AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 43-A(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 43-A(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion (Vindhyachal STPS II — NTPC)

Factual and Procedural Background

These petitions were filed by the petitioner, NTPC (a Central Government generating company), seeking approval of tariff for Vindhyachal Super Thermal Power Station Stage‑II (2 × 500 MW) ("Vindhyachal STPS II") for the period 1 July 2000 to 31 March 2004. Two petitions are identified: Petition No. 20/1999 (seeking approval from 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2001) and Petition No. 77/2002 (seeking approval for 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004).

The record shows earlier techno‑economic clearance by the Central Electricity Authority (CEA) dated 9.5.1989 at an estimated cost of Rs. 1261.25 crore. Subsequent investment approvals and revised cost estimates were issued by the Central Government and CEA on dates including 16.2.1995, 16.4.1999 and 30.10.2001 with different approved/revised project cost figures. Unit commercial operation dates (COD) were 1.7.2000 (Unit I) and 1.10.2000 (Unit II). The petitions set out tariff basis and periods depending on the Ministry of Power and Commission notifications cited in the petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether tariff for Vindhyachal STPS II for the period 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2004 should be approved, and if so, on what basis and amounts.
  2. Determination of the appropriate dates of commercial operation (COD) for Units I and II for tariff purposes.
  3. Determination of allowable capital cost and allocation between units for tariff fixation, including treatment where audited accounts as of COD are not available.
  4. Appropriate debt‑equity ratio to be applied for computation of interest and return on equity.
  5. Appropriate normative plant load factor / target availability to be applied for recovery of fixed charges and computation of working capital.
  6. Rate of return on equity to be allowed (whether 16% or 12%).
  7. Methodology for computing interest on loan, including treatment of various loan components, commitment fees, government guarantee fees and foreign exchange variation.
  8. Appropriate basis and rates for depreciation and for Advance Against Depreciation (AAD).
  9. Appropriate basis for Operation & Maintenance (O&M) expenses and whether water charges may be allowed separately.
  10. Elements and methodology for computing working capital and interest on working capital (including receivables, fuel stock, spares, O&M and margin).
  11. Computation of energy (variable) charges and the mechanism for fuel price adjustment (FPA) and annual energy charge adjustment (AECA).
  12. Whether amounts already recovered on interim orders should be adjusted against revised charges and whether additional categories of charges (FERV, incentives, taxes, filing fee) can be recovered.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (NTPC) Submissions

  • Filed tariff petitions (No.20/1999 and No.77/2002) seeking approval for specified periods using Ministry of Power and Commission notifications as applicable.
  • Submitted capital cost figures (not certified by statutory auditors) and proposed allocation of 55% of total capital cost as on station COD to Unit‑I and 45% to Unit‑II for allocation at the time of Unit‑I commissioning.
  • Adopted a debt‑equity ratio of 70:30 (as in revised cost estimates) for tariff calculations.
  • Claimed return on equity at 16% and interest, depreciation, O&M, working capital, energy charges and other elements as set out in its petitions and supporting forms.
  • Claimed base energy charges of 62.83 paise/kWh (petition No.20/1999) and 70.07 paise/kWh (petition No.77/2002) for specified periods (subject to FPA).
  • Requested recovery of the filing fee of Rs. 10 lakh in Petition No.77/2002 in instalments and inclusion of additional charges such as FERV, incentive, taxes, development surcharge as applicable under notifications.

Respondents' Submissions

  • Contended that debt‑equity ratio should be 80:20 (the ratio applicable to Independent Power Producers), not 70:30.
  • Contended that return on equity should be 12% (historic pre‑1.11.1998 rate) rather than 16%.
  • Raised other contentions challenging components of tariff computation (specific contentions are not exhaustively elaborated in the opinion beyond the points above).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Commission's Reasoning and Analysis

The Commission's reasoning applies and interprets the Ministry of Power notifications (30.3.1992) and the Commission's notification (26.3.2001) and other governmental approvals and records submitted by the petitioner. The Commission proceeded topic‑by‑topic; the essential analytical steps recorded in the opinion are summarized below.

Dates of Commercial Operation (COD)

- The CEA techno‑economic clearance dated 26.5.1989 was silent on COD. The Commission therefore relied on the Government of India (Ministry of Power) investment approval dated 16.2.1995 for scheduled CODs. The actual CODs (Unit‑I: 1.7.2000; Unit‑II: 1.10.2000) show both units commissioned ahead of schedule. The Commission accepted the actual CODs for tariff purposes.

Capital Cost and Allocation between Units

- The applicable rule (Ministry of Power notification 30.3.1992 and Commission notification 26.3.2001) is that actual capital expenditure on completion of the generating station is the criterion for fixation of tariff. If actual expenditure exceeds approved project cost, excess as approved by CEA or an independent agency may be treated as actual capital expenditure for tariff.

- In multi‑unit projects the allocation principles in the notifications were applied. The petitioner did not have audited accounts drawn and certified as of each unit COD; it submitted uncertified capital cost figures. The petitioner proposed allocating 55% of the capital cost at station COD to Unit‑I (argument: common auxiliaries capitalised with Unit‑I). The Commission noted the submitted figures and that the expenditure considered was less than the revised cost estimates approved by the Central Government (Ministry of Power letter dated 30.10.2001). Accordingly, the Commission allowed tariff based on the capital expenditure amounts as submitted for the respective dates of commercial operation. The Commission also accepted spares capitalised as Rs. 1,984 lakh per petitioner’s books.

Debt‑Equity Ratio

- The Commission observed the approved financial package was not on record. Based on actual allocated gross block and loans drawn up to 31.3.2001, the computed ratio was approximately 67:33. The petitioner had used 70:30 in its revised cost estimates and in tariff computations. The respondents pleaded for 80:20. The Commission adopted debt‑equity of 70:30 for calculation of fixed charges, following the petitioner's adopted ratio and the absence of an approved financial package on record.

Target Availability / PLF

- For the period 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2001 the petitioner used PLF of 68.49% based on the Ministry notification dated 30.3.1992; the Commission allowed this. For 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 the petitioner’s target availability of 80% (in line with Commission notification dated 26.3.2001) was accepted for recovery of full fixed charges and in computation of working capital.

Return on Equity (ROE)

- The Ministry (30.3.1992) and Commission (26.3.2001) notifications prescribe return on equity at 16% on paid up and subscribed capital. The respondents argued ROE should be payable at 12% (historic rate). The Commission observed that the terms and conditions prescribed by the Central Government and the Commission require ROE @ 16% and accordingly allowed return on equity at 16% per annum. The Commission set out the opening/closing/average equity balances and the resulting ROE amounts allowed for the tariff years.

Interest on Loan

- Interest on loan was to be computed on outstanding loans considering repayment schedules as per the approved financial package (if available). The Commission worked normative loan based on the 70:30 debt‑equity ratio.

- The Commission adopted the earlier formula for annual repayment for interest computation (Annual actual repayment during the year × normative loan at the beginning of the year / Actual loan at the beginning of the year) or the petitioner's claimed figure, whichever was higher.

- Specific points in computation: (a) loan amounts worked out from normative debt‑equity; (b) only loan drawals up to 31.3.2001 were considered; (c) for loans with floating rates the interest rate prevailing as on 1.4.2001 was used for the period 1.4.2001 onwards, subject to later adjustment on actual rates (with liberty to approach the Commission for disputes about adjustments); (d) commitment fee at 0.75% p.a. indicated by petitioner for IBRD loans was not allowed because commitment fee applies on undisbursed portion and would have been capitalised; (e) government guarantee fee @1% p.a. for IBRD loans indicated in Form‑8 was allowed; (f) weighted average rate of interest on loan was computed applying actual rates on the normative average loan; detailed loan‑wise calculations and ERV (foreign exchange rate variation) effects were appended in the order.

Depreciation

- Depreciation was computed in accordance with Ministry of Power notification (30.3.1992) and rates notified under Section 43‑A(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 (notification dated 29.3.1994). Commission's notification (26.3.2001) prescribes historical cost basis and straight line method. Because both units came into operation in 2000–2001 no depreciation was provided for the financial year 2000–2001 (the year's depreciation prior to 1.4.2001 is worked out on opening gross block). For 1.4.2001 onwards depreciation is chargeable from the first year pro‑rata as per Commission notification; the Commission worked depreciation on average of opening and closing block and appended calculations. Depreciation amounts for years are set out in the order.

Advance Against Depreciation (AAD)

- Commission's notification (26.3.2001) provides AAD where originally scheduled loan repayment exceeds depreciation; AAD = originally scheduled loan repayment (ceiling 1/12th of original loan) minus scheduled depreciation. AAD provisions did not apply prior to 1.4.2001. The Commission used actual gross loan and actual repayment as on 1.4.2001 for computing AAD and set out AAD amounts by year in the order.

Operation & Maintenance (O&M) Expenses

- Ministry notification (30.3.1992) and Commission notification (26.3.2001) prescribe methods for computing base O&M: 2.5% of actual capital expenditure in year of commissioning (with prescribed escalation mechanics). The base year for Vindhyachal STPS II is 2000–2001 (year of commissioning). The Commission applied the prescribed methodology (2.5% base and escalations) to compute O&M expense allowances for tariff years. Because O&M charges were allowed on a normative basis, separate water charges claimed by the petitioner were not approved.

Working Capital and Interest on Working Capital

- Working capital components considered: one month fuel cost (at normative PLF/target availability), coal and oil stock, one month O&M (cash), spares (at actuals subject to maximum 1% of capital cost less 1/5th of initial spares capitalised), and receivables equivalent to two months average billing (fixed + variable charges). The Commission set out detailed computations of fuel cost, coal/oil stock, spares and receivables and produced summarized working capital tables.

- The Commission noted its notification (26.3.2001) did not address financing of working capital margin separately; therefore interest and return were not separately calculated on the working capital margin and interest on total working capital was worked out. The Commission used an annual average SBI PLR of 11.50% as the rate of interest on working capital for the tariff years (in line with earlier Commission decisions) and computed interest on working capital accordingly.

Energy (Variable) Charges, FPA and AECA

- The Commission applied the operational norms from Ministry and Commission notifications for Station Heat Rate, auxiliary consumption and secondary fuel oil consumption to compute base energy charges. The order sets out base energy charge paise/kWh values for the relevant periods (for example: 63.37 paise/kWh as on 1.7.2000 and about 69.74 paise/kWh as on 1.4.2001) and notes these are subject to fuel price adjustment (FPA).

- The Commission specified the monthly FPA formula (FPA = A + B) and defined the variables (normative SFC, SHR, AC, monthly prices and GCVs, base prices and base GCVs). The Commission also provided the annual energy charge adjustment (AECA) formula and defined the variables for annual reconciliation based on actual or normative (whichever lower) operating parameters and actual fuel prices/GCVs. The order states that energy charges will be finally adjusted on an annual basis as per actual annual weighted average operating parameters and fuel prices/GCVs, with the AECA formula applied.

Adjustment of Interim Recoveries and Other Allowances

- The Commission noted the petitioner had already recovered fixed and variable charges from respondents on the basis of interim Commission orders. The Commission directed that amounts already recovered shall be adjusted against the revised charges decided in this order.

- The petitioner is also entitled to recover other charges where applicable (Foreign Exchange Rate Variation, incentive, reimbursement of income‑tax, other taxes/cess levied by statutory authority, Development Surcharge and other charges in accordance with Commission notification dated 26.3.2001), subject to orders of superior courts. The petitioner shall be entitled to recover the filing fee of Rs. 10 lakh paid in Petition No.77/2002 in ten equal monthly instalments of Rs. 1 lakh each, to be shared by respondents in proportion to fixed charges approved for the period 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004, subject to confirmation that the amount has not been included in O&M expenses.

Holding and Implications

Primary Ruling: The Commission approved tariff for Vindhyachal STPS II as computed in the order for the periods concerned and disposed of Petitions No. 20/1999 and No. 77/2002. The order accepts the actual CODs (1.7.2000 and 1.10.2000), allows capital cost and spares as submitted (subject to the limits and conditions described), applies a normative debt‑equity ratio of 70:30, allows return on equity at 16%, and sets out the computations for interest on loan, depreciation, AAD, O&M, working capital, interest on working capital, and base energy charges with FPA/AECA mechanisms.

Direct consequences for the parties: - The tariff components and amounts set out in the order constitute the basis for billing and recovery for the period 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2004 as specified. Interim recoveries already made by the petitioner are to be adjusted against the revised charges determined by the Commission in this order. The petitioner may recover other allowable charges (FERV, incentive, taxes, filing fee instalments etc.) under the conditions specified in the order and subject to superior court orders, if any.

Broader implications: The order implements the methodologies prescribed in the Ministry of Power and Commission notifications (dated 30.3.1992 and 26.3.2001 respectively) for multi‑unit projects and tariff computation. The Commission's determinations reflect the application of those notifications to the facts before it (including acceptance of actual CODs, acceptance of petitioner‑provided capital costs where below revised estimates, adoption of petitioner’s 70:30 debt‑equity without an approved financial package on record, and allowance of ROE @ 16% as per notifications). The opinion does not purport to create judicial precedent beyond the application of the governing notifications and the specific factual determinations in this case.

End of summary.

    National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd. v. Madhya Pradesh State Electricity Board

    These petitions have been filed by the petitioner, NTPC, a generating company owned by the Central Government for approval of tariff in respect of Vindhyachal Super Thermal Power Station Stage-II (2 × 500 MW), (hereinafter referred to as “Vindhyachal STPS II”) for the period from 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2004

    2. The techno-economic clearance for Vindhyachal STPS II was accorded by CEA in terms of its letter dated 9.5.1989 at a cost of Rs. 1261.25 crore. Subsequently, the Central Government in Ministry of Power, vide its letter dated 16.2.1995 accorded investment approval for Rs. 2753.38 crore, including IDC of Rs. 589.40 crore and WCM of Rs. 56.29 crore, based on 3rd Quarter of 1994 prices. CEA revised its sanction to Rs. 2837.00 crore, vide its letter dated 16.4.1999 considering the prices of 4th Quarter of 1996. Ministry of Power vide its letter dated 30.10.2001 issued the revised cost estimates for the generating station based on 2nd Quarter 2001 prices, for Rs. 2702.00 crore, including IDC of Rs. 254.57 crore, Working Capital Margin of Rs. 57.70 crore and FERV of Rs. 108.95 crore.

    3. Vindhyachal STPS II comprises of two units with capacity of 500 MW each, the date of commercial operation of these units being 1.7.2000 and 1.10.2000 Petition No. 20/1999 has been filed for approval of tariff from 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2001 based on Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 and in Petition No. 77/2002 approval of tariff for the period 01.04.2001 to 31.03.2004 is sought based on the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 The periods for which approval of tariff for different units has been sought are thus as under:

    Unit Basis Period Unit I Ministry of Power Notification dated 30.3.1992 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 Units I and II Ministry of Power Notification dated 30.3.1992 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 Units I and II Commission's Notification dated 26.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004

    4. The details of the fixed charges claimed by the petitioner are given hereunder:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    Ser No. Particulars As per the Petition 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1 Interest on Loan 6694 12125 14334 14070 12632 2 Interest on Working Capital 1795 3415 3322 3489 3647 3 Depreciation 9532 17685 9599 9599 9599 4 Advance Against Depreciation 0 0 5826 5826 5826 5 Return on Equity 6711 12202 12693 12693 12693 6 O & M Expenses 4539 8292 7007 7428 7874 7 Water Charges 0 0 1896 1896 1896 TOTAL 29272 53720 54677 55001 54167

    5. The details of Working Capital furnished by the petitioner and its claim for interest thereon are summarised hereunder:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    Ser No. Particulars As per the Petition 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 Interest on Working Capital Fuel Cost 1628 3264 3899 4178 4479 Coal Stock 745 1493 1810 1927 2051 Oil stock 276 555 557 648 753 O & M expenses 378 691 584 619 656 Spares 1816 3317 2803 2971 3149 Receivables-2 months 8834 16754 18085 18697 19161 Total Working Capital 13676 26074 27737 29039 30250 Working capital Margin(WCM) 2815 5630 5770 5770 5770 Total Working Capital allowed 10861 20444 21967 23269 24480 Weighted Average Interest Rate 14.02% 14.02% 12.35% 12.35% 12.35% Interest on Working Capital 1493 2811 2712 2873 3022 Interest on WCM 167 334 332 339 348 Return on WCM 135 270 277 277 277 Total Interest on working capital 1795 3415 3322 3489 3647

    6. In addition, the petitioner has claimed Energy Charges @ 62.83 paise/kWh in petition No. 20/1999 and @ 70.07 paise/kWh for the period from 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 in petition No. 77/2002.

    DATE OF COMMERCIAL OPERATION

    7. In so far as the dates of commercial operation of respective units are concerned, we find that the techno-economic clearance of the Central Electricity Authority dated 26.5.1989 is silent on the subject. The Commission, therefore, has relied on investment approval of Government of India dated 16.2.1995 The scheduled commercial operation dates (CODs) as per this investment approval of Government of India dated 16.2.1995 and actual CODs of Unit-I and Unit-II of stage-II are as follows:

    Scheduled COD Actual COD Unit-I 8/2000 1.7.2000 Unit-II 8/2001 1.10.2000

    From the above, it can be seen that both the units of Stage-II have been commissioned ahead of schedule. The Commission, therefore, accepts these actual dates of commercial operation for the purpose of tariff.

    CAPITAL COST

    8. As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.92 and the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, the actual capital expenditure incurred on completion of the generating station shall be the criterion for fixation of tariff. It is further provided that where actual expenditure exceeds the approved project cost, the excess expenditure as approved by CEA or an appropriate independent agency shall be deemed to be actual capital expenditure for the purpose of determining the tariff. Ministry of Power notification further provides that in case of a multi unit project, the percentage of capital cost as specified by CEA in its techno-economic clearance shall be considered for fixation of tariff, on commercial operation of the progressive units but in case of delay in commissioning of second or subsequent units from the scheduled date, the project cost, for the period of delay, shall be retrospectively approved for the tariff purpose in the ratio of proportionate allocation of units. The provisions contained in the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 in regard to multi unit generating station are that in respect of such stations, for the purpose of tariff the capital cost of the project shall be broken up into stages and by distinct units forming part of the project. The common facilities shall be apportioned on the basis of the installed capacity of the units where break up of the project cost is not available and in case of on-going projects.

    9. The petitioner was not following the practice of drawing the account and getting them audited on the dates of commercial operation of each of the units. Accordingly these are not available on the respective dates of commercial operation of the units. The petitioner has, however, submitted the following details of capital cost, though these are not certified by the statutory auditors:

    Ser No. Description Amount (Rs. in lakh) 1. Gross Capital expenditure as on 31.3.2001 239211.00 2. Capital works in progress 701.00 3. Construction spares and advances 1916.00 4. Capital commitments (Committed liabilities) 1734.00 SUB - TOTAL 243562.00 5. Additional capitalisation from 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 (within the scope of approved project) 1004.00 6. TOTAL 244566.00

    10. The petitioner in its written submission dated 28.8.2002 stated that the capital cost as on the date of commercial operation of Unit-I (1.7.2000) can be derived by considering 55% of the capital cost as on the date of commercial operation of the station, as according to the petitioner, at the time of commissioning of the first unit all common auxiliary systems are completed and their cost gets capitalised along with capitalisation of Unit-I. Accordingly, 55% of the capital cost as on the date of commercial operation of the station, that is, 1.10.2000 has been allocated to Unit-I and the balance 45% of project cost has been considered as the cost of Unit-II, since the Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 envisages allocation of capital cost in proportion to capacity, only if there is delay in the inter-unit commissioning. Accordingly, the capital cost of units-I and Units-I & II to be considered for tariff works out as detailed below:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    The capital cost of Unit-I as on the date of commercial operation, that is, 1.7.2000 131014.00 The capital cost of Unit-I & II as on the date of commercial operation, that is, 1.10.2000 238207.00 Additional Capital Expenditure during the period 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1004.00 Capital cost as on 1.4.2001, that is, the start of new tariff period 239211.00

    11. The expenditure being considered is less than the revised cost estimates approved by the Central Government in Ministry of Power vide its letter dated 30.10.2001 We, therefore, allow tariff based on the capital expenditure on the respective date as arrived at above

    12. The amount of spares capitalized should be taken as Rs. 1984 lakh as indicated by the petitioner, based on books of accounts for 2000–2001.

    DEBT-EQUITY RATIO

    13. As per Ministry of Power Notification dated 30.3.92 and the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, the interest on loan capital and return on equity are to be computed, as per the financial package approved by CEA or an appropriate independent agency, as the case may be. The petitioner has claimed tariff by considering debt and equity in the ratio of 70:30. It has been submitted by the respondents that debt and equity should be in the ratio of 80:20 as applicable to IPPs.

    14. The approved financial package for the generating station is not available on record. Based on the actual allocated gross block of the project as on 31.3.2001 and loans drawn up to 31.3.2001, the debt-equity ratio works out to be approximately 67:33. However, debt and equity in the ratio of 70:30 is stated to have been considered by the petitioner in the revised cost estimates. The petitioner has adopted the same ratio in its tariff calculations. Therefore, debt-equity ratio of 70:30 has been considered for calculation of the fixed charges.

    TARGET AVAILABILITY/PLF

    15. The petitioner has considered PLF of 68.49% for the generating station for the period 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2001 on the basis of Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 This has been allowed. For the period 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 the petitioner has considered Target Availability of 80% which is in line with Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, for recovery of full fixed charges and computation of fuel element in the working capital for the period from 1.4.2001 onwards.

    RETURN ON EQUITY

    16. As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.92 and the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, return on equity shall be computed on the paid up and subscribed capital and shall be 16% of such capital. The petitioner has claimed return on equity @ 16%. The respondents have, however, submitted that return on equity should be payable at 12%. In case of generating stations, return on equity was charged in tariff @ 12% per annum till 31.10.1998 However, it was increased to 16% with effect from 1.11.1998 The respondent has contended that there was no justification to increase return on equity from 12% to 16%. As the things stand, the terms and conditions prescribed by the Central Government as also the Commission legislate that return on equity should be allowed @ 16%. Accordingly, we do not find any justification in support of the issue raised. In our computation of tariff, return on equity @ 16% per annum has been allowed. The charges payable by the respondents on account of return on equity as under:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 Opening Balance 39304 71462 71763 71763 71763 Increase/Decrease due to FERV 0 0 0 0 0 Increase/Decrease due to additional capitalisation 0 301 0 0 0 Closing Balance 39304 71763 71763 71763 71763 Average Equity 39304 71613 71763 71763 71763 Rate of Return on Equity 16.00% 16.00% 16.00% 16.00% 16.00% Return on Equity 6289 11458 11482 11482 11482

    INTEREST ON LOAN

    17. As per Ministry of Power Notification dated 30.3.92 and the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, the interest on loan capital shall be computed on the outstanding loans, duly taking into account the schedule of repayment, as per the financial package approved by CEA or an appropriate independent agency, as the case may be. The normative loan amount has been worked out by considering debt-equity in the ratio of 70:30 as already decided. In accordance with earlier decisions of the Commission, the annual repayment amount for calculation of interest on loan as worked out by the following formula, or as claimed in the petition, whichever is higher, has been considered:

    Annual actual repayment during the year × normative loan at the beginning of the year/Actual loan at the beginning of the year.

    18. The other salient features in regard to calculation of interest on loan are stated herein after:

    (a) Loan amount has been worked out from the normative debt-equity ratio.

    (b) The loan drawls up to 31.3.2001 only have been considered.

    (c) Some of the loans carry floating rate of interest. Therefore, interest rate prevailing as on 1.4.2001 has been considered for interest computation for the period 1.4.2001 onwards. However, interest on loan would be subject to adjustment on the basis of actual rate of interest applicable for the period 1.4.2001 onwards. In case the parties are unable to agree to adjustment of rate of interest, any one of them is at liberty to approach the Commission for appropriate decision.

    (d) The commitment fee @ 0.75% per annum as indicated by the petitioner in Form-8 of the petition has not been allowed in case of IBRD loans as commitment fee is generally applicable on un-disbursed portion of loans and would have been capitalised.

    (e) The Government Guarantee fees @ 1% per annum as indicated in Form-8 of the petition in case of IBRD loan has been allowed.

    (f) On the basis of actual rate of interest on actual average loan, the weighted rate of interest on loan has been worked out and the same has been applied on the normative average loan during the year to arrive at the interest on loan. The necessary calculations in support of weighted average rate of interest are appended below:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 Days in the Year 365 365 365 365 366 Period (days) 92 182 365 365 366 1 HDFC-II Gross Loan-Opening 8000 8000 8000 8000 8000 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Opening 8000 8000 8000 8000 8000 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment 0 0 0 0 1143 Net Loan-Closing 8000 8000 8000 8000 6857 Average loan 8000 8000 8000 8000 7429 Rate of Interest 11.82% 12.05% 12.05% 12.05% 12.05% Interest 945 964 964 964 895 2 SBT Gross Loan-Opening 0 1000 1000 1000 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Opening 0 1000 1000 1000 Addition 1000 0 0 0 Repayment 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Closing 1000 1000 1000 1000 Average loan 500 1000 1000 1000 Rate of Interest 12.55% 12.55% 12.55% 12.55% Interest 63 125 125 125 3 SBH Gross Loan-Opening 0 1000 1000 1000 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Opening 0 1000 1000 1000 Addition 1000 0 0 0 Repayment 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Closing 1000 1000 1000 1000 Average loan 500 1000 1000 1000 Rate of Interest 12.55% 12.55% 12.55% 12.55% Interest 63 125 125 125 4 SBI-I Gross Loan-Opening 12100 12100 21100 21100 21100 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Opening 12100 12100 21100 21100 21100 Addition 0 9000 0 0 0 Repayment 0 0 0 0 3014 Net Loan-Closing 12100 21100 21100 21100 18086 Average loan 12100 16600 21100 21100 19593 Rate of Interest 11.82% 12.05% 12.05% 12.05% 12.05% Interest 1430 2000 2542 2542 2360 5 SBI NY-I (in INR) Gross Loan-Opening 19406 19993 20224 20224 20224 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 0 Net Loan-Opening 19406 19993 20224 20224 20224 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment 0 0 0 0 20224 Net Loan-Closing 19993 20224 20224 20224 0 Average loan 19700 20109 20224 20224 10112 Rate of Interest 7.58% 7.58% 7.58% 7.58% 7.58% Interest 1492 1523 1532 1532 766 ERV 587 231 0 0 0 6-A IBRD-O (USD-EQ)-INR Gross Loan-Opening 88235 90697 85512 85512 85512 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 6805 6805 8728 13044 17686 Net Loan-Opening 81430 83892 76784 72468 67826 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment-15th June 0 0 2118 2279 2451 Repayment-15th Dec 1923 2198 2363 2542 Net Loan-Closing 83892 76784 72468 67826 62833 Average loan 82661 80338 74626 70147 65329 Rate of Interest 6.21% 6.15% 6.11% 6.11% 6.11% Interest 5133 4942 4560 4286 3992 ERV 2462 -5185 0 0 0 6-B IBRD-A (USD)-INR Gross Loan-Opening 12287 12659 12804 12804 12804 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 2134 Net Loan-Opening 12287 12659 12804 12804 10670 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment-15th June 0 0 0 1067 1067 Repayment-15th Dec 1067 1067 Net Loan-Closing 12659 12804 12804 10670 8536 Average loan 12473 12731 12804 11737 9603 Rate of Interest 6.64% 6.64% 6.64% 6.64% 6.64% Interest 828 845 850 779 638 ERV 371 145 0 0 0 6-C IBRD-B (Tr. A) (EURO)-INR Gross Loan-Opening 10927 10419 10518 10518 10518 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 1753 Net Loan-Opening 10927 10419 10518 10518 8765 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment-15th June 0 0 0 877 877 Repayment-15th Dec 877 877 Net Loan-Closing 10419 10518 10518 8765 7012 Average loan 10673 10468 10518 9641 7888 Rate of Interest 5.18% 5.18% 5.18% 5.18% 5.18% Interest 553 542 545 499 409 ERV -508 99 0 0 0 6-D IBRD-B (Tr. B) (EURO) Gross Loan-Opening 580 553 558 558 558 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 0 0 0 0 47 Net Loan-Opening 580 553 558 558 511 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment-15th June 0 0 0 0 47 Repayment-15th Dec 0 47 47 Net Loan-Closing 553 558 558 511 418 Average loan 566 555 558 535 465 Rate of Interest 5.59% 5.59% 5.59% 5.59% 5.59% Interest 32 31 31 30 26 ERV -27 5 0 0 0 6 IBRD-Total INR Gross Loan-Opening 112029 114327 109392 109392 109392 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 6805 6805 8728 13044 21620 Net Loan-Opening 105225 107522 100664 96348 87772 Addition 0 0 0 0 0 Repayment-15th June 0 0 2118 4223 4441 Repayment-15th Dec 0 1923 2198 4353 4532 Total repayment 0 1923 4316 8575 8974 Net Loan-Closing 107522 100664 96348 87772 78799 Average loan 106373 104093 98506 92060 83286 Rate of Interest 6.15% 6.11% 6.08% 6.08% 6.08% Interest 6546 6360 5986 5595 5064 ERV 2298 -4935 0 0 0 TOTAL LOAN Gross Loan-Opening 151535 154420 160716 160716 160716 Cumulative Repayment up to previous year 6805 6805 8728 13044 21620 Net Loan-Opening 144731 147615 151988 147672 139097 Addition 0 11000 0 0 0 Repayment 0 1923 4316 8575 33355 Net Loan-Closing 147615 151988 147672 139097 105742 Average loan 146173 149802 149830 143384 122419 Rate of Interest 7.12% 7.33% 7.53% 7.59% 7.63% Interest 10414 10973 11275 10884 9336 ERV 2885 -4704 0 0 0

    19. The computations in support of interest on notional loan are appended hereinbelow:

    COMPUTATION OF INTEREST ON NOTIONAL LOAN

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 Gross Loan-Opening 91710 166745 167447 167447 167447 Cumulative Repayment up to the Previous Year 6805 7348 9425 13912 22828 Net Loan-Opening 84905 159397 158023 153535 144619 Increase/Decrease due to FERV 0 0 0 0 0 Increase/Decrease due to additional capitalisation 0 703 0 0 0 Total 84905 160099 158023 153535 144619 Repayments of loan during the year 0 2077 4487 8916 34679 Net Loan-Closing 84905 158023 153535 144619 109940 Average Net Loan 84905 158710 155779 149077 127280 Rate of Interest 7.12% 7.33% 7.53% 7.59% 7.63% Interest 6049 11626 11723 11316 9707

    DEPRECIATION

    20. As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992, depreciation for computation of annual fixed charges is to be considered in accordance with the rates notified by the Central Government from time to time under Section 43-A(2) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948. These rates were notified by the Central Government vide notification dated 29.3.1994 The Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, prescribes that the value base for the purpose of depreciation shall be historical cost of the asset and the depreciation shall be calculated annually as per straight line method at the rates of depreciation prescribed in the Schedule thereto.

    21. Depreciation for the tariff period has been calculated by taking the individual assets and their depreciation rates as per Ministry of Power's notification dated 30.3.92 read with notification dated 29.3.1994 and the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001 For the period 1.4.2001 onwards. Since both the units have been put on commercial operation in the year 2000–2001, no depreciation has been provided for the year 2000–2001, because the depreciation for the period prior to 1.4.2001 is worked out on the opening gross block during the year. For the period 1.4.2001 onwards, since the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 stipulates that the depreciation shall be chargeable from the first year of operation on pro-rata basis, the depreciation has been worked out on the average of opening and closing block during the year. The necessary calculations in support of depreciation are appended below:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 Rate of Depreciation 3.63% 3.63% 3.63% Depreciation recovered in tariff 0 0 8688 8688 8688 Advance Against Depreciation (AAD) recovered in tariff 0 228 5266 Depreciation 0 0 8688 8916 13954

    ADVANCE AGAINST DEPRECIATION

    22. As per the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, Advance Against Depreciation shall be permitted wherever originally scheduled loan repayment exceeds the depreciation allowable and shall be computed as follows:

    AAD = Originally scheduled loan repayment amount subject to a ceiling of 1/12th of original loan amount minus depreciation as per schedule.

    23. The provision of Advance Against Depreciation was not applicable prior to 1.4.2001 The actual gross loan and actual repayment as on 1.4.2001 has been considered for computing Advance Against Depreciation. The petitioner is entitled to claim any Advance Against Depreciation as shown below:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 1/12th of Loan(s) 13954 13954 13954 13954 13954 Scheduled Repayment of the Loan(s) 4487 8916 34679 4487 8916 Minimum of the above 4487 8916 13954 4487 8916 Depreciation during the year 8688 8688 8688 8688 8688 Advance Against Depreciation 0 228 5266 0 228

    O&M EXPENSES

    24. As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992, operation and maintenance expenses including insurance for the first full year, after commissioning of the generating station shall be calculated as a percentage on the actual capital expenditure on the basis of one of the following alternatives, namely:

    (i) At the rate of 2.5 per cent of the actual capital expenditure of ceiling on capital provided in the power purchase agreement; or

    (ii) At 2 per cent of the actual capital expenditure on ceiling on capital expenditure provided in the power purchase agreement together with actual expenditure on insurance.

    Provided that total of 2 per cent of the actual capital expenditure on ceiling on capital expenditure provided in the power purchase agreement and the actual expenditure on insurance shall not exceed 3 percent on the capital expenditure.

    25. The Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001 lays down that the base O&M expenses for the new generating stations shall be fixed at 2.5% of the actual capital cost as approved by CEA or an appropriate Independent agency, as the case may be, in the year of commissioning and shall be escalated @10% p.a for subsequent years to arrive at O&M expenses for the base year 1999–2000 level. Thereafter, the base O & M expenses shall be further escalated at the rate of 6% p.a to arrive at permissible O & M expenses for the relevant year.

    26. In the present case, the base year is 2000–2001, which is also the year of commissioning of the generating station. In accordance with the above methodologies, the petitioner shall be entitled to O&M expenses in tariff as computed hereinbelow:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 %age of Capital Cost 2.50% Escalation Factor after 1 year 6.00% Unit - I 3275 3275 3423 3628 3846 Unit - II 2680 2760 2926 3101 Additional Capitalisation-year I 13 25 27 29 O & M Expenses 3275 5968 6208 6581 6976

    27. The petitioner has claimed water charges separately. As the O&M charges have been allowed on normative basis, the water charges as claimed by the petitioner have not been approved.

    INTEREST ON WORKING CAPITAL

    28. Working capital has been calculated considering the following elements:

    (a) Fuel Cost: As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.92 and the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, fuel cost for one month corresponding to normative Plant Load Factor/Target Availability is permissible. Accordingly, the fuel cost is worked out for one month on the basis of operational parameters as given in Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 and the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001

    (b) Coal Stock and Oil stock: As consolidated audited accounts are available for Vindhyachal stage-I & II, coal and oil stock figures for stage-II for the period prior to 1.4.2001 have been worked out after excluding the provision of coal/oil stock made in tariff for stage-I and for the period 1.4.2001 onwards, coal and oil stock figure for stage-II has been worked out based on corresponding capacity.

    (c) O&M Expenses: As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 and as per the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, operation and maintenance expenses (cash) for one month are permissible as a part of the working capital. Accordingly, O&M expenses for working capital has been worked out for 1 month of O&M expenses considered in tariff of the respective year.

    (d) Spares: As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.92 and as per the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, maintenance spares at actuals subject to a maximum of 1% of the capital cost but not exceeding 1 year's requirements less value of 1/5th of initial spares already capitalised for first 5 years are required to be considered in the working capital. Accordingly, the spares requirement for the purpose of working capital has been worked out @ 1% of the capital cost less value of 1/5th of initial spares already capitalised. The amount of initial spares stated to be capitalized by the petitioner is Rs. 1984 lakh. The calculations in support of spares are as under:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 Capitalised Initial Spares 1984 1% of the Capital Cost 330 1188 2392 2392 2392 Less: 1/5th of Capitalised Initial Spares 100 198 397 397 397 230 990 1995 1995 1995

    (e) Receivables: As per Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.92 and as per the Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001, receivables will be equivalent to two months average billing for sale of electricity calculated on normative plant load factor/Target Availability. However, receivable has been worked out on the basis of two months of fixed and variable charges. The supporting calculations in respect of variable charges as a part of receivables are tabulated hereunder:

    Computation of variable charge component of working capital

    For the period 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2001 For the period 1.10.2000 to 31.12.2001 For the period 1.1.2001 to 31.3.2001 For the period 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 Annual Generation corresponding to Normative PLF MU 2249.90 4499.79 5249.76 7008.00 Value of 15 days Coal Stock Rs. in Lakh 485.85 971.70 1114.75 1725.43 Value of 60 days Oil Stock Rs. in Lakh 200.94 401.89 398.54 489.86 Fuel Cost-1 Month Rs. in Lakh 1087.06 2174.12 2462.49 3747.12 Energy Charges for Two month Rs. in Lakh 2174.12 4348.24 4924.98 7494.25

    29. The other relevant details in support of computation of fuel cost, oil/coal stock and receivables are appended herein below:

    1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 27.12.2000 28.12.2000 to 29.3.2001 1.10.2000 to 29.3.2001 30.3.2001 to 31.3.2001 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 Stablisation period Stablisation period After Stablisation period Stablisation period After Stablisation period Unit-I Unit-I Unit-II Combined Days 92 88 92 180 2 182 365 365 366 Days in the Full Year 365 365 365 365 365 365 365 365 366 Hours in a Day 24 24 24 24 24 24 24 24 Annual Hours of Operation 8760 8760 8760 8760 8760 8760 8760 8784 Hours of Operation for the period 2208 2112 2208 4320 48 8760 8760 8784 Plant Load Factor (hours/kW/year) 4500 4500 6000 4500 6000 7008 7008 7027 Normative PLF/Target Availability (%) 51.37% 51.37% 68.49% 51.37% 68.49% 80.00% 80.00% 80.00% Capacity (MW) 500 500 500 500 1000 1000 1000 1000 Energy Generated for the period (MU) 567 542 756 1110 33 7008 7008 7027 Aux. Power Consumption (With cooling tower and steam driven pumps) 8.50% 8.50% 8.00% 8.50% 8.00% 8.00% 8.00% 8.00% Aux. Power Consumption for the period (MU) 48 46 60 94 3 561 561 562 Energy Sent Out for the period (MU) 519 496 696 1015 30 6447 6447 6465 Gross Station Heat Rate (Kcal/kWh) 2600 2600 2500 2600 2500 2500 2500 2500 Specific Oil Consumption (ml/kWh) 5.00 5.00 3.50 5.00 3.50 3.50 3.50 3.50 Oil Stock Weighted Avg. GCV of Oil (Kcal/Lit.) 9977.00 9977.00 9977.00 9977.00 9977.00 9986.37 9986.37 9986.37 Heat Contribution by Oil (Kcal/kWh) 49.89 49.89 34.92 49.89 34.92 34.95 34.95 34.95 Requirement of Oil for the period (ltrs) 2835616 2712329 2646575 5547945 115068 11021918 24528000 24528000 24595200 Oil Stock(60 days) (KL) 1849.32 3633.60 4032.00 4032.00 4032.00 Weighted Avg. Price of Oil (Rs./KL) 10866.35 10866.35 10866.35 10866.35 10866.35 10866.35 12149.36 12149.36 12149.36 Oil Stock- 60 days - (Rs. in Lakh) 201 395 490 490 490 Coal Stock Weighted Avg. GCV of Coal (Kcal/kg) 4039.00 4039.00 4039.00 4039.00 4039.00 3910.64 3910.64 3910.64 Heat Contribution by Coal (Kcal/kWh) 2550.12 2550.12 2465.08 2550.12 2465.08 2465.05 2465.05 2465.05 Specific Coal Consumption (kg/kWh) 0.6314 0.6314 0.6103 0.6314 0.6103 0.6303 0.6303 0.6303 Requirement of Coal for the period (mt) 358066 342498 461502 700564 20065 1524630 4417449 4417449 4429552 Coal Stock (15 days) (mt) 58380 125656 181539 181539 181539 Weighted Avg. Price of Coal (Rs./mt) 832.25 832.25 832.25 832.25 832.25 832.25 950.45 950.45 950.45 Coal Stock-15 days - (Rs. in Lakh) 486 1046 1725 1725 1725 Fuel Cost Oil Stock - 1 Month (KL) 938 1842 2044 2044 2050 Oil Stock - 1 Month (Rs. in Lakh) 102 200 248 248 249 Coal Stock - 1 month (mt) 118382 254803 368121 368121 369129 Coal Stock - 1 month (Rs. in Lakh) 985 2121 3499 3499 3508 Fuel Cost - 1 month (Rs. Lakh) 1087 2321 3747 3747 3757 Receivables Variable Charges Coal (Rs/kWh) 0.5743 0.5743 0.5521 0.5743 0.5521 0.6512 0.6512 0.6512 Oil (Rs/kWh) 0.0594 0.0594 0.0413 0.0594 0.0413 0.0462 0.0462 0.0462 Rs./kWh 0.6337 0.6337 0.5934 0.6337 0.5934 0.6974 0.6974 0.6974 Variable Charges for the period 3288 3145 4128 6433 179 13885 44966 44966 45089 Variable Charges - 2 months 2174 4641 7494 7494 7515 Fixed Charges - 2 months 2753 5149 6771 6804 7455 Receivables 4927 9790 14265 14298 14970

    30. The Commission's notification dated 26.03.2001 is silent about the financing of the working capital margin. Therefore the return and interest is not separately calculated on working capital margin and interest on the total working capital is worked out.

    31. The annual average SBI PLR of 11.50% has been considered as the rate of interest on working capital during 2002–2001 and the tariff period 2001–2002 to 2003–2004, in line with the Commission's earlier decision.

    32. The necessary details in support of calculation of Interest on Working Capital are appended below:

    (Rs. in lakh)

    2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 Days in the Year 365 365 365 365 366 Period (days) 92 182 365 365 366 Fuel Cost 1087 2321 3747 3747 3757 Coal Stock 486 1046 1097 1097 1097 Oil Stock 201 395 315 315 315 O & M Expenses 273 497 517 548 581 Spares 913 1985 1995 1995 1995 Receivables 4927 9790 14265 14298 14970 Total Working Capital 7887 16035 21937 22002 22716 Rate of Interest 11.50% 11.50% 11.50% 11.50% 11.50% Interest on Working Capital 907 1844 2523 2530 2612

    ANNUAL FIXED CHARGES

    33. The annual fixed charges for the period 1.4.1999 to 31.3.2004 allowed in this order are summed up as below:

    (Rs. in Lakh)

    Particulars 2000–2001 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2002 1.4.2002 to 31.3.2003 1.4.2003 to 31.3.2004 1 Interest on Loan 6049 11626 11723 11316 9707 2 Interest on Working Capital 907 1844 2523 2530 2612 3 Depreciation 0 0 8688 8688 8688 4 Advance Against Depreciation 0 0 0 228 5266 5 Return on Equity 6289 11458 11482 11482 11482 6 O & M Expenses 3275 5968 6208 6581 6976 TOTAL 16520 30895 40624 40825 44731

    VARIABLE CHARGES

    34. In terms of Ministry of Power Notification dated 30.3.1992 and the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 following operational norms have been considered for the computation of energy charges:

    Period 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2000 1.10.2000 to 31.12.2000 1.1.2001 to 31.3.2001 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 Station Heat Rate (kCal/k Wh) Unit-I 2600 2600 2500 2500 Unit-II - 2600 2600 2500 Average 2600 2600 2550 2500 Aux Energy Consumption (%) Unit-I 8.50 8.50 8.00 8.00 Unit-II - 8.50 8.50 8.00 Average 8.50 8.50 8.25 8.00 Sec. fuel oil consumption Unit-I 5.00 5.00 3.50 3.50 Unit-II - 5.00 5.00 3.50 Average 5.00 5.00 4.25 3.50

    35. Energy charges computed by the petitioner for period 1.7.2000 to 31.3.2001 are based on average operational norms arrived at for 5.5/5.75 years tariff period. Escalation on fuel prices have been considered for computing working capital requirements. Since there is no specific provision of this either in Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 or the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, the same has not been considered in our computations.

    36. The above values of station heat rate correspond to gross calorific value of fuel.

    37. Neither Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 nor the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 provide for limiting the actual stock as per audited balance-sheet. Therefore, the coal stock has been adopted based on stock for 15 days at normative PLF level.

    38. The Energy Charges have been computed based on the data furnished in the petitions and are summarised below:

    Computation of Energy Charge as on 1.7.2000 & 1.4.2001

    For the period 1.7.2000 to 30.9.2001 For the period 1.10.2000 to 31.12.2001 For the period 1.1.2001 to 31.3.2001 For the period 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 Description Unit As on 1.7.2000 As on 1.4.2001 Capacity MW 500.00 1000.00 1000.00 1000.00 Normative PLF/Availability % 51.37 51.37 59.93 80.00 Gross Station Heat Rate KCal/kW h 2600.00 2600.00 2550.00 2500.00 Specific Fuel Oil Consumption ml/kWh 5.00 5.00 4.25 3.50 Aux. Energy Consumption % 8.50 8.50 8.25 8.00 Weighted Average GCV of Oil KCal/l 9977.00 9977.00 9977.00 9986.37 Weighted Average GCV of Coal KCal/Kg 4039.00 4039.00 4039.00 3910.64 Weighted Average Price of Oil Rs./KL 10866.35 10866.35 10866.35 12149.36 Weighted Average Price of Coal Rs./MT 832.25 832.25 832.25 950.45 Rate of Energy Charge ex-bus per kWh Sent Paise/kW h 63.37 63.37 61.35 69.74

    39. The base energy charges have been calculated on base value of GCV, base price of fuel and normative operating parameters as indicated in the above table and are subject to fuel price adjustment. Ministry of Power notification dated 30.3.1992 as amended from time to time, and the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 provide for fuel price adjustment for variation in fuel price and GCV of fuels. It is further provided that for the purpose of calculating the tariff, the operating parameters, that is, ‘Station Heat Rate’, Secondary Fuel Oil Consumption’ and ‘Auxiliary Consumption’ shall be determined on the basis of actuals or norms, whichever is lower. Accordingly, the base energy charges approved on the basis of norms shall be subject to following adjustments:—

    (i) Fuel price and GCV variation (Coal and Secondary Fuel oil) based on monthly weighted average as per the formula given below:—

    FPA = A + B

    Where,

    FPA - Fuel price Adjustment for a month in Paise/kWh Sent out A - Fuel price adjustment for Secondary Fuel oil in Paise/kWh sent out B - Fuel price adjustment for Coal in Paise/kWh sent out

    Where,

    SFCn - Normative Specific Fuel Oil consumption in ml/kWh SHRn - Normative Gross Station Heat Rate in kCal/kWh ACn - Normative Auxiliary Consumption in percentage Pom - Weighted Average price of fuel oil as per PSL for the month in Rs./KL. Kom - Weighted average GCV of fuel oils fired at boiler front for the month in Kcal/Litre Pos - Base value of price of fuel oils as taken for determination of base energy charge in tariff order in Rs./KL. Kos - Base value of gross calorific value of fuel oils as taken for determination of base energy charge in tariff order in Kcal/Litre Pcm - Weighted average price of coal as per PSL for the month at the power station in Rs./MT. Kcm - Weighted average gross calorific value of coal fired at boiler front for the month in Kcal/Kg Pcs - Base value of price of coal as taken for determination of base energy charge in tariff order in Rs./MT Kcs - Base value of gross calorific value of coal as taken determination of base energy charge in tariff order in kCal/Kg

    40. The energy charges shall be finally adjusted on annual basis as per actual annual average values of operating parameters achieved for the station i.e station heat rate, auxiliary energy consumption and specific fuel oil consumption provided any or all of the actual operating parameters are lower than their respective normative values indicated in the table. The annual energy charge adjustment shall be done as per the formula given below:—

    AECA = (P − Q − R) × 10-9

    Where,

    AECA - Annual Energy Charge Adjustment in Rs. Crore P - Energy charge payable for the year based on operational parameters (Actual or normative whichever is lower) and weighted average price and GCV of fuels for the year in paise Q - Total amount recovered as monthly fuel price adjustment for the year in Paise R - Total amount recovered as base energy charge for the year in Paise

    Where,

    ESO Annual - Energy sent out in the year in kwh sent out based on actual drawls for the tariff period up to 31.3.2001 and based on generation schedules given by RLDC for the tariff period 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 SFCA - Actual average secondary fuel oil consumption of the station for the year in ml/kWh sent out Ko - Weighted average GCV of secondary fuel oil for the year in kCal/Litre Po - Weighted average price of secondary fuel oil for the year in Rs./KL SHRA - Actual yearly weighted average gross station heat rate in kCal/kWh generated Pc - Weighted average price of coal for the year in Rs./MT Kc - Weighted average GCV of coal for the year in kCal/kg FPAmi - Fuel price adjustment for the ith month in paisa/kWh sent out ESOmi - Energy sent out for the ith month in kWh sent out based on actual drawls for the tariff period up to 31.3.2001 and based on generation schedules given by RLDC for the tariff period 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 BEC - Base Energy Charge as per tariff order in Paise/kWh sent out ACA - Actual average Auxiliary Consumption of the station for the year in percentage

    41. In case the adjustment period is less than a year, adjustment shall be done for the actual period.

    42. The fixed and variable charges have been decided by us in the preceding paras for Vindhyachal STPS II. The petitioner has already recovered fixed and variable charges from the respondents based on the interim orders of the Commission. The amount already recovered shall be adjusted against the revised charges decided by us through this order.

    43. In addition to these charges, the petitioner is entitled to recover other charges also like Foreign Exchange Rate Variation, incentive, claim for reimbursement of Income-tax, other taxes, cess levied by a statutory authority, Development Surcharge and other charges in accordance with the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, as applicable. This is subject to the orders, if any, of the superior courts. The petitioner shall also be entitled to recover from the respondents filing fee of Rs. 10 lakh paid in petition No. 77/2002, in ten equal monthly instalments of Rs. one lakh each and shall be shared by the respondents in proportion of fixed charges approved for the period from 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 This is subject to the confirmation that the amount has not been included in O&M expenses.

    44. This order disposes of Petitions No. 20/1999 and 77/2002.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd. v. Madhya Pradesh State Electricity Board
    (Aug 1, 2003)