Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Gur Dayal v. Kaunsila

    Straight and Brodhurst, JJ. (After stating the facts as set out above, continued:)— The personal obligation of the defendant Sitau to maintain the plaintiff-respondent is conceded, and as regards house No. 1 the defendants Madho, Ramdial, and Bisheshar neither appealed to the Judge nor have they to this Court. The sole point for us, to determine, therefore, is, whether the maintenance of the plaintiff-respondent was such a charge on the property of her husband Sitau, that his donees and the appellant Gurdial the vendee from them took the house No. 2 subject to such maintenance. Much stress is laid upon the ruling of this. Court in Jamna v. Machul Sahu in which it was held that where a husband in his life-time made a gift of his entire estate, leaving his widow without maintenance, the donee took and held such estate subject to her maintenance. But the circumstances of that and of the present case are somewhat different; for here the donees of the illeged gift asserted that it was made to them by Sitau in consideration of their discharging certain debts due from him, and it would seem that a mortgage of the two houses was first made to raise money sufficient to pay such debts; and then house No. 2 was subsequently sold to the appellate Gurdial in order to release the mortgage. Now if, must be admitted that payment of her husband's debts, whether he be alive or dead, must take precedence of a wife or widow's maintenance, and we are unable to find anything in the Hindu Law authorizing the notion that such maintenance can stand in the way of salep or alienations being made by the husband during his lifetime? or by his heirs after his death, to satisfy his creditors. Since be ruling above referred to there has been a Full Bench decision of this Court—Sham Lal v. Banna —by which it was held ??? maintenance of a Hindu widow is not, until it is fixed and charged on her deceased husband's estate by decree or agreement, a charge on such estate which can be enforced against a bona fide purchaser of such estate for value without notice.” In that case it was further very clearly pointed out that if the estate had passed to a purchaser to satisfy a claim against the original owner for which it was responsible under the Hindu Law, the purchaser would not take it subject even to maintenance, fixed and charged upon it before his purchase. We are unable to see how in this respect the maintenance of a wife and that of a widow stands upon, a different footing; and in this view of the matter it seems to us necessary to have a clear finding on the following issue:—Was the sale of house No. 2 to the appellant Gurdial a genuine and bona fide transaction for good consideration; and was such consideration employed in discharging a debt or debts due and owing by Sitau. For the purpose of determining this question we remand the case under s. 566 of the Code.

    Case remanded.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gur Dayal v. Kaunsila
    (Feb 13, 1883)