Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Md. Zamil Ahmad /S v. The State Of Bihar & Ors. /S

    Navin Sinha, J.:— I.A No. 4348/13 has been filed to condone delay of one year and 263 days in filing the appeal.

    2. We have considered the submissions and explanation on behalf of the appellant and the opposition on behalf of the State. Considering that compassionate appointment had been terminated 14 years later, we deem it proper to condone the delay and take up the appeal for consideration on merits.

    3. The present appeal arises from order dated 8.11.2010 dismissing C.W.J.C No. 5713/06. The learned Single Judge held that the appellant being the brother of her deceased brother was not entitled to compassionate appointment and the termination called for no interference.

    4. Since the facts of the case have not been noticed in the order under appeal, we consider it necessary to set out the same. The brother of the appellant was deceased in harness while working as a Police Constable in the District Police Force. His wife (sister-in-law of the appellant) requested that compassionate appointment may be provided to the appellant in lieu of her. The appellant came to be appointed on 29.2.1991 recognizing him as the brother of the deceased employee. Subsequently termination followed on the ground that the policy for compassionate appointment did not contain any provision for appointment of the brother-inlaw (described in Hindi as “Dewar”). We therefore formed the impression that the authorities were considering the status of the appellant as the brother-in-law of the widow ineligible for compassionate appointment ignoring the fact that the appointment was provided to him in the capacity of the brother of the deceased. That complication of fact now stands fully resolved.

    5. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the Government instructions referred to in the order of termination were never served upon him though it was not denied that a show cause notice was issued and cause shown. There has been no misrepresentation, fraud or forgery practiced by him. The authorities gave him compassionate appointment aware of all facts. On occasions the Court has directed compassionate appointment of persons not covered by the policy also. Termination of a compassionate appointment after such long period of time is unjustified.

    6. Learned Principal Additional Advocate General appearing on behalf of the State submitted that even on 29.2.1991 when the appellant came to be appointed he was ineligible to be considered under the prevailing policy dated 30.11.1984 which made only the wife, son and unmarried daughter or widowed daughter-in-law eligible. He submits that even the subsequent policy which came on 5.10.1991 shortly after his appointment or even thereafter a brother does not come within the category of persons eligible to be considered for compassionate appointment.

    7. The law with regard to compassionate appointment stands too well entrenched by now. Being an exception to Article-14 of the Constitution requiring the appointment on all posts in Government by open advertisement and competitive merit selection, it has been carved out as exception to provide compassionate appointment for the family of the deceased faced with penury due to the sudden death. In the present case, the wife of the deceased was eligible and was never denied consideration. She requested the appellant to be appointed believing that he would look after her and the family. Time and again the Courts have held that any compassionate appointment can be strictly in accordance with the policy only and the Courts cannot, on basis of misplaced sympathy, go beyond the policy to direct compassionate appointment. On the face of the facts, the very appointment of the appellant on 29.2.1991 was contrary to the policy. The submission on behalf of the appellant that the letter dated 29.2.1991 referred to in his order of appointment or the letters dated 2.5.2005 and 25.5.2005 mentioned in his order of termination dated 23.6.2005 were never served on him along with the show cause notice does not appeal to us. If the appellant as the brother of the deceased was not eligible to be considered under the policy for compassionate appointment, natural justice can be of no avail to him as it would amount to a useless formality as held in (2007) 13 SCC 352 (Secretary, Andhra Pradesh Social Welfare Residential Educational Institutions v. Pindiga Sridhar) in which the compassionate appointment provided to an ineligible came to be terminated without a show cause notice even on admitted facts.

    8. The last submission on behalf of the appellant based on sympathy and long continuance from 1991 to 2005 cannot persuade us in exercise of powers under Article-226 of the Constitution or the Letters Patent jurisdiction subsequent thereto to give directions for reinstatement contrary to the policy.

    9. We may only appropriately quote from (1994) 4 SCC 448 (para-16).

    “16. ….The exercise of extra ordinary jurisdiction constitutionally conferred on the Apex Court under Article-142(1) of the Constitution can be of no guidance to the jurisdiction under Article-226….”

    10. We therefore find it difficult to interfere in appeal or consider grant of any relief to the appellant even on grounds of sympathy.

    11. The appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Md. Zamil Ahmad /S v. The State Of Bihar & Ors. /S
    (Dec 20, 2013)