JUDGMENT
1. One Khushal was indebted to several persons. He executed a mortgage on 2nd January 1931 in favour of Govindram and Deokisan. A part of the consideration of the mortgage was an amount due on the basis of a prior mortgage dated 2nd February 1927 and some cash advanced at the time of the mortgage-deed. The mortgagees sued the mortgagor on the basis of the mortgage and obtained a preliminary decree which was made final on 19th November 1932. In pursuance of the decree possession was taken on 26th November 1932. Some of the unsecured creditors of the mortgagor thereafter applied to get the mortgagor adjudged insolvent. This application for insolvency was filed on 5th December 1932, and the mortgagor Khushal was adjudged insolvent on 26th June 1934. After adjudication the creditors applied for annulment of the mortgage dated 2nd January 1931 in favour of Govindram and Deokisan under Section 53 of the Provincial Insolvency Act. The mortgage was annulled on 2nd February 1937. Thereafter the creditors applied to the Court for recovery of mesne profits from the transferees Govindram and Deokisan from the date on which they entered into possession, viz., 26th November 1932. On behalf of the transferees it was contended that they were not at all liable for mesne profits and that in any case they were not liable to account till the transfer in their favour was avoided by order of the Court annulling it. The order for annulment was passed on 2nd February 1937. It was, therefore, contended that no account of mesne profits can be gone into up to 2nd February 1937. The following issues were selected by the trial Court for preliminary decision:
“(2) Whether the applicant can claim profits from them for the period as stated in the application of the appellant.
(3) Whether the non-applicants are not, for the reasons stated by them liable to pay any profits, prior to the annulment order.”
2. Both the Courts below came to the conclusion that the transferees were not accountable for the profits before the date of annulment.
3. It is against this decision of the lower appellate Court that this second appeal is filed by the creditors. The main point involved in appeal, therefore, is from which date the transferees should be held liable to render an account of the mesne profits, whether from the date on which they entered into possession, viz., 26th November 1932, or from the date on which the transfer in their favour was declared annulled, viz., 2nd February 1937.
4. It is not disputed before us that the transfer was set aside under Section 53 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, and not under S. 54 thereof. We mention this because an attempt was made in the Courts below to urge that the case fell under Section 54 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, and not under S. 53. On a perusal of the record we are clearly of the opinion that the creditors had applied for setting aside the transfer under Section 58 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, and the case was treated throughout as one falling under S. 53 only. The contention that it also fell under Section 54 of the Insolvency Act, was, therefore, rightly abandoned by the counsel for the appellants before us. Section 53 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, runs as under:
“Any transfer of property not being a transfer made before and in consideration of marriage or made in favour of a purchaser or incumbrancer in good faith and for valuable consideration shall, if the transferor is adjudged insolvent on a petition presented within two years after the date of transfer, be voidable as against the receiver and may be annulled by the Court.”
5. It will not be out of place here to point out that Section 53 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, was amended to make the meaning clear by using the word ‘voidable’ in place of the word ‘void’ which was used in the previous Act. The wording of the section thus very clearly indicates that a transfer of the nature mentioned therein is voidable as against the Receiver and is not void ab initio and may be annulled by the Court. The section gives the Court a discretion to annul it. An application for annulment can be made only after adjudication and not before, and only if the Receiver chooses to avoid it and not otherwise; and even if the Receiver chooses to avoid it there is a further condition under S. 53, viz., that it will be void only if the Court declares it so. It is thus clear from the section that till the transfer is actually annulled by the Court it remains a valid transaction. As the transfer is valid till it is annulled by the Court under Section 53 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, it follows that no accountability for profits can arise until the passing of such an order because the possession of the transferee is lawful under a valid title and not wrongful.
6. It was, however, urged on the basis of a Privy Council decision reported in A.I.R 1932 P.C 891 that such a transfer is void from its inception and mesne profits are claimable from the date of the transfer and not from the date of the order of annulment. The Privy Council case was one between the parties to the transaction, which was set aside on the ground that it had been obtained by undue influence and fraud. In such a case, their Lordships of the Privy Council held on a finding being arrived at that the transaction was obtained by undue influence and fraud it ought to be held that the possession of the transferee was wrongful from the date on which he entered into possession in pursuance of such a transfer. Their Lordships very clearly stated that the transaction could not be regarded as a contract voidable at the option of the person defrauded and good until avoided. Inasmuch as it was not a transaction which required to be set aside and which was valid as between the parties till avoided their Lordships held that fraud being established the person defrauded had the right to claim mesne profits from the date of possession and not from the date of its being declared void. This Privy Council case has, therefore, no application to the facts of the present case in which, as already observed by us, the transaction is one which is valid as between the parties till the Receiver or the creditors at his or their option choose to have it declared void and the Court agrees.
7. Another case that was relied on is I.L.R (1939) Mad. 917.2 That case has also no application to the facts of the present case. That was a suit by a reversioner for possession on the death of a widow on the ground that the alienation made by her was not binding on him. It was rightly held in that case that it being found that the alienation was not justified by legal necessity the plaintiff was entitled to possession together with mesne profits on the death of the widow and not from the date of the institution of the suit as was contended by the other side. The suit was governed by Article 141, Limitation Act, and the article merely refers to a suit for possession and does not suggest that the reversioner has to set aside any transaction before he becomes entitled to possession thereof. This was very clearly pointed out by their Lordships of the Madras High Court at p. 926 of the above mentioned ruling. Both these cases were, therefore, cases in which the plaintiff was not bound by law to set aside the transaction at his option and are, therefore, clearly distinguishable from the case falling under Section 53 of the Provincial Insolvency Act.
8. Pollock, J. in 31 N.L.R Sup. 1783 held that if a transfer was annulled under S. 53 the possession of the transferee was not wrongful till it was annulled. He further held that a transfer coming under Section 54 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, is not void ab initio but is merely voidable and is valid until set aside, and that the transferee was in lawful possession of the property transferred until the date of annulment of the transfer by the insolvency Court. We are concerned with a case under Section 53 of the Insolvency Act, and so far as it is a case under S. 53, there can be no doubt that the transfer is not void ab initio but is merely voidable and is valid until annulled. The possession of the transferee, therefore, is lawful and not wrongful till the date of annulment, and the transferee is not responsible for mesne profits up to that date. For the reasons given above we uphold the order of the Court below and dismiss the appeal with costs.
V.R/D.H
9. Appeal dismissed.