Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts

    V. Rami Reddy v. Superintendent Of Post Offices

    Bharati Ray, Member (J):— This application has been filed by the applicant seeking for the following relief:

    (i) To call for the relevant records from R-1 and R-2 and the relevant DPC minutes relating to his selection and appointment as a Postman leading to the issue of the impugned orders No. B.III/3/97-98.Seniority dt. 11.02.1999 and No. B.III/3/97-98.Exam/OA 1331/98 dt. 11.05.2005 (Annexures A.III & A.X) of R-1 and quash the same as arbitrary, illegal and in violation of the settled law to the extent that they result in denial of qualifying service to him from 30.09.1996 onwards or atleast from the date the vacancy arose in 1997.

    (ii) And consequently to direct R-1 and R-2 to prepone his selection and appointment as a Postman to 30.09.1996 or to the actual date by which the vacancy arose in 1997 notionally, with all consequential service and monetary benefits and in particular pensionary benefits and qualifying service for the purpose of pension and by condoning the interruptions in his service under the provisions of Rule 28(a) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, by conducting a Review DPC if necessary.

    2. The facts of the case are that the first respondent issued a notification dated 7.2.1997 proposing to conduct a departmental examination for promotion to the cadre of Postman/Mailguard against the vacancies of 1996. The examination was scheduled to be conducted on 11.05.1997 Among the various conditions of eligibility prescribed in the notification, the one relating to age limit in respect of Extra Departmental Agents under the outsiders quota was as under:

    ED Agents who have put in 5 years of regular service as on 1.7.1997 and and are within the age-limit of 50 years (55 years for SC/ST and 53 years for OBC) as on 1-7-1997 are eligible.

    3. The applicant who was at that time an Extra Departmental Agent employed in the first Respondent's jurisdiction applied in response to the notification of 7.2.1997 for appearing at the departmental examination scheduled to be held on 11.5.1997 as he fulfilled the prescribed conditions stipulated in the notification. The cut-off date was 1st July, 1997 for calculating the age limit of 50 years for appearing at the examination.

    4. The first respondent issued another notification dated 3.2.1998 proposing to conduct a departmental examination against the vacancies of 1997 on 10-05-1997 but the date was later corrected to 10-05-1998. However, no examination was conducted on the notified date. One more notification was issued by the 1st respondent on 8.7.1998 proposing this time to hold a combined examination for the vacancies of 1997 and 1998 on 09-08-1998 and fixing the last date for the receipt of applications as 20.07.1998 The applicant applied well in time in response to this latest notification but the respondents refused him permission to participate in the examination which was finally held on 23.08.1998 for the reason that he had already crossed the upper age limit by 01.07.1998 which was the latest cut-off date for the purpose age calculation of intending candidates. Aggrieved by the same the applicant has approached this Tribunal earlier in OA 1120/98 which was disposed of on 8.1.1999 with the following direction:

    “By an interim order dated 3.9.1998, the applicant was provisionally permitted by this Tribunal to appear for the examination to fill up the 1997 vacancies only but to withhold the publication of his result till disposal of this OA. The result of the applicant in respect of the examination held on 27th September, 1998, for the vacancies of 1997 shall now be declared and further necessary action shall be taken forthwith to impart pre-appointment training, if any due, and thereafter to appoint him to the post of postman without any avoidable delay as per his own merit and subject to the fulfilment of other conditions prescribed provided he is found to be within the zone of selection.”

    5. The applicant filed another OA 1331/98 along with one Sk. Mahaboob Subhani which was also disposed of on the same day i.e on 8.1.1999 with the following direction:

    (a) The respondents should review the selections made under ‘Seniority quota’ of vacancies separately and independently for 1996, 1997 and 1998 and notionally promote the next available senior officials in the EDAs seniority list with reference to the available unfilled vacancies due to the declining of promotions by the senior-most qualified officials, and their eligibility for each of the three years of selection should be reckoned as though such selection is made in that year itself;

    (b) The case of Sri V. Rami Reddy, one of the applicants in these OAs, is that he was eligible to be considered against seniority quota vacancies under ‘OC’ category in respect of 1996 and 1997 vacancies as he was within the upper-age-limit of 50 years prescribed. His claim should be considered against 1996 and 1997 seniority quota vacancies independently, including declination of vacancies for those years, and if otherwise eligible, he should be promoted to the cadre of postman treating him as within the upper-age limits prescribed. Such, incidentally, is the purport of the order passed in OA 1120/98 which has been disposed of separately today.

    Time for compliance is two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

    Thus the OAs are disposed of with no order as to costs.”

    6. It is admittedly submitted by the learned counsel for the applicant that in pursuance of the order of this Tribunal dated 8.1.99 in OA 1120/98 the applicant was permitted to appear in the examination. Pursuant to the order passed by this Tribunal earlier the applicant was appointed to the cadre of Postman under seniority quota against 25% of vacancies under direct recruitment on the basis of length of service for the vacancies of 1996, 1997 and 1998 as can be evident from the memo dated 11.2.1999, copy of which is enclosed as Annexure A.III at page 18-A and 19-A of the OA. The applicant is at sr. no. 5 in the list of candidates.

    7. The applicant joined the service accordingly and submitted representation to the 1st respondent long after five years of joining i.e 1.2.2005 wherein he has extracted para-8 of the order of the Tribunal dated 8.1.99 in OA 1331/98 and requested to consider his case in accordance with the order of this Tribunal and also the rules of recruitment on seniority basis and issue suitable order giving him appointment with effect from 1.4.1997 atleast to make him eligible for pension. It is his contention that by giving him appointment with effect from 1999 instead of at least from 1.4.1997 the applicant has been deprived of getting the benefit of pension.

    8. Respondents have contested the application by filing a counter reply.

    9. We have heard Mr. TVVS Murthy learned counsel for the applicant. None appeared on behalf of the respondents. We have gone through the facts of the case and material papers placed before us.

    10. In the reply, the respondents have taken the point of limitation. Insofar as the point of limitation is concerned the learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that since OA is admitted, question of limitation cannot be taken at this stage. Be that as it may, the fact remains that the applicant filed two applications being No. 1120/98 and 1331/98. The OA 1120/98 which was filed by the applicant was disposed of by the Tribunal with a direction as extracted above. It is fairly submitted by the learned counsel for the applicant that in the examination the applicant appeared but could not qualify. However, he has been given appointment under the seniority quota as can be evident from the letter of appointment (supra). It is true that this Tribunal in another order has said about giving effect of the appointment notionally but that was not mentioned in another OA. However, the fact remains that applicant was given appointment in 1999, he accepted the same and joined the post in 1999 but submitted representation in the year 2005 to consider his case in accordance with the order of the Tribunal dated 8.1.99 as mentioned above, which has been rejected by the first respondent by impugned letter dated 11.5.2005 which is enclosed as Annexure A-X to the OA.

    11. It, therefore, appears that applicant has approached the Tribunal this time for implementation of the order of this Tribunal passed in 1999 through the present OA which is not permissible. Even if this application (OA) is treated as an application filed under section 27 of Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 such application for implementation of the order of the Tribunal can be filed within one year from the date of its becoming final. In this context, it will not be out of place to refer to the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Hukam Raj Khinvsara v. UOI, 1997 SCC (L&S) 943 wherein the Apex Court has held that “In view of the provisions contained in Sections 27, 20(2) and 21(1)(a), final order passed by the Tribunal is executable within one year from the date of its becoming final.” From the impugned letter dated 11.05.2005 it appears that change of date in appointment will also affect seniority.

    12. In view of the above discussion and legal position, the relief claimed by the applicant cannot be granted at this stage. OA is dismissed accordingly with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    V. Rami Reddy v. Superintendent Of Post Offices
    (Jul 24, 2008)