Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 29(2) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (the Rent Act for short),
  • provisions contained in Order 41 Rules 31 of the Code.
  • provisions of Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 of Order 41
  • provisions of Rule 31 of Order 41 of the Code.
  • Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 & 31
  • Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Section 29(2) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (the Rent Act for short),
  • provisions contained in Order 41 Rules 31 of the Code.
  • provisions of Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 of Order 41
  • provisions of Rule 31 of Order 41 of the Code.
  • Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 & 31
  • Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15
Smart Summary

Summary of Court Opinion (Revision Application under Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Revision Application was filed under Section 29(2) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 by the defendant/appellant-tenant challenging:

  • The judgment and order dated 18.09.2000 of the learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, S.D. Surendranagar in Regular Civil Suit No. 58 of 1995, which accepted the landlords' suit for eviction; and
  • The judgment and order dated 07.09.2007 of the learned Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No. 1, Surendranagar in Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000, which confirmed the Trial Court's decree.

Relevant facts as stated in the opinion:

  • The respondents (landlords) filed RCS No. 58 of 1995 seeking eviction on multiple grounds, including arrears of rent and that the tenant had constructed permanent structures without consent.
  • The tenant filed a written statement (Exh. 13). The Trial Court framed issues (Exh. 14) and held that the landlord was entitled to decree of eviction under Section 12(3)(a) because the tenant had failed to pay rent for 25 months.
  • The tenant appealed (Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000); the Appellate Court dismissed the appeal on 07.09.2007. The tenant then filed the present Revision Application challenging primarily the manner in which the first appellate court disposed of the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the first appellate court (Lower Appellate Court) complied with the requirements of Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and Paragraph 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual when deciding the first appeal.
  2. Whether the impugned judgment and order of the Lower Appellate Court should be quashed and set aside, and the matter remanded for fresh consideration after framing proper points for determination in accordance with the statutory provisions and the Bombay Civil Manual.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (petitioner/tenant)'s Arguments

  • The Lower Appellate Court wrote a judgment that did not comply with the Code of Civil Procedure and the Bombay Civil Manual: it failed to frame points for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 and Paragraph 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual.
  • The settled legal position requires that the first appeal be decided strictly in adherence to Order 41 Rule 31 and that the first appellate court must give reasons for its decision on each point independently.
  • Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. A. Ramalingam (2011) and related authorities for the proposition that the appellate court must independently assess evidence, formulate points for determination, and give reasons.
  • Relief sought: quash and set aside the impugned appellate judgment and remand the matter to the Lower Appellate Court for fresh consideration after properly framing points for determination.

Respondent (landlords)'s Arguments

  • The impugned judgment and order of the lower Appellate Court was just, legal and proper; the Appellate Court considered the case on merits.
  • The absence of formally formulated points of determination would not vitiate the judgment if the Appellate Court has considered the merits; hence there is no need to remand the case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. A. Ramalingam, 2011 (2) R.C.R (Civil) 385 Holds that the first appellate court must formulate points for determination, independently assess relevant evidence on important aspects, and give reasons; substantial compliance with Order 41 Rule 31 is required. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the lower Appellate Court had not complied with the statutory requirements and to support quashing and remanding the impugned judgment for fresh consideration after proper formulation of points.
Sukhpal Singh v. Kalyan Singh, AIR 1963 SC 146 Cited as authority on appellate procedure and the duty of the appellate court to appreciate facts/evidence and give reasoned decisions (as referenced in H. Siddiqui). Referenced as part of the chain of authorities reinforcing the requirement that the first appellate court must independently assess evidence and give reasons.
Girijanandini Devi v. Bijendra Narain Choudhary, AIR 1967 SC 1124 Cited in support of principles about appellate courts' duties in assessing and deciding appeals (as referenced in H. Siddiqui). Used to support the general proposition that the appellate court must consider material on record and give reasons.
G. Amalorpavam v. R.C. Diocese of Madurai, 2006 (2) R.C.R (Civil) 426 : (2006) 3 SCC 224 Authority cited for appellate court's obligation to independently assess evidence and decide points after formulating them (as referenced in H. Siddiqui). Relied upon as part of the judicial precedent establishing the duty of the first appellate court to adhere to Order 41 Rule 31 requirements.
Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari, 2007 (2) R.C.R (Rent) 465 : (2007) 8 SCC 600 Cited for the principle that appellate courts must independently consider evidence and give reasoned findings (referenced through H. Siddiqui). Used to reinforce the requirement of reasoned consideration by the first appellate court.
Gannmani Anasuya v. Parvatini Amaren-dra Chowdhari, 2007 (3) R.C.R (Civil) 381 : AIR 2007 SC 2380 : (2007) 10 SCC 296 Another Supreme Court authority cited in the chain of cases emphasizing the appellate court's duty to formulate issues and give reasons. Invoked by the Court to support the proposition that the first appellate court must conduct a reasoned independent assessment.
B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy, 2011 (1) R.C.R (Civil) 802 : (2010) 13 SCC 530 Explains that the first appellate court must reflect conscious application of mind, deal with all issues and evidence, and record findings supported by reasons. The opinion quotes this authority to emphasize that the first appeal is a valuable right and that the appellate judgment must address issues with reasons; it is used to justify remand for proper adjudication.
Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) By Lrs., 2001 (3) R.C.R (Civil) 243 : (2001) 3 SCC 179 Cited for the proposition that an appellate court must address all issues of law and fact and give reasons for findings (as referenced in B.V. Nagesh). Used within the authority chain to support the requirement of reasoned findings by the first appellate court.
Madhukar v. Sangram, 2001 (2) R.C.R (Civil) 704 : (2001) 4 SCC 756 Cited alongside Santosh Hazari to support principles about appellate adjudication and reasoned judgments. Relied upon as part of the jurisprudence requiring comprehensive appellate consideration of issues and evidence.
Mahmad Ahmadbhai v. Fatmaben Abdulla, 2007 (4) GLR 2789 State High Court decision cited as consonant with the principle that appellate courts must properly formulate points and decide after reasoned consideration. Cited by this Court as an example of similar view taken by this Court on appellate duty; supports remand direction.
Prajapati v. Prajapati, 2010 (2) GLH 551 High Court authority referenced in support of the proposition that appellate courts must properly frame points and consider the appeal on merits. Invoked to show consistency of approach in remanding matters where the appellate court failed to formulate proper points.
Dumala Vahpara Gram Panchayat v. Chunilal Tribhovandas Patel, 1999 (2) GLH 959 High Court authority cited as reflecting similar principles regarding appellate adjudication and the framing of points. Referenced by this Court as among authorities supporting the requirement of framing points and giving reasons; applied to justify remand.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following sequence, based strictly on the contents of the opinion:

  1. Identification of the core challenge: The petitioner's principal grievance was that the Lower Appellate Court did not frame proper points for determination under Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 of the Code and Paragraph 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual, and hence did not give independent reasoned findings.
  2. Examination of the points actually framed by the lower Appellate Court: The Court reproduced the three points the Appellate Court had formulated:
    • (i) Whether the appellant proves that learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, (S.D) Surendranagar, has erred in allowing RCS No. 58/1995 of the respondents?
    • (ii) Whether the appellant proves that interference is required in the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court?
    • (iii) What Order?
    The Court observed that these points were not properly formulated in accordance with the statutory provisions and the Bombay Civil Manual.
  3. Application of established legal principles: The Court referred to and relied on precedents (notably H. Siddiqui and others) which lay down that:
    • The first appellate court must formulate points for determination in terms of the statutory provisions;
    • It must independently assess the relevant evidence on all important aspects and give reasons for its decision on each point rather than merely expressing concurrence with the Trial Court;
    • Substantial compliance with Order 41 Rule 31 is required and the judgment must reflect the appellate court's conscious application of mind.
  4. Assessment of the impugned judgment against these principles: The Court concluded on "mere perusal" of the impugned judgment that the Lower Appellate Court had failed to discharge its obligations as the first Appellate Court—specifically by not properly framing points for determination and by not giving independent reasons on each point.
  5. Remedial conclusion: Because of that failure, the Court held that the impugned appellate judgment deserved to be quashed and set aside and the matter remanded for fresh consideration on merits after framing proper points for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 & 31 and Paragraph 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual.
  6. Ancillary directions: The Court ordered that the Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000 be restored to file, be decided expeditiously preferably within six months after affording hearing; directed the petitioner-tenant to deposit rent before the lower appellate court during pendency; permitted direct service; vacated earlier interim relief; and ordered that the petitioner shall not be evicted during the pendency of the appeal. Registry was directed to remit the record to the lower Appellate Court forthwith.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Revision Application was allowed. The impugned judgment and order dated 07.09.2007 passed in Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000 by the learned Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No. 1, Surendranagar, was quashed and set aside, and the matter was remanded to the lower Appellate Court to be decided afresh on merits and in accordance with law after formulating proper points for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 & 31 and Paragraph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual.

Immediate Consequences for the Parties

  • The Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000 stands restored to file and is to be heard and decided by the lower Appellate Court afresh.
  • The lower Appellate Court is directed to decide the appeal as expeditiously as possible, preferably within six months from receipt of the record, after providing opportunity of hearing to the parties' advocates.
  • The petitioner-tenant must deposit the rent before the lower Appellate Court during the pendency of the appeal.
  • Direct service was permitted; earlier interim relief granted was vacated.
  • The petitioner/defendant-tenant shall not be evicted from the suit premises during the pendency of the appeal.
  • Registry to remit the record and proceedings to the lower Appellate Court forthwith.

Broader Legal Implication Stated by the Court

The Court affirmed the settled principle (as reflected in Supreme Court and High Court authorities) that the first appellate court must substantially comply with Order 41 Rule 31 by formulating points for determination, independently assessing evidence, and giving reasoned findings on each point; failure to do so may vitiate the appellate judgment and occasion quashing and remand.

    Hemlataben Mangalsinh v. Shantaben Chandulal Narshidas

    1. By way of the present Revision Application under Section 29(2) of the Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (“the Rent Act” for short), the defendant/appellant-tenant has challenged the judgment and order dated 18.09.2000, passed by the learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, S.D Surendranagar, in Regular Civil Suit No. 58 of 1995, by which the suit filed by the present respondents-landlords for the decree of eviction is accepted as well as the judgment and order dated 07.09.2007 passed by the learned Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No. 1, Surendranagar in Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000, confirming the judgment and order passed by the Trial Court.

    2. Brief facts of the case are as under :— The present respondents who are the landlord filed Regular Civil Suit No. 58 of 1995 in the Court of learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, S.D Surendranagar, and prayed for a decree of eviction on several grounds including the arrears of rent and the tenant had constructed permanent structures in the suit premises without the landlord's consent. The suit was opposed by the tenant by filing written statement at Exh. 13. The Trial Court framed issues at Exh. 14 and reached to the conclusion that the landlord was entitled for the decree of eviction under Section 12(3)(a) since the defendant/tenant had failed to pay the rent of 25 months.

    3. The said decision was challenged by the present petitioner/defendant-tenant by way of filing Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000, in the Court of learned Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No. 1, Surendranagar. Learned Appellate Court dismissed the appeal filed by the defendant by order dated 07.09.2007 Hence the present revision.

    4. Mr. Jay M. Thakkar, learned Counsel, appearing for the petitioner has raised the contention with regard to the manner in which the Lower Appellate Court has disposed of the appeal by writing a judgment contrary to the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “the Code” for short) as well as the Bombay Civil Manual. He submitted that the Lower Appellate Court has not framed any point for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 as well as Paragraph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual. He has further submitted that it is a settled legal position that the first appeal has to be decided strictly in adherence with the provisions contained in Order 41 Rules 31 of the Code. It is further submitted that the Lower Appellate Court, being the first appellate Court, must give reasons for its decision on each point independently. Lastly, it is submitted that the Lower Appellate Court has failed to comply with the provisions of Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 of Order 41 as well as Paragraph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual.

    5. Mr. Jay M. Thakkar, learned Advocate for the petitioner in support of his submission has relied upon a decision of the Supreme Court in the Case of H. Siddiqui (dead) by H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. A. Ramalingam., as reported at 2011 (2) R.C.R (Civil) 385 : 2011 (2) GLR 1429 and submitted that the Hon'ble Apex Court has, after relying upon several decisions, held that if the first Appellate Court's Judgment is based on the independent assessment of the relevant evidence on all important aspects of the matter and the findings of the Appellate Court are well founded and quite convincing and such an exercise should be done after formulating the points for determination in terms of the said provisions and the Court must proceed in adherence to the requirements of the said statutory provisions.

    6. Mr. Jay M. Thakkar, learned Advocate for the petitioner, has also relied upon Paragraph 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual that the appellate Court should frame suitable points for determination in appeals in accordance with the same principles on which issues are framed in the Trial Court.

    7. Mr. Jay M. Thakkar, learned Advocate for the petitioner therefore, submitted that the impugned judgment and order passed by the Lower Appellate Court be quashed and set aside and the matter be remanded to the Lower Appellate Court for fresh consideration in accordance with law after framing points for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 and 31 as well as Paragraph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual.

    8. On the other hand, Mr. Ashish M. Dagli, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent has opposed the submissions made by learned Advocate for the petitioner and supported the impugned judgment and order passed by the lower Appellate Court. He further submitted that the first Appellate Court has considered the case on merits and the judgment and order passed by the lower Appellate Court is just, legal and proper and the same would not stand vitiated merely because points of determination have not been formulated by the lower Appellate Court and, therefore, there is no need to remand the case for fresh consideration to the first Appellate Court.

    9. I have heard learned Advocate Mr. Jay M. Thakkar, appearing for the petitioner and Mr. Ashish M. Dagli, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondents. It is apparent from the main grounds, on which the impugned judgment and order passed by the lower Appellate Court has been assailed, that the same does not meet with the requirements of the Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 &31 as well as Paragarph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual. The lower appellate court has formulated points for determination, which are reproduced as under:

    (i) Whether the appellant proves that learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, (S.D) Surendranagar, has erred in allowing RCS No. 58/1995 of the respondents?

    (ii) Whether the appellant proves that interference is required in the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.

    (iii) What Order?

    10. Now considering the points which are formulated by the lower Appellate Court, I am of the opinion that, the lower Appellate Court has committed error in not properly formulating the points for determination. The lower Appellate Court ought to have framed points for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 & 31 as well as Paragraph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual and ought to have given reasons for its decision on each point independently. The Apex Court in the case of H. Siddiqui (dead) by LRs. (supra) in the context of Order-41 Rule-31 has observed in paras-21 and 22 as under:

    “21. The said provisions provided guidelines for the appellate Court as to how the Court has to proceed and decide the case. The provisions should be read in such a way as to require that the various particulars mentioned therein should be taken into consideration. Thus, it must be evident from the judgment of the appellate Court that the Court has properly appreciated the facts/evidence, applied its mind and decided case considering the material on record. It would amount to substantial compliance of the said provisions if the appellate Court's judgment is based on the independent assessment of the relevant evidence on all important aspect of the matter and the findings of the appellate Court are well founded and quite convincing. It is mandatory for the appellate Court to independently asses the evidence of the parties and consider the relevant points which arise for adjudication and the bearing of the evidence on those points. Being the final Court of fact, the first appellate court must not record mere general expression of concurrence with the trial Court judgment rather it must give reasons for its decision on such point independently to that of the trial Court. Thus, the entire evidence must be considered and discussed in detail. Such exercise should be done after formulating the points for consideration in terms of the said provisions and the Court must proceed in adherence to the requirements of the said statutory provisions.” (Vide: Sukhpal Singh v. Kalyan Singh, AIR 1963 SC 146; Girijanandini Devi v. Bijendra Narain Choudhary, AIR 1967 SC 1124; G. Amalorpavam v. R.C Diocese of Madurai, 2006 (2) R.C.R (Civil) 426 : (2006) 3 SCC 224; Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari, 2007 (2) R.C.R (Rent) 465 : (2007) 8 SCC 600; and Gannmani Anasuya v. Parvatini Amaren-dra Chowdhari, 2007 (3) R.C.R (Civil) 381 : AIR 2007 SC 2380 : (2007) 10 SCC 296.

    “22. In B.V Nagesh v. H.V Sreenivasa Murthy, 2011 (1) R.C.R (Civil) 802 : JT 2010 (10) SC 551 : (2010) 13 SCC 530, while dealing with the issue, this Court held as under:

    “4. The appellate Court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial Court. The first appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case therein is open for re-hearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate Court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate Court. Sitting as a Court of appeal, it was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. The first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the judgment in the first appeal must address itself to all the issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in support of the findings. (Vide: Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) By Lrs., 2001 (3) R.C.R (Civil) 243 : (2001) 3 SCC 179 and Madhukar v. Sangram, 2001 (2) R.C.R (Civil) 704 : (2001) 4 SCC 756.”

    11. A similar view was taken by this Court in the case of Mahmad Ahmadbhai v. Fatmaben Abdulla as reported in 2007 (4) GLR 2789; in the case of Prajapati v. Prajapati, 2010 (2) GLH 551 as well as in the case of Dumala Vahpara Gram Panchayat v. Chunilal Tribhovandas Patel, as reported at 1999 (2) GLH 959.

    12. In view of above settled principle of law, while delivering the judgment, the first Appellate Court is required to substantially comply with the provisions of Rule 31 of Order 41 of the Code. In the present case, on mere perusal of the impugned judgment and order of the lower Appellate Court, it is abundantly clear that the lower Appellate Court has failed to discharge the obligation placed on it as a first Appellate Court. In my opinion, the judgment and order of the lower Appellate Court deserves to be quashed and set aside and the case is required to be remanded to the lower Appellate Court for considering the same afresh on merits and in accordance with law after framing points for determination in accordance with Order 41 Rules 11, 14, 15 & 31 as well as Paragraph No. 414 of the Bombay Civil Manual. In the result, the present Revision Application succeeds. The impugned judgment and order dated 07.09.2007 passed in Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000, by the learned Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No. 1, Surendranagar, is hereby quashed and set aside and the matter is remanded to the lower Appellate Court to decide the same afresh on merits and in accordance with law after formulating proper points for determination. Accordingly, Regular Civil Appeal No. 37 of 2000 shall stand restored to file. The lower appellate Court shall decide the appeal as expeditiously as possible preferably within a period of six months from the date of receipt of order, after affording an opportunity of hearing to the learned Advocates for the respective parties. The petitioner-tenant shall deposit the rent before the lower appellate Court during the pendency of the Appeal. Rule is made absolute to the aforesaid extent only. Direct Service is permitted. Interim relief granted earlier shall stand vacated. However, the petitioner/defendant-tenant shall not be evicted from the suit premises during the pendency of appeal by the respondents/plaintiffs-landlords.

    13. Registry is directed to remit the Record and proceedings to the lower Appellate Court forthwith.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hemlataben Mangalsinh v. Shantaben Chandulal Narshidas
    (Jan 21, 2013)