By the Court:-
By way of this writ petition, petitioners seek to challenge inaction on the part of the respondents as they are not treating the appointments of the petitioners as Teacher Gr.II (Science) from the date the candidates lower in merit were given appointment.
The respondents, vide order dated 06.09.2011, rejected the candidature and finally cancelled the selection of petitioners on the post of Teacher Gr.II (Science), made pursuant to advertisement dated 13.08.2008 Aggrieved thereby, petitioners filed Writ Petitions. Similarly situated persons had also filed Writ petition No. 3836/2011 - Devi Bijani v. State of Rajasthan, which came to be dismissed by this court vide order dated 25.08.2011 and in that light, the writ petitions filed by petitioners were also dismissed. Petitioners preferred Special Leave Petitions before the Supreme Court, which came to be allowed and the petitioners were declared eligible and qualified to be appointed as Teacher Gr.II, and accordingly corrigendum was issued on 04.08.2010 with a direction to the respondent concerned to provide appointment to the petitioners on the post of Teacher Gr.II (Science). The Supreme Court held that since the rules were amended during continuation of the process of selection, therefore those candidates, who had appeared in the examination and were found eligible on the date of issuance of advertisement and stood qualified, were declared eligible for appointment. In compliance of the order of the Supreme Court, the respondents have provided appointment to the petitioners in December, 2013 and January, 2014. However, the respondents are not treating their appointment on the post from the date the candidates lower in merit were appointed i.e 07.11.2011 and, therefore, they are made to suffer financial loss as well as loss of seniority in the cadre and other service benefits.
This Court dealt with similar controversy in Writ Petition No. 7907/2003 - Indra Singh v. State of Rajasthan, decided vide judgment dated 17.01.2009 In that case also the petitioner applied for the post of Senior Teacher (English). The respondents rejected his candidature on the ground that he earlier secured appointment on lower post claiming benefit of ex-serviceman and that he does not have the Degree of B.A in English. He filed writ petition challenging the action of the respondents. So far his earlier appointment on lower post claiming benefit of ex-serviceman, the court held that if a candidate has secured appointment on a lower post claiming benefit of ex-serviceman and applies for appointment on higher post, he would still be entitled to the benefit of being ex-serviceman but this benefit would not be available to him on the same post. This court held him eligible for appointment as he had English subject as an optional subject in all the three years of degree course. It was further held that for the purpose of appointment on the said post, a candidate needs to possess English as one of the optional/elective subjects. This court while allowing the writ petition directed that since the petitioner is already in service of the respondents, he shall be entitled to only notional benefits of seniority and increments etc. for the intervening period. His appointment, however, would be effective from the date of appointment of candidate so selected below him in merit list.
Dealing with similar controversy while deciding two writ petitions, being S.B Civil Writ Petitions No. 451/2004 (Smt. Shobha Sharma v. State) and 1578/2002 (Smt. Shobha Sharma v. State of Rajasthan) vide its judgment dated 13.02.2009, this court directed the respondents to treat the petitioner to have been appointed with effect from 07.02.1992 immediately above all the candidates who were lesser meritorious than the petitioners. Petitioner however was held entitled to notional benefits for the intervening period for the purpose of pay, annual grade increments, revision of pay scales revised from time to time and selection scale as also seniority deeming as if she was appointed on 07.02.1992
Another similar controversy was also decided by this court vide its judgment dated 01.12.2008 in Writ Petition No. 2515/2002 - Sita Ram Saini v. State. In that case also, after prolonged litigation up to the Supreme Court, the respondents gave appointment to the petitioner therein but treated his appointment and granted him benefit of seniority from the date of appointment only. He filed said writ petition claiming seniority at appropriate place on the basis of his placement in the merit. This court allowed the writ petition and directed the respondents to treat him to have been appointed with effect from the date the candidate immediately below him in merit was appointed, and assign him seniority as per his placement in the merit list, with all consequential benefits of seniority. However, he was held entitled only to notional benefits.
This Court in Suman Bai v. State - 2009 (1) WLC (Raj.) 381, held that candidates in lower order of merit cannot become entitled merely because they had approached court earlier. Petitioners had a fresh cause of action for approaching in such situation and their writ petition not barred either as res judicata or as being him in properly constituted. This directed the respondents to treat petitioners senior to respondents, who were in lower order of merit.
It is further contended in the writ petition that in the matter of School Lecturers (English) in the same Department, where appointments were delayed because of the fault of the State authorities, the candidates were accorded appointment from the date the candidates stood lower in merit were appointed and they have been granted all consequential benefits of services.
The petitioners approached the respondents by way of representations for extending them same benefits of service which have been granted to the candidates who stood lower in merit than the petitioners, but till date nothing has been done. Hence, this writ petition on behalf of the petitioners for a direction to the respondents to treat their appointment from the date the candidates lower in merit, were given, with all consequential benefits of service, such as seniority, continuity of service, pay fixation, grant of annual grade increments.
Having regard to the facts of the case, writ petition is disposed of requiring the petitioners to make a representation to respondent no. 2 - Director, Secondary Education, Bikaner, along-with a copy of this order, who shall, after verifying the facts stated above, consider and decide the same by a speaking order within a period of three months from the date of its making, addressing the grievance of the petitioners for extending them the relief as prayed for, as the candidates, who stood lower in merit, are getting benefit of higher pay, seniority, annual grade increments and other service benefits including the selection scales. If the respondent no. 2 decides to place the petitioners above in seniority than the candidates who stood lower in merit, then the petitioners would be entitled to all benefits of seniority but they would be entitled only to notional benefits.