Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rules A-80, A-81 and 102-C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rules A-80, A-81 and 102-C

    Mangal v. Prem Lal .

    S.P Pandey, Member:— This is a second appeal under Section 331(4) of the UPZA and LR Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act) preferred by the plaintiff, Mangal against the judgment and decree, dated 22.6.95/11.7.1995 passed by the learned Additional Commissioner, Jhansi Division, Jhansi in appeal No. 43/67 of 1993-94.Lalitpur, arising out of the judgment and decree dated 15.2.1994 passed by the learned trial court in suit No. 32 of 1992-93 under Section 229-B/209 of the Act.

    2. Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the instant second appeal are that Mangal plaintiff instituted a suit under Section 229-B/209 of the Act for declaration of his rights over the land in dispute as bhumidhar with transferable rights, as the father of the defendants 3 to 5, Durga had no concern with the land in dispute and the entry of Class-9 made in his favour is against Rules which should be expunged. Notices were issued to the defendants 1 to 5. Defendant 1 and 2 did not contest the case while the defendants 3 to 5 contested the suit by filing their written statement.

    3. The learned trial court after completing the requisite trial, decreed the suit of the plaintiff and ordered for expunction of the entry of Class-9 made in favour of Durga, the father of defendants 3 to 5 on 15.2.1994 Aggrieved by this order, an appeal was preferred. The learned Additional Commissioner by his order dated 22.6.1995 allowed the appeal. It is against this order and decree that this second appeal has been preferred by the plaintiff before the Board.

    4. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the record on file. For the appellant, it was contended that the order passed by the learned lower appellate court is illegal, perverse and without jurisdiction as the plaintiff is recorded as the original tenure-holder and bhumidhar with transferable rights over the land in dispute and the entry in Class-9 in favour of the respondents 1 to 3 have been illegally made; that the learned court below has erred in reversing the findings recorded by the learned trial court which have been arrived at after the appraisal of evidence on the record and keeping the provisions under Rules A-80, A-81 and 102-C of the Land Records Manual in view; that the order passed by the learned Additional Commissioner is no order in the eyes of law as he failed to meet the findings recorded by the learned trial court in favour of the plaintiff-appellant; that the learned trial court has rightly decreed the suit of the plaintiff as he had no knowledge of the entry of Class-9 made in favour of the defendants 3 to 5 and the onus of proving service of PA-10 on the plaintiff was on the defendant and as such the impugned order passed by the learned lower appellate court cannot be sustained in law. In support of his contentions, he has relied upon the case law reported in 1982 RD 1 (HC). In reply, the learned counsel for the respondent urged that since the learned trial court has decreed the suit on the basis of surmises and conjectures, the learned lower appellate court was perfectly justified in allowing the appeal; that the plaintiff had full knowledge of the proceedings and the learned trial court failed to decide this issue which was relevant for the correct decision of the case; that the learned lower appellate court has rightly dismissed the suit of the plaintiff as the failed to substantiate his claim by adducing cogent and convincing evidence and as such no interference is called for with the same in this second appeal.

    5. I have closely and carefully considered the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the parties and have also gone through the relevant records on file. A bare perusal of the record clearly reveals that on the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial court has framed seven issues including issue No. 1 to the effect whether the plaintiff is bhumidhar with transferable rights in possession of the land in dispute, and issue No. 2 to the effect whether the entry in Class-9 is irregular. After thoroughly, and analytically discussing these issues, the learned trial Court came to the conclusion that the procedure laid down for issuance of PA-10 and making the entry in class-9 have not been legally followed and the defendants could not adduce any document or evidence which may go to prove their cultivatory possession over the land in dispute in 1372F. Since the defendants failed to establish their possession year after year on the land in dispute, no rights could accrue to them under Section 210 of the Act. It also concluded that since the provisions of para A-80, A-81, A-82 and 102-C of the Land Records Manual were not followed, the entry of Class-9 made in favour of Durga, father of the defendants 3 to 5 is irregular and as such it decreed the suit of the plaintiff. On the contrary, the learned Additional Commissioner did not address himself towards the findings recorded by the learned trial court on the point of issuance of PA-10 and year to year possession of the defendants over the land in dispute. He simply allowed the appeal on the basis of the entry in Class-9 being 27 years old. The learned lower appellate court ought to have analysed, discussed and considered as to whether this entry in Class-9 is regular or not and made after following the procedure prescribed by law for the same. So far as the issuance of PA-10 is concerned, it admitted that there is a lot of irregularities in the issuance of PA-10 but it brushed aside these facts, simply saying that it is wrong to say after 27 years that service of PA-10 was not effected on the plaintiff or his ancestors and came to the conclusion that the decree passed by the learned trial court was not justified and is liable to be annulled and as such allowed the appeal. In respect of onus of proving service of PA-10 on the plaintiff, it did not say anything.

    6. After giving my due and careful throught to the matter in question, I come to the conclusion that the impugned order passed by the learned lower appellate court cannot be sustained in law as the findings recorded by the learned trial court were not reversed by it. The findings recorded by the learned trial court were arrived at after due appreciation of evidence on record and considering the facts and circumstances of the instant case. The learned Additional Commissioner did not address himself towards these findings recorded by the learned trial court, with which I entirely agree. The first appeal has been allowed by the learned court below in a very slip-shod manner and as such the order passed by the learned court below is liable to be set aside. It do not find any force in the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the respondent who has miserably failed to substantiate his claim.

    7. In consequence, this second appeal succeeds and is allowed accordingly, the order passed by the learned Additional Commissioner is set aside and that of the learned trial court is hereby maintained and confirmed. Let records be returned forthwith to the courts concerned.

    8. Appeal Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mangal v. Prem Lal .
    (Jul 13, 2001)