Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 116 REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1951
  • REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1950
  • S. 30 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950,
  • Rule 60 of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961
  • provisions of the Constitution or of this Act
  • Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act. Support
  • provisions Clauses (b) and (c) of Section 22.
  • Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act
  • Section 22, or Section 23, and(b)
  • provisions of sub-section (2),
  • Section 30 of the 1950 Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 116 REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1951
  • REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT 1950
  • S. 30 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950,
  • Rule 60 of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961
  • provisions of the Constitution or of this Act
  • Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act. Support
  • provisions Clauses (b) and (c) of Section 22.
  • Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act
  • Section 22, or Section 23, and(b)
  • provisions of sub-section (2),
  • Section 30 of the 1950 Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Hegde, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal under Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, arising from the decision of the Bangalore Election Tribunal in Election Petition No. 8 of 1962. The appellant was the Congress nominee for the Malleswaram Constituency in the Mysore Assembly General Election held on 19 February 1962. Votes were counted and the result announced on 25 February 1962. The first respondent, an independent candidate, was declared elected with a margin of 265 votes over the appellant. Other respondents (2 to 8) were ex parte below and are not parties to this appeal. The election petition (and this appeal) is contested only between the appellant and the first respondent.

In the election petition the appellant challenged the validity of the election on various grounds and alternatively sought a recount and that, after recount, if he was found to have more votes, he be declared elected. On appeal, the appellant narrowed the contentions before this Court to two principal points: (1) that the election was void because the electoral roll omitted 465 voters of "Pit Colony", and (2) alternatively, that a recount should be ordered because of irregularities in counting.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the election held on 19-2-1962 is void because the electoral roll was defective by excluding 465 voters from Pit Colony (i.e., whether such defect can vitiate the election under Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951).
  2. Whether, alternatively, a recount of the votes should be ordered due to alleged irregularities in the counting process (including alleged removal of candidates/agents during counting, improper rejection of votes, relocation of part of the counting, missing ballot papers, clerical mistakes in Forms 16 and 20, and alleged improper rejection of a recount request).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The election is void because the final electoral roll (published 5-10-1961) omitted 465 persons of Pit Colony who were included in a preliminary list; their names were allegedly removed by the Electoral Registration Officer without affording them the opportunity to be heard as required by the rules.
  • In the alternative, the appellant sought a recount on multiple grounds:
    • The Returning Officer sent away candidates and their agents about 6:30 p.m. and continued counting in their absence, contrary to Rule 60 of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961.
    • Many votes (1,841 rejected ballots) were rejected without giving the appellant or his agents an opportunity to examine them, so valid votes for the appellant may have been invalidated.
    • A part of the counting after about 2 p.m. was continued at a different place inaccessible to candidates/agents.
    • Out of ballots issued, 314 were not traced and left unexplained.
    • Several mistakes in Forms 16 and 20 indicate careless counting.
    • The appellant's request for a recount was improperly rejected by the Returning Officer.

Respondent's / Returning Officer's Arguments

  • The respondent denied that the 465 persons resided in Malleswaram at the relevant date and said they had left earlier; thus their exclusion from the electoral roll was proper and in accordance with the rules. The Tribunal below upheld the respondent's contention (though this Court did not need to decide that point).
  • The Returning Officer's account of counting:
    • Counting began about 11 a.m. and was complete by about 6:30–7:00 p.m.; only tabulation remained and the Returning Officer asked candidates and agents to retire to an upstairs room and return later for scrutiny of Form No. 20; they were summoned back about 10:30 p.m. and permitted to scrutinise the tabulation statements before declaration.
    • The Returning Officer denied that any counting continued in the absence of candidates/agents or that recount requests were presented earlier; Ex. P-1 was presented only after declaration.
    • The counting procedure involved supervisors and counting assistants at multiple tables, booth-wise counting, and a process for showing doubtful papers to candidates/agents and escalating to the Assistant Returning Officer for final decision; no contemporaneous objections were made by the appellant or his agents during counting.
    • Only 21 ballot papers were missing (not 314); press reports alleging larger shortages were inadmissible hearsay in the absence of the reporter's evidence.
    • Mistakes in Forms 16 and 20 were clerical and not material to the result.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B.M. Ramaswamy v. B.M. Krishnamurthy, A.I.R. 1963 S.C. 458 Established that under Section 30 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, civil courts have no jurisdiction to question the legality of actions taken by an electoral registration officer in preparing or revising electoral rolls; procedural non‑compliance may make an action illegal but not nullify the officer's jurisdictional act — remedy is by appeal under the statutory scheme (e.g., R.24 or prescribed appeals), not by civil proceedings. The Court relied on this decision to hold that a challenge to the correctness or legality of the electoral roll (the appellant's complaint about omission of 465 voters) cannot be entertained in an election petition under Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act and that this Court lacked jurisdiction to examine the electoral roll issue.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two analytical stages corresponding to the appellant's contentions.

1. On the electoral-roll (defect) contention:

  • The appellant relied on Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 — a provision which permits Tribunal annulment of an election if the result has been materially affected by non‑compliance with the Constitution or the 1951 Act or rules/orders made under it.
  • The Court observed that the allegations concerned non‑compliance with the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and rules made thereunder (the law governing preparation and revision of electoral rolls), not with the 1951 Act or its rules. The 1951 Act does not itself deal with preparation of electoral rolls.
  • Because the alleged contraventions were of the 1950 Act and its rules, the Court held they could not be made the basis of an election petition under Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act. The Court cited the Supreme Court decision in B.M. Ramaswamy as supporting authority.
  • Independently, the Court relied on Section 30 of the 1950 Act which unequivocally denies civil courts jurisdiction to entertain questions whether any person is entitled to be registered or to question the legality of actions taken by electoral registration officers; the statutory remedy is the prescribed appeal route (Sections 22–24 and rules). Consequently, the appellant's attack on the electoral roll was barred for want of jurisdiction and the Tribunal could not examine that grievance in an election petition.

2. On the recount / counting irregularities contention:

  • The Court examined each of the appellant's specific allegations about counting irregularities.
    • Allegation that the Returning Officer sent away candidates/agents at about 6:30 p.m. and continued counting in their absence: the Returning Officer testified that substantive counting was over by 6:30–7:00 p.m. and what remained was tabulation, performed upstairs; candidates/agents were asked to retire temporarily and were later called back around 10:30 p.m. before declaration — the Tribunal found the appellant's and supporting witnesses' evidence to be artificial/unreliable and preferred the Returning Officer's account; Ex. P-1 (the contemporaneous document) did not support the appellant's version and appeared to have been prepared after tabulation.
    • Allegation that votes were rejected without opportunity for scrutiny: the Returning Officer described the multi‑table, supervised, booth‑wise counting regime in which doubtful papers were to be shown to candidates/agents, then reviewed by supervisors and the Assistant Returning Officer who gave reasons for acceptance/rejection. No contemporaneous objections were recorded from the appellant or his agents; the Court found the appellant's complaint on this point to have been raised belatedly (first in Ex. P-1) and thus unsustainable.
    • Allegation of a part of counting being done at a remote place inaccessible to agents: the Returning Officer denied any counting at a different place; a claim that additional tables were placed was, on scrutiny of evidence, consistent merely with rearrangement or larger tables and did not establish that counting took place out of reach of agents; the Court accepted the Returning Officer's version.
    • Allegation of 314 missing ballot papers: the Court accepted the Returning Officer's statement that only 21 ballot papers were unaccounted for and rejected reliance upon a newspaper report (reporter not produced); the Court regarded the small number of missing ballots in an election of over thirty‑eight thousand issued ballots as unsurprising and not attributable to defective counting.
    • Mistakes in Forms 16 and 20: the Court inspected originals and found clerical mistakes only; no demonstration was made that such mistakes materially affected the result.
    • Allegation that the request for a recount was improperly rejected: the Returning Officer swore that no recount application was presented to him before he declared results and signed the declaration; Ex. P-1 was presented only after declaration. The Court accepted this and held that recount could not properly have been ordered at that stage by the Returning Officer.
  • On credibility the Court noted the Returning Officer was a responsible IAS officer, there was no suggestion of collusion, and contemporaneous conduct and documents (including broadcast/blackboard booth totals and timing of Ex. P-1) supported the Returning Officer's version. Several witnesses for the appellant were found unreliable or their testimony unsupported by contemporaneous evidence.
  • Accordingly, none of the alleged irregularities were found to establish a materially affected result or to justify ordering a recount.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The appellant's challenge to the election on the basis of alleged defects in the electoral roll was rejected as not maintainable in an election petition under Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of the 1951 Act and, independently, because Section 30 of the 1950 Act precludes civil courts from inquiring into the legality of electoral registration officers' actions; the statutory appeal channels under the 1950 Act are the exclusive remedies for electoral-roll disputes.
  • The appellant's alternative claim for a recount based on the alleged counting irregularities was rejected on the facts: the Court found the returning officer's account credible, contemporaneous procedures (blackboard announcements, microphone broadcasts, supervised booth-wise counting) and the timing of Ex. P-1 inconsistent with the appellant's allegations, and the asserted defects were either unsupported, clerical, or immaterial to the result.
  • The appeal was dismissed with costs (advocate's fee) of Rs. 500.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle; it applies existing statutory jurisdictional limits (notably Section 30 of the 1950 Act) and the authority of the Supreme Court in B.M. Ramaswamy to deny the remedy sought. No new precedent was announced beyond application of the cited authorities to the facts of this case.

Note: This summary is restricted to and derived solely from the material contained in the provided opinion. No external facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text have been introduced.

    K. Sriramulu (Petitioner) v. K. Deviah ().

    Hegde, J.:— This is an appeal under Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, to be hereinafter referred to as the “1951 Act”. It arises from the decision of the Bangalore Election Tribunal (the Principal District Judge, Bangalore) in Election Petition No. 8 of 1962 on its file. The petitioner therein is the appellant in this appeal. He was the Congress nominee for the Malleswaram Constituency of the Mysore Assembly in the General Election held in 1962. The respondents in the Election Petition are the other candidates who contested that election. The Election was held on 19-2-1962. Votes were counted on 25-2-1962. On the same day, the result was announced. The first respondent, an independent candidate, was declared to have been elected by securing 265 votes more than the petitioner. Admittedly, the other respondents lagged very much behind the petitioner and the 1st respondent. Respondents 2 to 8 were ex parte in the Tribunal below and they have not been made parties to this appeal. In the Election petition as well as in this appeal the contest is only between the appellant and the 1st respondent, who will be hereinafter referred to as the respondent.

    2. In his petition, the petitioner challenged the validity of the Election held on various grounds. He further contended that the counting of the votes was not in accordance with the prescribed rules. He asserted that on a proper counting, he is likely to be found to have secured more votes than the 1st respondent. He prayed that the Election held may be declared void or in the alternative, to order a recount of the votes and after recount, if be is found to have secured more votes than the 1st respondent, to declare him as the successful candidate.

    3. Many of the allegations made in the petition and tried to be established in the Court below, were not pressed in this Court. In this Court, Sri G.R Ethirajulu Naidu, the learned counsel for the petitioner appellant formulated just two contentions for our decision. They are;

    (1) the election held on 19-2-1962 is void as the same was held on the basis of a defective electoral roll in so far as that roll did not include in it 465 votes of voters residing in the Pit Colony, which is a part of the Malleswaram Constituency, or

    (2) in the alternative to order a recount of the votes polled because of the irregularities committed at the time of the counting.

    We shall now proceed to consider the merits of these contentions.

    4. Coming to the contention that the Election held on 19-2-62 is an invalid Election because the electoral roll was defective, these are the facts stated in support of that contention:—In the preliminary list of voters published on 8-9-1961, 465 persons residing in the Pit Colony of Malleswaram had been included as voters; at the instance of R.W 2 and one Kanna, the Electoral Registration Officer removed their names from the electoral roll of the Malleswaram constituency without giving the persons concerned an opportunity to have their say as required by the rules. It is said that the Officer did not even satisfy himself that the persons concerned had ceased to reside in the constituency in question and in so doing he ignored the rules on the subject. It was argued that the final electoral roll published on 5-10-61 is defective as it did not include the 465 voters of the Pit Colony and that defect has vitiated the Election. The respondent has denied the allegation that the persons concerned were residing on the relevant date, in any part of Malleswaram constituency. According to him, they had left Malleswaram constituency and taken up residence either in Rajajinagar or in some other part of the City long before the final electoral roll was prepared and therefore, they were rightly excluded from the electoral roll of Malleswaram constituency. He also contended that the removal of their names from the electoral roll was effected in accordance with the rules. The Court below has upheld the contention of the respondent. But, we have not thought it necessary to go into that question, as in our opinion in an Election petition, the correctness of the electoral roll cannot be gone into.

    5. The right to challenge the validity of an Election is a statutory right and not a common law right or a right in equity. That right being a conferred right its scope is limited by the contents of the relevant statutory provision. The petitioner relies on Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of “the 1951 Act” in support of his contention that the Election held is void. Therefore, we have to see whether that provision supports him. That provision reads:

    “Subject to the provisions of sub-section (2), if the Tribunal is of opinion that the result of the election, in so far as it concerns a returned candidate, has been materially affected by any non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution or of this Act or of any rules or orders made under this Act, the Tribunal shall declare the election of the returned candidate to be void.”

    (Underlining is ours)

    There was no complaint that any of the provisions of the Constitution has been contravened. It was also not said that either any of the provisions of “the 1951 Act” or any rule or order made under that Act has been contravened. It may be remembered that “the 1951 Act” does not deal with the preparation of electoral roll. The electoral roll was prepared under the provisions of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, to be hereinafter referred to as “the 1950 Act”. The grievance of the petitioner is that certain provisions of “the 1950 Act” and several of the rules framed thereunder have been contravened. Assuming without deciding that this grievance is genuine, even then, that grievance cannot be made the basis of an Election petition under Section 100(1)(d)(iv) of “the 1951 Act”. Support for this view is found from the decision of the Supreme Court in B.M Ramaswamy v. B.M Krishnamurthy . A.I.R 1963 S.C 458..

    6. There is yet another reason why we cannot entertain the above mentioned grievance of the petitioner, that reason being that this Court has no jurisdiction to examine the legality or correctness of an electoral roll. Part III of “the 1950 Act” deals with the preparation of the electoral rolls for the Assembly Constituencies. Relevant sections are Sections 21 to 24 of that Act. Section 21 deals with the preparation and revision of electoral rolls. Section 22 deals with correction of entries in electoral rolls. For our present purpose, the relevant provisions Clauses (b) and (c) of Section 22. They read:—

    “If the electoral registration officer for a constituency, on application made to him or on his own motion, is satisfied after such inquiry as he thinks fit, that any entry in the electoral roll of the constituency ……………

    (b) should he transposed to another place in the roll on the ground that the person concerned has changed his place of ordinary residence within the constituency, or

    (c) should be deleted on the ground that the person concerned is dead or has ceased to be ordinarily resident in the constituency or is otherwise not entitled to be registered in that roll,

    the electoral registration officer shall, subject to such general or special directions, if any, as may be given by the Election Commission in this behalf, amend, transpose or delete the entry:

    Provided that before taking any action on any ground under Clause (a) or Clause (b) or any action under Clause (c) on the ground that the person concerned has ceased to be ordinarily resident in the constituency or that he is otherwise not entitled to be registered in the electoral roll of that constituency, the electoral registration officer shall give the person concerned a reasonable opportunity of being heard in respect the action proposed to be taken in relation to him”.

    Section 23 deals with inclusion of names in electoral rolls. In this case, we are not concerned with that provision. Then we go to Section 24, which provides for appeals. That Section reads:

    “An appeal shall lie within such time and in such manner as may be prescribed—

    (a) to the Chief Electoral Officer, from any order of the electoral registration officer under Section 22, or Section 23, and

    (b) to the Election Commission, from any order of the Chief Electoral Officer under Section 23”.

    The only other section in that Act, which is necessary, may important, for our purpose, is section 30, which says:

    “No Civil court shall have jurisdiction—

    (a) to entertain or adjudicate upon any question whether any person is or is not entitled to be registered in an electoral roll for a constituency; or

    (b) to question the legality of any action taken by or under the authority of an electoral registration officer, or of any decision given by any authority appointed under this Act for the revision of any such roll.”

    7. The grievance of the petitioner as mentioned earlier is that the names of 465 voters residing in Pit Colony have been removed from the electoral roll without jurisdiction and without adhering to the relevant rules in the Registration of Electors Rules 1960. In other words, the petitioner is disputing the correctness as well as the legality of the electoral roll prepared. This, he cannot do in view of Section 30 of “the 1950 Act”. That much appears to be obvious. That conclusion of ours is put beyond controversy by the decision of the Supreme Court in Ramaswamy's case, referred to earlier. The relevant discussion is found in paragraphs 7 to 9 of the report. This is what Subba Rao, J., who spoke for the Court observed therein (see paragraph 9 of the report):

    “It is not disputed that an application was filed before the registration officer for the inclusion of the appellant's name in the electoral roll; it is also common case that the electoral registration officer did not follow the procedure prescribed in R. 26 relating to the posting of the application in a conspicuous place and inviting objections to such application. It cannot, therefore, be denied that the inclusion of the name of the appellant in the electoral roll was clearly illegal. Under S. 30 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, no civil Court shall have jurisdiction to question the legality of any action taken by, or under the authority of, the electoral registration officer. The terms of the section are clear and the action of the electoral registration officer in including the name of the appellant in the electoral roll, though illegal, cannot be questioned in a civil court; but it could be rectified only in the manner prescribed by law, i.e, by preferring an appeal under R. 24 of the Rules, or by resorting to any other appropriate remedy. But it was contended before the High Court that the action of the electoral registration officer was a nullity in-as-much as he made the order without giving notice as required by the Rules. We find it difficult to say that the action of the electoral registration officer is a nullity. He has admittedly jurisdiction to entertain the application for inclusion of the appellant's name in the electoral roll and take such action as he deems fit. The non-compliance with the procedure prescribed does not affect his jurisdiction, though it may render his action illegal. Such non-compliance cannot make the officer's act non est, though his order may be liable to be set aside in appeal or by resorting to any other appropriate remedy”.

    8. In view of this decision the petitioner's contention as regards the correctness or legality of the electoral roll has to be ruled out as unsustainable, which means that the petitioner's attack against the Election as such fails.

    9. This takes us the next question, whether the petitioner is entitled for a recount of the votes. Recount is asked for on the following grounds:—

    (1) Though the counting is required to be continuous under Rule 60 of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 and though the same has to be done in the presence of the candidates or their agents, the returning officer unlawfully sent away the candidates and their agents at about 6-30 p.m on the day of counting and thereafter continued the counting in the absence of the candidates and their agents;

    (2) Several votes were rejected without giving any opportunity to the petitioner or his agents to examine them and therefore it is likely that some valid votes have been invalidated;

    (3) After about 2 p.m on the day of counting a part of the counting was continued at a different place and to that place, the candidates and their agents were neither permitted to go nor was it possible to go.

    (4) Out of the ballot papers issued on the day of the Election 314 were not traced and there is no explanation for the same;

    (5) There are several mistakes in Forms Nos. 16 and 20 which are indicative of the fact that no care was bestowed in the matter of counting; and

    (6) The petitioner's request for a recount was improperly rejected.

    We shall now take up each one of these grounds and examine their correctness.

    10. The petitioner's case is: the counting of the votes of Malleswaram constituency commenced at about 11 A.M at about 2 P.M the Returning Officer (R.W 1.) found that the counting was lagging behind; therefore, he arranged some more tables at a distant place and posted additional counting assistants at that place; to that place, the petitioner and his agents were not permitted to go nor could they go in view of the fact that the petitioner had been permitted to have only 5 counting agents; at about 6-30 P.M all of a sudden, without any reason, R.W 1 asked all the candidates and their agents to quit the place of counting; the petitioner protested against that order and refused to leave the place; but he was told that if did not leave the place he will be forcibly sent out; immediately thereafter, he went and got drafted Ex. P-1, signed the same and tried to present it to R.W 1, but R.W 1 refused to accept it; consequently, he went and reported the matter to the Mayor Sri Krishna Iyer (P.W 4); the Mayor sent the Administrative Officer to the Returning Officer with a request that the candidates and their agents should be permitted to be present at the place of counting, but the Returning Officer did not agree to that suggestion; the Administrative Officer came and reported to the Mayor that R.W 1 told him that the candidates and their agents would be called in at the time of the declaration of the result. This case of the petitioner is supported by P.Ws 2 and 1. R.W 1 in his evidence has denied these allegations. Dealing with the allegation of sending away the candidates and their agents in the middle of the counting, he stated that at about 6.30 or 7 P.M the counting of the votes of the Malleswaram constituency was over. All that remained was to tabulate the number of votes. He entrusted the tabulation work to some officer and told the candidates and their agents to retire to a room in the upstairs of the Corporation building and come back when the tabulation work was over, which information would be duly intimated to them. His further case is that at about 10-30 P.M he sent for the candidates and their agents and they were permitted to scrutinise the Form No. 20 statements (tabulation statements). After that, the contents of Form No. 20 statements were read out. Thereafter, he declared the result of the Election and signed the prescribed declaration. It is only after he declared the result and signed the declaration, Ex. P-1 was presented to him. It was presented at about 10.45 P.M and he passed orders thereon at about 11 P.M The Returning Officer is a responsible officer. He is a member of the Indian Administrative Service. It was not alleged that he had colluded or had any reason to collude with the respondent nor was it said that he had any reason to be hostile to the petitioner. The petitioner is naturally an interested witness; is his election agent. So far as P.W 2 is concerned, he is a defeated candidate in another constituency. P.W 3 is one of the defeated candidates of the Malleswarm constituency. The evidence of these witnesses was not accepted by the Tribunal below. We have been taken through their evidence. Their evidence is artificial and unacceptable. The evidence of the petitioner does not find support from the evidence of P.W 4, the Mayor. All that P.W 4 says is that at about 7 P.M the petitioner came and complained to him that he was asked to go away from the place of counting; but he (P.W 4) told him that he could not do anything in the matter. He does not support the petitioner's story of the Administrative Officer going to the Returning Officer with a message from P.W 4 and his returning without success. The Administrative Officer has not been examined in this case. It is unnecessary to go into the details of the petitioner's case as if is completely falsified by Ex. P-1. According to the petitioner, Ex. P-1 was got written by him, because, he and his agents were sent away from the place of counting. Ex. P-1 is silent about that incident. There is not even a whisper about that incident in Ex. P-1. In Ex. P-1 it is not even suggested that the counting continued after the candidates and their agents were sent away. Hence, the petitioner's version, that the votes were counted after he and his agents were sent away, must be held to be untrue.

    11. It is seen from the evidence on record that as soon as the counting of votes of any particular booth was over, the votes polled by each candidate and the votes rejected were written on a black-board kept at the counting place. Further, those informations were broadcast through a mike. Hence, the candidates and their agents had opportunity to know the votes secured by each of the candidates in the several booths. Therefore, once the counting was over, there was little room for any manipulation. It would have been desirable to have the candidates and their agents at the time of tabulation. But the fact that the tabulation was done behind their back could not have affected the result of the Election nor could it have vitiated the counting.

    12. It is true that as many as 1841 votes have been rejected as invalid votes. It is not the case of the petitioner that all these votes or even majority of those votes were cast in his favour. The petitioner's case is that at the time of counting of votes, whenever a counting assistant thought that a vote may be invalid, he kept it aside and the same was not shown to the candidates or their agents and thereafter, they were rejected by the Assistant Returning Officer behind the back of the candidates and their agents. As against the evidence of the petitioner and his witnesses on this point, we have the testimony of the Returning Officer. From his evidence, it is gathered that some days before the counting day, he called a meeting of the candidates and their agents and explained to them the procedure of counting. From his evidence, it is seen that at the time of the counting, he was sitting on a dais and supervising the counting. The counting was done at 16 different tables. At each table, there was a supervisor. Under each supervisor, there were two or more counting assistants. The counting was done boothwise. At each table the ballot box or boxes of one particular booth was taken out for counting at a time; the votes polled by the various candidates were sorted out; whenever a counting assistant had reason to think that a vote may be invalid, he had to show the ballot paper to the candidates and their agents present at that table and thereafter it had to be scrutinised by the Supervisor; ultimately the ballot paper had to be taken to the Assistant Returning Officer, who passed final orders thereon, either accepting the ballot paper as valid or rejecting the same as invalid and he had to give his reasons in support of his conclusion. R.W 1 says, and we have no reason to disbelieve his evidence, that at the time of the counting, neither the petitioner nor any of his agents had complained to him that votes were being rejected without giving them opportunity to scrutinise them. According to him, no objection was taken by the petitioner or his agents, at the time of counting about the rejection of votes. If the version put forward by the petitioner is true, naturally he or his agents, would have kicked up a row at the time of the counting. They would not have kept quiet. It is not the case of the petitioner that at the time of the counting he or his agents raised any objection as regards the rejection of votes. The complaint as regards the rejection of votes appears to have been put forward for the first time in Ex. P-1. In these circumstances, the complaint as regards rejection of votes cannot be sustained.

    13. At this stage, we may also consider the truth of the petitioner's allegation that though he presented Ex. P-1 to R.W 1 at about 6-30 or 7 P.M, R.W 1 refused to accept the same, and he accepted it at about 10-45 P.M This allegation is belied by the contents of Ex. P-1. The main prayer made in Ex. P-1 is one for recounting. The petitioner could never had made a prayer for recounting if the counting was going on or even if the tabulation was going on. A reading of Ex. P-1 shows that it must have been prepared after the tabulation was complete.

    14. In support of the contention that the rejection of votes was not done in accordance with rules, our attention was invited to a portion of the deposition of R.W 2, the election agent of the respondent, wherein he had stated that whenever a counting assistant opined that a ballot paper may be invalid, he kept it aside and that be did not know what happened it. In our opinion, nothing much turns on this statement. R.W 2 was not a counting agent. He was only the election agent of the respondent. He must have been generally supervising the counting. The persons who watched the counting assistants were the counting agents. The evidence of R.W 2 on this point is inconclusive. Suffice it to say that his evidence does not support the petitioner's case.

    15. Now, coming to the allegation that at about 2 P.M on the day of counting, a part of the counting of votes was arranged to be done at a place far away from the place of counting and to that place, the candidates or their agents had no access or could not have had access. This allegation of the petitioner has been denied by the Returning Officer. The Returning Officer's version is that at about 2 P.M he found that the counting of votes in the Malleswaram constituency was lagging behind the schedule. But by that time, the counting of votes in some of the other constituencies was either over or was Dearly over. Therefore, we drafted some of the counting assistants engaged in counting of votes in those constituencies to count votes in Malleswaram constituency and to facilitate their work, he had the tables re-arranged. He denies that any additional tables were placed. He is positive that no counting took place at a different place. It is true that R.W 2 in one portion of his cross-examination has stated that certain additional tables were placed to facilitate the counting, but he later corrected himself and deposed that smaller tables were replaced by bigger tables. Even if we accept the evidence of R.W 2, that some additional tables were placed, the same does not support the petitioner's case that a part of the counting was done at a different place. On this point again, we have no reason to disbelieve the evidence of the Returning Officer.

    16. R.W 1 has denied the petitioner's case that 314 votes were missing. According to him only 21 out of the thirty-eight thousand and odd ballot papers issued to voters were not found in the ballot boxes. The petitioner's version that there was a shortage of 314 votes is said to be based on some news paper report. We did not know the basis of that report. The correspondent who gave that report has not been examined. Hence, the report in question is not admissible in evidence. R.W 1 has given the details of the missing votes. It is not surprising that in an election in which more than thirty-eight thousand ballot papers had been issued, twenty-one ballot papers are missing. Under the present Election rules, it is true the voter has to put his ballot paper in the ballot box in the presence of the Polling Officer. But the ingenuity of some of the voters has evidently outwitted the Polling Officers. Evidence has been placed before us to show that some voters, instead of putting the ballot papers issued to them into the ballot boxes, have put in other pieces of papers containing slogans or comments or criticism about some one or other. Missing of ballot papers is not a peculiar phenomena in this Election. From our experience of Election cases, we are satisfied that it has happened in every constituency. To conduct an Election, it is necessary to employ hundreds of officers. All of them may not be vigilant. The shortage of 21 ballot papers cannot be reasonably attributed to defective counting.

    17. Sri Ethirajulu Naidu, the learned counsel for the appellant pointed out to us certain mistakes in Forms 16 and 20. We have verified the originals. We are satisfied that these are clerical mistakes. We were not told how these mistakes have any bearing, materially or otherwise, on the result of the Election. We do not think it necessary to detail these mistakes, as in our judgment, they have no bearing on the result of the Election.

    18. Lastly, we come to the complaint that though the petitioner prayed for a recount of the votes polled, before the election results were announced, the Returning Officer improperly rejected that prayer. The Returning Officer swears that no application for recount was given to him till be declared the result and signed the necessary declaration. According to him, Ex. P-1 was given to him after the Election result was announced and hence he could not recount the votes. We accept that evidence and reject the contention of the petitioner that his prayer for recount was improperly rejected.

    19. For the reasons mentioned above, we dismiss this appeal with costs. Advocate's fee Rs. 500.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K. Sriramulu (Petitioner) v. K. Deviah ().
    (Mar 17, 1964)