Dharam Chand Chaudhary, J. (Oral).
An order passed on 19th September, 2011 by learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Rampur Bushahr, allowing thereby the respondent herein to sue himself as an indigent person is under challenge on the grounds inter alia that the procedure prescribed under Rule 6 and 7 of Order 33 CPC has not been followed and also that the mandatory provisions enshrined under Order 33 and the Rules have been misinterpreted and wrongly applied, which has resulted into miscarriage of justice to the petitioner. It has been specifically submitted that the plaint was not presented by respondent No. 1-plaintiff in person as required under law. The inquiry as envisaged under Order 33 Rule 1 to 7 CPC has also not been conducted.
2. On hearing learned counsel on both sides and also going through the record, it is crystal clear that the plaint has been presented by Shri Ashok Mehta, Advocate on behalf of the respondent-plaintiff on 14 June, 2011. On 21st June, 2011, when came up for office report, the plaintiff-respondent was represented by Mr. Mehta. The provisions contained under Rule 3 of Order 33 CPC amply demonstrate that the application/plaint is required to be presented in the Court by the applicant/plaintiff, in person, unless, he is exempted from appearance and in that event, the same is required to be presented by his authorized agent, who is in a position to answer the material questions in relation thereto. Not only this, but under sub-rule 4 of Order 33 CPC, the Court may record the statement of the applicant/plaintiff and in the event of presentation of the application/plaint by his authorized agent, the statement of such agent with regard to the merits of the claim led therein. The non presentation of the application/plaint in the manner prescribed by Rule 2 and 3 supra is one of the grounds of rejection thereof under Rule 5 of Order 33 CPC. Therefore, the impugned orders, Annexures P-2 and P-6 are bad in the eyes of law on this score alone.
3. No doubt, the report with regard to the indigency of the respondent-plaintiff in terms of Rule 1-A of Order 33 CPC has been sought from the Collector and it is on the basis of this report, he has been permitted to institute the suit in the capacity of an indigent person, however, without following the procedure prescribed under Rule 6 and 7 of Order 33 CPC.
4. It has been held by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Vidhya Chand v. Smt. Shaimu Devi, 2003 (1) Shim.L.C, 297 that the procedure prescribed under Rules 2 to 4, 6 and 7 is required to be followed while considering the application for seeking permission to sue as an indigent person. The trial Court has not followed the procedure so prescribed and as such the order is not only illegal, but also passed mechanically and without application of mind. The same, therefore, is perverse and as such not legally sustainable. I, therefore, quash and set aside the orders Annexures P-2 and P-6 and remand the application to the trial Court for fresh disposal in the light of the observations hereinabove and in accordance with law. The trial Judge shall proceed afresh in the matter from the stage of Rule 3 of Order 33 CPC.
5. With the above observations the petition stands disposed of, so also the pending application(s), if any.
6. The parties through learned counsel representing them are directed to appear in the trial Court on 20 September, 2014. The record be sent back so as to reach in the trial Court well before the date fixed.