Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Paritosh Chanda v. Union Of India And Ors.

    Rumi Kumari Phukan, J.:— Heard Mr. M.A Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. S.C Keyal, learned Asstt. Solicitor General of India and Mr. R. Dhar, learned Government advocate for the State of Assam.

    2. The petitioner herein has challenged the impugned ex parte order dated 10.7.2008 passed by the learned Foreigners Tribunal (2nd) Mangaldoi in FT Case No. 650/07 (S.P Enquiry No. 157/06) declaring the petitioner foreigner of post 25.3.1971 stream on the ground that a reference case No. 157/06 was initiated by the respondent No. 3 expressing the petitioner as doubtful citizen and accordingly FT (2) Case No. 650/07 was registered against him. According to the petitioner though notice was issued to the petitioner but he did not receive the same and, therefore, he could not contest the case and ultimately by the ex parte order dated 10.7.2008 he has been declared foreigners of post-25.3.1971. The petitioner could learn the aforesaid order only when the police came to search him in his residence. After knowing the aforesaid ex parte order he applied the same through his advocate and copy was obtained on 7.8.2014 and thereafter this writ petition was filed on 5.12.2014 The petitioner could gather from the ex parte judgment that notice was acknowledged by him with his thumb impression. According to the petitioner he never use thumb impression as he put his signature in all communications by putting his signature.

    3. We have considered the submissions so made by the learned counsel for both the parties and perused the impugned order. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner the impugned ex parte order is a complete communication gap. On the other hand learned counsels for the respondents have vehemently opposed such contention that ignorance of law is no excuse and as admittedly the petitioner knowingly did not contest the proceeding and as such there is no scope to interfere with the order so passed by the learned Tribunal.

    4. We have carefully gone through the impugned order dated 10.7.2008 passed by the learned Tribunal which reflect that in spite of receipt of notice the petitioner did not appear before the learned Tribunal for which the learned Tribunal has passed the impugned ex parte order. Admittedly, the petitioner was aware of the aforesaid proceeding as notice was served upon him and the F.T Case relates to the year 2007, however, on receipt of the case by the learned Tribunal the same was tried by the learned Tribunal Mangaldoi in view of the fact that the petitioner has received notice as has been evident from the acknowledgement of the notice whereby he was directed to appear before the Tribunal to prove his citizenship otherwise he will be declared foreigner. But peculiarly the petitioner neither appear before the Tribunal nor filed any written statement to contest the case even after opportunity was given to him for his representation. Obviously as per section 9 of the Foreigners Act, 1946 burden lies on the proceedee to prove the citizenship as it is within his knowledge that as regards the date of birth, place of birth and all details about family tree as all are being the personal knowledge of the person concerned but not on the State authority. The petitioner herein did not avail the opportunity to prove her citizenship and such a contention on the part of the petitioner that due to wrong advice by people he did not turn up before the proceeding cannot be accepted.

    6. The Full Bench of this court in the case of Assam v. Moslem Mandal, 2013 (1) GLT 809 it has been held that while dealing with the power of a Tribunal to set aside ex parte order, has held that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to entertain such application to pass necessary order provided that it is proved to the satisfaction of the Tribunal that proceedee was not served with a notice in the reference proceeding or the proceedee was prevented by sufficient causes from appearing in the proceeding and the reasons beyond his control. It has also been held that such an application should not be entertain in a routine manner. The Tribunal can entertain such application provided that proceedee would demonstrate the existence of special/exceptional circumstances to entertain the same by way of pleadings in the application filed for setting aside the ex parte order.

    8. Although the petitioner herein has filed some documents by way of additional affidavit before this court which was never laid before the Tribunal, the same cannot be looked into by this court as has been held by the Division Bench of this court reported in 2010 (2) GLT 1 (Moslem Mondal v. Union of India.), wherein it has been held that writ court could have examined only the materials available before the Tribunal and not the new evidence. A writ proceeding is not a substitute for a proceeding before a Tribunal.

    9. In view of the above matters on record as well as the proposition of law, as laid down by the Full Bench decision the petitioner has failed to make out a case for interference by invoking extraordinary jurisdiction. Rather, petitioner has failed to set forth any special or exceptional circumstances to set aside the ex parte order. There being no illegality or irregularly in the impugned order so passed by the learned Tribunal, the present writ petition stands dismissed. Consequently, the respondent authority will take the follow up action for deportation of the petitioner as directed by the Tribunal.

    10. With the directions above, this writ petition stands disposed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Paritosh Chanda v. Union Of India And Ors.
    (Nov 17, 2016)