Das, J.:— This appeal arises out of an application for ascertainment of mesne profits and we are concerned with two points. The first is whether the learned Subordinate Judge is right in directing that the opposite-party respondents should be liable for mesne profits from 1310 to Fagun 1316 and secondly whether the principle for ascertainment of mesne profits adopted by the learned Subordinate Judge is right.
2. On the first question I have come to the conclusion that the learned Subordinate Judge has taken an entirely correct view. It has been argued before us by Mr. K.B Dutt, on behalf of the decree-holders appellants that we ought to make no dishmotion between the defendants against whom the original decree was passed and the respondents who have taken an assignment of the interest or the original judgment-debtor, and he says that if the deed of assignment executed by the original defendants in favour of the present respondents were produced we might be in a position to ascertain what exactly is the interest that has been purchased by the present respondents. In my view that is a question entirely between the original defendants and their assignees.
3. The plaintiffs can take no advantage of that at all. The question is whether the respondents who trespass upon the land on a particular date should be liable for mesne profits prior to that date. There is in my view no justification whatever for holding that they should be liable.
4. The definition of mesne profits in the Code of Civil Procedure negabives the argument which has been advanced before us by Mr. Dutt.
“Mesne profits means those profits which the person in wrongful possession of such property actually received or might with ordinary diligence have received therefrom, together with the interest on such profits, but shall not collide profits due to improvements made by the person in wrongful possession.”
5. Now obviously the respondents could have received nothing ab all before their actual entry upon the land. This seems be have been the view of Phear, J. in the case of Inderjeet Singh v. Radhey Singh(1) “Mesne profits” said that learned Judge,
“Ought not to be estimated for any period (during) which the defendant, who is to be made responsible for them, was not active in keeping the plaintiff out of possession.
6. The liability for mesne profits depends not upon the purchase bub upon the entry upon the land. That entry book place in Chait 1316, and, therefore, they are liable for mesne profits from Chait 1316.
7. The next question is whether the principle for ascertainment of mesne profits adopted by the learned Subordinate Judge is correct. In my view this is not the correct principle at all. Now the land is proprietor's private land within the meaning of section 120 of the Bengal Tenancy Act. There is no evidence whatever that before the lease in question was executed in favour of the original defendants the proprietors ever let out the land on lease. We must assume therefore that on the expiry of the lease the proprietors intended to cultivate the land themselves. The principle on which the learned Subordinate Judge should have acted is laid down in the case of Pandit Luchmi Narayan v. Sheikh Mazhar Hassan, namely, that be should have dealt with the matter on the basis of the actual price of the produce and should have awarded the plaintiffs the actual price of the produce less the necessary costs of oultivation. The result is that this appeal is allowed in part and the case remanded to the learned Subordinate Judge for decision according to law. The learned Subordinate Judge will proceed on the basis of actual produce according to the decision in the case of Pandit Lachmi Narayan v. Sheikh Mazhar Hassan(2).
8. It appears that one of the appellants was a minor and that he was under the guardianship of Babu Mahabir Narayan Choudhury. The guardian died in the month of October, 1920, but the appellant has now attained his majority. Let these facts be noted.
9. The cross-objection has not been pressed and is dismissed. Costs will abide the result and will be disposed of by the learned Subordinate Judge. If the plaintiffs ultimately succeed they will be entitled to costs in proportions to their success.
10. Ross, J.:— I agree.
11. Caw remanded.