AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Commissioner Of Income Tax-I (S) v. Shashiben Rajendra Jain Opponent(S)

    Jayant Patel, J.:— The Revenue has preferred the present appeal on the following substantial questions of law formulated by the appellant at paragraph 2(A) and (B), which read as under:-

    “2(A) Whether the Appellate Tribunal has substantially erred in holding that the disclosure made by the assessee was not over and above the income declared in its books of accounts despite the fact that this amount was disclosed by the assessee during the survey?

    (B) Whether the Appellate Tribunal has substantially erred in not appreciating the fact that the statement recorded u/s. 133A is deemed to be statement recorded u/s 131(1) and the statement recorded u/s 131(1) has all the evidentiary value especially because the taxes related to the disclosure were paid and such statement was not retracted till the filing or return?”

    2. We have heard Ms. Bhatt, learned Counsel for the appellant and Mr. Shah, learned Counsel upon caveat for the Assessee.

    3. The relevant facts are that during the survey the Assessee had declared the income for the respective year of Rs. 35,00,000/-. Thereafter, when assessment took place, A.O, treated the income of Rs. 35,00,000/- in addition to the income tax declared in the Income Tax Return and assessed the amount of tax. The matter was carried in appeal and CIT(A) confirmed the order of A.O The Tribunal observed at paragraph 8 as under:-

    “8. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material on record. It is an undisputed fact that during the course of survey, Assessee admitted to the income of Rs. 35 lacs but in the return of income filed by the Assessee the income of Rs. 32,49,328/- was offered to tax. It is also a fact that the additional of Rs. 35 lac has been made only on the basis of admission made by the Assessee during the course of survey. Before us, revenue has not brought any material on record to demonstrate that the addition of Rs. 35 lac made by the A.O, is backed by tangible material apart from the statement recorded during the course of survey. Considering the aforesaid facts, more so, when ld. A.R, has admitted to confirmation of the addition of the differential amount, we are of the view that in the present case, the addition be restricted to Rs. 2,50,672/- being the shortfall in the amount admitted during the course of survey and as declared by the Assessee in the return of income. Thus this ground of the Assessee is partly allowed.”

    4. Resultantly, the Tribunal partly allowed the appeal. Under these circumstances, the Revenue has preferred the present appeal.

    5. As such, the aforesaid finding of Tribunal shows that as per the Tribunal the Revenue has not brought any material on record to demonstrate that the additional of Rs. 35,00,000/- made by the A.O, is taxed by any tangible material apart from the statement recorded during the course of survey. The statement made is considered by the Tribunal and upon appreciation of evidence of the statement if the Tribunal has found that the Assessee admitted the income tax of Rs. 35,00,000/- for the respective year and the Tribunal did not find that it was in addition to the income already declared, such aspect would fall in the arena of finding of fact, which would be beyond the scope of Second Appeal.

    6. Attempt was made by the learned Counsel for the Revenue to contend that the statement made can be interpreted to mean the income declared of Rs. 35,00,000/- in addition to the normal income to which we find that the same cannot be accepted, because we have not found any perversity in the finding of fact by the Tribunal for treating the income of the Assessee at Rs. 35,00,000/-. In any event, when there is no perversity in the finding of fact, this Court in exercise of the power in Second Appeal would substitutel another finding of fact as sought to be canvassed.

    7. Apart from the above, there is no substantial questions of law would arise for consideration as the whole appeal is based on questions of fact and not on questions of law.

    8. Hence, we find that, as there is no substantial questions of law, no interference is called for to the order of the Tribunal. The appeal is meritless. Hence, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income Tax-I (S) v. Shashiben Rajendra Jain Opponent(S)
    (Jan 19, 2015)