AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • u/s 12(2) of the Jharkhand Control of Crimes Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred as the Act for short),
  • u/s 386/307/326/34 of the I.P.C and Section 27 of the Arms Act
  • u/s 302/34 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act
  • u/s 302 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act,
  • Bihar Control of Crimes Act, 1981 under section 12
  • Bihar Control of Crimes Act, 1981, Section
  • Sub-section 1 of Section 12
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • u/s 12(2) of the Jharkhand Control of Crimes Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred as the Act for short),
  • u/s 386/307/326/34 of the I.P.C and Section 27 of the Arms Act
  • u/s 302/34 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act
  • u/s 302 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act,
  • Bihar Control of Crimes Act, 1981 under section 12
  • Bihar Control of Crimes Act, 1981, Section
  • Sub-section 1 of Section 12
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judicial Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition challenged two orders: (a) an order dated 10.5.2013 of the District Magistrate, Bokaro (memo No. 3-563.Legal) directing detention of the petitioner under Section 12(2) of the Jharkhand Control of Crimes Act, 2002 ("the Act") until 9.5.2014; and (b) an order dated 21.6.2013 (memo No. 3.CCA/24/16/2012-2559/Ranchi) of the Under Secretary (Home), Government of Jharkhand, confirming the District Magistrate's detention order.

The petitioner's factual complaint (as presented in the petition) was that the detaining authority relied on facts and several criminal cases that, according to the petitioner, related to individual law-and-order matters rather than matters affecting public tranquility or public order, and that in some of those cases the petitioner had already been acquitted or granted bail. The Superintendent of Police, Bokaro had proposed detention by referring to several criminal cases and certain station diary entries; the District Magistrate passed the impugned detention order under Section 12(2) of the Act; the petitioner made a representation which he alleges was not properly considered; and after an Advisory Board opinion the Government approved the detention order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the detention order dated 10.5.2013 passed under Section 12(2) of the Act (and its subsequent confirmation by the Government) is legally sustainable when some grounds relied upon by the detaining authority are alleged to be nonexistent, irrelevant or relate only to individual law-and-order offences rather than public order;
  2. Whether an order of detention based on multiple grounds becomes vitiated if one or more grounds are nonexistent or irrelevant (as argued by the petitioner relying on precedents such as Biram Chand and others), or whether Section 12A (grounds severable) prevents such invalidation;
  3. Whether the facts and criminal cases cited by the detaining authority establish satisfaction that the petitioner's activities were likely to affect "public order" so as to justify preventive detention under Section 12(2) of the Act;
  4. What is the legal standard for the detaining authority's satisfaction — whether it must record a finding of guilt in the criminal cases or only be satisfied that detention is necessary to prevent acts prejudicial to the maintenance of public order (as discussed in Pratap Singh).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The District Magistrate considered facts that were not available or relevant; the grounds of detention relate to individual law-and-order matters and not to public tranquility or public order, hence detention under Section 12(2) is not justified.
  • Several of the criminal cases relied upon either resulted in bail or acquittal: (i) bail granted in Chandankiyari (Amlabad) P.S. Case No. 59 of 2012 (order dated 5.3.2013); (ii) bail in Chandankiyari (Amlabad) P.S. Case No. 144 of 2012 (order dated 6.12.2012); (iii) acquittal in Chandankiyari (Bhojudih) P.S. Case No. 43 of 2005 (judgment dated 22.3.2013); (iv) bail in Jaipur (Purulia) P.S. Case No. 20 of 2005 (order dated 25.2.2013); and (v) provisional bail in Kashipur (Purulia) P.S. Case No. 25 of 2012 (order dated 16.5.2012).
  • No public petition had alleged that the petitioner threatened society or extorted money from jail; some station diary entries relied on were made at police instance.
  • Relied on authority (Biram Chand v. State of U.P., AIR 1974 SC 1161) and other decisions to argue that if one of several grounds is nonexistent/irrelevant the whole detention order falls because the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority cannot be ascertained without that ground.
  • Relied upon Pappu Yadav (1987 Bihar Law Judgments 300) and Kuso Sah (1974 1 SCC 185) to stress the distinction between law-and-order and public order and to argue that detention is not permissible if activities do not disturb public order.

Respondent-State's Arguments

  • Section 12A (grounds of detention severable) was not available when the petitioner's relied-upon judgments were passed; Section 12A provides that when an order is made on multiple grounds it shall be deemed to have been made separately on each such ground, and an order is not to be invalidated merely because one or more grounds are vague, non-existent, non-relevant or invalid for any other reason.
  • Even if some grounds are defective, Section 12A prevents those defects from automatically invalidating the entire order of detention.
  • The criminal cases and station diary entries considered by the detaining authority showed conduct that affected the public at large (e.g., extortion/rangdari, manipulating railway tenders, threats and assaults), not merely isolated individual grievances; therefore the detaining authority was justified in concluding that detention was necessary to prevent acts prejudicial to maintenance of public order.
  • The petitioner's representation was considered; the Advisory Board recommended and the Government approved the detention order, so there is no merit in the writ petition and it should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Biram Chand v. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1974 (SC) 1161 Principle that an order of detention based on subjective satisfaction may be vitiated if one of the grounds is nonexistent or irrelevant, because it is not possible to say whether detention would have been ordered without that ground. The petitioner invoked this authority to argue that a nonexistent/irrelevant ground should invalidate the detention. The Court considered the principle but observed that after insertion of Section 12A the petitioner’s reliance on that principle is not available in the same manner; Section 12A makes grounds severable and thus the presence of some invalid grounds does not necessarily invalidate the order.
Pappu Yadav alias Rajesh Ranjan Yadav v. State of Bihar, (1987) Bihar Law Judgments 300 Held that where an order of detention is passed on several grounds, if one of those grounds is found irrelevant the order becomes unsustainable. The petitioner relied on this decision to challenge the detention. The Court noted the decision but held that the legal position has been affected by the insertion of Section 12A, which prevents automatic invalidation of a detention order merely because some grounds are irrelevant.
Kuso Sah v. State of Bihar, (1974) 1 SCC 185 Emphasized distinction between law-and-order and public order; detention under preventive detention statutes requires jeopardy to public order, not merely individual disturbances. The petitioner cited this precedent to argue that the cases relied on related only to individual law-and-order matters. The Court analyzed the facts of the cited cases and station diary entries and concluded that the activities alleged could be viewed as affecting public order; further, Section 12A limited the scope of Kuso Sah-based attacks on the detention order.
Pratap Singh v. State of Jharkhand, 2011 (4) JLJR 108 Clarified that the detaining authority must be satisfied whether detention is necessary to prevent acts prejudicial to maintenance of public order; the authority need not record a finding of guilt in criminal proceedings and the grant of bail is not dispositive. The Court expressly relied on paragraph 18 of Pratap Singh to hold that the detaining authority's satisfaction relates to likelihood of affecting public order and that grant of bail or acquittal in particular cases does not necessarily negate the need for preventive detention. This principle informed the Court's acceptance of the detaining authority's assessment in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record, the statutory provisions and the cited case law. Its analysis proceeded in two main strands:

  1. Standard for detention and reliance on Pratap Singh: The Court quoted and relied on paragraph 18 of Pratap Singh v. State of Jharkhand (2011 (4) JLJR 108) to explain the proper standard: the detaining authority is entitled to consider allegations (from FIRs or charge-sheets) to decide whether detention is necessary to prevent a person from acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. The authority does not have to adjudicate guilt or record a finding of guilt; what is required is subjective satisfaction about the likelihood of the person's activities affecting public order. The grant of bail in criminal cases is not determinative of the necessity for preventive detention.
  2. Review of facts and cases cited by the detaining authority: The Court summarized the five criminal cases relied on by the District Magistrate — including offences under sections such as 386, 307, 326, 467, 468, 471, 420, 120(B), 386/387/120(B), and two cases under 302 and related Arms Act provisions — and noted the factual allegations (e.g., demands of 'rangdari' (extortion), movement with fabricated documents, and allegations connected to serious offences including murder and arms-related charges). The Court also noted several station diary entries referenced by the detaining authority.
  3. Effect of acquittals or bail and gravity of offences: The Court accepted that even if the petitioner had been acquitted in one case and granted bail in others, that did not necessarily diminish the gravity of the allegations or the justification for preventive detention. The Court reiterated that the detaining authority's assessment of likely prejudice to public order was the relevant criterion, not the outcome of individual criminal proceedings.
  4. Effect of Section 12A (grounds severable): The respondents relied on Section 12A of the (Bihar) Control of Crimes Act, 1981 (as described in the opinion) which provides that where an order is made on two or more grounds, it shall be deemed to have been made separately on each ground and shall not be invalid merely because one or more grounds are vague, non-existent, non-relevant or invalid. The Court observed that after insertion of Section 12A, the petitioner’s contention that one or more defective grounds should invalidate the entire detention order was not available in the same way; accordingly, the existence of some defective grounds would not automatically render the order of detention illegal.

In light of the standard articulated in Pratap Singh, the specific allegations in the cited FIRs/charges and the safeguarding effect of Section 12A as interpreted by the Court, the Court concluded that the grounds advanced in the writ petition were not sufficient to quash the detention order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was dismissed; accordingly, the detention order passed by the District Magistrate and approved by the Government was upheld. The Court's core ruling may be expressed as: DISMISSED — detention order maintained.

Immediate implications: The direct legal effect is that the petitioner's challenge failed and the detention order remains in force (the writ petition stands dismissed). The Court applied existing authorities (notably Pratap Singh) and statutory provision Section 12A to sustain the detention; the decision affirms that, on the facts presented, the detaining authority's subjective satisfaction regarding likely prejudice to public order was adequate.

The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal doctrine beyond its application of precedent and Section 12A to the facts; its effect is to uphold the impugned detention in this individual case.

    Awadhesh Singh Alias Abhay Pratap Singh Petitioner(S) v. The State Of Jharkhand And Others (S)

    This writ petition (criminal) has been filed with a prayer to quash the order dated 10.5.2013 issued by the District Magistrate, Bokaro vide memo No. 3-563.Legal in exercise of power conferred u/s 12(2) of the Jharkhand Control of Crimes Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred as ‘the Act’ for short), whereby the petitioner has been directed to be detained in custody till 9.5.2014 and also to quash the order dated 21.6.2013 issued vide memo No. 3.CCA/24/16/2012-2559/Ranchi passed by Under Secretary (Home), Government of Jharkhand by which aforesaid order passed by the District Magistrate has been confirmed.

    2. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid orders and directions, the petitioner has preferred this writ petition on the ground that the District Magistrate has considered the facts which was not available and the cases referred, making grounds for detention of the petitioner in custody do not come under the purview of public tranquility, rather the cases referred, relate to respective individual which would be a case of law and order and for that the petitioner cannot be detained in custody for such a period.

    3. It is contended that- (i) in Chandankiyari (Amlabad) P.S Case No. 59 of 2012 registered u/s 386/307/326/34 of the I.P.C and Section 27 of the Arms Act, the petitioner was granted bail by this Hon'ble Court vide order dated 5.3.2013 passed in B.A No. 440 of 2013; (ii) in Chandankiyari (Amlabad) P.S Case No. 144 of 2012 registered u/s 467/468/471/420/120(B) of the I.P.C, he has been granted bail by learned Sessions Judge, Bokaro vide order dated 6.12.2012; (iii) in Chandankiyari (Bhojudih) P.S Case No. 43 of 2005 registered u/s 386/387/120(B) of the I.P.C, the petitioner was acquitted from the charges vide judgment dated 22.3.2013; (iv) in Jaipur (Purulia) P.S Case No. 20 of 2005 registered u/s 302/34 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act, he has been granted bail by learned ACJM, Raghunathpur, Purulia by order dated 25.2.2013; and (v) in Kashipur (Purulia) P.S Case No. 25 of 2012 registered u/s 302 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act, he has been granted provisional bail by learned Sessions Judge, Purulia on 16.5.2012 till 17.6.2013

    When the petitioner was likely to be released from custody, the Superintendent of Police, Bokaro on his own by referring aforesaid cases had sent proposal to the District Magistrate, Bokaro for detaining the petitioner in custody. It is made clear that no pubic petition was filed to the effect that petitioner is a threat to the society or he had been threatening any one form jail for the purpose of extorting money. In order to strengthen the recommendation, few station diary entries made at the instance of police itself, have also been cited. On the basis of proposal made by the Superintendent of Police, the District Magistrate, Bokaro has passed impugned order dated 10.5.2013 in exercise of powers conferred u/s 12(2) of the Act. The petitioner had made representation against order of detention, but it was not properly considered and the authority concerned rejected the same arbitrarily. After having opinion of Advisory Board, order of the District Magistrate was approved by the Government of Jharkhand vide 3.CCA/24/16/2012-2559/Ranchi dated 21.6.2013 The detention order so passed and approved is contrary to law and detention of the petitioner is nothing but an illegal detention and therefore aforesaid orders are liable to be quashed and appropriate direction to release the petitioner be passed.

    It was submitted that writ petitioner was acquitted in one of the cases referred by the detaining authority. Some irrelevant facts which were not available, were also considered against passing of such order. By referring the judgment reported in AIR 1974 (SC) 1161Biram Chand v. State of Uttar Pradesh, it was pointed out that order under the Act is the decision of the detaining authority which depend on subjective satisfaction. If one of the grounds is non-existent or irrelevant or is not available under the law, the entire detention order will fall, since it is not possible to predicate as to whether the detaining authority would have made an order for detention even in the absence of nonexistent or irrelevant ground. The conclusion is, therefore, irresistible and in that view of the matter the impugned order is invalid and the detention on this score alone is liable to be held illegal.

    The learned counsel has also relied on the judgment reported in 1987 Bihar Law Judgments 300Pappu Yadav alias Rajesh Ranjan Yadav v. State of Bihar, in which it was held that- (B) Bihar Control of Crimes Act, 1981, Section 12(2)-Order of detention-Passed on several grounds-One of those grounds-If found irrelevant-Order becomes unsustainable. He has also relied on the judgment reported in (1974) 1 SCC 185Kuso Sah v. State of Bihar and submitted that the there is distinction between law and order and public order. If the activities of the detenue do not disturb the public order or the society at large or prejudicial, then he cannot be detained by exercise of power conferred u/s 12(2) of the Act.

    4. On the other hand, learned counsel, appearing for the respondents-State has submitted that Section 12A of the Act was not available when the judgments cited by the writ petitioner were passed. Section 12A speaks as follows:-

    “12-A. Grounds of detention severable.- (1) Where a person has been detained in pursuance of an order of detention whether made before or after the commencement of the Bihar Control of Crimes Act, 1981 under section 12 which has been made on two or more grounds, such order of detention shall be deemed to have been made separately on each of such grounds and accordingly-

    (a) such order shall not be deemed to be invalid or inoperative merely because one or some of the grounds is or are.

    (i) vague.

    (ii) non-existent

    (iii) non-relevant

    (iv) not connected or not proximately connected with such person or

    (v) invalid for any other reason whatsoever. and it is not therefore possible to hold that the Government or officer making such order would have been satisfied as provided in section 12 with reference to the remaining ground or grounds and made the order of detention.

    (b) The Government or officer making the order of detention shall be deemed to have made the order of detention under the said section after being satisfied as provided in that section with reference to the remaining ground or grounds.”

    By referring provision contained u/s 12A, it was submitted that even if some of the grounds are found vague or non-existent or irrelevant or not connected proximately or invalid for any other reason, shall be no ground for setting aside order of detention. It was further submitted that the cases under reference on which the detaining authority satisfied himself before passing detention order are not solely affecting the individuals, rather criminal activities of the writ petitioner was so that it was affecting the public at large. He is terrors in the society and nobody dare to speak against him. The facts narrated in the F.I.R lodged against writ petitioners clearly indicate that he used to indulge in managing tender in Railways and for that the contractor of his choice are only permitted to file tender to receive contract and the person who did not agree to the wish of the writ petitioner, is being threatened with dire consequences and subjected to assault. This sort of activity of the writ petitioner is not confined to causing grievance only to individuals but this is causing disturbance to the tender process of the Government and the activities come well within purview of public order and prejudicial.

    The representation filed by the writ petitioner was well considered and after giving thought and consideration and also after being recommended by the Advisory Board, the detention order passed by the District Magistrate was approved by the Government. There is no merit in this writ application and the same is liable to be dismissed.

    5. I have examined the case record and relevant provisions of law and also the judgments cited above. In Paragraph-18 of the judgment in the case of Pratap Singh v. State of Jharkhand reported in 2011 (4) JLJR 108 it has been held as follows:-

    “18. In the case in hand, the detaining authority has considered the facts of five criminal cases wherein undisputedly writ petitioner is accused. The detaining authority gave the facts of the cases in the reasons for order which were the facts mentioned in the First Information Report or as mentioned in the charge-sheet submitted after investigation. The detaining authority had no right to accept or reject the allegation levelled in the First Information report or made in the challan. He was supposed to look into the allegations and to satisfy for the purpose of finding out whether the detention of such accused is necessary in a view to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to maintenance of “Public Order” and there is a reason to fear that activities of antisocial elements cannot be prevented otherwise than by immediate order of detention of such person. Sub-section 1 of Section 12 nowhere provides that for arriving at such conclusion referred above, he has to record a finding of complete guilt of the accused in a criminal case. What is required is that the detaining authorities satisfaction with respect to the person concerned and his activities which are “likely to be affecting” the “Public Order” necessitating his immediate detention. The grant of bail may not be relevant factor and is not of much importance because of the simple reason that the Court may pass the order of bail as in the opinion of the Court the detention of the accused in that particular case may not be necessary. A person against whom several allegations are there and he may escape the conviction in one of criminal case that itself is not any indication that there cannot be apprehension of involving himself in activities detrimental to the “Public Order”.”

    The District Magistrate has referred, five cases registered against writ petitioners, one was registered vide Chandankiyari (Amlabad) P.S Case No. 59 of 2012 registered u/s 386/307/326/34 of the I.P.C and Section 27 of the Arms Act in which allegation against the petitioner is that he had demanded Rangdari and when he was not obliged, the incident took place. The second Case was registered vide Chandankiyari (Amlabad) P.S Case No. 144 of 2012 dated 12.10.2012 registered u/s 467/468/471/420/120(B) of the I.P.C, in which the petitioner was found moving in a vehicle with false and fabricated documents. The third case i.e Chandankiyari (Bhojudih) P.S Case No. 43 of 2005 registered u/s 386/387/120(B) of the I.P.C also indicates that the accused persons had been demanding Rangdari. The fourth case is Jaipur (Purulia) P.S Case No. 20 of 2005 registered u/s 302/34 of the I.P.C and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act and the fifth case is also u/s 302 of the I.P.C vide Kashipur (Purulia) P.S Case No. 25 of 2012. Besides those cases, Amlabad (OP) Station Diary Entry No. 05 dated 1.3.2013, Bhojudih (OP) Station Diary Entry No. 94 dated 6.3.2013, Amlabad (OP) Station Diary Entry No. 162 dated 11.3.2013 and Bhojudih (OP) Station Diary Entry No. 239 dated 14.3.2013, have also been entered. Even assuming it to be correct that he was acquitted in one of the cases and granted bail in rest cases, that does not lower down the gravity of the offence for which he has been prosecuted.

    After insertion of Section 12‘A’, the grounds on which the learned counsel has been banking upon for quashing of the detention order, now not available and therefore if, out of several grounds, if any one or some one is vague or non-existent or irrelevant or not connected or not proximately connected or even invalid, the order of detention cannot be held illegal.

    I do not find the grounds taken in this writ application are tenable to quash the detention order passed by the District Magistrate and approved by the Government. Accordingly, this writ petition stands dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Awadhesh Singh Alias Abhay Pratap Singh Petitioner(S) v. The State Of Jharkhand And Others (S)
    (Mar 7, 2014)