The appeal is argued on the ground that the rights of the contesting defendants were disallowed by Exhibit G, the order against the 4th defendant in C. M. P. No. 11 of 1909 in the District Munsif's Court, Ranipet, which has not been set aside by any decree and has, therefore, become conclusive.
Contra it is argued that, as Exhibit G was not passed after investigation, a suit to set it aside is not subject to the one year's limitation, and if, therefore, has not yet become conclusive. This would no doubt have been well-founded under Sects. 278 and 283 of Act XIV of 1882. But under the latter section it was only orders under Sects. 280, 281, and 232, which became conclusive after one year, whilst under O. 21, Rule 63, the language is wider— “where a claim or objection is preferred, the party against whom an order is passed, etc.”—and we cannot restrict it to cover only cases, in which an investigation has taken place. In these circumstances the plaintiff's contention must prevail.
The result is that the decrees of the Lower Courts are set aside and the plaintiffs are given the decree asked for. The argument on which they have succeeded here was not referred to before the District Munsif and it is not clear that it was put forward in the Lower Appellate Court.
Each party will therefore bear his own costs throughout.
Appeal allowed.