Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Land Acquisition Collector v. Amar Singh

    Surinder Singh, J (Oral).

    The appellants felt aggrieved by the award passed by the learned District Judge in Reference Petition No. 198 of 1994/95, decided on 17.3.2001 on the ground of awarding excess amount enhancing it manifold.

    2. Heard and gone through the record.

    3. Precisely, the facts giving rise to the present appeal can be stated thus. The Government of Himachal Pradesh in the Department of M.P.P and Power, issued notification dated 3.7.1991, published in Himachal Pradesh Government Gazette on 20.7.1991, under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, in short the “Act” for acquisition of the impugned land for public purpose, situated in revenue estate, Majhagaon for construction of residential accommodation for staff of the Nathpa Jhakri Power Project (NJPC) near the power project. Accordingly, notification under Sections 6 & 7 of the Act was issued on 27.2.1992 The Collector also invited objections of the petitioner and ultimately passed the award on 14.5.1993, assessing the market value of the land under acquisition at the rate of Rs. 1723.25 per bigha on the basis of one year average for ‘Banjar Kadeem’, which worked out at Rs. 432/- only per bigha without mentioning the value of other land of a better classification.

    4. Feeling dissatisfied by the impugned award, the claimant preferred the objection petition under Section 18 of the Act before the Land Acquisition Collector for enhancement which was referred under Section 19(2) of the Act to the Reference Court for its determination.

    5. According to the claimant-respondent, the value of the land under acquisition was more than 2.00 lacs per bigha and the petitioner had a structure over it for which no money was paid; whereas his claim was resisted and contested by the appellants maintaining the adequacy of the award passed by the Land Acquisition Collector and stated that there was no such structure, as alleged. Accordingly, the parties were at issue with respect to the inadequacy of the award. They examined their respective witnesses. The petitioner could not lead any cogent evidence to prove the existence of any structure over the acquired land, whereas RW-1 Shankar Dass, Land Acquisition Patwari, categorically stated that at the time of demarcation of the impugned land on the spot, no such structure was found existing, though he stated that the land in question was ‘Banjar Kadeem’; the demarcation report is Ext. RW-2.A and nature of land is also depicted as such in revenue record which fact has also been corroborated by RW-2 Kamal Singh, Junior Engineer. Therefore, the petitioner was rightly held not entitled to any compensation for structure/super structure, as alleged by him. These findings have also not been challenged.

    6. In so far as the landed property is concerned, the learned Reference Court took cognizance of the award Ext. PX passed by the learned Reference Court with respect to the land passed in Land Reference Case No. 240 of 1995/91, decided on 30.9.1999. The land on the said award was also acquired for the same purpose as in the present case in adjacent Village Kotla. The notification under Section 4 of the Act in that case was published in the year 1988, but in the instant case, it was published in the year 1991. On considering the matter, the learned Reference Court assessed the market value of the land at the rate of Rs. 75,000/- per bigha without any further escalation over and above the price w.e.f the year 1988 for want of any documentary evidence qua its location, size, shape, tenure, user and potentiality when compared with the impugned land situated in Village Majhgaon. Further, it also considered the sale transaction Ext. PW-5.A which was proximate to the time of the notification in the instant case, which comes to around one lac per bigha. However, it is well settled that when a large extent of land is acquired, determination of compensation and the value of the small chunk cannot be blindly applied as held in P. Rajan v. The Kerala State Electricity Board 1997 (1) CCC 61 (SC). Thus, an adequate deduction is required to be made. If in the instant case, 25% deduction is allowed, the market value also comes to Rs. 75,000/- per bigha.

    7. Further, PW-5 Charan Dass proves the sale transaction Ext. PW-5.A. According to him, the nature of the land, so purchased by him, was ‘Ghasni’, whereas the impugned land was better than the land purchased by him. The land under acquisition is situated at a fast developing and upcoming area of Majhgaon, where the appellants have commissioned the project and is admittedly abutting to Jeori Sarahan State Highway, where there are facilities of school, hospital, telecommunication and other commercial activities. Thus, the land under acquisition is located in the prime commercial centre of the area. The very purpose of the purchase of small piece of land by PW-5 Charan Dass also indicates that he also had purchased 1.15 biswas of land for commercial activity. The land under acquisition is also surrounded by the project area having its advantages for it due to carrying out of the scheme for which the property was acquired.

    8. Therefore, keeping in view the advantages and disadvantages of the impugned land and also on the strength of the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in K. Vasundara Devi v. Revenue Divisional Officer (Lao).) (1995) 3 SCJ 447, in my considered opinion, the learned trial Court rightly assessed and awarded the amount of Rs. 75,000/- per bigha, the market value of the land, with statutory interest.

    9. Therefore, for the aforesaid reasons, I do not find any infirmity in the impugned award, as such, the appeal sans merit and is accordingly dismissed.

    Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Land Acquisition Collector v. Amar Singh
    (Oct 10, 2012)