Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of Order 41 of CPC elicit that Rule 23
  • Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC and under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC
  • Order 43 Rule 1(u) of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Clause (a) of Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC.11.
  • Clause (a) of Rule 27(1) of Order 41 of CPC
  • Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of Order 41 of CPC
  • Clause (aa) of Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC,
  • Order 41 Rule 23 or Rule 23-A of CPC
  • Rule 23/23-A of Order of 41 of CPC,
  • 41 Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of CPC.
  • Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC
  • provisions of Rule 23-A.5.
  • Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC
  • Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC
  • Order 41 Rule 23 of CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of Order 41 of CPC elicit that Rule 23
  • Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC and under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC
  • Order 43 Rule 1(u) of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Clause (a) of Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC.11.
  • Clause (a) of Rule 27(1) of Order 41 of CPC
  • Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of Order 41 of CPC
  • Clause (aa) of Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC,
  • Order 41 Rule 23 or Rule 23-A of CPC
  • Rule 23/23-A of Order of 41 of CPC,
  • 41 Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of CPC.
  • Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC
  • provisions of Rule 23-A.5.
  • Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC
  • Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC
  • Order 41 Rule 23 of CPC

    Babulal & Others. v. Chanda Bai & Others.

    JUDGMENT

    This miscellaneous appeal under Order 43 Rule 1(u) of the Code of Civil Procedure has been filed assailing the judgment dated 05.05.2005 rendered in First Appeal No. 109-A/2004 by the First additional Judge to the Court of District Judge, Guna, whereby while allowing the said appeal, the appellate Court without commenting on the merits of the case has set aside the decree of the trial Court, whereby the suit has been dismissed remanding the matter to the trial Court for reconsideration after accepting the application filed in the appellate Court under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC for production of additional evidence of the plaint in Civil Suit No. 15-A/1995 pending before Civil Judge, Class-II, Raghogarh and the map appended therewith and the written statement of defendants no. 1, 2, 3 and 4 in Civil Suit No. 15-A/1995 and the map appended therewith. The appellate Court while passing the impugned judgment has also allowed the application of the plaintiffs under Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC directing summoning of record of the said Civil Suit No. 15-A/1995.

    2. Learned counsel for the appellants has contended that the order of remand is beyond the scope of order 41 Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of CPC. It is further contended on behalf of the appellants that the appellate Court misdirected itself while allowing the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC as there was no occasion to do so since none of the three pre-requisites for invocation of Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC were made out. Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of Order 41 of CPC are reproduced hereunder for convenience :-

    “23. Remand of case by Appellate Court.- Where the Court from whose decree an appeal is preferred has disposed of the suit upon a preliminary point and the decree is reversed in appeal, the Appellate Court may, if it thinks fit, by order remand the case, and may further direct what issue or issues shall be tried in the case so remanded, and shall send a copy of its judgment and order to the Court from whose decree the appeal is preferred, with directions to re-admit the suit under its original number in the register of civil suits, and proceed to determine the suit; and the evidence (if any) recorded during the original trial shall, subject to all just exceptions, be evidence during the trial after remand.

    23-A. Remand in other cases.-- Where the Court from whose decree an appeal is preferred has disposed of the case otherwise than on a preliminary point, and the decree is reversed in appeal and a re-trial is considered necessary, the Appellate Court shall have the same powers as it has under rule 23.”

    3. A bare comparative perusal of the provisions of Rule 23 and Rule 23-A of Order 41 of CPC elicit that Rule 23 comes into play when the trial Court rendered a judgment and decree only upon a preliminary point and not on merits of the suit. On the other hand, Rule 23-A occupies the field in respect of all those cases where the suit has not been disposed of merely on the preliminary point, but adopt the same procedure of remand as contained in Rule 23.

    4. In the instant case, a reading of the impugned judgment indicates that Civil Suit No. 9-A/2003 was decided on merits on 25.10.2004 after adducing and marshalling of evidence and, therefore the suit had not been decided on a preliminary point. Resultantly, the instant case does not fall within the purview of Rule 23 and thus necessarily for the purpose exercise of power of remand by the appellate Court, would be governed by the provisions of Rule 23-A.

    5. The appellate Court while rendering the impugned judgment in paragraph 12 has observed that during the cross-examination of one Suresh, who was deposing on behalf of the plaintiffs, the trial Court did not allow the plaintiffs to produce in evidence the plaint and the written statement of Civil Suit No. 15-A/1995, which led to filing of an application under Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC before the trial Court praying for summong of the record of Civil Suit No. 15-A/1995, pending before Civil Judge, Class-II, Raghogarh, which was also rejected on account of having been filed with delay. The appellate Court has further held that the plaint and the written statement in the said Civil Suit No. 15-A/1995 was an important piece of evidence to prove or disprove the material fact of partition in Civil Suit No. 9-A/2003 and, therefore the denial by the trial Court led to arising of a cause to the plaintiffs before the first appellate Court under Clause (a) of Rule 27(1) of Order 41 of CPC to seek production of additional evidence in the appellate Court. Therefore the first appellate Court allowed the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC filed by the plaintiffs.

    6. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents has supported the impugned order and has prayed for sustaining the same.

    7. Considering the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellants, this Court finds that allowing of the applications under Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC and under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC was rightly made by the first appellate Court.

    8. Learned counsel for the appellants has further contended that no order of remand under Order 41 Rule 23 or Rule 23-A of CPC can be passed by the appellate Court without first interfering with the judgment and decree of the trial Court on merits; whereas in the instant case, the first appellate Court has not interfered with the judgment and decree of the trial Court on merits and has remanded the matter for reconsideration.

    9. Learned counsel for the appellants has relied upon the decision in the case of Municipal Corporation, Hyderabad v. Sunder Singh reported in (2008) 8 SCC, 485 laying down that the power under Order 41 Rule 23 of CPC of remand should be sparingly exercised.

    10. Further reliance has been placed on the decisions in the cases of (1) N. Kamalam v. Ayyasamy(2001) 7 SCC 503; (2) Peer Mohammad v. State of M.P 2010 (1) MPLJ; (3) J. Lingaiah v. G. Hanumanthappa(2001) 10 SCC 751; (4) Maya Devi v. Raj Kumari Batra 2011 (1) MPLJ 326; and (5) P. Purushottam Reddy v. Pratap Steels Ltd.(2002) 2 SCC 686. The first decision cited by the learned counsel in the case of N. Kamalam v. Ayyasamy (Supra) has no application to the present case as the Apex Court in the said case was dealing with factual matrix involving attempts on the part of a party which filed the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC after 10 years to fill up lacunae in the evidence; whereas in this case, the facts demonstrate that the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC was filed without any delay and also that there was no attempt to fill up the gaps in the evidence. It is noticed that the Single Bench of this Court while rendering the second decision in the case of Peer Mohammad Saeed (Supra) was persuaded by the factual matrix of non-fulfillment of one of the pre-conditions requisite under Clause (aa) of Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC, which is not the case here. Third case of J. Lingaiah (Supra) of the Apex Court is in regard to the scope of power of remand cited by the learned counsel. It is noticed that in the said case the issue for which remand order was made by the lower Court, had already been decided on merits and, therefore the Apex Court rightly held that on the issue, which has been decided on merits, provision of remand cannot be exercised for reconsideration of the said issue. For obvious reason, this decision of J. Lingaiah (Supra) has no application to the factual matrix attending the instant case. Fourth decision on the case of Maya Devi (Supra) of the Apex Court cited by the learned counsel again relates to the power of remand. In the said case, the Apex Court after holding that the power of remand is discretionary in nature, held that since the lower Court had failed to assign reasons while remanding the matter, the order of remand was vitiated. This case of Maya Devi (Supra) again is of no avail since the order of remand in question herein is a speaking order. Fifth case of P. Purushottam Reddy (Supra) of the Apex Court enumerating power of remand of the appellate Court holds that unless the three pre-requisites mentioned under Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC are not satisfied, the power of order of remand should not ordinarily be made. This case of the Apex Court of P. Purushottam Reddy (Supra) in fact helps the appellant to the extent that the first appellate Court while passing the order of remand has categorically held that the trial Court has wrongly refused to allow evidence which was sought to be adduced and, therefore the case of remand was squarely made out under Clause (a) of Rule 27 of Order 41 of CPC.

    11. Testing the rival submissions on the anvil of Rule 23/23-A of Order of 41 of CPC, it is seen that wide powers are bestowed upon the Appellate Court for exercising the power of remand. The language employed by Rule 23 does not indicate that the Legislature intended to restrict the power of the appellate Court to only such cases where the appellate Court interferes with the decree and judgment of the trial Court on merits and not otherwise. No such intention can be derived from the plain reading of the language used in Rule 23. The term “and the decree is reversed in appeal and a re-trial is reconsidered necessarily” used in Rule 23A, demonstrates that the appellate Court is empowered to reverse the decree of the trial Court notwithstanding the trial Court decree having been passed on merits or on preliminary point. Imputing any such meaning, which is not evident from plain reading of the statutory provisions under Rule 23-A, would be offensive to the intent and object of the provision and against the basic principles of statutory interpretation.

    12. The judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Municipal Corporation, Hyderabad v. Sunder Singh (Supra) cited by the learned counsel for the appellants is not applicable to the attending facts and circumstances of the case for the reason that the first appellate Court had rightly found that disallowing of the application under Order 13 Rule 10 of CPC had caused prejudice to the plaintiffs to the extent of denying them reasonable opportunity of proving their case.

    13. This Court is thus, of the opinion that the first appellate Court has not committed any illegality in remanding the matter to the trial Court for reconsideration without examining the judgment and decree of the trial Court on merits.

    14. Accordingly this miscellaneous appeal deserves to be and is hereby dismissed as being merit-less without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Babulal & Others. v. Chanda Bai & Others.
    (Nov 11, 2011)