Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 26, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • section 154(1)(a) of the Regulation.4.
  • section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation
  • section 154(3) of the Regulation
  • provisions of Order 26, Rule 23,
  • provisions of Order 26, Rule 13,
  • section 154(1)(e)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 26, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • section 154(1)(a) of the Regulation.4.
  • section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation
  • section 154(3) of the Regulation
  • provisions of Order 26, Rule 23,
  • provisions of Order 26, Rule 13,
  • section 154(1)(e)

    Moimunnessa v. Faizur Rahman

    1. This appeal was once decided by this Court on 10.2.84, when it was stated that the appellant could prefer objection relating to the report of the Commissioner (appointed by the Court) before the Collector to whom the decree had been referred to effect partition. It may be stated that the entire controversy relates to the question as to whether the objection to the commissioner's report has to be filed before the Collector or the civil court, which had passed the decree. It may be pointed out that the suit relates to partition of landed property, after which the separate estate would be liable for an annual amount of revenue less than five rupees.

    2. After disposal of the appeal on 10.2.84, the appellant filed a review application which came to be allowed on 23.11.84 The learned Judge allowing the same stated that the previous judgment passed in this appeal shall be reviewed by this Court.

    3. Sri Senapati has submitted that this Court had earlier stated that the objection to the commissioner's report would be filed before the Collector in view of its observation in para 13 that “(i) has not been pointed out or there is no material on record to find that the present case is under the exception envisaged under section 154(1)(a) of the Regulation”.

    4. Mr. Senapati submits that this was an apparent error inasmuch as there were materials on record to show that the case attracted the aforesaid exception inasmuch as the result of the partition would have been to form a separate estate liable for an annual amount of revenue less than five rupees. It is on this ground that the revenue authorities has earlier refused to entertain the case of partition and the matter came before the civil court.

    5. In the present case, we are not concerned with the question whether the civil court had jurisdiction to entertain the suit for partition. What is material to be seen is whether the partition in pursuance of the civil court's decree has to be made by the Collector or the Court could do so by appointing commissioner as visualised by Order 26, Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure. According to Shri Senapati as the present was a case which attracts section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation (meaning “The Assam Land & Revenue Regulation, 1986”) it was within the competance of the civil court to exercise the same powers in making the partition of a revenue-paying estate, as it has the power in making partition of a revenue-free estate, as provided in section 154(3) of the Regulation. Some assistance is also sought to be derived by the learned counsel from-section 4 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, which has stated that in the absence of any specific provision to the contrary, nothing in this Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect, inter alia, any special or local law now in force. It is submitted that this section has saved the power of the civil court conferred by section 154(3) of the Regulation which was a local law in force when the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, was-enacted.

    6. Submission of Shri Lahiri, appearing for the respondents, is that there is a specific provision to the contrary in the Code, and as such what has been provided in section 154(3) of the Regulation which is a mere enabling section, cannot over ride the provisions of the Code. According to Shri Lahiri, a partition of an undivided estate assessed to payment of revenuer to the Government has to be made by the Collector or his deputy inasmuch as section 54, which deals with this aspect of the matter, is mandatory having stated that such a partition “shall be made” by the Collector or any gazetted subordinate of the Collector deputed by him in this behalf” (Emphasis supplied). As to the reliance by Shri Senapati on the provisions of Order 26, Rule 13, Shri Lahiri has submitted that this provision gets attracted “in any case not provided by section 54”. According to the learned counsel as this case is clearly covered by section 54, the partition had to be made by the Collector or his deputy and not by issuance of any commission by the Court, as was done in the present case.

    7. The Code of Civil Procedure being a later enactment than the Regulation, and there being a specific provision in section 54 as to who would effect partition of an undivided estate assessed to the payment of revenue to the Government and the present being a case where the property is assessed to revenue (the amount of the same being immaterial for this purpose), I do not think if enabling power conferred by section 154(3) of the Regulation can be drawn upon by the civil court. To allow the civil court to invoke the power given by this provision of the Regulation would in fact come in clash with section 54 which is mandatory in character having stated that the partition of the present nature “shall be made” by the Collector or his deputy. In view of this language used by section 54, I am of the opinion that provisions of Order 26, Rule 23, cannot be invoked by a Court inasmuch as this Rule has clearly stated that commission to make partition would be issued “in any case not provided for by section 54”. It will bear repetition to say that the present case is one which has been taken care of section 54.

    8. In view of the above, despite the fact that this Court had earlier observed in its judgment on 10.2.84 that there was Mo material on record to find that the present case was under the Exception envisaged by section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, I am not satisfied if the operative part of that judgment giving an opportunity to the appellant-petitioner to prefer objection before the Collector can be altered.

    9. Accordingly, while reviewing the earlier decision of this Court, it is stated that the objection which the appellant has to prefer to the report of the commissioner shall be before the Collector and it would still be open for the appellant to do so. It may be stated that by leaving the appellant to ventilate her objection before the Collector, she is not being left without any remedy. Not only this, if she feels aggrieved at the order of the Collector, a forum would be available to her to make grievance about the same also: this forum being the Assam Board of Revenue.

    10. The appeal is disposed of as stated above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Moimunnessa v. Faizur Rahman
    (Feb 4, 1986)