AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Regulation) Act (for short MMDR Act) and Jharkhand Mineral Dealer's Rules, 2007.
  • Section 414 of Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Regulation) Act (for short MMDR Act) and Jharkhand Mineral Dealer's Rules, 2007.
  • Section 414 of Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This application challenges that part of the order dated 30.9.2013 passed by the 1st Additional Sessions Judge, Saraikella in Cr. Revision No. 79 of 2013, which affirmed the order dated 11.9.2013 passed by the S.D.J.M. in Misc. Case No. 2 of 2013 (Kandra P.S. Case No. 32 of 2013). The impugned order had rejected the prayer for release of three trucks (nos. JH 05-AD-5514, JH 05-AD-0514, JH 02-L-0487), three Hywas (nos. JH 05-AS-2173, JH 05-AS-2174, JH 05-AS-5213) and two other vehicles (nos. JH 05-AT-0628 and JH 05-AT-0629).

The prosecution's case, as stated in the record, is that on receiving secret information a raid was conducted behind the hotel of Santosh Majhi where 1,600 MT of coal was found stored. Six trucks, two pay-loaders and three Hywas were present. The coal was suspected to be stolen and it was suspected that persons were trading coal illegally. A case was registered for an offence under Section 414 of the Indian Penal Code and for contravention of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act (MMDR Act) and the Jharkhand Mineral Dealer's Rules, 2007. The vehicles were seized.

After seizure, an application for release of five trucks and three Hywas was rejected by the court below on the ground that confiscation proceedings had already been initiated. A revision was similarly rejected by the revisional court. The petitioner filed the present application challenging that outcome.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a court may order release of vehicles seized in proceedings for contravention of the MMDR Act (i.e., whether the MMDR Act contains a provision preventing release of seized vehicles).
  2. Whether it is appropriate to keep seized vehicles in police custody where the vehicles have been hypotheticated to a financial institution.
  3. Whether the absence of a charge-sheet (or the fact that charge-sheeting is only under Section 414 IPC for some accused) affects the propriety of releasing seized vehicles pending confiscation proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the MMDR Act contains no provision that bars a court from releasing a vehicle that is the subject of confiscation proceedings.
  • Reference was made to an order in Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013 (Biva Jha) dated 19.12.2013 in which this Court ordered release of a pay-loader after observing that no MMDR Act provision prevented release, that the charge-sheet in that matter had been filed only under Section 414 IPC for some accused, and that the vehicle had been hypotheticated to a financial institution — making police custody inappropriate.
  • The petitioner argued that, on the same reasoning as in Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013, the present application should be allowed, noting further that the petitioner in the present matter had not yet been charge-sheeted and thus stood on a stronger footing.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013 The court took notice that no provision seems to be there under the MMDR Act which prevents the court from making the order for releasing the vehicle seized in a case for contravention of the MMDR Act; that a charge-sheet had been submitted against some of the accused persons only under Section 414 of the Indian Penal Code; and that the vehicle had been hypotheticated to a financial institution. The Court in that matter allowed release of the pay-loader, finding it inappropriate to keep the vehicle in police custody under those circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted the prior order in Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013 and the reasons recorded therein. It observed that the earlier order had taken judicial notice that the MMDR Act does not appear to contain any provision that bars a court from ordering release of a vehicle seized in proceedings for contravention of the MMDR Act. The Court also noted that in the earlier matter the charge-sheet had been filed only under Section 414 IPC against some accused, and that the seized vehicle had been hypotheticated to a financial institution — factors that led the Court in that matter to conclude that police custody of the vehicle was inappropriate.

Applying the same considerations to the present case, the Court found that most of the vehicles here were said to be hypotheticated to a financial institution. For that reason, and on the basis of the reasoning in the earlier order, the Court concluded that it would not be proper or appropriate to allow the vehicles to remain in police custody pending confiscation proceedings.

The Court therefore exercised its authority to order conditional release rather than permitting continued police custody of vehicles that appear to have been hypothecated.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The application is allowed and the listed vehicles are ordered released in favour of the petitioner.

The Court ordered release of three Trucks (nos. JH 05-AD-5514, JH 05-AD-0514, JH 02-L-0487), three Hywas (nos. JH 05-AS-2173, JH 05-AS-2174, JH 05-AS-5213) and two other vehicles (nos. JH 05-AT-0628 and JH 05-AT-0629) on the condition that the petitioner furnishes a security bond of Rs. 1,43,00,000/- (one crore & fourty three lakhs) with one surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the S.D.J.M., Seraikella, and gives an undertaking to produce the vehicles whenever required by the court.

Implications: The direct effect is the conditional release of the seized vehicles to the petitioner subject to the prescribed security and surety. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new authoritative precedent beyond applying the reasoning of the earlier order in Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013 to the facts of this case.

    Mukesh Kumar Raju Tiwari Petitioner v. The State Of Jharkhand Opp. Party

    Heard the parties.

    This application is directed against that part of the order dated 30.9.2013 passed by 1st Additional Sessions Judge, Saraikella in Cr. Revision No. 79 of 2013, affirming the order dated 11.9.2013 passed by S.D.J.M in Misc. Case No. 2 of 2013 (Kandra P.S Case No. 32 of 2013), whereby and whereunder prayer for release of three Trucks bearing nos. JH 05-AD - 5514, JH 05-AD - 0514 and JH 02-L - 0487 as well as three Hywas bearing nos. JH 05-AS - 2173, JH 05-AS - 2174 and JH 05-AS - 5213 and also two other vehicles bearing nos. JH 05-AT-0628 and JH 05-AT - 0629 was rejected.

    It is the case of the prosecution that on receiving secret information that some persons have indulged themselves in doing business of coal clandestinely, a raid was laid behind the hotel of Santosh Majhi, where 1600 MT of coal was found stored. There six trucks, two Pay-loaders and three Hywas were found standing over there. The coal was suspected to be the stolen one and at the same time, it was also suspected that some persons have indulged themselves in trading of coal illegally and for that a case was registered for commission of the offence under Section 414 of Indian Penal Code as well as for contravention of the provision of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act (for short MMDR Act) and Jharkhand Mineral Dealer's Rules, 2007. The trucks, Pay-loaders and also Hywas were seized.

    Upon seizure of the said vehicles, an application was filed on behalf of the petitioner for release of five trucks as well as three Hywas before the court below which prayer was rejected on the premise that the confiscation proceeding for confiscating the vehicle has already been initiated. That order was challenged before the revisional court but the revisional court by assigning the same reason also rejected the revision application.

    Being aggrieved with this order, this application has been filed.

    Mr. Amit Sinha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, submits that by the same impugned order, the prayer for release of the trucks as well as Pay-loaders and also Hywa had been rejected. Against the order rejecting the prayer for release of Pay-loader, one Biva Jha had moved to this Court vide Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013. This Court after taking into account the fact that under the MMDR Act no provision is there which puts bar upon a court to release the vehicle, a subject matter of confiscation proceeding, and further that no case is made out under the MMDR Act, has passed an order to release the Pay-loader in favour of the petitioner (Biva Jha) vide order dated 19.12.2013 passed in Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013 and, therefore, on the same reasoning, this application also deserves to be allowed particularly when the petitioner has still not been charge-sheeted whereas in that case, referred to above, the petitioner (Biva Jha) has been charge-sheeted and thereby the case of the petitioner stands on far better footing.

    On perusal of the order dated 19.12.2013 passed in Cr.M.P No. 3095 of 2013, it does appear that the Court while allowing the said application had taken notice of the fact that no provision seems to be there under the MMDR Act which prevents the court from making the order for releasing the vehicle seized in a case for contravention of the MMDR Act. Further, the Court has also taken notice of the fact that the charge-sheet has been submitted against some of the accused persons only under Section 414 of Indian Penal Code. Further, the Court has taken notice of the fact that the vehicle, which has been seized, had been hypotheticated to a financial institution and in the circumstances, it was found by the Court that it would not be proper and appropriate to allow the vehicle to be kept in the police custody.

    Here in the instant case, most of the vehicles are said to have been hypotheticated to a financial institution. Therefore for the same reason, which has been assigned in that case, referred to above, I do find that it would not be proper and appropriate to allow the vehicles to be kept in the police custody.

    Accordingly, let three Trucks bearing nos. JH 05-AD - 5514, JH 05-AD - 0514 and JH 02-L - 0487 as well as three Hywas bearing nos. JH 05-AS - 2173, JH 05-AS - 2174 and JH 05-AS - 5213 and also two other vehicles bearing nos. JH 05-AT-0628 and JH 05-AT - 0629 be released in favour of the petitioner on furnishing security bond of Rs. 1,43,00,000/- (one crore & fourty three lakhs) with one surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the S.D.J.M, Seraikella on giving undertaking that whenever it shall be required by the court, the same would be produced.

    In the result, this application is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mukesh Kumar Raju Tiwari Petitioner v. The State Of Jharkhand Opp. Party
    (Jan 2, 2014)