Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Bhioraj Jethmal v. Janardhan Nagorao

    1. This is an application to advise an order of the Additional Subordinate Judge, First Class, Amraoti, dismissing the applicant's application made under O. 9, R. 13 of the CPC. The applicant was defendant in the suit based on a promissory note. He admitted the execution of the promissory note, but pleaded repayment of Rupees ???. The burden being incumbent on him to substantiate his plea, he was called on to lead evidence. He summoned five witnesses of whom only two were present on 25th April, 1931. For want of time the case was adjourned till 28th August, 1931. On that day the defendant's witnesses were absent and warrants were ordered to be issued against the witnesses who had been served with summons, and the case was fixed for hearing on 26th September, 1931. On that day neither the defendant nor the witnesses were present. Mr. Kale, pleader however entered formal appearance, for the defendant. The Court declared the defendant's case as closed on account of the defendant's default in appearance, in producing his witnesses and also in payment of the process fees, as ordered on the previous late. The Court delivered the judgment and passed a decree against the defendant on the same day. The defendant filed an application, later in he day, for setting aside the ex parte decree. He stated in the application that he had not paid the process fees as he witnesses had agreed to accompany him to the Court voluntarily. It is also mentioned that the witnesses were present in Court, but that there was delay attending the Court on account of ??? rain. This application was dismissed by the trial Court on the ground that the judgment was pronounced under O. 17, R. 3 of the CPC, and that the application made for setting aside the decree passed in pursuance of it was lot maintainable under O. 9, R. 13 of the CPC

    2. The scope of Rr. 2 and 3 of O. 17 of the CPC, had been the subject of conflicting decisions until the question was considered by a Full Bench of the Madras High Court in Pichamma v. Sreeramulu(1). Under the circumstances resembling those in the present case the Full Bench held that the case fell within O. 17, R. 2, and not R. 3, so that the decree was capable of being treated as an ex parte decree under O. 9, R. 13. The same view was taken in Ram Adhin v. Ram Bharose(2), E. Mylne v. T. Koir(3), Ko Tha Lin Bwin v. Ko Hla Kye(4), Basayya v. Allayya(5) and Abdul Karim v. Batilal Gujrati, AIR 1930 Nag 152. The material provisions of O. 17 have to be read with those of O. 9 of the CPC. O. 9 deals with the consequences of non-appearance of parties in obedience to the summons issued by the Court for their appearance which is the first hearing of the case. O. 17 bears on the subsequent progress of the suit and deals with the consequences arising from the default of the party consisting in the non-appearance of the parties or in failure to perform some act necessary for the progress of the suit such as the production of documentary evidence or causing the attendance of witnessed. O. 17, R. 2, specifically provides for the event of the failure of the party to appear in the course of the trial, and it gives a discretion to the Court either to dispose of his suit in one of the modes directed by O. 9 or make such other order as it thinks fit. As the non-appearance of the party or parties concerned at any stage of the suit subsequent to the first hearing is analogous to the cases dealt with in O. 9, the Court has been given the power to put such cases in the category of O. 9. At the same time, in view of R. 1, O. 17, the Court is also empowered to grant an adjournment. R. 3 contemplates a case where the parties are present but commit default in some way which impedes the progress of the suit. It is obvious that while R. 2 applies to cases where the hearing is adjourned for any purpose and the parties fail to appear at the adjourned hearing, R. 3 contemplates a case where the hearing is adjourned at the instance of a party for some one or other of the purposes specified by R. 2 and the party fails to perform the act or acts during the time allowed by the Court.

    3. But cases are bound to happen when the party fails to appear in person and also to perform the specified act or acts for which the adjournment was granted. It is in cases of this kind that the question as to whether R. 2 or R. 3, O. 17 is to be applied arises. R. 3 presupposes the appearance of the party, at whose instance the case was adjourned, but who is unable to give proper explanation as to the omission to perform the specific act or acts for which the adjournment was granted at his instance. When the party is present it is possible for the Court to demand an explanation. What further action is to be taken would be determined on the nature of the explanation. If the Court is satis, filed with the explanation it may adjourn the case under O. 17, R. 1. If it is not, then the Court may proceed to judgment on such material as there is on record on the assumption that the party has no evidence to produce or witnesses to tender.

    4. The Court is bound to pass some order to indicate its view of the explanation tendered by the party and why further adjournment was thought un-necessary. This order is capable of being considered by the appellate Court under Section 105(1) of the CPC, when an appeal from the decree comes to be filed. The position is different when the party is absent and there is nobody duly instructed appearing in Court able to give any explanation on behalf of the party. In such a case it is obviously inexpedient and unreasonable that the Court should at once proceed to judgment.

    5. The appropriate course would be to treat the case as falling under R. 2 so as to give the Court a discretion either to proceed under O. 9 or adjourn the case. In either case it is open to the party to appear in the Court and give proper explanation for his default in the performance of the act necessary for the progress of the suit. If the Court proceeds to dispose of the case under R. 3 in the absence of the party, he would have only two courses open either to move the Court by a review petition or prefer an appeal from the decree passed against him. As remarked by Kumaraswami, J., in Pichamnta v. Sreeramuli at p. 292 (of 41 Mad.) “there can be no review if the Judge does not preside when the application is made.” Nor can the appellate Court consider the ex plantation by the defaulted party fo the first time in appeal from the decree since it is not its province to make ??? investigation occasioned by the explain nation as the original Court would be expected to do. While considering the aspect of the matter Mukerji, J., gave an illustration which is almost identical with the facts of the present case, in these words:

    “I will take an extreme case. Say a defendant obtained time to produce his witnesses; of the date fixed for hearing he did all he could arrive at the Court in time, but there happened to be a railway accident whereby he and he witnesses were delayed. Where is he to prov. the facts: Ram Adhin v. Ram Bharose?”

    6. His answer was: Not in the appellant Court. This is precisely the situation which has arisen in the present case. Here, the defendant alleges that he and his witnesses were delayed on the was by heavy rains and that consequent neither he nor his witnesses were able ??? be present in Court in the early ??? when the case was called on for hearing the application shows that the defendant arrived with his witnesses in the Court a little after 12 noon. All the he wants to do is to satisfy the Court a to his inability to keep his witnesses in attendance exactly as he would do, had the decree been passed ex parte under O. 9, R. 6.

    7. The foregoing discussion makes it clear that the proper way of ??? Rr. 2 and 3, O. 17, would be to treat the disposal of the suit as having been made in accordance with R. 2 in cases when on account of non-appearance of the party the explanation for failure to per form acts referred to in R. 3 was due but was not given on account of his absence. On behalf of the non-applicant reliance is placed on Jhanda Singh v. Sadiq Muhammad(6). A different view was taken in that case for the ??? reason that both parties had produced all their evidence and on the day fixed for argument one of the parties was unable to attend. That case stands on totally different footing.

    8. It is urged that a pleader was present in Court on behalf of the defendant there is nothing in the order sheet to show that he had received instructions a account for the default committed by is client. The mere physical presence ??? the pleader under the circumstances ??? be regarded as equivalent to ??? of the party. I therefore hold that the decree passed by the lower court was, in view of O. 17, R. 2, one ??? under O. 9, R. 6, and that defendant's application made under O. 9, 13, was competent. I set aside the power Court's order and direct that the power Court will investigate the application. The non-applicant will pay the costs of the applicant. Pleader's fees Rs. 25.

    9. Order set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhioraj Jethmal v. Janardhan Nagorao
    (Oct 23, 1933)