Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • provisions of the Rent Control Order
  • Article 227, Indian Constitution,
  • Section 93 of the Hyderabad Transfer of Property Act, corresponding to Section 111 of the Indian Act,
  • clause 1 & clause 2 of Section 7 of the Madras Building Lease & Rent Control Act, 1949.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • provisions of the Rent Control Order
  • Article 227, Indian Constitution,
  • Section 93 of the Hyderabad Transfer of Property Act, corresponding to Section 111 of the Indian Act,
  • clause 1 & clause 2 of Section 7 of the Madras Building Lease & Rent Control Act, 1949.

    Mohommed Gous Mohiuddin v. Karunnissa Begum .

    1. This is a revision petition filed against the order of the Appellate authority under the Hyderabad Rent Control Order, directing the petitioner to vacate the premises occupied by him. Petitioner is in occupation of the up-stair portion of the building as tenant of the respondent.

    2. A preliminary objection is raised that no revision will lie but that the proper procedure is to apply for a writ of certiorari.

    3. This question is now pending decision before a Full Bench of this High Court. Without, however, deciding the issue we treat this application also as an application for writ of certiorari. We also assume jurisdiction under Article 227, Indian Constitution, & proceed to decide the application.

    4. The petitioner's contention is that under Hyderabad Rent Control Order promulgated in 1353F. (about 7 years ago) S. 8, as it then stood, provided that no notice to evict the premises shall be issued to the tenant by the landlord without the permission of the Rent Controller; that only after such permission was obtained from the Rent Controller, the landlord could issue notice under Section 93 of the Hyderabad Transfer of Property Act, corresponding to Section 111 of the Indian Act, to evict the premises & that in default of compliance of the notice the landlord could file a suit in the regular civil Court & obtain a decree for ejectment. In Farwardi 1357F. (about 3 years ago) the said S. 8 was amended & the amended section lays down that no tenant of a building shall be evicted therefrom whether in execution of a decree or otherwise, whether before or after the promulgation of this order & a landlord who seeks to evict his tenant shall apply to the Rent Controller for permission in that behalf. The amended section practically corresponds to the first para, of clause 1 & clause 2 of Section 7 of the Madras Building Lease & Rent Control Act, 1949. The Advocate for the petitioner argues that by virtue of the amended section referred to it has now become obligatory for the landlord to have issued not ice under Section 93 of the Hyderabad Transfer of Property Act corresponding to Section 111 of the Indian Act, before he could take proceedings before the Rent Controller. In out opinion that is begging the question. The amended section provides that no tenant shall be evicted even under a decree or otherwise except in due compliance of the provisions of the Rent Control Order & also that a landlord, wishing to evict a tenant, shall apply to the Rent Controller. If the order contemplated the issue of notice to the tenant there could have been a clear provision to that effect in the order itself. It may further be pointed out that the Hyderabad Bent Control Order was promulgated under the powers given by S. 3, Defence of Hyderabad Regulation, & S. 4, Defence of Hyderabad Regulation, provides that any Regulation or Order promulgated under S. 3 shall be valid notwithstanding it conflicts with any other law or Regulation. In our opinion one of the objects of the Sent Control Order is to see that tenants are not ejected from their holdings in these times when it is difficult to secure houses by mere reliance on the terms of the tenancy & that in the public interest the Rent Controller shall up his discretion in the light of the provisions of the Order & pass equitable order whether or not to evict the tenant. We, therefore, hold that the provision relating to action under the Transfer of Property Act has become inapplicable to cases of ejectment coming within the purview of the Rent Control Order & it is not, therefore, necessary for a landlord, wishing to proceed under the said Order, to issue notice under the Transfer of Property Act before commencing such proceedings. We are fortified in our opinion by two decisions of the Madras High Court, reported in R. Krishnmurihy v. S. Partha Sarathy, A.I.R (36) 1949 Mad. 780, which is a Division Bench ruling Krishna Murty v. Partha Sarathy, & the Single Bench ruling reported in D.P Merchant v. Bank Of Mysore, Ltd. ., A.I.R (36) 1949 Mad. 784. There is, therefore, no substance in the contention that issue of notice is a condition precedent to the initiation of the proceedings under the Rent Control Order. The Advocate for the petitioner has also argued on merits that the Bent Controller & the Appellate Authority have taken into consideration the fact that rights of privacy are affected by reason of the tenant staying in the up-stair portion of the house while the land-lady herself is occupying the down-star portion & that it is an irrelevant consideration. Parties are Muslims & the two officer who decided the matter under the Rent Control Order having come to a decision on a question of fact, we do not consider it necessary to interfere with their finding. In the result we reject the petition.

    5. Revision rejected.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohommed Gous Mohiuddin v. Karunnissa Begum .
    (Jun 19, 1951)