees are still not available and next academic temporary appointments to start; even urgent temporary appointments under Rule 28 of the Rules of 1971 are not possible due to short span of one month and a half left to start with the process of admission and academic session, therefore, as per the aims and objects of the Scheme, respondents are directed to consider the cases of the petitioners for continuation in service till regularly selected candidates from RPSC/persons selected and recommended by the DPC for promotion are made available in the light of the above observations;

    III. Even in case of appropriate order of continuation in service till regularly selected candidates from RPSC/DPC selected persons are available, the petitioners are not entitled for wages of the vacations, in other words, when the schools are closed.

    IV. In case the regularly selected candidates from RPSC/persons selected and recommended by the DPC for promotion are made available, then the respondents can terminate services of the petitioners after preparation of the seniority list on the State level as per their date of appointment and merit assigned to them, by following the principle of ‘last come first go’ to the extent of availability of the selected candidates and while doing so, the respondents will keep the interest of the present students and prospective students in view.”

    It is further made clear that the portion which has been stayed by the Division Bench of this Court shall remain stayed in the light of the order of the Division Bench and that is about the preparation of the seniority list at State level.

    The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners are also directed to submit the court fees of Rs. 25/- for each of the petitioners in case it is a joint writ petition and certified copy of this order may be issued to the petitioners only subject to payment of this Court fee.

    (PRAKASH TATIA), J.”

    3. The Division Bench of this Court in D.B Civil Special Appeal No. 580/2009 in SBCWP No. 4187/2009 has held as under:

    “These appeals involving identical issues have been considered together and are taken up for disposal by this common order.

    The appellants-petitioners were engaged as “Vidhyarthi Mitra” to undertake teaching work in schools on contract basis under the scheme framed by the State Government; they approached this Court by filing the respective writ petitions stating the grievance, inter alia, that their services would not be continued after summer break. It appears that the engagement of some of incumbents continued during the pendency of the litigation pursuant to the orders passed by the Court. Thereafter, a batch of petitions involving similar issues was decided at Jaipur Bench of this Court on 08.05.2009 with certain directions essentially to the effect that the respondents shall consider the cases of the petitioners for continuation in service until the regular selections were made but with the observations that the petitioners would not be entitled for salary during the period of vacations i.e, when the schools remain closed. Following the said decision, the respective writ petitions as preferred by the present appellants have been decided by the learned Single Judge of this Court in the same terms and with the same directions. Hence, these appeals.

    It is noticed that the intra-court appeals as filed at the Jaipur Bench against the order dated 08.05.2009 have since been considered and dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Rajendra Kumar Saini v. State of Rajasthan, reported in 2010 (1) WLC (Raj.) 171.

    In the said decision, this Court has clearly held while dismissing the similar nature appeals that the appellants-petitioners are not entitled to claim regularization on the post on which appointments were given on contractual basis; that the appellants-petitioners, not appointed as per the recruitment rules, are not entitled to make a claim for equal pay; and they are not entitled to make a claim of salary for summer vacations.

    We do not find any ground to differ from the view already expressed by the co-ordinate Bench.

    Accordingly, these appeals stand dismissed. No costs.

    (Dinesh Maheshwari), J.

    (A.M Sapre), J.”

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that vide letter dtd. 4.6.2010 Annex. 1 in SBCWP No. 6106/2010, the Dy. Secretary, Elementary Education Department of the State has already communicated to the Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner that such Vidhyarthi Mitras employed on contract basis of the Academic Session 2009-2010 shall be continued for Academic Session 2010-2011 and therefore, the petitioners' contract for service as Vidhyarthi Mitras upto the end of Academic Session 2010-2011 can be continued in terms of said order. However, he submitted that under the Rationalisation and Equalisation policy of the State Government for declaring the teachers/Vidhyarthi Mitras as surplus in the schools in order to maintain ratio of teachersstudents, the Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner had sought guidance from the Dy. Secretary, Elementary Education, Government of Rajasthan vide Annex. 4 dtd. 26.6.2010 that in the aforesaid communication dtd. 4.6.2010 if additional line about the Vidhyarthi Mitras to be transferred and absorbed in other blocks/Tehsils and Districts against the vacant post may also be absorbed is added, that would facilitate the transfer and absorption under Rationalisation/Equalisation Policy of the State Government, of present Vidhyarthi Mitras also. The contents of letters dtd. 4.6.2010 and 26.6.2010 are reproduced hereunder for ready reference:

    5. Mr. R.L Jangid, learned AAG does not dispute existence of these two communications.

    6. In view of aforesaid, these writ petitions are also disposed of in view of earlier decision of this Court by Single Bench as well as Division Bench and aforesaid quoted decisions of the State Government vide letter dtd. 4.6.2010 and 26.6.2010 and the respondents shall continue the contract of employment of present Vidhyarthi Mitras petitioners who have worked for Academic Session 2009-2010 till the end of Academic Session 2010-2011 and shall also consider the case of present petitioners — Vidhyarthi Mitras for transfer and absorption under the Rationalisation and Equalisation Policy also in other Blocks/Tehsil and Districts as requested by the Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner vide letter dtd. 26.6.2010 to the Principal Secretary, School and Sanskrit Education, Jaipur vide Annex. 4 dtd. 26.6.2010 The decision shall not confer any right on the petitioners — Vidhyarthi Mitras to continue in said position after the end of Academic Session 2010-2011 unless State Government itself takes a decision otherwise in this regard.

    7. These directions will apply to the present petitioners and all other similarly situated Vidhyarthi Mitras who have worked for Academic Session 2009-2010, even if they have not approached this Court by way of a writ petition and the respondents will be bound to give similar treatment to all other similarly situated person without requiring them to approach this Court by way of fresh writ petition.

    8. Those Vidhyarthi Mitras who worked for the Academic Session 2008-2009 or prior to that but did not work as such for the Academic Session 2009-2010, are not entitled to the aforesaid relief as such. However, if such Vidhyarthi Mitras make any representation and vacancies are still available with the State Government for Academic Session 2010-2011, their cases may be considered for reemployment. If however, it is not found appropriate to re-employ such Vidhyarthi Mitras, the Principal Secretary may pass one common order for such Vidhyarthi Mitras employed for Academic Session 2008-2009 or prior to that and it will not be necessary for all respective District Education Officers or any other authority to pass separate orders on such representations.

    9. The aforesaid writ petitions are accordingly disposed of. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prahalad Kumar Sharma v. State Of Rajasthan & Ors.
    (Jul 22, 2010)