Veena Chhotray, Member (A):— The applicant, a Postal Assistant under the Respondent-Ministry of Telecommunication, was vide Disciplinary Authority's (for short DA) order dated 18.8.2005 imposed a penalty of reduction of pay by one stage in the time scale of pay of Rs. 5200/- to 5100/- for a period of two years without cumulative effect (Annexure A/3). This penalty was upheld by the Appellate Authority (AA) vide order dated 10/13.3.2006 (Annexure A/4). This OA seeks to quash the aforesaid impugned orders imposing the penalty along with the Charge Memo dated 21.2.2000 (Annexure A/1) and the Disagreement Note by the DA (Annexure A/2).
2. The charge sheet under CCS (CCA) Rule 14 was served on the applicant vide order dated 21.2.2000 The article of charge reads as follows:—
‘ARTICLE 1
That the said Shri Ajab Singh while functioning as NSC/KVP discharge counter PA Agra HO during the period 22.11.95 to 10.2.96 committed a grave misconduct in-as-much as he failed to check and challenge the re-discharged paid vouchers dated 6.1.96, 21.12.95, 8.1.96, 19.1.96, 22.1.96 and 24.1.96, in respect of Agra Fort HQ KVP No. 05BB 445588 dated 21.3.90 Regn. No. 1179, Agra HO NSC VI issue No. 19F 649934 dtd. 28.11.88 Regn. No. 64748, NSC VIII issue No. 00EE 112120 dtd. 29.8.89 Regn. No. 210, 00EE 112165 dtd. 20.9.89 Regn. No. 305 and 00EE 112187 dtd. 5.10.89 Regn. No. 366 and Agra HO KVP No. 03CC 220394 dtd. 24.4.90 Regn. No. 5727 received from Idgah colony PO Agra amounting to Rs. 99955/-. The above mentioned NSCs/KVPs were already discharged at Agra HO on 23.9.95, 31.8.95, 2.9.95, 30.9.95, 5.10.95 & 27.10.95 respectively. Thus the department had to sustain a loss of Rs. 99955/- due to his gross negligence, carelessness and non-observance of Rules.
Thus the said Shri Ajab Singh is therefore, alleged upon that he violated the provisions of Rule 33(2) of PO SB Man. Vol. II and also failed to maintain absolute integrity, devotion to duty and acted in such a manner which is unbecoming of a Govt. servant violating the provisions of Rule 3 (1)(i), 3(1) (ii) and 3(1)(iii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
(emphasis supplied)
The charges were not found proved during the enquiry. The DA, however, recording Disagreement Note and providing the Charged Officer (CO) an opportunity to represent his case, held the charge proved and imposed the aforesaid penalty. This was upheld by the AA.
3. We heard the learned counsels on both sides and also perused the written submissions. The main ground for challenging the impugned orders is that the penalty in this case has been imposed on a charge which was not a part of the Charge Sheet served on the CO. Para 5 of the OA avers that while the Inquiry Officer (IO) had held the charge against the applicant as ‘not proved’, the DA vide Disagreement Note sought to prove something which did not form a part of the charge. It is further averred that as per the Charge Memo, the charge framed against the applicant was that he had filed to check and challenge the re-discharged paid vouchers of Agra Fort HO NSCs/KVPs and thereby the Department had sustained a loss. However, in the Disagreement Note it was alleged that the applicant had re-discharged the already discharged Kisan Vikas Patrikas and thus there was a difference and a contradiction between the charge sheet and the charge penalized by the DA.
3.1 While the Article of Charge in the charge sheet has been recounted with relevant portion high lighted in para 2 above, the charge as mentioned in the Disagreement Note of the DA is extracted as here under:
“I disagree with the enquiry report findings since the charged official in his statement exhibit K/1 dated 23.09.2003 had mentioned that he noticed some overwriting and discrepancy in the KVPs, he even wrote to Sr. P.M regarding the same out in absence of reply. He discharged the KVPs knowing fully well that all was not right with the KVPs in question. He showed negligence leading to success of the fraud, hence he is guilty of not having direct complicity in the fraud. Copy of the enquiry report is enclosed h/w.”
4. The other grounds adduced pertained to an alleged denial of reasonable opportunity; the case being of no evidence with no “misconduct”; and inordinate delay in the impugned actions. The averments regarding denial of reasonable opportunity to the CO have been made in para-5 (G) (H) (I) and (J) of the OA. Similarly para 5 (M) of the OA relates to this being a clear case of no evidence.
4.1 It is noticed that both the above contentions of the applicant are supported by the IO's report. In the portion relating to ‘EVALUATION OF EVIDENCE”, the following observations by the IO have been made:
“The Statement of SPM Idgah Colony Agra was relevant because re-discharge of already paid NSC/KVP vouchers in Agra HO was alleged in the article of charge against him at Idgah Colony Post Office. Like wise F.I.R as requisitioned at Sl. No. 4 of his application was also relevant in this case to disclose the fact as to how the fraud to came to light but this was also not allowed by the then IO. Moreover the defence witness, Shri Babu Lal, the then Sr. Post Master Agra HPO was also not allowed by the I.O vide order sheet No. 5 dated 5-6-2000 while he was not a prosecution witness.”
(emphasis supplied)
The relevant conclusive ‘FINDINGS’ from the inquiry report are also extracted as below:
“In the light of facts and circumstances, the charged official was deprived of the reasonable opportunity to some extent, and the prosecution could not establish the abstraction of the discharged NSC/KVP vouchers Exh. Ka-19, Ka-5, Ka-22, Ka-28, Ka-16 and Ka-13 from the custody of the charged official due to his negligence resulting in loss of Rs. 99955/- to the Department”.
(emphasis supplied)
4.2 As per the inquiry report, the charge against the CO could not be proved and he was exonerated there from. The DA, however, took a different view. The sole ground for DA's disagreement with the inquiry report was on the basis of a purported statement by the CO and certain inferences drawn from that, as would be evident from the following extracts from the DA's order:
“The charge has not been proved by the I.O A copy of inquiry report dated 30-6-2005 was sent to the charged official for submitting the defence on 21-7-2005, in which a note of disagreement was issued by the undersigned, that charged official in his statement exhibit K/1 dated 23-09-2003 had mentioned that he noticed some overwriting and discrepancy in the KVPs, he even wrote to Sr. P.M regarding the same. But in absence of reply, he discharged the KVPs knowingly well that all was not right with the KVPs in question. He showed negligence leading to success of the fraud, hence he is guilty if not having direct complicity in the fraud.”
(emphasis supplied)
A perusal of CO's comments on the Disagreement Note (Annexure A/6) as well as enquiry report show that no such statement dated 23.09.2003 was made by the CO and this instead refers to a deposition on that date by DW-1 Shri B.R Karoria, the then ASPO (C), Agra. To say the least, this prima facie error shows a non-application of mind and some apparently hasty conclusions on the part of the DA.
The case of the applicant is that the KVPs in question had been re-discharged by SPM Idgah Colony, PO Agra who was solely responsible for the loss allegedly sustained by the Department. Besides, the rule cited in the Article of Charge only required a general checking which in this case had been done by the applicant. Further, it was he who had brought it to the notice of the higher authorities the fact of re-discharging of already discharged KVPs by Idgah Colony P.O Agra. These contentions of the applicant are borne out by the report of the Inquiry Officer.
4.3 The learned counsel for the applicant would also contend that even as per the DA's order, no motive to make a fraud successful has been found. It is averred that even presuming that there was a negligence on the part of the CO, this would not amount to ‘misconduct’. In support, the judgment of the Apex Court in Inspector Prem Chand v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, (2007) 4 SCC 566, upholding the following definition of misconduct is referred:—
‘Misconduct means, misconduct arising from ill motive; acts of negligence, errors of judgment, or innocent mistake, do not constitute such misconduct.”
4.4 Further the plea of delay defeating justice has been averred in para-5(ix) of the OA. While the cause of action occurred in 1996-97, the Charge Memo was served on 21.2.2000; the order by DA on 18.8.2005 and the AA's order upholding the penalty on 13.3.2006, thus while six years were taken to pass the order of penalty from the date of issue of Charge Memo, there was a gap of nearly 9 to 10 years from the point of cause of action itself.
5. To conclude, nearly all the contentions made in support of the OA are found to merit consideration. There is, apparently unjustified delay of more than 10 years in imposition of the penalty. It is established in a catena of judgments of the Apex Court and of various High Courts that in the matter of disciplinary proceedings and imposition of penalty while delay in itself would not ordinarily be a cause for quashing the orders, still unjustified delay is a source of harassment for the officer besides also causing a prejudice in defence. Further, the order of penalty rests on a charge that was not framed against the charged official. We would respectfully refer to the following dicta made by the Hon'ble High Court of Punjab & Haryana High Court in Baldev Singh v. Union of India, (1994) 8 SLR 797:—
“It is clear from the above noted cases that an employee cannot be punished for a charge which is not levelled against him. Employer's action of punishing an employee in respect of the charge which is not levelled against him results in breach of the principles of natural justice and it has the effect of rendering the order passed by the employer in nullity.”
This is a case in which despite a finding of clear exoneration by the Inquiry Officer, the Disciplinary Authority chose to disagree without any objectively demonstrable basis. The order of the Appellate Authority only chooses to reiterate the view taken by the Disciplinary Authority. We also find this being a case of virtually no evidence and there being no ‘mis-conduct’ in the strict sense of the term. Besides, even as per the inquiry report, there has been a denial of reasonable opportunity for self-defence to the CO.
6. For the foregoing reasons, the OA is allowed and the impugned orders are quashed and set aside. Consequently the CO is entitled to all consequential benefits. Respondents are directed to pass appropriate order within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall be no order as to costs.