Sonia Gokani, J.:— The applicants herein are the petitioners of Special Civil Application No. 11149 of 2015 where they have challenged the decision of the respondent State of cancelling the recruitment exercise for the post of Revenue Talatis Class-III wherein more than 7 lakh candidates appeared in the written test. More than 7500 candidates were called for verification of documents and thereafter the State shortlisted 1500 candidates for being appointed on the said post of Revenue Talatis.
2. It appears from the averment made in the petition that in response to the advertisement issued for the post of Revenue Talatis on 16.1.2014, approximately 7,53,703 candidates applied. The applications were invited online from 16.1.2014 and the last date of submission was 30.1.2014 Multiple Choice Questions with minus marks were to be attempted by way of screening test.
3. Prior to one day of examination, FIR No. 46 of 2014 came to be filed before Sector 7 Police Station. Police authorities looked into the aspect and examination continued. On 18.2.2014 the police authority was in knowledge of the fact that complaint with regard to the illegality and malpractice was before the Local Crime Branch (LCB), Gandhinagar. Hoever, on having been verified by seniors officers, the State continued with the examination.
4. On 21.2.2014 one Mr. R.B Naik, Deputy Section Officer of the Education Department, was arrested and he was suspended thereafter. Pursuant to the investigation, it had been revealed to the authority that many of the OMR sheets were having some identification marks. Therefore, Gujarat Technological University had suggested screening of OMR sheets and authority had found out nearly 13,207 OMR sheets which had been identification marks. It was also noticed by 26.5.2014 that 23 candidates had made mark “b” on the right side of OMR sheets.
5. On 28.5.2014 for getting the details of those who have marked the papers with remark “b”, hard disks were collected and reported to Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL), Gandhinagar, for scrutiny. On 5.6.2014, physical copies of 27 candidates of such OMR sheets have been sent to the concerned police officer. These persons have been arrested whereas three persons are still absconding, according to the respondent authority as per the letter communicated by LCB, Gandhinagar. It is also the matter of record that after preliminary manual assessment/examination, candidature of 98 candidates was suggested to be cancelled. 63 of such candidates whose answer sheets were found with mark “b” were called by the police authority. On 11.8.2014, it was decided to go with declaration of the results. However, on 19.8.2014, Public Accounts Committee met and it was decided to cancel the candidature of those candidates who have made mark “b” on the OMR sheets and to prepare the details through the Deputy Registrar, Gujarat Technological University in case of 98 candidates who have also made same identification marks on their OMR sheets.
6. On 20.9.2014 one Vipul Panchal alleged against one Dhirubhai Bhil, Peon of Revenue Department and a woman employee Shital Jani of having allegedly involved in the malpractice and therefore both were transferred. 123 candidates were having similar addresses, and details of their addresses have been sent to LCB and yet result came to be published on 17.10.2014 In the provisional merit list, 8456 candidates were found to have qualified and their details have been placed on website category-wise and they have been called between 17.10.2014 and 21.10.2014 for examination of their testimonials.
7. On 17.10.2014 one Shri. Babubhai Damor indicated that 100 persons who passed are close relatives and has given additional list of other candidates who have cleared examination due to malpractices were from one family of one PSI of Chakalia of Mahudi. Details of 127 candidates and 198 candidates had been prepared, out of which 47 candidates were common and therefore, total 258 candidates were found requiring some attention.
8. By way of the Civil Application, a request has been made by learned advocate for the original petitioner-applicants herein not to allow the State to go ahead with the advertisement for the post of Revenue Talati without completing the process of recruitment that has been commenced with the publication of advertisement on 15.1.2014
9. Learned advocate Mr. Joshi for the applicants has fervently urged that there was a Civil Suit came to be filed before Bhavnagar Court being Regular Civil Suit No. 83 of 2014 questioning the action of the respondent State in preparing the provisional select list and going ahead with the examination, alleging that large scale illegalities have been perpetrated in the instant case. He has pointed out that in the written statement filed by the State and in the reply given to the notice of interim injunction, State has been categorically stating that some of the anti-social elements have attempted to unnecessarily draw the issue of malpractice out of proportion. Examination has been conducted in transparent manner. Some elements have tried to lure the candidates and that cannot be a ground for cancelling the examination. He has urged that such stand was taken by the State on 15.3.2014 Nothing has happened in one and half year period which would allow the State to conduct the examination and proceed to go ahead with recruitment advertisement once again. According to him, it is not unusual for the siblings to clear in one particular examination and it is not unusual for the candidates to have similar addresses if they are otherwise staying as paying guest or the students have chosen to appear from a particular case. He has urged that details of Public Accounts Committee and details of those candidates whose addresses are similar, are not provided to the petitioners. He has urged that decision to cancel the examination has no rational basis. The petitioners, therefore, would have right to be appointed. He has relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of East Coast Railway v. Mahadev Appa Rao reported in (2010) 7 SCC 678.
10. Learned Government Pleader Ms. Shah appearing for the State has taken this Court through the chronology of events and argued that post of Revenue Talati which has been created in the year 2008 requires to be filled up urgently. She has pointed out that although on the previous day of the examination, a complaint was filed, on having verified that there was no leakage of papers, examination was conducted. Thereafter, one complaint came to be filed of those candidates who were tainted, the list was segregated and rest of the examination had been continued. According to her, when OMR sheets of 13207 candidates were found to have some identification marks, even those answer sheets have been separated and later on at the behest of investigating agency, entire hard disc was directed to be sent to FSL through investigation agency. Result of which is still awaited. However, every possible attempt was made to save the examination and the State was not desirous to cancel it. She pointed out that the very concerned Revenue Department was permitted to go ahead with examination instead of State Selection Agency. This fact itself shows that the State is in hurry to recruit the persons on the post of Revenue Talati.
11. 900 more seats are created and in all there are 2480 seats are vacant as on today. She has also pointed out that duties of Revenue Talatis are very vital. To share the burden of Talati-cum-Mantri to ensure that some of the tasks are expeditiously attended, they have been given the task of deciding mutation of entries and also to check the encroachment of the government waste land, periodical verification of the land etc. and therefore, it would be so much vital for the State not to take any chance if there are allegations of large scale illegalities to continue with the recruitment process. She has emphasised on the decision of the Public Account Committee and has urged after the holistic view, the State has chosen to scrap the entire examination. She has relied on the following decisions:
1. All India Railway Recruitment Board v. K. Shyam Kumar reported in (2010) 6 SCC 614.
2. Tanvi Sarwal v. Central Board of Secondary Education reported in (2015) 6 SCC 573.
12. Having heard both sides, it would be apt to deal with the decision of the Apex Court rendered in the case of East Coast Railway v. Mahadev Appa Rao (supra) where the Apex Court was dealing with the issue of cancellation of selection test and where the Court had examined the scope of issue and the fact to be considered to hold that there will be a mandatory need for proper application of mind and reasons to be given in cancellation of order. It further assailed that it also depends on the source and credibility of information made available to competent authority. However, essential requirement is that competent authority must have taken decision after due application of mind instead of acting mechanically or impulsively. In the matter before the Apex Court departmental test cancelled on the basis of certain complaints that proper facilities for taking typewriting test were not provided for some of the candidates who failed in test. The record of the department when examined did not show that the decision for cancellation was an informed decision. Therefore, the Court did not approve such decision. It would be vital to be reproduced the relevant findings and observations at paragraph Nos. 28 to 31 of the said judgement:
“28. That is not, however, the position in the instant case. The order of cancellation passed by the competent authority was not preceded even by a prima facie satisfaction about the correctness of the allegations made by the unsuccessful candidates leave alone an inquiry into the same. The minimum that was expected of the authority was a due and proper application of mind to the allegations made before it and formulation and recording of reasons in support of the view that the competent authority was taking.
29. There may be cases where an enquiry may be called for into the allegations, but there may also be cases, where even on admitted facts or facts verified from record or an enquiry howsoever summary the same maybe, it is possible for the competent authority to take a decision, that there are good reasons for making the order which the authority eventually makes. But we find it difficult to sustain an order that is neither based on an enquiry nor even a prima facie view taken upon a due and proper application of mind to the relevant facts. Judged by that standard the order of cancellation passed by the competent authority falls short of the legal requirements and was rightly quashed by the High Court.
30. We may hasten to add that while application of mind to the material available to the competent authority is an essential pre-requisite for the making of a valid order, that requirement should not be confused with the sufficiency of such material to support any such order. Whether or not the material placed before the competent authority was in the instant case sufficient to justify the decision taken by it, is not in issue before us. That aspect may have assumed importance only if the competent authority was shown to have applied its mind to whatever material was available to it before cancelling the examination. Since application of mind as a thresh-hold requirement for a valid order is conspicuous by its absence the question whether the decision was reasonable having regard to the material before the authority is rendered academic. Sufficiency or otherwise of the material and so also its admissibility to support a decision the validity whereof is being judicially reviewed may even otherwise depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case. No hard and fast rule can be formulated in that regard nor do we propose to do so in this case.
31. So also whether the competent authority ought to have conducted an enquiry into or verification of the allegations before passing an order of cancellation is a matter that would depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case. It may often depend upon the nature, source and credibility of the material placed before the authority. It may also depend upon whether any such exercise is feasible having regard to the nature of the controversy, the constraints of time, effort and expense. But what is absolutely essential is that the authority making the order is alive to the material on the basis of which it purports to take a decision. It cannot act mechanically or under an impulse, for a writ court judicially reviewing any such order cannot countenance the exercise of power vested in a public authority except after due and proper application of mind. Any other view would amount to condoning a fraud upon such power which the authority exercising the same holds in trust only to be exercised for a legitimate purpose and along settled principles of administrative law.”
13. Thus, what is essential prerequisite for making of a valid order is whether the competent authority had applied its mind to the material that was available before cancelling the examination. The Court held that it is not to be confused with the sufficiency of such material to support any such order.
14. In Tanvi Sarwal v. Central Board of Secondary Education (supra) malpractices were alleged to have been perpetuated by organized gang effectively to help various examinees during examination. Though police investigation unearthed 44 confirmed beneficiaries in various States across country, police frankly admitted impossibility of identifying each and every beneficiary amongst six lakh examinees in 1050 examination centres throughout country. Fresh examination was directed by the Court. The Court held that if such tainted examination is saved, it would compromise merit and frustrate genuine students, with aversion to concept of examination. The Court even went on to the extent of saying that even if one undeserving candidate goes undetected, it would be denial of claim of a deserving candidate. Examination was held not possible to be cleansed of all participating beneficiary candidates with certainty. Therefore, it was held that annulment of tainted examination and departure from time schedule in such extraordinary fact situation would not in any way be repugnant to rendering the decision in the case of Mridul Dhar (5), (2005) 2 SCC 65 and Priya Gupta (2012) 7 SCC 433 for holding them. Some of the observations would be vital to be reproduced:
“18. As has been noticed hereinabove, the disclosures in the investigation suggest that the benefit of answer key has been availed by several candidates taking the examination, by illegal means. Though as on date, 44 such candidates have been identified, having regard to the modus operandi put in place, the numbers of cellphones and other devices used, it is not unlikely that many more candidates have availed such undue advantage, being a part of the overall design and in the process have been unduly benefited qua the other students who had made sincere and genuine endeavours to solve the answer paper on the basis of their devoted preparation and hard labour. In view of the widespread network, that has operated, as the status reports disclose and the admission of the persons arrested including some beneficiary candidates, we are of the opinion, in view of the strong possibilities of identification of other candidates as well involved in such malpractices that the examination has become a suspect. As it is, the system of examination pursued over the decades, has been accepted by all who are rational, responsible and sensible, to be an accredited one, for comparative evaluation of the merit and worth of candidates vying for higher academic pursuits. It is thus necessary, for all the role players in the process, to secure and sustain the confidence of the public in general and the student fraternity in particular in the system by its unquestionable trustworthiness. Such a system is endorsed because of its credibility informed with guarantee of fairness, transparency, authenticity and sanctity. There cannot be any compromise with these imperatives at any cost.
19. Segregation only of the already 44 identified candidates stated to be the beneficiaries of the unprincipled manoeuvre by withholding their results for the time being, in our comprehension cannot be the solution to the problem that confronts all of us. Not only thereby, if the process is allowed to advance, it would be pushed to a vortex of litigation pertaining thereto in the foreseeable future, the prospects of the candidates would not only remain uncertain and tentative, they would also remain plagued with the prolonged anguish and anxiety if involved in the ordeal of court cases. Acting on this option, would in our estimate, amount to driving knowingly the students who are not at fault, to an uncertain future with their academic career in jeopardy on may counts. Further, there would also be a lurking possibility of unidentified beneficiary candidates stealing a march over them, on the basis of the advantages availed by them through underhand dealings as revealed. Having regard to the fact, that the course involved with time would yield the future generations of doctors of the country, who would be in charge of public health, their inherent merit to qualify for taking the course can by no means be compromised.
23. We are aware that the abrogation of the examination would result in some inconvenience to all concerned and that some extra time would be consumed for holding a fresh examination with renewed efforts therefor. This however, according to us, is the price, the stakeholders would have to suffer in order to maintain the impeccable and irrefutable sanctity and credibility of a process of examination, to assess the innate worth and capability of the participating candidates for being assigned inter se merit positions commensurate to their performance based on genuine and sincere endeavours. It is a collective challenge that all the role players would have to meet, by rising to the occasion and fulfil the task ahead at the earliest, so as to thwart and abort the deplorable design of a mindless few seeking to highjack the process for selfish gain along with the unscrupulous beneficiaries thereof. Though the Board has taken a plea that having regard to the enormity of the exercise to be undertaken, the same cannot be redone before four months, we would emphasise that this is an occasion where it (the Board) ought to gear up in full all its resources in the right spirit, in coordination with all other institutions that may be involved so as to act in tandem and hold the examination afresh at the earliest.
24. In the course of the arguments, this Court was apprised that on previous occasions such type of examination had been held anew within a period of one month. We have no reason to doubt, that all other institutions would not lag behind to extend all possible assistance to the Board in its renewed endeavour. We are not unaware that in holding the present examination as well as in participating in the exercise, all genuinely concerned have put in tireless efforts. All these, however, have been rendered futile by a handful of elements seeking to reap undue financial gain by subjecting the process to their evil manoeuvres. We have thus no hesitation to order that the All India Pre-Medical and Pre-Dental Test stands cancelled. CBSE would now have to hold a fresh examination at the earliest, by complying with all the necessary and prescribed norms, being mindful of the exigency amongst others of the commencement of the academic session which presently stands scheduled to be on and from 1.8.2015”
15. This Court is conscious of the fact that nearly 7,53,000 candidates appeared for the examination of Revenue Talati pursuant to the advertisement issued on 16.1.2014 After allowing process of conducting of examination by the Revenue Department itself. At the initial stage, the examination continued and the authority also published provisional merit list. Nearly 8657 candidates were declared to have been qualified and 8456 candidates were called for verification on 17.10.2014 and 21.10.2014
16. As has been detailed in the chronology hereinabove, right from the time the examination was to be conducted, certain allegation were made of malpractices and illegalities. However, till the State authorities had filed written statement and reply to the interim injunction in the suit before the Bhavnagar Court which challenged the entire recruitment, the State authority was not at all inclined to cancel the examination. It appears, prima facie, that identification marks on the OMR sheets were made by some of them with mark “b” and in case of nearly 13000 candidates, such identification marks had been noticed which led to the cancellation of candidature of 97 candidates, whereas in case of remaining candidates, their mark sheets have been sent to FSL, Gandhinagar. Later on the investigating agency deemed it to proper to collect and send the hard discs for scrutiny by the FSL. This was done somewhere in May, 2014 and the result is awaited.
17. Thereafter, number of illegalities have been alleged and eventually it appears from the record that decision has been taken by accepting Public Account Committee's recommendation to cancel the examination and proceed ahead with the recruitment. Prima facie, this Court is of the opinion that the matter would require consideration. Since the State has given 5 years' relaxation to all the candidates over and above other relaxations which are available under different Government Resolutions and orders, there is no prejudice to them It is not indefeasible right of any candidate even if selected to be appointed. The decision of the authority would need to be closely examined by the Court and it is prerogative of the candidate to ensure that in the order of cancellation not only there is application of mind but there is sufficiency of the material which goes into due application of mind to such material.
18. The petitioners have also asked for additional documents and they are entitled to get the same. The matter would require detailed consideration and Rule needs to be issued in the main matter.
19. Rule. Learned AGP Mr. Rindani waives service of rule for the respondent State. It is to be noted that 900 more seats are created after the respondent State has proceeded ahead with the recruitment on 16.1.2014 and 80 additional vacancies have been created. Thus, for 980 seats, there are no issues and the State, therefore, can proceed ahead with the same. However, decision to conduct fresh examination as far as 1500 seats is concerned, as 126 petitioners are before this Court, any process of recruitment would be subject to the outcome of the present petition.
20. Rule to be made returnable on 15.2.2016 Let pleadings to be over in the next six weeks. The decision of the committee along with details of addresses of 258 candidates shall be furnished to the other side on or before 23.12.2015
21. The Civil Application stands disposed of.