AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules 1965.
  • provisions of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rule, 1965.
  • rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules
  • Central Reserve Police Force Rule 94(a)(2)(ii). Respondent 2
  • rule 94(a)(2)(ii) of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules
  • Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965.
  • rule 108 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules
  • CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE ACT
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • clause (ii) of sub-rule (2) of rule 94
  • provisions of Article 311
  • Clause (ii) of Rule 94(a)(2)
  • Sub-rule (5) of this rule
  • sub-rule (5) of rule 108
  • sub-rule (1). Sub-rule (4)
  • CRP Rules 94(a)(2)(ii).
  • Sub-rule (1)
  • Sub-rule (2)
  • Sub-rule (3)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (1) of rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules 1965.
  • provisions of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rule, 1965.
  • rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules
  • Central Reserve Police Force Rule 94(a)(2)(ii). Respondent 2
  • rule 94(a)(2)(ii) of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules
  • Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965.
  • rule 108 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules
  • CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE ACT
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • clause (ii) of sub-rule (2) of rule 94
  • provisions of Article 311
  • Clause (ii) of Rule 94(a)(2)
  • Sub-rule (5) of this rule
  • sub-rule (5) of rule 108
  • sub-rule (1). Sub-rule (4)
  • CRP Rules 94(a)(2)(ii).
  • Sub-rule (1)
  • Sub-rule (2)
  • Sub-rule (3)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by C.R. Thakur, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging a termination order (Annexure 16) dated 23rd July, 1973 (the judgment record also mentions a July 29, 1973 communication) terminating him from the post of Company Commander in the Indo‑Tibetan Border Police (ITBP / Border Police).

Key factual points (as stated in the opinion):

  • The petitioner joined the Emergency Commission of the Indian Army on 14 April 1963, served in the Army until 21 August 1967, and was deputed to the Indo‑Tibetan Border Police on that date. He was absorbed in the ITBP and given seniority from the date of joining the Army.
  • He was appointed Company Commander with effect from 22 August 1967 on the terms in Annexure 1 and was governed by the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) Act and Rules as amended.
  • After completion of three years' service (1970), he became entitled to quasi‑permanent status and on 1 May 1970 the Government converted many temporary posts to permanent posts, including the Company Commander post; petitioner featured in the seniority list and later moved in seniority due to promotions of others.
  • On or about 9 October 1971 a patrol party including constable Palas Ram became scattered in heavy snowfall; Palas Ram was reported missing. Multiple search efforts and a Court of Enquiry (which included the petitioner as a member) failed to establish what happened to Palas Ram. Civil police investigations were conducted; arrests and suspensions occurred; proceedings were dropped after civil police initially failed to make a case.
  • Subsequently, after about one year and ten months, an ex‑constable Sonam Ram made a statement saying he was an eyewitness to Palas Ram’s murder; the civil police allegedly found a skull. Sonam Ram had earlier been transferred and discharged after adverse reports and, according to the petition, harboured enmity toward the petitioner.
  • On 29 May 1973 (order dated that day), the Commandant transferred the petitioner from ‘A’ Company to ‘B’ Company; the petitioner did not hand over charge, sought interviews and explanations, and allegedly fell ill before some meetings. On July 23/29, 1973 he received a termination order (Annexure 16) terminating his services forthwith under the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965; the order stated payment in lieu of one month’s notice would be made but the petitioner alleged non‑payment and non‑issuance of T.A. and discharge certificate.
  • The petitioner sought quashing of the termination order, declaration of permanency or quasi‑permanency and consequential benefits including salary and seniority.
  • Respondents raised preliminary objections including that the termination was an innocuous exercise of power under the terms of temporary appointment and applicable rules; that the petitioner was a temporary employee and not confirmed; and that salary had in fact been drawn (per respondents' reply supported by treasury vouchers).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner had acquired permanence or quasi‑permanent status such that his termination could not be effected under the impugned rules and terms of appointment.
  2. Whether the termination order (Annexure 16) was punitive, stigmatic or in substance a punishment attracting the protections of Article 311 of the Constitution.
  3. Whether the respondents complied with the contractual and statutory requirement to pay one month’s salary in lieu of notice at the time of termination.
  4. Whether the transfer order (and the authority of the Commandant to transfer) and alleged disobedience of that transfer were the real grounds for termination (i.e., whether the termination was for misconduct connected with the inquiries into the disappearance of Palas Ram).
  5. Whether applicable statutory and service rules (specifically CRPF Rules — Rule 94 and Rule 108 — and the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965 (rule 5)) permit the termination effected in this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that having completed four years' service and being certified as "fit for permanent retention" he had acquired permanence (or at least quasi‑permanency) and could not lawfully be terminated as a temporary employee.
  • He argued that the uniform grant certified under CRPF Rule 94(a)(2)(ii) (balance of Rs. 450 on completion of three years) and the certification of fitness for permanent retention indicated confirmation/permanency.
  • He submitted the termination was unlawful because the payment in lieu of one month's notice required by his letter of appointment and the termination order was not paid simultaneously as envisaged; he alleged he did not receive the salary, allowances, T.A. or a discharge certificate.
  • He argued the termination was essentially punitive and connected to the enquiries surrounding the disappearance/murder of Palas Ram and his alleged disobedience of the transfer order, thereby making the order one of punishment rather than an innocuous administrative termination.
  • Counsel relied upon authorities (not specified in the summary) to argue that the termination order had punitive effects and that the court should look at attendant circumstances to determine whether the order was in truth a punishment.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondents contended that the petitioner was a temporary employee and his termination was effected by a competent authority under the relevant rules and terms of appointment; this raised disputed questions of fact inappropriate for interference by writ.
  • They denied that the petitioner had acquired permanent or quasi‑permanent status and pointed out administrative reasons for non‑confirmation generally.
  • They stated the certification under Rule 94(a)(2)(ii) was a procedural step to enable payment of the uniform grant and did not amount to confirmation in a substantive post.
  • They asserted that the Commandant was competent to order the transfer and that the termination was in accordance with paragraph 4(i) of the appointment letter and rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965.
  • They further averred that the petitioner had, in fact, drawn his monthly salary (treasury vouchers) and had drawn another sum in lieu of one month's notice; this factual assertion in the return was not controverted by the petitioner.
  • They denied any extraneous or mala fide consideration influenced the appointing authority to terminate the petitioner’s services.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the facts and relevant provisions of the service rules relied upon by both sides and applied those rules to the petitioner's circumstances. The analysis proceeded in key steps:

  1. Examination of the certification and uniform grant under CRPF Rule 94(a)(2)(ii): The court observed that the grant of Rs. 450 upon completion of three years (or on confirmation, whichever is earlier) and the concomitant certificate that the petitioner was "fit for permanent retention" did not by themselves amount to confirmation in a substantive/permanent post. The rule requires such certification for payment of the allowance where the officer is not substantive; it does not convert a temporary appointment into a permanent appointment.
  2. Analysis of Rule 108 (probation and confirmation): The court reviewed sub‑rules of Rule 108, including that appointment/promotion to a superior post is on probation for two years, confirmation follows on being considered fit subject to availability of substantive vacancies, the Government may extend probation, and sub‑rule (5) which provides that if no action is taken under subs (2), (3) or (4), the post shall be treated as engagement from month to month terminable on one calendar month's notice on either side. The court held that sub‑rule (5) militated against the petitioner’s contention that mere expiry of probation conferred automatic confirmation; rather, after probation, retention may continue month‑to‑month terminable by one month’s notice.
  3. Contractual right of termination and payment in lieu of notice: The court noted the appointment letter (Annexure 1) expressly provided that the appointment was temporary and terminable by one month's notice by either side and that the appointing authority reserved the right to terminate forthwith by payment of salary and allowances for the notice period. The court took the termination clause (para 4(i)) and the proviso to Sub‑rule (1) of rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965, as authorizing summary termination on payment in lieu of notice.
  4. Factual determination on payment of salary in lieu: The petitioner alleged he had not been paid in compliance with Annexure 16. The respondents replied, pointing to treasury vouchers showing the petitioner drew his salary for July 1973 (Rs. 1,130) and an identical amount in lieu of one month's notice (another Rs. 1,130), both on 1‑8‑1973. The petitioner filed no rejoinder to contradict these particulars. The court treated the respondents' uncontested averment and supporting vouchers as falsifying the petitioner's assertion of non‑payment and observed it was thus unnecessary to pursue that matter further.
  5. Whether the termination was punitive/stigmatic and thereby attracted Article 311 protections: The court considered the petitioner's contention that the termination was in substance a punishment rooted in inquiries concerning Palas Ram’s disappearance and alleged disobedience of transfer orders. The court evaluated the record and documents and concluded there was no material to show that the enquiries or the alleged disobedience formed the very basis of the termination. The termination order (Annexure 16) was a plain administrative termination not casting any stigma. The court emphasized that the allegations of mala fide in the petition primarily concerned Sonam Ram and Dharam Prakash and not the appointing authorities; there was no evidence that the Commandant or the respondents were biased or had pre‑judged the petitioner.
  6. Conclusion from combined legal and factual analysis: Given (a) the rules showing that certification for a uniform grant does not equal confirmation, (b) Rule 108’s sub‑rule (5) permitting month‑to‑month termination where confirmation action is not taken, (c) the contractual provision for termination with payment in lieu, and (d) the uncontroverted factual position that salary and the amount in lieu of notice were drawn, the court concluded that the termination was lawful and administrative rather than punitive.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is dismissed. The court expressly dismissed the petition and made no order as to costs.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The petitioner’s challenge to the termination order was rejected; the termination stands as a lawful administrative termination under the terms of appointment and applicable rules.
  • The court found no basis to treat the termination as punitive or as attracting the safeguards of Article 311, since the order did not cast stigma and there was no persuasive material that the termination was grounded on the enquiries into the disappearance of Palas Ram or on improper prejudice by the respondents.
  • No broader precedent was set by the court in this opinion; the decision applied the service rules and facts to resolve the petition and dismissed it without costs. The opinion does not indicate establishment of a new legal principle beyond the application of the cited rules to the stated facts.

End of summary — all content in this HTML document is based solely on the material contained in the provided opinion and does not include any information inferred or sourced externally.

    Shri B.P Misra (Petitioner) v. Union Of India And Others (S).

    C.R Thakur, J.:— The petitioner has by this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India called in question the termination order (Annexure 16) dated 23rd July, 1973, from the post of Company Commander in the Indo-Tibetan Border Police.

    2. The petitioner had joined the Emergency Commission of the Indian Army with effect from April 14, 1963 He continued in the Army upto August 21, 1967, when he was deputed to the Indo-Tibetan Border Police, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. He was absorbed in the Indo-Tibetan Border Police after his services were dispensed with by the Army authorities but the continuity in service was maintained and he was given seniority from the date of joining the Army. He was appointed as Company Commander in the Indo-Tibetan Border Police (shortly called the Border Police) with effect from 22-8-1967 on the terms and conditions of appointment as contained in Annexure 1 to this petition he was governed by the Central Reserve Police Force Act and the Rules, as amended from time to time, After completion of three years service in 1970, the petitioner became entitled to quasi permanent status. With effect from May I, 1970, the Government of India converted 80 per cent of 80 various sanctioned temporary posts in the Border Police Battallions into permanent posts vide Annexure 2. The post of the Company Commander held by the petitioner was also converted into a permanent post. Then all the 64 posts of Company Commander were declared permanent. The petitioner was at serial No. 30 in the seniority list (Annexure 3). Six persons were promoted to the posts of Assistant Commandants, as such the petitioner was placed at serial No. 24 in the seniority list. The petitioner had completed four years of service on September 10, 1972, and, therefore, he was sanctioned a uniform grant of Rs. 450/-, representing the balance of initial uniform grant of Rs. 900/-, as admissible to him, vide Central Reserve Police Force Rule 94(a)(2)(ii). Respondent 2 also certified him to be fit for permanent retention is the Force (Annexures 4 & 5).

    3. The petitioner further averred that on October IX, 1971, a party of eight personnels, including constable Palas Ram, under Havildar Amar Singh left for Kunnu Post but due to heavy snow-fall and hail-storm the party had disorganized and scattered. Out of the party personnels, Palas Ram could not reach the destination and was reported missing. The petitioner despatched a search party on October 19, 1971 for a search for the missing constable Palas Ram. Another party which was also sent reported the recovery of a coat, Parkha and some blood stained earth but there was no trace of any body, after on a Court of Enquiry, consisting of Shri J.P Verma, IPS, Assistant Commandant, Presiding Officer, the petitioner and Jamadar Gurdyal Singh Kapoor, Junior Commissioned Officer, was constituted under the orders of the higher authority. The Court of Enquiry came to the conclusion that in the absence of any evidence it could not be established as to what actually happened to the missing constable Palas Ram. The proceedings were forwarded thereafter to the higher authorities. Thereafter the matter of disappearance of Constable Palas Ram was reported to the Local Civil Police by the Commandant, VI Battalion of the Border Police, which was started investigation. The party of eight personnels including Hav. Amar Singh was arrested by the Civil Police, Kalpa. These persons were subsequently suspended by the Commandant. This enquiry was conducted by one Dharam Prakash, S.I of Police. It is averred that during the course of enquiry by the Court of Enquiry, one day Dharam Prakash S.I came to Kunnu Post in a drunken state and tried to disturb the proceedings by shouting and using abusive language and created a scene. The result was that the Presiding Officer of the Court of enquiry preferred a complaint before the Superior Border Police authorities and requested that civil police may be requested to entrust the enquiry to some other officer. On August 2, 1972, the civil police also interrogated the petitioner. On his appearance before the District Inspector, Himachal Pradesh Police, Kalpa, he was informed that he was to be charged under section 302 IPC for the alleged murder of Palas Ram in conspiracy with Subedar Sadhu Singh, ‘A’ Company. The matter was reported by the petitioner to the Commandant as also to the Deputy Inspector-General Border Police on August 5, 1972, vide Annexure 6. The Civil Police also failed to establish any case and, therefore, the proceedings were dropped. The suspension orders of the entire party including Hav. Amar Singh were revoked.

    4. Thereafter the higher authorities ordered to institute a departmental enquiry against Havildar Amar Singh, Incharge party. Subsequently he was demoted to the rank of Naik.

    5. The enquiry by the civil police was re-opened on the reported statement made after the lapse of about one year and ten months of one Sonam Ram, Ex-constable of VI Battalion of the Border Police, who stated that he was eye witness to the murder of constable Palas Ram. It was said that Dharam Prakash S.I against whom a complaint was lodged was said to have found a skull purporting to be that of missing constable Palas Ram in the forest area.

    6. It is further averred that Sonam Ram ex-constable who was working in ‘A’ Company under the command of the petitioner was transferred to ‘E’ Company in the same Battalion on the report of the petitioner about his poor and unsatisfactory conduct. Subsequently he was discharged from the service. Eversince his transfer and discharge, Sonam Ram harboured feelings of enmity towards the petitioner. As a result of his discharge Sonam Ram came forward with the allegation that he saw constable Palas Ram being murdered and contacted S.I Dharam Prakash of the civil police against whom a complaint had been lodged by the Presiding Officer of the Court of Enquiry. Dharam Prakash and other civil police authorities poisoned the mind of the Commandant to the effect that the petitioner's conduct in connection with Palas Ram's case was not fair. All of a sudden, on May 29, 1973, the Commandant VI Battalion of the Border Police ordered the transfer of the petitioner from ‘A’ Company to ‘B’ Company Shri D.S Malik, Assistant Commandant, officiating Company Commander ‘B’ Company was simultaneously transferred to ‘A’ Company. The transfer of the petitioner was being effected by the Commandant without prior approval of transfer having been secured from the Deputy Inspector-General or even any order from him to this effect. The petitioner further averred that the order of transfer made by the Commandant, who was not competent to transfer him was a colourable exercise of power connected with the case of missing constable Palas Ram. The petitioner, however, could not hand over the change of his post consequent to his transfer orders. He made a request for interview in connection with his transfer and to explain the facts with regard to the disappearance of constable Palas Ram, but he did not receive any reply. However, on a reminder being issued, he was informed on June 4, 1973 that he would be communicated the decision on his application which was under consideration. He was on June 5, 1973 called upon to submit a written an explanation to the Deputy Inspector-General through the Commandant for not having handed over the charge of his Company and on the same day he received another order in the evening from the Commandant that his interview with the Deputy Inspector-General stood deferred. Thereafter he was taken ill and he replied to the order on June 6, 1973. On June 15, 1973 the petitioner was called for interview and he was told that the transfer order had no connection with the case of Palas Ram. On July 29, 1973 the petitioner was handed over a letter (Annexure 16) terminating forthwith his services under Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rules, 1965. It was stated in that order that he was to be paid salary in lieu of one month notice but in fact he was not paid his salary and allowances in compliance to the order, Annexure 16. The petitioner vide his letter, dated July 31, 1973 to the Commandant requested for one month salary as per termination order. The Commandant asked him to sign the pay bill even though the petitioner could not do so because after the termination order coming into effect he ceased to possess disbursing and drawing powers. The petitioner requested for payment of T.A and for issue of a discharge certificate, but he was not either given the T.A or the discharge certificate. It is in these circumstances that the petitioner brought this writ petition for quashing the order of termination and also to declare him to be a permanent or at any rate a quasi permanent Company Commander in the Border Police and also to declare him entitled to all the consequential benefits including the benefit of salary and seniority.

    7. The respondents took up preliminary objection to the effect that the order terminating services of the petitioner is wholly an innocuous order and it cannot be labelled as a penal one. The petitioner was a temporary employee and his services have been terminated by a proper authority under the rules. These are disputed questions of fact involved in the writ petition and as such no writ is maintainable. It was denied that the petitioner had acquired the status of a permanent employee. It was further contended that no officer of the rank of the petitioner had so far been confirmed against permanent post due to administrative reasons. It was also denied that the petitioner was one of the senior-most Company Commander. His services were terminated according to the terms of his appointment. The petitioner was never declared as a quasi-permanent employee and he had been a temporary employee only throughout. The certificate as referred to by the petitioner in para 13 of the petition had become procedurally necessary and it was issued by the Inspector-General under rule 94(a)(2)(ii) of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules to unable the petitioner to draw his uniform grant. It was further averred that the Commandant was fully competent to order transfer of the petitioner. It was also averred that the petitioner had actually drawn his salary for the month of July, 1973 amounting to Rs. 1,130/- vide treasury voucher No. 14, dated 1-8-1973 and also another identical amount of Rs. 1,130/- in lieu of a month's notice vide treasury voucher No. 15 again dated 1-8-1973, both the amounts having been drawn from the Kalpa treasury. The Petitioner drew his emoluments alter the termination order came into effect when he had ceased to possess the drawing and disbursing powers and hence the submission of the petitioner is wholly self contradictory. The Services of the petitioner had been terminated in terms of para 4(i) of the offer of appointment (Annexure 1 to the petition). The petitioner was not entitled to the issue of a discharge certificate in view of the clear provisions of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Services) Rule, 1965. The petitioner was also not entitled to any T.A It was also averred that no extraneous consideration influenced the appoining authority to terminate his services.

    8. The petitioner did not file any rejoinder to this writ petition.

    9. The learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the petitioner was a permanent employee because after having put in 4 years service he was certified to be fit for permanency. Annexure 4, dated February 10, 19/2, only states that on completion of three years' service as Company Commander, the petitioner was sanctioned a uniform grant of Rs. 450/- representing the balance of his initial uniform grant of Rs. 900/- as admissible to him under CRP Rules 94(a)(2)(ii). In the next paragraph it has been stated: “It is certified that the officer is fit for permanent retention in the force.” This rule which has been referred to above does not say that this uniform allowance is only granted when a person he appointed against a substantive or a permanent post. Clause (ii) of Rule 94(a)(2) reads as under:

    “Rs. 450/- representing the balance on completion of three years' service as gazetted officer in the Force or on confirmation, whichever is earlier, subject to the stipulation that the Officer concerned, if not substantive when the amount becomes due, is certified by the Inspector General of Police as fit for permanent retention in the Force.”

    10. In the instant case the petitioner had admittedly put in more than three years' service on February 10, 1972 when this uniform grant was allowed to him and this grant as is evident is admissible only on the completion of three years' service in the Force or on confirmation whichever is earlier. There is no order of confirmation and he had already put in more than three years' service and, therefore, he was entitled to the grant of Rs. 450/- as uniform grant. But, this would not mean that he had become a permanent employee or had been posted against a substantive post. The only thing was that he was held entitled to this grant on completion of three years' service under clause (ii) of Sub-rule (2) of rule 94 and not that it conferred any right on the petitioner to contend that he had become a permanent hand.

    11. The learned counsel for the petitioner has invited my attention to rule 108 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules which provides for probation and confirmation. Sub-rule (1) says that the selected candidates shall be appointed or promoted to a Superior post in the Force on probation for a period of two ears. Sub-rule (2) states that on the completion of the period of probation, the candidates shall, if considered fit for permanent appointment, be confirmed in their appointments subject to the availability of substantive vacancies in permanent posts. Sub-rule (3) says that the Government may extend the period of two years specified in Sub-rule (1). Sub-rule (4) states that if on the expiration of the period of probation if the person is not found to be fit for permanent appointment the candidate may be discharged or the Government may pass such orders as they think fit. Sub-rule (5) of this rule reads as under:

    “Where no action is taken by Government under Sub-rule (2) or (3) or (4), the period after the prescribed period of probation shall be treated as an engagement from month to month terminable on either side on the expiration of one calendar month's notice in writing”.

    12. Hence it is obvious that in case the petitioner is not confirmed after the expiry of the probationary period or the period is not extended or he is not discharged then his retention shall be treated as an engagement from month to month terminable on either side on the expiration of one calendar month's notice in writing. The petitioner cannot rely upon this rule in his favour, it rather helps the respondents therefore, the submission of the petitioner's learned counsel that in view of rule 108 after the expiry of two years' period he stood confirmed, specially to the post against which he was to be made permanent was available and that if his probation was not extended or discharged then he was automatically confirmed is not correct in view of sub-rule (5) of rule 108 of the aforesaid rules.

    13. The second point that has been urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the termination of his services under the terms and conditions of his latter of appointment was unwarranted. The letter of appointment is Annexure 1, dated 5th September, 1967 Para 1 of this letter states that the post is temporary and is likely to continue indefinitely. Para 2 mentions the scale of pay and the allowances and the fixation of pay and seniority in the case of a released Army officer. Para 3 talks about the entitlement of allowances. Para 4(i) is reproduced as below:

    “The appointment may be terminated at time by a month's notice given by either side viz the appointee or the appointing authority, without assigning any reason. The appointing authority however, reserves the right of terminating the services of the appointee forthwith or before the expiry of the stipulated period of notice by making payment to him of a sum equivalent to the pay and allowances for the period of notice or the udexpired portion thereof”

    14. The submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the termination order was wrong, inasmuch as the petitioner had not been made the payment of his salary in lieu of one month's notice, as en-vised under sub-para (1) of pard 4, According to the learned counsel one of the conditions of his appointment, that in case of termination of his services he was to be made the payment of salary and allowances in lieu of one month's notice or the unexpired portion thereof has not been complied with. The petitioner was not paid his salary. The impugned Annexure 16 says that the services have been terminated in pursuance of proviso to Sub-rule (1) of rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules 1965. It was stated therein that he shall be paid a sum equivalent to the amount of pay and allowances for a period of one month (in lieu of the period of notice). Therefore, from this order it is evident that his services were terminated forthwith without any notice of the month and, therefore, according to the terms of this order also he was entitled to the payment of his salary and allowances simultaneously with the service of this order of termination of his services. To be more precise, the submission made by the petitioner is that he was not made payment simultaneously along with the order of termination of his services. This assertion that no salary or allowances were paid in compliance to the order of termination, annexure 16 is found in para 48 of the petition. The later portion of the reply given by the respondents in Para 40 of the return to this paragraph 48 is that: In fact when the petitioner submitted his application dated 31-7-1973 (annexure 17 filed by the petitioner) asking for a month's salary, the commandant, vide his letter dated 1-8-1978 (annexure 20 filed by the petitioner) also advised the petitioner on these lines ‘that he himself was the drawing and disbursing officer and that he was personally responsible to draw the salary and allowances’. Incidentally, the petitioner actually drew his salary for the month of July, 1973, amounting to Rs. 1,130/- vide treasury voucher No. 14, dated 1-8-1971 and also another identical amount of Rs. 1,130/- in lieu of a month's notice vide treasury voucher No. 15 again dated 1-8-1973, both the amounts having been drawn from the Kalpa Treasury”. There is no rejoinder filed by the petitioner to controvert this submission made by the respondents in reply. Hence this uncontroverted reply falsifies the assertion of the petitioner made in para 48 of the petition as also para 49 of the same. In view of this reply it is not necessary to further go into the matter of non-payment of salary and allowances when the petitioner had actually drawn the same in his capacity as drawing and disbursing officer. The third point aigtated is that even though rule 5 which has now been amended applies to the case of the petitioner and he has been paid salary in accordance therewith yet the order, Annexure 16, is punitive and not innocuous. The ground for termination of his services is the enquiry into the case of death of Palas Ram as already mentioned above. Therefore, according to him, the foundation for termination of the services is the alleged misconduct of the petitioner in connection with the murder of Palas Ram. Further that the petitioner disobeyed the order of transfer, inasmuch as he did not hand over the charge as directed. According to the petitioner, these are the grounds which formed the very basis for the termination of his services. I have already given the facts about the missing of Palas Ram and the consequent enquiries conducted in that behalf. The impugned order, Annexure 16, would show that it is a simple order of termination without casting any stigma. If there is no stigma then there cannot be said to be any violation of the provisions of Articls 311 of the Constitution. The learned counsel submits that the Court has to look to the attendant circumstances, resulting into the passing of the termination order. The attendant circumstance?, as already stated above, are the enquiries and the alleged misconduct of the petitioner in connection with the alleged murder of Palas Ram as also the disobedience of the order of transfer. The learned counsel has also cited a number of authorities to show that the order of termination was by way of punishment. Although rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules was quoted in the order of termination, it was nothing, but the colourable exercise of power. In substance and in effect the termination was by way of punishment. There can be no dispute with the principle that the Court has to sea whether the order is merely a motive or the very foundation for termination of the services of the petitioner. The various documents that have been filed and referred to by the learned counsel do not in any way show that the enquiry into the death of Palas Ram and the alleged disobedience of the order of transfer formed the very basis for the termination of the services of the petitioner. No doubt the petitioner was arrested by the civil Police, Kalpa, but nothing was found against him and his party and the police enquiry proved futile and so was the enquiry conducted by the Court of Enquiry on which the petitioner himself was one of the members. There is no doubt that the petitioner on receipt of the order of transfer did not hand over the charge. He had been making representations from line to time for interview and to explain the circumstances that led to the missing of Palas Ram. But nothing can be inferred from the record as also the documents referred to by the learned counsel for the petitioner that it was because of the aforesaid two facts that services of the petitioner were terminated. It was one of the conditions of his service that his services were liable to be terminated by one month's notice or without notice on payment of one month salary in lieu of the notice without assigning any reasons. In para 24 onwards of the petition the allegations made by the petitioner are against Sonam Ram, and Dharam Parkash and there is nothing against the respondents if they were instrumental in making allegations against him with regard to the alleged murder of Palas Ram. In para 28 he has made a specific mention that Palas Ram ex-constable who was working in ‘A’ Company under his command was transferred to ‘E’ Company in the same Battalion on his report due to his poor and unsatisfactory conduct. Subsequently he was discharged from service. Eversince his transfer and as a result of his discharge the said Sonam Ram harboured feelings of enmity towards the petitioner and did not hesitate to express his ill-will towards him openly. In para 30 of the petition it has been stated that as a consequence of his discharge, Sonam Ram came forward with the allegation that he saw constable Palas Ram being murdered and contacted S.I Dharam Parkash of the civil police against whom a complaint had already been lodged by the Assistant Commandant, Presiding Officer of the Court of Inquiry. Dharam Parkash and other higher civil police authorities tried to poison the mind of the Commandant to the effect that the petitioner's conduct in connection with Palas Ram's case was not fair although this was done with the motive to vindicate the grudge that Dharam Parkash and Sonam Ram bore against the petitioner. Therefore, from this what follows is that the allegations of mala fide are against Dharam Prakash and Sonam Ram and not against the authorities, i.e the respondents. The only submission as made in para 31 is that the civil police authorities tried to poison the mind of the Commandant. But there is nothing to infer that the Commandant was in any way prejudiced against the petitioner so as to pass an order of termination. It is pure and simple order of termination without casting any stigma so as to be hit by the provisions of Article 311 The removal, therefore, cannot be said to be consequent to the enquiries or the prejudice of any kind on the part of the respondents, nor is it because of the alleged disobedience of the order of transfer. That being in this submission that the enquiries into the death of Palas Ram and the disobedience to the order of transfer is the very foundation for the passing of the order of the termination, is not established.

    15. In these circumstances, the writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed. However, there is no order as to costs.

    16. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri B.P Misra (Petitioner) v. Union Of India And Others (S).
    (Apr 13, 1977)