Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13(2)(a) of the Bihar VAT Act, 2005
  • Sub-Section (2) of Section 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13(2)(a) of the Bihar VAT Act, 2005
  • Sub-Section (2) of Section 3

    Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. State Of Bihar

    Ramesh Kumar Datta, J.

    I.A No. 7558/2015 In CWJC No. 17151/2014:

    1. The interlocutory application has been filed for amendment in the relief and prayer portion of the writ application challenging the vires of the second proviso to Sub-Section (2) of Section 3 of the Bihar Tax on Entry of Goods into Local Areas for Consumption, Use or Sale therein Act, 1993 and other declarations as prayed for in para-3 of the amendment petition.

    2. The amendment is opposed by learned senior counsel for the respondent-State stating that it would cause grave prejudice to the respondents as the petitioner has enjoyed the benefit of interim protection for more than a year on account of the order dated 26.9.2014 passed by this Court and further that allowing such an amendment would result in the plea of alternative remedy being extinguished.

    3. It is further submitted that no attempt has been made to explain as to why the challenge is sought to be made at this stage by way of amendment when it was and is always open to the petitioner to file a separate writ petition challenging the vires of any provision of the Act. It is also contended that the petitioner has no locus standi to challenge the vires as it is a beneficial provision which gives right of set off to the import of the goods into the local area so far as liability under the Bihar VAT Act is concerned and it is only the Oil Distribution Companies which can claim to be affected by the said provisions and challenge the vires and not the petitioner.

    4. Meeting the aforesaid objection, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that there was no interim protection granted by this Court rather the order of this Court dated 26.9.2014 had clearly mentioned that no order was being passed with regard to interim protection because the learned Principal Additional Advocate General submitted that until the returnable date, the amount demanded would not be recovered and no coercive measure shall be taken against the petitioner. It is submitted that the rule was made returnable on 08.10.2014 and thus there was not even an undertaking of the respondents in existence after the said date.

    5. It is further argued by learned counsel for the petitioner that the question as to whether the plea of alternative remedy would not remain or does remain cannot be of any importance in view of the fact that it is always open to the petitioner to challenge any provision of the Statute which is ultra vires the provisions of the Constitution. It is also submitted by learned counsel while raising various contentions with regard to the order under challenge that it was realized that the effective relief cannot be obtained because the provisions themselves were ultra vires the Constitution and thus challenge has been made.

    6. It is also submitted that the petitioner does have locus standi to challenge the vires because of its effect on the price on which the transaction is to be made with the purchaser from the petitioner, as also the levy of entry tax on the goods of which local sale has been made by the petitioner.

    7. It is also submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that it is the action of the respondents that have seriously injured the petitioner as they slept over the matter for many years allowing such transaction to continue for a long time, as only upon the audit objection they have woken up and had they acted in a timely manner then the petitioner even on the existing provisions would have made attempts to order its business and transaction in a manner so that the tax liability would not have arisen.

    8. It is also submitted that jurisdictional issues are involved in the matter and plea of alternative remedy does not require to be looked into particularly in view of the fact that the matter has remained on the list of this Court and the pleadings of the parties are complete and it only requires a final hearing.

    9. On a consideration of the submissions of learned counsels for the parties, this Court is not in agreement with the submission of learned counsel for the State that the petitioner has no locus standi to challenge the vires of the Act as undoubtedly the petitioner has made local sales of its own which would be affected by the taxation provisions of the Entry Tax Act. Apart from the same there is some substance even in the submission that the sales made to the other Oil Marketing Companies would affect the actual price on which the sale has been made in view of the imposition of Entry Tax Act even if the same has to be borne by the purchaser but ultimately it is a question of cost of the transaction and not merely the price which the seller may have to pay the purchaser.

    10. This Court also finds that though technically no interim protection was granted to the petitioner but on account of the undertaking given by learned Principal Additional Advocate General, the matter had continued thereafter to be heard so as to be disposed of at the admission stage itself; hence the respondents have refrained from taking any coercive steps against the petitioner. But the fact remains that the petitioner has raised this plea after nearly a year of the filing of the writ petition on 25.9.2014

    11. In the aforesaid circumstances, the amendment petition is allowed but upon the condition that the petitioner shall deposit with the respondents an amount of Rs. 125 (one hundred twenty five) crores by 12th February, 2016 towards the tax liability which shall be subject to the ultimate result in the matter.

    12. It is further made clear that upon such deposit no coercive action shall be taken against the petitioner until the disposal of the writ petitions.

    13. I.A No. 7558/2015 is, accordingly, disposed of.

    I.A No. 7232/2015:

    14. The interlocutory application has been filed for amendment to the writ petition so as to challenge the notification being SO No. 43 dated 4.5.2006 issued under Section 13(2)(a) of the Bihar VAT Act, 2005 in its Column No. 3 with respect to Entry Nos. 1 and 2 and for further ancillary declaration as stated in para-29 of the interlocutory application.

    15. In view of the fact that I.A No. 7558/2015 has already been allowed and considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the prayer for amendment is allowed.

    16. I.A No. 7232/2015 is, accordingly, disposed of.

    17. Put up the matter on 15 February, 2016 at 11.30 A.M

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. State Of Bihar
    (Jan 27, 2016)