Ravi Kumar Mathur, Presiding Officer:— This order shall dispose of IA No. 347/03 earlier moved by learned Counsel for defendant under Order VII Rule 11 read with Section 151 of CPC and Section 22 of the Act whereby learned Counsel for defendant has sought rejection of the instant OA qua-defendant No. 2 in so far as he stands in the capacity of a legal heir only and defendant Nos. 3 and 5. Reply was filed on behalf of the applicant Bank (AB) and arguments of both sides were heard on last date i.e 5.5.2004
2. Learned Counsel for the defendants had submitted that the applicant Bank has concealed many material facts and information from this Tribunal and has not approached with clean hands and fair intentions in so far as the liabilities of defendant Nos. 2; 3 and 5 are concerned. It is interesting to note that where as defendant No. 2 has been arrayed as one of the defendants in the instant OA. He has also been impleaded as one of the LRs of late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda who had expired much prior to the filing of the OA. Similarly, defendant Nos. 3 and 5 have been joined as LRs of deceased Shri Desh Raj Manchanda.
3. The gravamen of the arguments of learned Counsel for the defendants impressing this IA was that prior to the death of Shri Des Raj Manchanda, the applicant Bank had got executed security document from defendant No. 1 company on 20.10.1997 and the alleged credit limit were secured by the third party guarantee bond executed by Shri Vijay Manchanda who is defendant No. 2 and Smt. Shashi Manchanda, defendant No. 4 and Shri Desh Raj Manchanda himself. Applicant Bank has also claimed the creation of equitable mortgages of properties belonging to defendant No. 4 and late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda which were also allegedly created on 20.10.1997
4. However, as per the facts borne out from the OA itself the third party guarantee of late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda stood automatically released upon the renewal of credit limit by the Bank after the death of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda because the applicant Bank has got defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 4 executed afresh set of security documents on 1.8.2000 in their alleged personal capacities. Learned Counsel for the defendants strenuously harping upon this aspect of the matter relying upon Section 62 of Contract Act submitted that with the Bank having so opted for execution of fresh set of security documents subsequently after the death of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda on 1.8.2000 by defendant No. 1 company and option of third party defendant Nos. 2 and 4 only the third party guarantee of the deceased guarantor late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda automatically stood released by virtue of the provision of the Section 62 of the Contract Act. Because according to him Bank by doing so or by opting so had got fresh set of security documents signed and executed by different set of persons especially giving rise to a new contract between the parties which so facto released Shri Desh Raj Manchanda from his personal guarantee and as such with the demise of such guarantee of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda or release thereof his legal heirs in their capacity as LRs could not be arrayed as defendant in the instant OA and no liability could be foisted on them to be discharged on the basis of the guarantee earlier given by Shri Desh Raj Manchanda.
5. Learned Counsel for the defendant has also further submitted that if the intention of the applicant Bank was to secure renewal of the guarantee of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda then they have also similarly asked the surviving LRs of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda to come forward to renew the fresh equitable mortgage earlier created in its favour on 20.10.1997 by late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda but Bank did not do so which clearly and in no uncertain terms indicates that Bank had no intention or desire to implead the LRs of late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda in their capacity as LRs. He has, therefore, submitted that the OA should be dismissed against defendant No. 2 in so far as he has been impleaded in the capacity of a legal heir of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda and defendant Nos. 3 and S who have been since impleaded as LRs of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda. However, OA may be allowed to stand against defendant No. 2 in his personal capacity as defendant No. 2 and not as LR of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda.
6. Learned Counsel for the applicant Bank strongly opposed the submissions of learned Counsel for defendants and submitted that the IA has been primarily moved to delay the matter unnecessarily and the defendants are out to frustrate the cause of the applicant Bank by all means. He has also submitted that the defendants have already sold some of the immovable properties mortgaged with the Bank and are going to sell the rest of the properties just to frustrate the cause of the applicant Bank. He has also submitted that a criminal case has been made against some of the officials of the Bank who, in convenience with the defendants conspired to cheat the applicant Bank by submitting false and forged documents of the mortgaged property and submitted that the contention of the learned Counsel for the defendants about the falsity of the claim of the applicant Bank is totally untenable and wrong and claim of the applicant Bank is wholly correct and based on documents executed by defendants. Learned Counsel for the applicant Bank further submitted that there was no creation of fresh documents but in fact mere renewal of the documents was got done in accordance with law, therefore, the provisions of Section 62 of Contract Act are not attracted and instead Section 129 of Contract Act is applicable in the instant case as in the case of continuing guarantee there was no necessity or need for applicant Bank to seek any fresh renewal of the guarantee of late Shri Desh Raj Manchanda through his LRs. As such the LRs in their capacity as LRs of Shri Desh Raj Manchanda are equally liable jointly and severally with other defendants in the instant case and as such the IA be dismissed.
7. I have heard both sides at length. I have perused the file and given my thoughtful consideration to their respective submissions. After having perused the fresh set of documents executed by defendants on 1.8.2000, I am inclined to agree with the submissions of learned Counsel for the defendants that it was a clear case of fresh novation of contract for which provision of Section 62 were rightly attracted and application of Section 129 could not be conceived under such facts and circumstances especially when LRs of deceased Shri Desh Raj Manchanda were not called upon to renew the guarantee extended by Shri Desh Raj Manchanda to the applicant Bank during his life-time. As such I am inclined to agree with the submissions of learned Counsel for the defendants that in view of this the OA in so far as it pertained to defendant No. 2 as LR only and 3 and 5 could not be sustained and the same is, therefore, dismissed against defendant No. 2 as LR only and 3 and 5. The OA shall, however, stand against the defendants in their capacity as borrower or guarantor but not as LR. With this the IA stands disposed of.
Ordered accordingly.