AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section-323 IPC, Rs. 300/- under Section 447 IPC, 300/- under Section 427 IPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section-323 IPC, Rs. 300/- under Section 447 IPC, 300/- under Section 427 IPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Four petitioners, Ram Sagar Sharma, Shiv Nath Sharma, Subhash Sharma, and Dharmendra Sharma @ Dharmendra Kumar, were convicted by the Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Class, Begusarai, for offences under Sections 323, 337, 427, and 447 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) related to an incident dated 28.07.1993. Ram Sagar Sharma died during the pendency of the revision petition and was not substituted by his legal heir, resulting in abatement of the petition against him. The incident involved alleged assault and damage to property of the informant, Ram Charitra Sharma, who accused the petitioners of attacking him, his children, and damaging his house tiles. The petitioners challenged the judgment and the subsequent confirmation and modification of sentences by the Addl. Sessions Judge, Begusarai.

The prosecution examined four witnesses and exhibited several documents, while the defence examined one witness and submitted a sale deed as evidence. The trial and appeal judgments convicted the petitioners with varying sentences and fines, which are the subject of the instant revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence presented by the prosecution was reliable and sufficient to uphold the convictions under Sections 323, 337, 427, and 447 IPC?
  2. Whether the inconsistencies and omissions in the prosecution witnesses' testimonies and the non-examination of certain key witnesses affect the credibility of the prosecution case?
  3. Whether the successive judgments of the lower courts warrant interference and setting aside on grounds of infirmities in evidence and trial procedure?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed examination of the prosecution evidence, noting significant inconsistencies and deviations from the initial written report lodged by the informant. The informant initially accused all four petitioners of assaulting him and his family, but later limited his allegations, exonerating two accused from personal assault and confining their actions to property damage. Witness testimonies also varied, with some failing to mention assaults on children or other family members and presenting contradictory accounts regarding the actions of the accused.

The court emphasized the principle that "falsus in uno falsus in omnibus" is not an accepted legal doctrine, requiring the court to distinguish reliable from unreliable parts of witness testimony. It categorized witnesses as fully reliable, fully unreliable, or partly reliable and partly unreliable, highlighting the challenge posed by the last category. The court found the prosecution witnesses' evidence intermingled with falsehoods difficult to separate, leading to a rejection of the prosecution case.

Further, the omission of family members as witnesses and the non-examination of the Investigating Officer were noted as factors undermining the prosecution's reliability. The court also scrutinized documentary evidence indicating a genuine land dispute as the motive behind the incident.

The court criticized the mechanical and incomplete manner in which the accused were examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., noting that not all incriminating material was put to the accused. Considering these cumulative infirmities, the court found the lower courts’ judgments unjustified.

Holding and Implications

The court set aside the successive judgments of the lower courts and allowed the revision petition.

The direct effect of this decision is the quashing of the convictions and sentences imposed on the petitioners in the impugned judgments. The opinion does not discuss any broader legal implications or establish new precedent.

    Ram Sagar Sharma v. Shiv Nath Sharma, Both Sons Of Late Ram Prasad Sharma.

    CAV ORDER

    Formerly, there were four petitioners namely, Ram Sagar Sharma, Shiv Nath Sharma, Subhash Sharma and Dharmendra Sharma @ Dharmendra Kumar out of whom Ram Sagar Sharma died during pendency of instant revision petition. However, he has not been substituted by his legal heir and on account thereof the instant petition is found abated against him.

    2. The petitioners named above have challenged the judgment dated 21.05.1999 passed by Sri Quamrul Hoda, Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Class, Begusarai in G.R No. 1831 of 1993 convicting all the petitioners for an offence punishable under Sections 447 of the IPC and directed each of them to undergo RI for a month. Petitioner, Ram Sagar Sharma (since deceased) and Shiv Nath Sharma were found guilty for an offence punishable under Sections 323 of the IPC and each of them were directed to undergo RI for three months while petitioners Subhash Sharma and Dharmendra Sharma @ Dharmendra Kumar were found guilty for an offence punishable under Sections 337, 427 of the IPC and each of them were directed to undergo RI for one month under both counts independently with a further direction to run the sentences concurrently as well as the judgment of affirmation dated 13.09.2010 passed by Addl. Sessions Judge-6th, Begusarai in Cr. Appeal no. 63/1999 confirming the conviction under Sections-323, 447, 427 of the IPC and modified the sentences by way of slapping fine of Rs. 500/- under Section-323 IPC, Rs. 300/- under Section 447 IPC, 300/- under Section 427 IPC against each of the petitioner while allowed the appeal with regard to Section-337 of the IPC.

    3. On 29.07.1993 Ram Charitra Sharma (PW-3) had filed written report disclosing therein that his Gotia, Ram Sagar Sharma and Shashi Nath Sharma came to his house and began to abuse him as well as also assaulted him with fists and slaps. Subhash Sharma and Dharmendra Sharma also joined subsequently and brick-batted on account of which tiles of his (informant) house were broken and then thereafter, all the four also assaulted his children as well as other members of the family. On hue and cry, one Md. Jamil and others came to rescue him. The motive for occurrence has been shown as the accused persons wanted to grab his land lying by the side of their house. He had further disclosed that the occurrence is of dated 28.07.1993 at about 7:00 p.m

    4. Accordingly, after registration of the case the police swung into investigation and after completing the same, submitted charge-sheet whereupon the petitioners were put on trial and met with ultimate results, the subject matter of instant revision.

    5. From the record it is apparent that altogether 4 PWs have been examined on behalf of prosecution out of whom PW-1 is Jagdish Sharma, PW-2 is Md. Muslim, PW-3 is the informant, Ram Charitra Sharma and PW-4 is Md. Jamil as well as also exhibited series of document while defence has also examined one DW, Arjun Prasad Sharma as well as also exhibited the documents/Ext-A, the Sale deed executed by Usha Devi.

    6. From the evidence available on the record, it is apparent that PW-1 and PW-2 have asserted that all the accused persons assaulted the informant, Ram Charitra Sharma by means of fists and slaps. They have also deposed that Dharmendra and Subhash Sharma had gone over the roof of Ram Charitra Sharma wherefrom brick-batted dismantling tiles which does not happen to be the version of the prosecution so coming out from the written report. Neither the written report speaks regarding assault made by Subhash and Dharmendra over the person of informant nor discloses that they after going over roof of informant brick-batted resulting dismantling the tiles. They also not spoke with regard to assault made by them to the children and other members of family of informant.

    7. PW-3 during his examination-in-chief has also changed the prosecution version. At an initial stage, he had named all the four persons for causing assault but subsequently, he changed the version whereunder exonerated Subhash and Dharmendra and confined them to the extent of causing brickbatting resulting damage of tiles. Moreover, he had parted with the allegation of assault over children as well as other family members by all the four accused persons as disclosed in the written report.

    8. PW-4 had deposed that Sagar and Shiv Nath came at the Darwaza of Ram Charitra and began to assault. Subhash and Dharmendra brick-batted on account of tiles of his roof got damaged. Again this witness had not spoken regarding assault over the person of children and other family members of informant.

    9.Falsus in uno falsus in omnibus has not been accepted as a sound legal principle and that is the reason behind casting of an obligation upon the court to separate the truth from falsehood. During appreciation of the same, three kinds of witnesses has been characterized i.e (a) fully reliable, (b) fully unreliable, (c) partly reliable and partly non reliable.

    10. There is no difficulty during analyzing the evidence of witness falling under category no.(a) as well as (b). Really, it happens to be the evidence of witness falling under category no. (c) which needs legal acumen. When the evidence of a witness is found inter-mingled with falsehood in such a way that it is difficult to separate independently, then in that event, the evidence of the prosecution witness is bound to be rejected out rightly.

    11. Now coming to the evidence on record as is evident from written report itself that two persons namely, Ram Sagar Sharma and Shiv Nath Sharma have been shown as assailants of informant which the informant while being examined as PW-3 had also asserted, is found inconsistent with the evidence of PWs-1 and 2 who have shown all the four accused persons responsible for causing assault over the person of Ram Charitra. From the written report, it is also apparent that Ram Charitra had alleged against all the four to be assailants of his children as well as other family members but the reason best known to the prosecution, the aforesaid theme has not been alleged by the witnesses including the informant himself. This intentional omission has got a bearing in the background of the fact that none of the family members have been cited as a witness more particularly, in a capacity of victim nor they have been shown as witness in the charge-sheet. Not only this, they have not even been named either in the written report or during course of evidence by the informant PW-3. The aforesaid deficiency in the light of non examination of I.O is found another circumstance denting over reliability of the prosecution case.

    12. Now coming to the exhibits, the prosecution had exhibited five documents showing the strained relationship persisting amongst the parties since before the occurrence as well as from Ext-4, the settlement slip, it is evident that it relates with Khesra No. 29 disclosing its settlement in the name of informant, Ram Charitra Sharma while the sale deed Ext-A dated 30.08.1980 shows purchase by petitioners Ram Sagar Sharma and Shashi Nath Sharma, the land incorporated therein including Khesra No. 29 from Usha Devi, daughter of Phudo Sharma, a genuine cause of dispute.

    13. From the questionnaire so framed while complying the mandate of law prescribed under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C, it is evident that it has completely changed the manner of occurrence. Apart from this, the questionnaire also suggests that it has been exercised in mechanical manner without placing all kinds of incriminating material having been produced by the prosecution during conduction of trial.

    14. The cumulative effect on account of presence of aforesaid infirmities did not justify the concurrence of successive judgments rendered by the learned lower court. On account thereof the successive judgments are set aside. Petition is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Sagar Sharma v. Shiv Nath Sharma, Both Sons Of Late Ram Prasad Sharma.
    (Jan 7, 2014)