Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
  • S. 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
  • S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act
  • S. 4 of the Workmen's Compensation Act
  • Workmen's Compensation Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
  • S. 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
  • S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act
  • S. 4 of the Workmen's Compensation Act
  • Workmen's Compensation Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 24 January 1970 by the Presiding Officer of the Central Government Labour Court at Dhanbad, which held that the workman (respondent 2) was entitled to receive Rs. 3,294.15 from the petitioner, the employer of Jamadoba Colliery of Tata Iron and Steel Company Ltd. Respondent 2, employed as a minor in pits 6 and 7, suffered an accident on 29 March 1966 causing rib fractures. Medical Boards examined him multiple times between June 1966 and March 1967, ultimately certifying fitness to resume work. The petitioner asked respondent 2 to join work in April 1967, but he did not. Subsequently, charges of unauthorized absence were framed, a domestic inquiry was held, and respondent 2 was dismissed on 30 December 1967.

Approval of the dismissal was sought under Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, but the Central Government Industrial Tribunal No. 2 at Dhanbad refused approval on 31 October 1968, finding justification for the workman’s absence. Respondent 2 resumed work on 6 December 1968. He then filed an application under Section 33-C(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act claiming wages and benefits for the period from dismissal to rejoining. The workman had been paid wages up to dismissal but not for the intervening period, leading to the impugned order awarding him wages.

Separately, respondent 2 filed a claim under Section 4 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, seeking Rs. 9,800 for permanent total disability from the injury. The Workmen's Compensation Commissioner awarded Rs. 3,920 for 40% partial disablement. Both the refusal to approve dismissal and the compensation award were final.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a workman who has received compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act is entitled to full wages for the period of absence due to injury.
  2. Whether wages are payable for a period during which the workman did not perform any work, either voluntarily or due to disability.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Respondent 2, having received compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act for 40% reduction in earning capacity, was not entitled to full wages but at most 60% of wages.
  • Wages are payable only for work done; since respondent 2 did not work during the period in question, no wages were payable.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court rejected the petitioner’s first argument, clarifying that the Workmen's Compensation Act compensates for injury and disablement and is not a substitute for wages. Compensation awarded for injury does not negate entitlement to wages.

Regarding the second point, the court analyzed the master-servant relationship and the certified standing orders governing service conditions. It acknowledged that generally, wages are payable in return for work done. If a servant does not work voluntarily, the master is not liable to pay wages. However, if the servant is unable to work due to disability, the employer cannot be indefinitely liable for wages without taking action such as dismissal or leave without pay according to standing orders.

In this case, the employer dismissed the workman, but the dismissal was not approved by the Industrial Tribunal, rendering the dismissal ineffective. No other action was taken to stop wage liability. Consequently, the workman was deemed to have continued in service, and the employer remained liable to pay wages for the disputed period.

Holding and Implications

The writ application was dismissed with costs.

The court upheld the Labour Court’s order entitling the workman to wages for the period between dismissal and rejoining. The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the employer’s liability to pay wages despite the injury and compensation awarded. No broader precedent or novel legal principle was established.

    Jamadoba 6 And 7 Pits Colliery (Of Tata Iron And Steel Company, Ltd.) v. Central Government Labour Court, Dhanbad

    N.L Untwalia, J.:— The petitioner has challenged in this writ application the order of the Presiding Officer, Central Government Labour Court at Dhanbad (respondent 1) made on 24 January, 1970, a copy of which is annexure 4 to the writ application, under S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, holding that the workman concerned (respondent 2) is entitled to receive a sum of Rs. 3,294.15 from the petitioner, who is the employer in relation to Jamadoba Colliery of Tata Iron and Steel Company, Ltd. Respondent 2 appeared, filed counter-affidavit and opposed the application at the time of the hearing.

    2. Respondent 2 while working in pits 6 and 7 of Jamadoba Colliery as a minor met with an accident on 29 March, 1966. A slab of coal fell on him which fractured his ribs. He was examined by the Medical Board on 30 June, 1966 as also on 29 September, 1966 and on both the occasions the Medical Board was of the opinion that he was not fit to work and may be able to work in a few month's time. The Medical Board certified on re-examination of respondent 2 on 30 March, 1967 that he had become fit to join the job. Thereupon, on two dates, that is, on 5 and 14 April, 1967, the petitioner asked him to join the work, but he did not. Thereafter, in accordance with Cl. 19(16) of the certified standing orders, charges were framed on 18/20 April, 1967, domestic inquiry was held and eventually respondent 2 was dismissed by an order, dated 30 December, 1967. Since, at the time of taking action of dismissal of respondent 2 a reference case was pending before the Central Government Industrial Tribunal No. 2, at Dhanbad, in Reference Case No 132 of 1967, the employer applied for approval of the order of dismissal to the Tribunal under S. 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act. The Central Government Industrial Tribunal by its order, dated 31 October, 1968(annexure 1), refused to accord approval to the order of dismissal. In short, the charge against respondent 2 framed by the petitioner was that the former had absented himself without reasonable cause. The defence was that since he was not fit to work, he could not join his job and, therefore, there was a reasonable cause for not joining his work. The Tribunal seems to have accepted workman's case and as against the opinion of the Medical Board given on 30 March, 1967, came to hold that there was justification for the workman not to join his work. In that view of the matter, the order of dismissal was not approved. Thereafter, respondent 2 offered to join his job on 22 November, 1968 and actually he resumed his work on 6 December, 1968. Sometime later he filed an application under S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act before the Central Government Labour Court at Dhanbad claiming wages and other benefits for the period from 30 December, 1967 to 5 December, 1968. It appears that the workman concerned was paid his wages upto the date of the order of dismissal, but was not paid his wages between the period which expired from the date of making of the order of dismissal up to his joining duty on 6 December, 1968. And that necessitated the filing of the application resulting in the impugned order (annexure 4).

    3. Respondent 2 filed an application on 13 January, 1967 under S. 4 of the Workmen's Compensation Act before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner, Dhanbad, claiming compensation of Rs. 9,800 on account of the injury sustained by him which, according to him, permanently and totally disabled him. A copy of this application is annexure 5 to the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the petitioner. That application was numbered as Workmen's Compensation Case No. 2 of 1967. The petitioner resisted that case. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi, by his order, dated 23 September, 1968(annexure 2) allowed a compensation of Rs. 3,920. The finding recorded by the Presiding Officer is that there was a partial disablement to the extent of 40 per cent and the earning capacity of respondent 2 was reduced to that. It seems that the order of the Tribunal, dated 31 October, 1968(annexure 1) refusing to accord approval to the dismissal order and of the order of compensation made by the Presiding Officer, Labour Court, are final. The petitioner has challenged the order made by the Labour Court under S. 33-C (2) of the Industrial Disputes Act in this writ application on the following grounds:

    (i) that respondent 2 having got compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act was not entitled to full wages, if at all he was entitled to 60 per cent of wages, as the compensation given to him was on the basis of reduction in his earning capacity to the extent of 40 per cent; and

    (ii) that wages are payable for the work done, and if the workman concerned did not do any work, either out of his volition or because of disability, he is not entitled to wages for the period during which no work was done by him.

    4. I have no difficulty in rejecting the first submission made on behalf of the petitioner. The scheme of the Workmen's Compensation Act is not to compensate the workman in lieu of wages. The compensation is for the injury caused. Obviously in a case of award of compensation under the said Act on account of death of a workman, one cannot say that the compensation is in lieu of wages. So also when a workman is injured, certain amount of compensation, which may not be at par with the quantum of damages, if an action in tort is commenced, is paid for the injury caused to the workman for the partial or total disablement caused to him, which may be temporary or permanent No case was brought to our notice, as there could be none, to say that merely because a workman gets compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act, he is not entitled to his wages. The first point, therefore, urged on behalf of the petitioner is rejected as being without any substance.

    5. In my judgment, the second ground of attack on the impugned order (annexure 4) was attractive and required some careful consideration. The service conditions of the workman concerned (respondent 2) were governed by the certified standing orders of the company. Under the general law of master and servant, I am inclined to think that if the servant does not do any work out of his own volition, the master can never be liable to pay wages. The contract of service may not come to an end, but the servant under the contract of service is bound to do work for the master and reciprocity of the promise of the master to pay wages is to be honoured when the servant does work. If he does not do the work without any rhyme or reason and out of his own volition, the master is not bound to pay his wages. If, however, the servant con cerned is unable to do work for the master, what will be the position of the liability of the latter? Undoubtedly, the master cannot be made liable to pay wages for an indefinite period. He may by his action put a stop to the running of his liability to pay wages either by giving notice to the servant or by putting him on leave without pay, if the servant has no leave due on full pay or half-pay. But surely for the inability of the servant, even though it may be for no fault of his, the master cannot be made to pay him indefinitely. Ordinarily and generally the service conditions of the work in an industry are governed by the certified standing orders. The employer, therefore, has got to take action in accordance with them. The action taken by the employer in this case was one of dismissal of the workman concerned. As I said above, before the order of dismissal was made, the workman seems to have been paid his full wages. That action of the employer was not approved by the Tribunal and so the workman continued in service of the employer and the employer could not deny him his wages. No other action, either according to the certified standing orders of the company, or if permissible even under the general law of master and servant, seems to or is claimed to have been taken by the employer. That being so, on a careful consideration of the matter, I have come to the conclusion that the workman continued in service of the master and there was no stopping to the running of his liability to pay the wages. It would bear repetition to say that the liability was sought to be stopped by the dismissal order which became non est on the refusal of the Tribunal to accord approval to it. The workman concerned, therefore, was entitled, as held by the Labour Court, to his wages, etc., for the period 30 December, 1967 to 5 December, 1968. The second point urged on behalf of the petitioner therefore, also fails.

    6. For the reasons stated above, the writ application is dismissed with costs. Hearing fee Rs. 64.

    7. G.N Prasad, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jamadoba 6 And 7 Pit... v. Central Government L...
    (Jul 10, 1972)