Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Capt. Vivek Ranjan v. Union Of India & Ors.

    1. The petitioner vide this petition has prayed that the order dated 21.12.2011 may be quashed whereby he was denied permanent commission/extension of service and respondents may be directed to consider the applicant for grant of permanent commission/extension based on the available inputs and ignoring any adverse input including non recommendation, if any, which has not been communicated to the applicant.

    2. The petitioner, after completing his B.Sc in Botany in 2004, applied for grant of Short Service Commission in response to the advertisement published by the Respondents in the Employment News and qualified for the same after successfully clearing written and Services Selection Board interview and he was inducted in the Army on 17.03.2009

    3. It has been stated that the petitioner, in May/June 2005 while climbing the vertical rope as part of the training, sustained ankle injury and he remained hospitalised from June 2005 to September 2005. He was placed in low medical category due to his medical problems and finally be passed out from the Academy on successful completion of training based on which he was granted Short Service Commission on 17.03.2007 in the Infantry in SIKH Regiment and was posted to 22 SIKH.

    4. The petitioner was detailed and subsequently proceeded to attend Young Officers Course from 24.09.2007 to 22.03.2008 at Infantry School, Mhow which he completed successfully. Since the petitioner did not complete 90 days physical service for the reporting year 2007 under any officer, he could not earn any CR for that period. During the month of June 2008, the petitioner submitted an application for leave as his marriage was fixed for 11.07.2008 seeking permission for marriage as per norms. However, he did not get any response from the CO and finally after intervention of the Second-in-Command, leave was sanctioned and the petitioner got married on 11.07.2008 On expiry of the leave, he joined back.

    5. In August 2008, while participating in battalion games, the applicant sustained knee injury and subsequently remained hospitalised from 27.08.2008 to 02.09.2008 After reporting back to the Unit, the petitioner again got admitted in the hospital for heel pain and was diagnosed with bone tumor in heel which developed due to sustained stamping of feet during training in the drill square. The petitioner remained hospitalised till 28.10.2008 The petitioner was advised to undergo surgery for such bone tumor and he was again admitted in the hospital from 10.11.2008 to 22.12.2008 for carrying out necessary tests for bone tumor and also got operated for Deviated Nasal Septum (DNS) during this period. Therefore, he was downgraded to low medical category S1H1A3P1E1 for SIMPLE BONE CYST CALCANEUM (LEFT) HEEL w.e.f 06.01.2009

    6. In the ACR for the period 01.01.2008 to 31.12.2008, he was granted ‘above average’ by the IO. He is not aware what the RO has written. He was again admitted to the hospital for surgery of SIMPLE BONE CYST CALCANEUM (LEFT) HEEL, bone tumor and was operated upon on 20.08.2009 During this period, the petitioner was also detected with Pituitary Micro Adenoma (Tumor on Pituitary Gland in Brain) and he remained hospitalised till 28.11.2009 He was advised specialised treatment at Army Hospital, Delhi Cantt. In the ACR for the period 01.01.2009 to 01.12.2009, the petitioner was again given ‘above average’. Thereafter, the petitioner was admitted in Army Hospital, Delhi Cantt. for surgery of Pituitary Micro Adenoma on 20.12.2010 and was operated upon on 21.12.2010 and remained hospitalised till 24.01.2011

    7. The CR for the period from 01.01.2010 to 28.11.2010 was initiated by CO 124 Inf Bn (TA) in his capacity as the IO and nothing adverse was communicated to the petitioner. Consequent to the surgery, he was placed in low medical category S1H1A1P3E1 by a duly constituted medical board held on 18.02.2011 but subsequently, he was upgraded to medical category S1H1A1P2E1 (Temp) w.e.f 12.05.2011

    8. The petitioner applied for grant of permanent commission vide his application dated 16.08.2011 and for extension of five more years in case he was not granted permanent commission.

    9. It is submitted that while the petitioner was in the process of completing the medical proceedings for initiation of AFMSF-2, he received an intimation from respondent No. 3 vide signal dated 24.11.2011, by which the petitioner was directed to forward his medical documents AFMSF-2 by 05.12.2011 which was otherwise required to be forwarded by 30.08.2011 The petitioner approached the concerned medical authorities for preparation of AFMSF-2 but the petitioner was referred to the concerned specialist and looking into the complicated medical background the petitioner learnt that the Medical Board proceedings AFMSF-2 will not be possible by 05.12.2011, as asked by the respondents because of the various procedure involved in the matter.

    10. The petitioner went to respondent No. 3 and brought out the delay which was expected for submission of AFMSF-2. However, the petitioner received intimation from the concerned officials that all inputs required by the Selection Board have already been forwarded and nothing can be submitted at that stage since the No. 5 Selection Board was scheduled to be held from 07.12.2011 He was given an impression that due to absence of requisite medical documents in terms of existing instructions, his result will be withheld or he will be withdrawn awaiting necessary medical documents and he will be given provisional extension for six months for completion of necessary documentation beyond a period of 5 years. However, it is submitted that neither was the petitioner granted permanent commission nor extension for five years as per his option by the Selection Board. He was ordered to be released w.e.f 16.03.2012 Meanwhile, the petitioner received a copy of the CR for the period from 01.01.2010 to 28.11.2011 initiated by the CO, 124 Inf Bn (TA) for signature and onward submission to respondent No. 3, which the petitioner could not receive earlier due to his prolonged hospitalisation and leave. Since the petitioner could not get permanent commission or extension for five years, therefore, the petitioner approached this Tribunal directly by filing the present petition, as it is stated that the statutory complaint is not available to the petitioner being a policy matter as communicated by the respondents to all the officers. As such, the petitioner has approached this Tribunal by filing the present petition challenging non grant of permanent commission/extension of service.

    11. A reply has been filed by the respondents wherein they have pointed out that medical data of individuals are not required to be placed before the Selection Board and the selection has not been adversely affected because of non-availability of medical data. But, to the contrary, the respondents have clarified that the applicant was graded ‘above average’ based on his demonstrated performance and was given positive recommendations for grant of permanent commission and extension of service by the reporting officers. However, based on his overall weak profile he was not found fit for permanent commission or extension.

    12. They have further reiterated that denial of permanent commission as well as extension of service is purely on the basis of grading and marks awarded by No. 5 Selection Board which is based on officer's overall performance as per Appendix-A of Ministry of Defence letter dated 30.09.1983 and the reason for applicant's non grant of permanent commission/extension due to non-availability of medical documents is his own presumption and need no comments. Therefore, one thing is clear that non-grant of permanent commission or extension has nothing to do with his medical category and it has been categorically stated by the respondents that the medical category has not influenced the non-grant of permanent commission or extension. But the respondents have stuck to the ground that the Selection Board did not find him suitable for grant of permanent commission or for extension on this basis of his CRs.

    13. In this connection, learned counsel for the respondents invited our attention to the criteria for grant of permanent commission/extension which is governed by the MOD letter dated 30.09.1983 The relevant portion of this letter reads as under:—

    “CRITERIA FOR GRANT OF PERMANENT COMMISSION TO SHORT SERVICE COMMISSIONED OFFICERS.

    1. The Selection Board will assess each officer's performance based on computerised Member Data Sheet. To facilitate the members to arriave at their decision, a computerised Member Data Sheet (MDS) indicating the year-wise performance of each officer including performance on Courses, Strong Points, Weak Points, Disciplinary awards, etc., will be made available. The computer evaluation as spelt out in para 4 below will have 80% weightage while 20% weightage will be given to the assessment of the members of the Selection Board.

    2. The members of the Selection Board will scrutinise the Member Data Sheet to take into account liberal/strict reporting, inconsistency in performance, nature and seriousness of disciplinary backgrounds, technical assessment, performance on courses, strong/weak points reflected in the pen-picture and appointments held by the officer and award the marks out of 20. They will also award the following gradings besides awarding the marks:—

    (a) Recommended for Permanent Commission— ‘B’ (b) Recommended for Extension only- ‘BE’ (c) Rejected for Permanent Commission and Extension ‘Z’ (d) Withdrawn (for want of sufficient material/Administrative reasons) ‘W’ (e) Deferred (in case the members feel that the fitness or otherwise of the officer an only be decided after watching the performance of the officer further). ‘D’

    3. In case of doubt, the benefit will go to the Service.

    4. For preparation of evaluation sheets, the EDP Centre will compute following information regarding the officers and allot marks and work out averages shown against each item:—

    (a) OAP Overall performance of the officer is evaluated by taking the average of figurative assessment of all reporting officers other than ETO and HTO. Average will be worked out for each year as well as for the entire period of officer's service. The latter OAP will be converted into a proportion of 60 marks.

    (b) Honours and Awards Honours and Awards received by the officer will be allotted marks as under:—

    Param Vir Chakra/Ashoka Chakra - 6 Maha Vir Chakra/Kirti Chakra - 4 Vir Chakra/Shaurya Chakra - 3 Sena Medal A/SM - 2 Mention-in-Despatches - 1 CO/A S's Commendation Card - 1

    The marks earned for the Honours and awards will be added up subject to the condition that the maximum will not exceed 6 marks.

    (c) Performance on Courses Gradings obtained by the officers on each course of instruction will be converted to points as under and average taken. The marks so obtained will be indicated on the evaluation sheet:—

    (i) D - 10 (ii) AXI, AI, Q1 - 9 (iii) A, AX, AYI, BXI - 8 (iv) AY, AZI, B1, BX, BYI, CXI - 7 (v) AZ, B, BY, BZI, CX, CYI, Q - 6 (vi) BZ, Cl, CY, CZI - 5 (vii) C, CZ - 4 (viii) E - 2 (ix) F - 0

    (d) Strong points reflected in each ACR earned by the officer will be awarded the following marks:—

    Mountaineering Expeditions or special Hazardous Missions including patrolling - 4 marks Represented the nation in sports/games - 3 marks Represented the service in sports/games - 2 marks Represented the formation in sports/games - 1 mark Innovate Skill - 1 mark Special writing habit - 1 mark

    Total marks obtained for the strong points will not exceed 4 marks. Where an officer has been given Honours or Awards, listed in the criteria for any of the Strong Points mentioned above, no marks will be given to the officer based on the strong points, but he will be awarded the marks for the Honours or Awards.

    (1) The marks for the games or sports will be awarded for the highest level represented during the period under consideration, e.g an officer who has represented the Services in 1980 and the Formation in 1981 will get marks for representing the Services only.

    (2) Marks for Mountaineering expedition or special hazardous missions including partrolling will only be given if it covers the following aspects:—

    (I) Mountaineering Expeditions

    (i) Expedition should have been at a national lever or recognised by the Indian Mountaineering Federation (IMF).

    (ii) The officer should have successfully led or scaled the peak or contributed significantly to the success of the expedition.

    (iii) The peak(s) must be of national or inter-national repute or hitherto unsealed peaks in difficult terrain.

    (II) Special Hazardous Missions including Patrolling

    The officers should have successfully led or participated in such a mission or patrol, over difficult terrain and hostile environment or in a hostile environment, obtaining distinct achievement.

    (e) Recommendation for Permanent Commission

    Recommendation of each reporting officer in every ACR will be awarded marks as under:—

    (i) ‘YES’ - 0 mark (ii) ‘NO’ - Minus 2 marks

    Note:— If, however, any reporting officer has inadvertently mentioned ‘NA’ against this will be indicated in the evaluation sheet by a Code ‘C’.

    (f) Weak Points

    (i) Minus 3 marks will be awarded to the reflection of the weaknesses relating to each of the following qualities in every report:—

    (a) Dependability

    (b) Discipline

    (c) Integrity and loyalty

    (d) Financial Management

    (e) Addition to wine

    (f) Loose morals

    (g) Personal Affairs

    (ii) All other weaknesses reflected, not falling within the purview of (i) above, will be awarded minus 0.5 mark each.

    (g) Disciplinary Awards

    While assessing officers with a disciplinary background, the gravity and nature of the offence which was committed should be taken into consideration by the board. Cases involving moral turpitude, gross negligence, acts of cowardice or un-officer like behaviours which reflects on the moral fibre of an officer will not be recommended for Permanent Commission.

    5. Marks/averages worked out as per details indicated in para 4 above will be added and the total marks obtained by each officer out of 80 marks will be indicated.

    6. Officers who fail in the Basic Young Officers Course will be listed as unfit for grant of Permanent Commission. Qualifying in the Basic Young Officers Course is a pre-requisite for grant of Permanent Commission as per Ministry of Defence letter No. 60983.AG/Org 2(MP) (a)/2907.D (AGII) dated 21 May, 1973.”

    14. It has further been clarified vide Army Order 18/88 and our attention was specifically invited to para 13 which reads as under:—

    “Guidelines for Assessment

    13. Assessment is made in accordance with the criteria approved by the Government. The salient points are given below:—

    (a) Officers are assessed on the merits of their service performance as reflected in the ACRs and course reports filed in the CR Dossier. Personal knowledge of an officer neither jeopardizes his selection nor is the basis for favourable consideration of his case.

    (b) While evaluating ACRs, the possibility of subjective/inflated reporting and fluctuation in performance of officers occasioned by following circumstances, are taken note of:—

    (i) Last ACR before assessment for PC.

    (ii) Set of initiating/reporting officers endorsing more than two reports.

    (iii) Period covered by the report, if less than six months.

    (c) Rating and assessment in mandatory qualities of loyalty, integrity and dependability are given due ifreightage.

    (d) More weightage are given to report earned from regimental appointment as opposed to staff/ERE if any.

    (e) Low Medical Category of the officer does not influence the assessment as it is an administrative restriction and not a criteria for assessment.”

    15. Mr. Pandey, learned counsel for the petitioner has emphasized that according to the MOD communication dated 30.09.1983, a total of 100 marks have been fixed. Out of which, a total of 80 marks have been fixed on the basis of computer evaluation as spelt out in para 4, while 20% weightage was given to the assessment of the members of the Selection Board. So far 80% is concerned, in para 4, a detailed analysis have been provided. So far as remaining 20% marks are concerned, which is at the discretion of the Members of the Selection Board, the same is also quantified in para 2 of the Policy letter. Para 2 says that the Selection Board will scrutinise the Member Data Sheet to take into account liberal/strict reporting, inconsistency in performance, nature and seriousness of disciplinary backgrounds, technical assessment, performance on courses, strong/weak points reflected in the pen-picture and appointments held by the officer and award marks out of 20. Therefore, the Selection Board has to recommend ‘B’ for Permanent Commission, ‘BE’ for extension and ‘Z’ for rejection of permanent commission as well as extension.

    16. In the present case, the minutes of the Selection Board have been placed before us and the Selection Board has categorised the petitioner in category ‘Z’. They have given the break-up of each Member. Out of the five Members, four Members have given him ‘Z’ and only one Member has given him ‘BE’. Thus, the total marks given by the Selection Board to the petitioner out of 20 are 7.80 and the assessment given is ‘Average’. The overall profile of the petitioner out of 80 marks is 54.96 i.e total marks out of 100 is 62.76

    17. Learned counsel for the petitioner stressed upon the guidelines which have been given in Army Order 18/88 and submitted that the assessment is to be made in accordance with the criteria approved by the Government and the Officers are to be assessed on the merits of their service performance as reflected in the ACRs and course reports filed in the CR Dossier. Personal knowledge of an officer neither jeopardizes his selection nor is the basis for favourable consideration of his case and while evaluating ACRs, the possibility of subjective/inflated reporting and fluctuation in performance of officers occasioned by following circumstances, are taken note of:—

    (i) Last ACR before assessment for PC.

    (ii) Set of initiating/reporting officers endorsing more than two reports.

    (iii) Period covered by the report, if less than six months.

    18. Learned counsel for the respondents also pointed out that as per para 13(e) of the said guidelines, Low Medical Category of the officer does not influence the assessment as it is an administrative restriction and not a criteria for assessment.

    19. One of the quality which has been reflected by the respondents in the CR of the petitioner relates to stamina, physical fitness, mental robustness and tenacity. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that he received 6 marks in 2008 from the IO and 6 marks from the RO. Similarly, in the year 2009 and 2010 also he received 6 and 7 marks. Learned counsel submits that these marks should not have been taken into consideration because ultimately these marks reflect the medical condition of the petitioner. Medical condition has not to be taken into consideration as per the above guidelines.

    20. That is true. But as a matter of fact, the ACRs are written on the qualities of an individual and the Selection Board cannot overlook it. The Selection Board has not taken into account the medical category of the petitioner as prohibited under para 13(e) of the AO 18/88 but they cannot ignore stamina, physical fitness, mental robust and tenacity of the petitioner. The Selection Board cannot ignore the 22 qualities mentioned in the ACR of an individual. Though, directly the medical category has not been taken into consideration by the Board, but if a person is not having Stamina or physical fitness or mental robustness, as specified in the ACR, the same cannot be ignored by the Selection Board. The Selection Board has gone through the procedure and has followed it methodologically and therefore, it cannot be said that referring to this weak point should not have been done. It may also be relevant to mention here that the Selection Board does not know the name of a person because the name of an individual, or his other personal data by which he can be identified, is not mentioned on the Master Data Sheet Form. Furthermore, there is no allegation of bias or malafides.

    21. For our satisfaction, we called for the personal data of other officers also and we have been informed by the learned counsel for the respondents that no person who had acquired less than 69.58 marks has been inducted for permanent commission and 64.47 marks for extension. Therefore, looking to all the angles, we are of the opinion that the case of the petitioner was fairly considered and he could not make it either for permanent commission or for extension.

    22. Consequently, we do not find any merit in the Petition. The petition stands dismissed. No order as to cost.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Capt. Vivek Ranjan v. Union Of India & Ors.
    (Sep 11, 2012)