AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • FATAL ACCIDENTS ACT 1855
  • section 173 of Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to Act, 1988)
  • provisions (sec.110A and sec.110B of Motor Act, 1988)
  • section 279/304A/427 I.P.C
  • Section 166 of Act, 1988
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • FATAL ACCIDENTS ACT 1855
  • section 173 of Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to Act, 1988)
  • provisions (sec.110A and sec.110B of Motor Act, 1988)
  • section 279/304A/427 I.P.C
  • Section 166 of Act, 1988
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This First Appeal from Order was filed under section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 by the Insurance Company aggrieved by the order dated 7.2.2012 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Varanasi in MACP No. 138 of 2010 (Smt. Renu Singh v. Pankaj Kumar Singh).

On 8/9 July 2016, the deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh, a Civil Judge, was traveling from Lucknow to Bahraich in his Ford Fusion car bearing registration UP-40 H-7100. A truck bearing registration UP-64 B-5886, driven rashly and negligently, collided with the deceased's car, causing his immediate death at the spot. The heirs of the deceased filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 seeking compensation of Rs. 1,58,00,000/- before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Varanasi.

The owner and driver of the truck disputed their involvement in the accident by filing written statements but did not provide oral or documentary evidence. The Insurance Company also denied the claim. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 56,06,000/- with 6% annual interest to the claimants. The claimants filed a cross-objection for enhancement which was not pressed, rendering the award final as to them.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the offending truck was involved in the accident causing the death of Pankaj Kumar Singh?
  2. Whether the driver of the deceased’s car contributed to the accident through negligence, thereby warranting reduction in quantum of compensation?
  3. Whether the Tribunal erred in holding the truck driver solely responsible for the accident?
  4. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal was excessive or justified?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Insurance Company)'s Arguments

  • The truck was not involved in the accident and was falsely implicated after an undue delay in filing the FIR.
  • The primary witnesses (PW-1 and PW-2) were not present at the accident scene and were "got-up" witnesses; PW-3’s testimony was unreliable and inconsistent.
  • The driver of the deceased’s car was negligent and contributed to the accident, hence the quantum of compensation should be reduced.
  • The Tribunal erred in holding the truck driver solely responsible without considering contributory negligence by the deceased.
  • The quantum of compensation awarded was excessive.

Respondents (Claimants)’ Arguments

  • The truck was involved in the accident as supported by FIR, charge sheet, and eyewitness testimony.
  • The negligence and rashness of the deceased had no role in the accident; the truck driver was solely negligent.
  • The delay in filing the FIR does not prejudice the claimants’ case.
  • The compensation awarded by the Tribunal was justified and based on relevant documentary evidence, including salary certificates and post-mortem reports.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, 2005 0 ACJ (SC) 1840 Application of the rule of res ipsa loquitur to motor vehicle accident cases; burden of proof on defendants to show reasonable care. The court referred to this precedent to affirm that the burden lies on the driver of the offending vehicle to prove reasonable care and that contributory negligence must be established by the opposing party.
Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 Guidelines for assessment of compensation in fatal accident claims. The Tribunal applied the Sarla Verma principles conservatively in awarding compensation to the deceased’s heirs, which the court upheld.
K.R. Madhusudhan v. Administrative Officer, (2011) 4 SCC 689 Compensation principles relating to employed persons. The Tribunal did not rely on this precedent; the court noted this but found no error in the conservative approach taken.
UPSRTC v. Km. Mamta, (2016) 4 SCC 172 : AIR 2016 SC 948 Principles regarding involvement and negligence in motor accident claims. The court relied on this decision to affirm the factual findings on involvement and negligence, finding no authoritative pronouncement contrary to the Tribunal’s conclusions.
Rylands v. Fletcher, (1868) 3 HL (LR) 330 Strict liability principle applied to motor vehicles as inherently dangerous. The court referenced this principle to emphasize the inherent danger of motor vehicles and the social justice rationale for compensation even absent direct negligence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the evidence including oral testimony, documentary evidence, FIR, charge sheet, post-mortem report, and driving license of the deceased. It found the Tribunal’s reliance on the charge sheet and the absence of rebuttal evidence from the truck’s owner and driver persuasive. The Insurance Company failed to discharge the burden of proving non-involvement of the truck as no credible evidence was produced, and the owner and driver did not appear for cross-examination or to testify.

The court elaborated on the legal principles of negligence, emphasizing that negligence is relative and must be inferred from facts. It underscored the statutory duty of care imposed by the Motor Vehicle Act, including the obligation to slow down at intersections. The court rejected the contention of contributory negligence by the deceased, finding no evidence to support it.

Applying the principle of res ipsa loquitur as discussed in Jacob Mathew, the court held that the truck driver was solely negligent. The Tribunal’s factual findings were upheld as they were neither perverse nor unsupported by evidence. The court also considered the quantum of compensation and found it reasonable, despite a conservative approach by the Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

The appeal filed by the Insurance Company is dismissed with costs.

The court upheld the Tribunal’s findings that the truck was involved in the accident and that the truck driver was solely negligent. The claimants’ entitlement to compensation was affirmed, and the quantum awarded was held to be justified. The decision has the direct effect of confirming the compensation awarded to the heirs of the deceased. No new legal precedent was established beyond affirming existing principles and the factual findings of the Tribunal.

    Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Renu Singh And Others S

    1. This First Appeal From Order has been filed under section 173 of Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to ‘Act, 1988’) by Insurance Company, being aggrieved by order dated 7.2.2012 passed by Sri. Dinesh Kumar Singh, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/Additional District Judge, Court No. 10, Varanasi in MACP No. 138 of 2010 (Smt. Renu Singh v. Pankaj Kumar Singh).

    2. The facts are; on 8/9.7.2016 deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh (Civil Judge, Bahraich) son of Sri. Shyam Narayan Singh, resident of House No. S-3,190D-4 Ardali Bazar, Police Station Cantt, Varanasi was coming from Lucknow to Bahraich from his Ford Fusion Car bearing registration No. UP-40 H-7100 and a Truck bearing Registration No. UP-64 B-5886 being driven on the road and due to rash and negligent driving by its driver, it dashed with Ford Fusion Car of Pankaj Kumar Singh-deceased. Due to negligence of driver of truck, Pankaj Kumar Singh died on the spot. He succumbed to death because of the accident, is not in dispute. The heirs of deceased initiated proceedings under Section 166 of Act, 1988 seeking compensation of Rs. 1,58,00,000/- for death of Pankaj Kumar Singh. The petition was filed before Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Varanasi.

    3. Owner filed objection/written statement taking a stand, disputing involvement of offending vehicle, namely truck in the said accident. Driver also disputed his involvement in the accident.

    4. Insurance company, present appellant also filed written submission/objection denying the claim. The claimant respondents filed rejoinder affidavit reiterating stand taken in claim petition. Neither owner nor driver of truck stepped into witness box before Tribunal to adduce oral evidence or documentary evidence in support of their written statements.

    5. Tribunal awarded amount of Rs. 56,06,000/- under various heads with 6% annual interest on the amount.

    6. Claimants have also filed cross objections by way of Appeal No. 3168 of 2012 seeking enhancement of compensation. However, during course of argument, the same was not pressed, therefore, as far as claimant-respondents are concerned, award stands final.

    7. The main submission on which Insurance Company has pressed appeal are;

    (i) The Truck with which accident of deceased was claimed, not involved in accident,

    (ii) Driver of car was negligent and or rather had contributed to the accident, therefore, quantum should need be reduced.

    8. The main thrust was that PW-1 and 2 were not present at the place of accident and were gotup witnesses. It is further submitted that FIR was belatedly filed and truck was sought to be impleaded as an offending vehicle whereas the truck was not at all involved in the accident. Tribunal did not consider written statement of owner or driver or insurance company and decided the matter, holding that truck in question was involved.

    9. Learned Counsel appearing for Insurance Company mainly contended that it is evident that the alleged offending truck in question has been falsely implicated by way of an after thought. It is further submitted that indisputably, PW-1 was not an eye witness of the incident, similarly testimony of PW-2 who was also not an eye witness was untrustworthy. It was only testimony of PW-3 who was sole isolated witness, whose testimony even otherwise suffers from apparent discrepancies and is wholly unreliable; despite thereof, Tribunal has held that the Truck was involved in the accident.

    10. We have heard learned counsel for parties and perused entire record including testimony, other documentary evidence and decision of Tribunal.

    11. Tribunal has held against owner/driver and insurance company of truck. Tribunal relied on the charge sheet and non appearance of driver and the owner of vehicle to adduce oral evidence despite the fact that they had appeared before Tribunal and filed their reply, yet did not step into witness box to prove that their vehicle was not involved in the accident and that the vehicle was somewhere else. Submission is that Truck in question was not involved and FIR was belatedly filed cannot be accepted as Tribunal has held that FIR, charge sheet and evidence of eye witnesses were consistent with each other and prove factum of involvement. The witnesses had also deposed that on the very day of accident they had informed nearby police station but nothing was done by police concerned. On query being made whether private investigation report by Insurance Company was placed on record, answer was no. Hence, submission of counsel appearing for Insurance Company that vehicle was not involved in the accident, cannot be accepted.

    12. The reason being that no rebuttal evidence was ever led before Tribunal. Insurance Company has not been able to discharge its burden as to non involvement of vehicle. Driver and the owner who could be best person to depose had chosen to remain absent. Insurance Company did not make any effort to get them examined. The fact is that driver, owner and Insurance Company did not lead any credible evidence to discharge their burden. Hence, findings of fact being not perverse, cannot be interfered with.

    13. We are not persuaded to hold that vehicle was not involved in the accident just because FIR was belatedly filed and or that the witnesses were from Varanasi. We hold that Tribunal has committed no error in holding that the truck in question was involved in the accident.

    14. Learned counsel for Insurance Company next contended that Tribunal has erred in holding driver of the truck as the sole offender. Despite the fact that driver and the owner had filed their written statements before Tribunal they did not come forward to prove facts pleaded that driver of car was equally negligent and Tribunal has erred in holding truck driver solely responsible. Learned counsel for appellant has taken us through the site plan, oral testimony and other evidence on record. It is submitted that Tribunal has based its judgment on surmises and conjuncture and that not joining Car No. UP-40 H-7100 is also bad in law. Learned counsel for Insurance Company has vehemently submitted that driver of truck was not solely responsible for accident. The findings recorded on issues 1, 2 and 3 according to counsel are erroneous and based on surmises and conjuncture. It is submitted that no eye witness has been examined so as to come to the conclusion that driver of truck was solely negligent. It is submitted that deceased was also negligent and Tribunal has erred in not considering contributory negligence of driver of the car.

    15. It would be relevant to discuss the principles for deciding contributory negligence and for that the principles for considering negligence will also have to be looked into.

    16. Negligence means failure to exercise required degree of care and caution expected of a prudent driver. Negligence is the omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided upon the considerations, which ordinarily regulate conduct of human affairs, would do, or doing something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do. Negligence is not always a question of direct evidence. It is an inference to be drawn from proved facts. Negligence is not an absolute term, but is a relative one. It is rather a comparative term. What may be negligence in one case may not be so in another. Where there is no duty to exercise care, negligence in the popular sense has no legal consequence. Where there is a duty to exercise care, reasonable care must be taken to avoid acts or omissions which would be reasonably foreseen likely to caused physical injury to person. The degree of care required, of course, depends upon facts in each case. On these broad principles, the negligence of drivers is required to be assessed.

    17. It would be seen that burden of proof for contributory negligence on the part of deceased has to be discharged by the opponents. It is the duty of driver of the offending vehicle to explain the accident. It is well settled law that at intersection where two roads cross each other, it is the duty of a fast moving vehicle to slow down and if driver did not slow down at intersection, but continued to proceed at a high speed without caring to notice that another vehicle was crossing, then the conduct of driver necessarily leads to conclusion that vehicle was being driven by him rashly as well as negligently.

    18. 10 Schedule appended to Motor Vehicle Act contain statutory regulations for driving of motor vehicles which also form part of every Driving License. Clause-6 of such Regulation clearly directs that the driver of every motor vehicle to slow down vehicle at every intersection or junction of roads or at a turning of the road. It is also provided that driver of the vehicle should not enter intersection or junction of roads unless he makes sure that he would not thereby endanger any other person. Merely, because driver of the Truck was driving vehicle on the left side of road would not absolve him from his responsibility to slow down vehicle as he approaches intersection of roads, particularly when he could have easily seen, that the car over which deceased was riding, was approaching intersection.

    19. In view of the fast and constantly increasing volume of traffic, motor vehicles upon roads may be regarded to some extent as coming within the principle of liability defined in Rylands v. Fletcher, (1868) 3 HL (LR) 330. From the point of view of pedestrian, the roads of this country have been rendered by the use of motor vehicles, highly dangerous. ‘Hit and run’ cases where drivers of motor vehicles who have caused accidents, are unknown. In fact such cases are increasing in number. Where a pedestrian without negligence on his part is injured or killed by a motorist, whether negligently or not, he or his legal representatives, as the case may be, should be entitled to recover damages if principle of social justice should have any meaning at all.

    20. These provisions (sec.110A and sec.110B of Motor Act, 1988) are not merely procedural provisions. They substantively affect the rights of the parties. The right of action created by Fatal Accidents Act, 1855 was ‘new in its species, new in its quality, new in its principles. In every way it was new. The right given to legal representatives under Act, 1988 to file an application for compensation for death due to a motor vehicle accident is an enlarged one. This right cannot be hedged in by limitations of an action under Fatal Accidents Act, 1855. New situations and new dangers require new strategies and new remedies.

    21. In the light of the above discussion, we are of the view that even if courts may not by interpretation displace the principles of law which are considered to be well settled and, therefore, court cannot dispense with proof of negligence altogether in all cases of motor vehicle accidents, it is possible to develop the law further on the following lines; when a motor vehicle is being driven with reasonable care, it would ordinarily not meet with an accident and, therefore, rule of res-ipsa loquitor as a rule of evidence may be invoked in motor accident cases with greater frequency than in ordinary civil suits (per three-Judge Bench in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, 2005 0 ACJ (SC) 1840).

    22. By the above process, the burden of proof may ordinarily be cast on the defendants in a motor accident claim petition to prove that motor vehicle was being driven with reasonable care or that there is equal negligence on the part of driver of another vehicle.

    23. From the entire testimony of P.W-4 it is proved that the negligence and rashness of the deceased had no role in the accident. As a matter of fact, the accident has occurred due to offending truck being driven rashly and negligently by the driver.

    24. Petitioner Smt. Renu Singh has through her own testimony proved the factum of both her children being dependents. Paper no. 9C being true copy of chik/F.I.R lodged in relation to the case crime no. 544/09 under section 279/304A/427 I.P.C at P.S-Phakharpur, District-Bahraich has been presented as documentary evidence on behalf of the appellants. The site of accident is proved. In such a circumstance, delayed lodging of F.I.R does not give rise to the possibility of any sort of prejudice being caused to anybody in a case of compensation. Paper no.-11C being true copy of post-mortem report of deceased has been presented as documentary evidence on behalf of appellants. From the said documentary evidence, factum of deceased being aged 40 years and death having occurred due to ante-mortem injuries is confirmed. Paper no.-19C being true copy of charge-sheet filed against Shajad Ali driver of truck number UP 64B-5886 in the aforesaid criminal case has been presented as documentary evidence on behalf of the appellants. From the said documentary evidence, it is prima facie proved that accident has occurred due to the vehicle being driven rashly and negligently by driver of the offending truck. Paper no. 23C being true copy of the driving licence of deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh has been presented on behalf of the claimants. From the said document it is proved that the said driving licence was valid from 30.5.2006 to 6.4.2019 and that deceased had a valid licence to drive light motor vehicle/motor cycle, meaning thereby that deceased was driving car with a valid driving licence on the day of accident.

    25. Truck is a very big vehicle where as a car is relatively a very small vehicle. The driver of truck should have taken proper care which he has not taken and therefore, it cannot be said that the driver of truck was not solely negligent. We find no reason to accept the submission of learned counsel for appellant that driver of truck was not solely negligent.

    26. In absence of any evidence, only on the basis of pleadings in written statement we are unable to accept the submission of counsel for appellant that there was contributory negligence. Submissions has been rightly rejected by Tribunal. Truck hit the car of deceased. It dashed the car on left side is proved. Tribunal has rightly held that accident speaks for itself and there was no fault for negligence on the part of driver of car. This is a finding based on evidence and in absence of any otherwise evidence a decree of reversal cannot be passed in appeal.

    27. It is next contended that the quantum is on higher side. Paper no.- 27C being payment certificate given by Civil Court, Bahraich has been presented as documentary evidence on behalf of the claimants. The said documentary evidence contains details of payables to deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh in Financial Years 2009-2010, 2010-2011 and 2011-2012. From the said documentary evidence it is proved that deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh was working as Civil Judge (Junior Division) at the time of accident. Paper no-44C being true copy of mark-sheet of deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh's High School Examination, 1984 has been presented as documentary evidence on behalf of claimants. From the said documentary evidence, deceased Pankaj Kumar Singh's date of birth is proved to be 7.4.1969 From the said documentary evidence, age of deceased is proved to be 40 years at the time of accident. However, we find that Tribunal was more conservative by relying on the decision in Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 and not on Sri. K.R Madhusudhan v. Administrative Officer, (2011) 4 SCC 689 which is relating to employed person. The rate of interest awarded is also on lower side. However, Senior Advocate for claimants has withdrawn cross objection filed to enhancement, we hold that Tribunal has not committed any error in awarding just compensation to the heir of deceased (judicial officer).

    28. Learned counsel for appellant has mainly contended about involvement of truck in the incident and on contributory negligence and quantum, though several other grounds have been taken in appeal but he did not press other grounds. Since, he failed to prove that Tribunal committed grave error as far as those grounds are concerned, therefore, in the light of decision in UPSRTC v. Km. Mamta, reported in (2016) 4 SCC 172 : AIR 2016 SC 948, we have reproduced concise statement of case as far as points for determination of involvement and negligence are concerned. On these points for our consideration no authoritative pronouncement has been cited and, therefore, on factual scenario, we find that vehicle was involved in accident and findings of facts as far as involvement and negligence of truck driver is established beyond reasonable doubt and we concur with the findings of Tribunal as far as those points are concerned.

    29. The appeal fails and is dismissed with costs throughout.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Renu Singh And Others S
    (Jul 19, 2016)