Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.

    Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami

    Banerjee, J.:— This appeal arises out of a suit brought by the Plaintiff-Appellant for assessment of additional rent on land said to have been proved by measurement to be in excess of the area for which rent was previously paid by the Defendants, under sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The defence was that the Defendants' tenure was a permanent one and was not liable to have any additional rent assessed thereupon. The Courts below have given effect to the defence, and dismissed the Plaintiff's suit; and hence this appeal by the Plaintiff. The contention on his behalf is, that the Court of Appeal below is wrong in holding that the Plaintiff could only succeed in a suit like this upon proof that the area for which additional rent is claimed is in excess of the original area leased to the Defendants. It is argued that having regard to the language of cl. (a) of sub-sec. (1) of sec. 52, the Plaintiff started his case sufficiently by showing that the area now found by measurement was in excess of the area of the tenure as shown in the Revenue-Survey papers of 1854, and that if the Defendants claim exemption from liability for additional rent on the ground of such excess being due to the addition to the tenure of land which previously belonged to the tenure but was lost by diluvion, the burden lay upon them to prove that defence.

    We are of opinion that this contention is not sound. If cl. (a) of sub-sec. (1) of sec. 52 had stood alone, there might possibly have been some room for such a contention as this; but that clause read with cl. (a) of sub-sec. (2) of the same section would go to show that before the landlord can claim any additional rent for land on the ground of its being in excess of the area for which rent had been previously paid by the tenant, the landlord must show that the alleged excess is really an excess over the area of the tenure as originally created. To hold otherwise would be to introduce the greatest possible uncertainty into the matter. For if the Appellant's contention be given effect to, the landlord may, where the area of the tenure or holding is liable to change by reason of fluvial action, select the area of the holding in any particular year which is most convenient for his purpose, that is, the area of the holding when it is at its minimum, as the standard with which to start, and he may say that he is entitled to rent upon the difference between that area and the area found by measurement at the time when the suit is brought, leaving it to the tenant to prove what the area was at the time when the tenure was first created. There may also arise a difficulty in the way of the landlord himself for if the landlord does not bring his suit for assessment of additional rent immediately upon the area being increased by fluvial action, but waits for a few years and goes on taking rent at the old rate, then, upon the Appellant's contention, the tenant might turn round and say that the rent he has been paying is for the area that is then found by measurement, because that is the area for which he had been previously paying the then existing rent. We do not think that could have been intended. On the contrary, we think the language of sub-sec. (2), cl. (a) by referring to the origin and conditions of the tenancy as some of the circumstances which the Court is required to have regard to, shows that the expression “the area for which rent has been previously paid” must be understood to mean the area with reference to which the rent previously paid had been assessed or adjusted. That is the view that accords with common sense, and that is the view which we think should be adopted upon a proper construction of sec. 52 taken as a whole, that is, of cl. (a) of sub-sec. (2) taken with cl. (a) of sub-sec. (2). That being so, we think that the Court of Appeal below was quite right in holding that the Plaintiff was not entitled to claim any additional rent when he failed to show what the area of the tenure was when first created, or, at any rate, when the confirmatory pattah of 1159 (1753) was granted. It was argued that the view we take would throw a very great difficulty in the way of the landlord's obtaining additional rent for any excess land, specially when the landlord is a recent auction-purchaser like the Plaintiff. We do not think that this consideration should weigh very much in a case like this; for the Legislature has by cl. (c) of sub-sec. (2) of sec. 52 advisedly made length of time during which the tenancy lasted without dispute as to rent or area, one of the matters to be taken into consideration by the Court in deciding a case like the present. There is another way of looking at the case. Cl. (a) of sub-sec. (2) requires the Court to have regard to the origin and conditions of the tenancy, for instance, whether the rent was a consolidated rent for the entire tenure or holding. Now, in the present case a confirmatory pattah fixed a certain rent as the rent payable for the two mouzahs in dispute, and not for any definite area. That being so, we think there is great force in the contention of the learned vakil for the Respondents, that this is not a case in which additional rent is to be decreed merely upon a comparison of areas. It is a case in which a consolidated rent was fixed for the tenure extending over two entire villages. For these reasons the judgment of the Court below is right and ought to be affirmed; and this appeal must be dismissed with costs.

    This judgment will govern the other appeal (No. 1937) which must accordingly be dismissed with costs.

    Maclean, C.J:— I am of the same opinion. I only desire to add that, in my opinion, a landlord cannot successfully claim additional rent under sec. 52 of the Bengal Tenancy Act, in respect of an excess of area, unless he can satisfy the Court that the rent originally fixed did not cover, and was not intended to cover, such excess of area. In the present case the same rent has been paid for some hundred and fifty years, during which period it is not unlikely that churs have been formed, destroyed and reformed, but no claim for additional rent has ever been made until this suit.

    S.C.S
    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajendra Lal Goswami v. Chunder Bhusan Goswami
    (Jul 24, 1901)