AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner joined service as a Mechanical Supervisor with effect from 29.1.1973 and was promoted to Executive Engineer, Class II, with effect from 28.4.1986, working in charge of the Public Health (Mechanical) Store, Sub-Division, Vadodara. The petitioner was served with a charge-sheet dated 7.8.2001 alleging (i) non-maintenance of store account regularly and relinquishing charge without handing over store articles, and (ii) shortage of stores articles worth Rs. 1,131,930.50/-. The petitioner submitted replies on 1.10.2001 and 13.10.2001. An Inquiry Officer was appointed on 23.7.2003.

By order dated 4.6.2004 the charge was held partly proved, and punishment was imposed in the form of stoppage of one increment without future effect and treating the period of suspension as such. The petitioner filed Special Civil Application No. 15538 of 2005, which was dismissed by a Single Judge on 17.1.2006. On Letters Patent Appeal No. 108 of 2007, a Division Bench on 4.4.2011 upheld the penalty of stoppage of one increment without future effect but quashed the treatment of the period of suspension as such and remanded the matter to the Disciplinary Authority to take a decision in accordance with law after hearing the petitioner.

Pursuant to the remand, the Disciplinary Authority passed an order dated 8.7.2011 treating the period of suspension (24.4.2000 to 23.4.2004) as such. The petitioner challenged that order by filing the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The record also notes that, in respect of a different misconduct, the petitioner was dismissed in departmental proceedings which are the subject matter of Special Civil Application No. 5475 of 2005 that is admitted and pending before this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Disciplinary Authority was justified in treating the period of suspension from 24.4.2000 to 23.4.2004 as such by the order dated 8.7.2011.
  2. Whether treating the period of suspension as such constitutes a punishment disproportionate to the proved misconduct, causing a break in service and adversely affecting fixation of retiral and other dues.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The punishment imposed by the impugned order dated 8.7.2011 is harsh and disproportionate to the alleged misconduct.
  • Treating the period of suspension as such would amount to a break in service and would operate adversely against fixation of retiral and other dues.
  • The Division Bench in the earlier order dated 4.4.2011 observed that treating four years of suspension as such would ruin the petitioner's entire service career, and for a charge of failure to supervise amounting to negligence, such punishment was disproportionate and deserved to be quashed and set aside.

Respondents' / Disciplinary Authority's Position (as recorded)

  • The Disciplinary Authority considered the nature of the misconduct and earlier orders of the Court, noted that the charge was partly proved, and compared the subsistence allowance paid (Rs. 4,83,501/-) against the regular salary that might have been received (Rs. 6,89,079/-), concluding that a loss was caused to the Department.
  • On those facts, the Disciplinary Authority held that treating the period of suspension as such was just and proper.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Om Kumar v. Union of India, (2001) 2 SCC 386 Doctrine of proportionality (general consideration by the Apex Court in disciplinary matters). The court referenced this authority as an example of the Apex Court's consideration of proportionality and concluded that, on the facts (proved misconduct and departmental loss), the punishment could not be said to be disproportionate.
Union of India v. G. Ganayutham, AIR 1997 SC 3387 Doctrine of proportionality (as considered by the Apex Court). The court cited this case among authorities where proportionality has been considered and relied on this principle to evaluate whether the punishment was disproportionate; concluding it was not.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record and the impugned order and summarized the Disciplinary Authority's approach: the Authority considered the nature of the misconduct, earlier judicial orders, and the fact that the charge was partly proved. The Authority also compared the subsistence allowance paid to the petitioner (Rs. 4,83,501/-) with the regular salary he might have received (Rs. 6,89,079/-), treating the difference as a loss to the Department. On this factual matrix the Authority concluded that treating the period of suspension as such was justified.

The Court further noted the doctrine of proportionality as considered by the Apex Court in cases such as Om Kumar v. Union of India and Union of India v. G. Ganayutham. Applying that principle to the proved misconduct and the Departmental loss, the Court concluded that the punishment imposed by treating the period of suspension as such could not be characterized as disproportionate. Consequently, the Court found no ground to interfere under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is rejected summarily with no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • The Disciplinary Authority's decision dated 8.7.2011 treating the period of suspension (24.4.2000 to 23.4.2004) as such stands unaltered by this petition.
  • The Court concluded that, on the facts before it (partly proved charge and the financial comparison regarding subsistence allowance), the punishment was not disproportionate and therefore did not warrant interference under Article 226.
  • The opinion does not announce any new legal precedent; it upholds the Disciplinary Authority's exercise of discretion in the facts of this case.

    V.C Dave Petitioner(S) v. Gujarat Water Supply And Sewerage Board (S)

    ORAL ORDER

    1. In this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the challenge is to the order dated 8.7.2011 passed by the respondents by which a decision afresh after hearing the petitioner is taken to treat the period of suspension from 24.4.2000 to 23.4.2004 as such.

    2. Mr. Vaishnav, learned counsel for the petitioner would contend that the petitioner who joined the service as Mechanical Supervisor with effect from 29.1.1973 came to be promoted as Executive Engineer, Class II, with effect from 28.4.1986 and was in charge at Public Health (Mechanical) Store, Sub-Division, Vadodara. The petitioner was issued charge-sheet on 7.8.2001 on two counts, namely, (i) non-maintenance of Store Account regularly and relinquishing charge without handing over store articles and (ii) for shortage of Stores articles worth Rs. 1,131,930.50/-. Thereafter, replies were submitted by the petitioner on 1.10.2001 and 13.10.2001

    3. Inquiry Officer was appointed on 23.7.2003 By order dated 4.6.2004, charge came to be partly proved and punishment was inflicted by imposing penalty of stoppage of one increment without future effect and treating the period of suspension as such. The petitioner filed Special Civil Application No. 15538 of 2005. Learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition by order dated 17.1.2006, against which, Letters Patent Appeal No. 108 of 2007 filed by the petitioner came to be dismissed by a Division Bench vide order dated 4.4.2011 upholding the penalty of stoppage of one increment without future effect. However, period of suspension treated by the Authority as such was quashed and set aside the matter was remanded to the Disciplinary Authority for taking a decision in accordance with law after hearing the petition.

    4. Accordingly, this petition is filed challenging the order dated 8.7.2011 by which the Disciplinary Authority has treated the period of suspension as such.

    5. It is to be noted that, for a different misconduct, in the departmental proceeding, the petitioner came to be dismissed from service which was the subject matter of Special Civil Application No. 5475 of 2005 which is admitted and pending before this Court.

    6. In the above fact-situation, Mr. Vaishnav, learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the punishment now imposed by the impugned order dated 8.7.2011 is harsh and disproportionate to the alleged misconduct and treating the period of suspension as such would tantamount to break in service and further it would operate adversely against the fixation of retiral and other dues. It is further submitted that the Division Bench in the order dated 4.4.2011 passed in Letters Patent Appeal No. 108 of 2007 observed that punishment of treating period of suspension of four years as such amounts to ruining the entire service career of the petitioner and, therefore, when there was charge of failure to supervise and to that extent the petitioner was negligent in performance of duties, such punishment would be disproportionate and contrary to law and deserves to be quashed and set aside.

    7. Upon perusal of the record and the impugned order, it reveals that the Authority below has considered the nature of misconduct and the earlier orders passed by this Court and after noticing the facts that the charge against the petitioners was partly proved and further the petitioner was paid subsistence allowance of Rs. 4,83,501/- against the regular salary he might have received Rs. 6,89,079/- and, thus, the loss was caused to the Department, according to the Disciplinary Authority, the punishment of treating the period of suspension as such was just and proper. The above decision of the Disciplinary Authority does not warrant any interference in exercise of powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in as much as doctrine of proportionality is now considered by the Apex Court in many cases including Om Kumar v. Union of India, reported in (2001) 2 SCC 386, and Union of India v. G. Ganayutham, reported in AIR 1997 SC 3387 and, considering the misconduct, which is held proved, the above punishment could not be said to be in any manner disproportionate. No interference is called for. This petition is rejected summarily with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V.C Dave Petitioner(S) v. Gujarat Water Supply And Sewerage Board (S)
    (Nov 21, 2011)