Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Acts and Rules,
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules,
  • SECTION 15 KERALA EDUCATION ACT
  • Kerala Education Act and Rules.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Acts and Rules,
  • provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules,
  • SECTION 15 KERALA EDUCATION ACT
  • Kerala Education Act and Rules.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Muneera T.P. v. State Of Kerala

    A.K Jayasankaran Nambiar, J.:— All these Review Petitions have been preferred seeking a review of the common judgment dated 23.11.2016 in W.P (C) Nos. 25695/16, 25619/16, 25292/16 and 25790/16. On account of the similarity in the contentions urged in Review Petition Nos. 1077/16 and 1081/16, the said review petitions are taken together for consideration. Similarly, Review Petition Nos. 1101/16 and 1104/16 are also considered together for the same reason.

    R.P Nos. 1077/2016 & 1081/2016:

    --------------------------------------------------------

    2. In these review petitions, the review petitioners essentially take objection to the observations in the judgment that suggest that, the sole argument advanced on behalf of the writ petitioners was that on the date when the State Government took a decision to acquire the School under Section 15, the closure of the Schools had already been effected and there was no such aided School in existence, which could have been acquired in terms of the said provision. It is stated that, the contention of the petitioners was that the closure of School at any stage before the issuance of the notification in terms of Section 15, including the date of issuance of the said notification, would denude the State Government of its powers under Section 15 of the Kerala Education Act. It is also stated that, the finding in the judgment that the cabinet decision dated 29.06.2016 had ratified the decision of the State Government, was not based on any material on record or sufficient pleadings in the writ petition.

    3. I have considered the said submission advanced by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the review petitioners in both the aforesaid review petitions. I find that the first submission of the learned Senior Counsel is factually correct, in that, the contention before this Court was that the closure of the school at any stage, including the stage of issuance of notification, would denude the State Government of its powers under Section 15 of the Kerala Education Act. The observation in the judgment, which suggests that the sole contention advanced on behalf of the petitioners was that on the date when the State Government took the decision to acquire the Schools, the closure of the Schools had already been effected and therefore there was no such aided School in existence which could have been acquired in terms of the provisions, is factually incorrect. I must hasten to add, however, that the said contention of the petitioners, namely, that the closure of the School at any stage before the issuance of the notification under Section 15, including the date of issuance of the notification, would denude the State Government of its powers under Section 15 of the Kerala Education Act would not have any impact on the decision rendered by this Court in the judgment under review since the finding of this Court at paragraph 10 of the judgment is that the only relevant point in time during which the aided school must exist for enabling the State to exercise its powers in terms of Section 15, is the date on which a decision is taken by the State Government. In the light of my findings on the said issue, the correctness of which can no doubt be assailed in appellate proceedings, I am of the view that, the aforementioned contention of the petitioners would be of no consequence, as far as the judgment under review is concerned. I therefore see no reason to review the judgment on this ground.

    4. Secondly, as regards the issue of ratification, I note that, the judgment clearly records the submission of the State Government at paragraph 5 and also makes a reference to the contention regarding ratification. The counter affidavit of the State Government had referred to the cabinet decision dated 29.06.2016 and a copy of the cabinet decision was also made available before this Court by the learned Advocate General, at the time of argument. It also appeared to this court that a copy of the said order was handed over to counsel for the petitioners although the learned Senior Counsel would submit that no such copy was handed over to them. At any rate, a copy of the said cabinet decision was handed over by the learned Advocate General to the learned counsel for the review petitioners, today. The legal contention that was raised, based on the averments in the counter affidavit, was that the State Government had, through the cabinet decision on 29.06.2016, effectively ratified an earlier decision taken by the Chief Minister on 07.06.2016 There is a detailed discussion of the said issue at paragraph 10 of the judgment with reference to the decisions relied upon by the State Government, at the time of hearing. I, therefore, feel that the issue was one that was urged before this Court at the time of hearing and it was under those circumstances that this Court also rendered a finding with regard to ratification of the decision of the Chief Minister by the subsequent cabinet decision dated 29.06.2016

    5. I, therefore, find that, no grounds are made out that would persuade me to review the judgment dated 23.11.2016 The review petitions therefore fail, and are accordingly dismissed.

    R.P Nos. 1101/2016 and 1104/2016:

    --------------------------------------------------------

    6. In the aforesaid review petitions, over and above the contentions that were already urged in connection with R.P Nos. 1077/16 & 1081/16, the additional contentions raised are that, pursuant to Exts. P1 to P4 judgments produced in the writ petition, the School in question could not function in law and hence, insofar as the decision of the State Government was much after the said judgments, the power to acquire a school could not have been exercised by the Government. In this connection, it must be noted that it is not a matter of dispute that notwithstanding the directions in the judgments referred above, the School in question was not actually closed in terms of the Kerala Education Act and Rules. As a matter of fact, this was the reason why the Contempt of Court Cases were filed at the instance of the petitioners. It is also not in dispute that, as a matter of fact, the School was closed in accordance with the provisions of the Kerala Education Acts and Rules, only during the pendency of the Contempt of Court Case proceedings. In the impugned judgment, this Court has specifically dealt with the scope of the power of the Government under Section 15 of the Kerala Education Act, and found that so long as the decision to acquire the school is taken at a point in time when the schools were in existence as a matter of fact and not closed down, then the exercise of the power of the State Government has to be seen as valid. In the light of the said finding, the contention that, by virtue of Exts. P1 to P4 judgment the School ought to have closed down earlier in point of time, cannot be of any avail to the petitioners, since factually, the position was otherwise. The review petitioners also raise an additional contention with regard to the applicability of Article 254(1) of the Constitution as also the issue of alleged repugnance. In this connection, it is relevant to note that the judgment under review deals with the issue in detail in paragraphs 12 to 16 thereof. Again, while the correctness of the said findings can be assailed in appellate proceedings, I am of the view that no grounds exist to exercise the power of review over the said judgment, on the said issue. Further, since I have found that the acquisition of the Schools would be governed by the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules, it would follow, by implication, that the provisions of the 2013 Act and the notification outlining the State policy in connection with land acquisition will have no bearing on the issue of compensation to be granted for acquiring the School.

    7. I, therefore, find that, no grounds are made out that would persuade me to review the judgment dated 23.11.2016, and therefore these review petitions are also dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Muneera T.P. v. State Of Kerala
    (Dec 20, 2016)