This is an appeal from the judgment of the Assistant Sessions judge of West Godawari acquitting one Rowthula Kondalrao of the offence of possessing counterfeit ten rupee currency notes punishable under S. 489(C) of the Indian Penal Code. The charge was that he was in possession of 38 counterfeit ten rupee currency notes knowing or having reason to believe the same to be counterfeit and intending to use the same as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. If this were a case in which the result depended upon the appreciation of the evidence in the case by the learned trial Judge, I should have been slow to interfere with his order of acquittal. This is not a case of that kind but one in which the only question for decision was the proper or legal inference to be drawn from the facts proved in the case. It was proved beyond doubt and the fact was indeed admitted by the accused in his statement in the trial Court that he was in possession of 38 counterfeit ten rupee currency notes knowing the same to be counterfeit. Thirty of them were tied up in a piece of cloth worn by him on his person at the cremation ground at Narasapur and the remaining eight were produced by him from a box in his house soon afterwards on being questioned by the Sub Inspector, P.W 2, whether he had any similar notes in his possession. A mere look at the notes shows that every one must have known them to be counterfeit and the accused himself admits in his statement that he knew them to be counterfeit. In fact his statement is to the effect that one Pulla Seshayya of Narasapur actually supplied him with eight of these notes 15 days before the seizure and told him that there were 30 more notes of the same nature hidden under the eaves of the shed in the cremation ground on the day of the occurrence at 6 A.M and that he went to bring the notes, the object being to introduce these notes into the house of one Satti Rami Reddi and then get the Police to seize the notes so as to get Rami Reddi into trouble. The explanation is that Rami Reddi was responsible for foisting a false case of possession of counterfeit coins on the accused in 1935, and the accused wanted to take revenge on him by foisting a case of possession of counterfeit notes on him. From this it is clear that the accused was perfectly aware of the fact that the currency notes in question were counterfeit and that he had them in his possession. The only question for decision was whether he possessed them with the intention of using them as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. The learned trial Judge while rightly observing that there can ordinarily be no direct evidence regarding the intention of a person in possession of counterfeit notes and that it has to be, if at all, inferred from the surrounding circumstances, at the same time appears to have thought that the circumstances established in this case did not lead to the inference that the intention of the accused was either to use the notes as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. It is not as if the learned trial Judge believed the accused's story that his intention was to foist them on someone else and that he had mentioned this fact to the Police Sub Inspector at the moment of the seizure of the thirty notes. In other words, he does not say he believes the evidence of D.W 1; nor does he say that otherwise the accused's explanation is reasonable or probable. He relies entirely on what he calls the miserable failure of the prosecution to establish that the intention of the accused was either to use the notes as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. The present case is not on all fours with that of Velayudham Pillai and another v. Emperor(1). That was a case in which the case for the prosecution itself was that the accused got counterfeit notes made or manufactured with the express object of foisting the case on a third person, an enemy of theirs. In these circumstances it was held that the intention which formed an essential ingredient of the offence with which they were charged was absent. The present case is not one in which it is the case for the prosecution that the accused was in possession of the counterfeit notes for the purpose of foisting them on anyone else. It is the case of the defence which has not been established even according to the trial Judge. In other words, the case for the prosecution remains unrebutted, and, as I pointed out before, the only question that arises for decision is whether on the evidence for the prosecution it can be reasonably and safely inferred that the intention of the accused was either to use the notes as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. So far as the defence is concerned, the learned trial Judge does not appear to have believed it and nowhere does he say that he believes it or the evidence of D.W 1 to the effect that this defence was put forward at the very moment of the seizure of the thirty notes. It may be mentioned that this defence was not put forward during the preliminary enquiry before the Magistrate, and that the first time when it appears to have been put forward was in the Sessions Court during the trial. I have no doubt that this defence is not true, and that it is an after-thought perhaps due to the decision referred to above. The facts established by the prosecution in this case are that as many as 38 counterfeit currency notes were in the possession of the accused, thirty of them in his person and the remaining eight in a box in his house, underneath some books, wrapped in a piece of paper. The large number of the notes is an important indication. The learned trial Judge himself quotes the following passage from Dr. Gour's Commentary with approval, namely, that “such intention relating as it does to future conduct, could only be proved by collateral circumstances, such as that the accused had palmed off such notes before, or that he was in possession of such and similar notes in such large numbers that his possession for any other purpose is inexplicable.” In other words, the number of counterfeit notes found in a man's possession and the circumstances in which they were so found may by themselves constitute a sufficient ground for drawing the inference that the intention was to use them as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. The learned Advocate for the respondent—accused—was unable to suggest any other possible intention as regards the possession of these notes by his client, apart from the explanation given during the course of the trial, namely, that they were intended to be foisted on Rami Reddi. That story is obviously untrue, and we are thus faced with the position that it is really impossible to conceive of any other intention than the intention of using the notes as genuine or that they may be used as genuine, and no other intention can even be suggested. After all, intention has to be presumed in the case of this offence as in the case of any other, of which a criminal intention is a necessary ingredient, and it is impossible to lay down any general rule which would apply to all cases. If, as has been found, the defence is not true, it follows that the accused must have gone to the cremation ground either with the currency notes to pass them on to another or to take charge of them, if he had got information that they were to be found there. If, as a matter of fact, the idea was to foist the notes on Rami Reddi, according to the accused's own statement, this business was to be done by Seshayya himself and there was no necessity therefore for the accused to go to the cremation ground himself to bring the notes which had been left there by Seshayya according to him. According to him Seshayya was his friend who was prepared to help him not only by providing him with the notes but also in the matter of foisting them on his enemy. In these circumstances it is impossible to accept the story that he went to the cremation ground to get the notes which had been left there by Seshayya for the purpose of foisting them on Rami Reddi. The whole story is incredible. In my opinion the only reasonable inference to be drawn is that the accused was in possession of these notes with the intention of using them as genuine or that they may be used as genuine. The learned trial Judge has, in my opinion, erred in failing to draw the “clear, indubitable and irresistible” inference from the facts established according to him by the prosecution. The judgment of acquittal is therefore set aside and the accused in the case, that is, the respondent in this appeal, is convicted of an offence punishable under S. 489(C) of the Indian Penal Code and is sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years.
Acquittal set aside.
N.R.R