Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent filed a claim against a partnership firm and its partners, with offices located at 39A, Harish Mukherjee Road in Kolkata and Adalat Road in Aurangabad. Service of summons was attempted at both addresses. At the Kolkata address, a notice was pasted on the outer wall when the appellants were not found. At the Aurangabad office, the court bailiff found the office closed and could not effect service on the partners. Subsequently, substituted service was ordered through advertisements in newspapers circulated in Pune and Aurangabad. The appellants filed an application to set aside an ex parte decree but made no attempt to correct or dispute the address stated in the cause-title. The trial court found that the appellants had deliberately evaded service and were available at the time of the execution application but not when summons were attempted. The appellants appealed against the trial court’s order dated August 18, 2016, which is the subject of this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in holding that the appellants deliberately evaded service of summons.
  2. Whether the substituted service through newspaper advertisements was valid and sufficient.
  3. Whether the application to set aside the ex parte decree was properly considered in light of the appellants’ conduct and address details.
  4. Whether the impugned order dated August 18, 2016, warrants interference by the appellate court.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the attempts made to serve summons on the appellants at their known addresses and found that the appellants had deliberately avoided service. The trial court noted the inconsistency that the appellants were reachable during the execution application but unavailable when summons were served. The court justified the substituted service through newspaper advertisements given the closure of the office and failure of personal service. The appellants’ failure to correct the address in their application to set aside the ex parte decree further supported the trial court’s conclusion that the appellants took the application for setting aside the decree for granted, aiming only to delay proceedings. Based on these facts and conduct, the court held that the trial court’s order did not require interference.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed as utterly unmeritorious.

The direct effect of this decision is that the impugned order dated August 18, 2016, stands affirmed. The appellants’ attempt to evade service and delay the decree has been rejected. Any payments made by the appellants to the decree-holder after the decree will be credited during execution, and the decree-holder must approach the executing court for orders regarding money deposited with the Registrar. No costs have been awarded, and the prayer for stay of the order has been declined. The opinion does not establish any new legal precedent beyond affirming the trial court’s findings on service and conduct of the parties.

    Auto Cars v. Trimurti Cargo Movers Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

    1. The Court: The order impugned does not call for any interference.

    2. The trial court appropriately found that the appellants had attempted to dodge service and the appellants were not available at their address in Aurangabad when the appellants had been attempted to be served. Indeed, the appellants took it for granted that the mere application for setting aside the ex parte decree would result in the decree being recalled and the appellants getting several more years to delay the inevitable.

    3. The claim by the respondent was against a partnership firm and its partners. Such partnership firm was said to have an office at 39A, Harish Mukherjee Road in Kolkata and at Adalat Road in Aurangabad. When the service of the summons was attempted, the appellants were not found at 39A, Harish Mukherjee Road and a notice was pasted at the outer wall of the building.

    4. However, service was attempted through the Bailiff in the Court at Aurangabad on the Adalat Road address of the relevant partnership firm. Service on the partners of the firm as named in the plaint was also attempted in the same office. Since the office was found to be closed, actual service could not be effected. On the prayer of the plaintiff for substituted service, advertisements were issued in the ‘Times of India’, Pune edition and in a Hindi and a Marathi paper also published from Pune. Since the Pune papers may be circulated in Aurangabad, orders were issued for effecting substituted service in papers published from Pune.

    5. In the application for setting aside the ex parte decree filed on behalf of the first defendant, the first defendant's address was clearly evident from the cause-title. No attempt was made in such application to indicate that the address was wrong or that the first defendant in the suit operated from some other premises.

    6. The trial court was justified in drawing the conclusions as evident from the order impugned dated August 18, 2016. The most peculiar feature as noticed by the trial court was that the appellants were alive to the execution application when served but when the summons was attempted to be reached at the same address, they were not available.

    7. The order dated August 18, 2016 does not call for any interference. The appeal is utterly unmeritorious.

    8. APO No. 200 of 2017 is dismissed. If any payments have been made by the appellants to the decree-holder after the passing of the decree, due credit will be given to such payments in course of the execution. As for the money lying deposited with the Registrar, Original Side, pursuant to orders in this appeal, it will be for the decree-holder to obtain appropriate orders from the executing court in such regard.

    9. There will be no order as to costs.

    10. A prayer for the stay of the operation of this order is made, which is declined.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Auto Cars v. Trimurti Cargo Movers Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
    (Apr 24, 2017)