Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts

    Narmada E Learning Pvt. Ltd. v. Umang Boards Pvt. Ltd.

    R1 to R3 filed CA 143/2014 for dismissal of CP 114/2013 and for referring this matter to Arbitration in terms of Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    2. Before going into the merits on CA No. 143/2014, it is necessary to bring in the facts of the petition in brief so that it would become easy to find out as to whether this CA is to be allowed or dismissed.

    3. This dispute is primarily between two groups namely Tulsian group (petitioners) and Dhanuka group (answering Respondents).

    4. R1 Company was incorporated in the year 1999 with an Authorized Share Capital of Rs. 4,00,00,000/- (Four crores only) divided into 40,00,000/- (Forty Lakhs) equity shares of Rs. 10/- each. The present issued, subscribed and Paid-up capital of the company is Rs. 3,63,67,700 divided into 36,36,770 equity shares of Rs. 10/- each, fully paid up. This company is carrying business of manufacturing Pre-Compressed electrical Insulation pressboards, laminated boards and its machine & moulded components, transform ens parts etc. Tulsian Group has subscribed to 4,10,000 equity shares at a premium of Rs. 130/- per shares for a sum of Rs. 616 lakhs, resulting into an effective stake of 13-85%.

    5. Before Tulsian group filing this CP, they filed CP No. 92/2011, wherein a settlement was arrived 5 an MOU dated 11.02.2012 On seeing the said MoU, CLB, on 01-03-2012 disposed CP 92/2011 in terms of the MoU dated 11.02.2012 That MoU says the principal promoter of the company is Dhanuka Group; the company has recently completed expansion plan with an increase of total capital outlay of approximately INR 38 crores. Tulsian group has come into the company as a strategic investor by investing INR 6.16 crores, for which requisite shares were allotted to the group on 15-08-2007. Owing to some differences between them, Tulsian group filed CP 92/2011. While the said CP was pending, both these rival groups entered into an amicable solution (MoU) with an intervention of Mr. Sursh Gag gar agreeing to see it implemented by 15 June 2012 and thereafter to enter into a Share Holders Agreement. Since Suresh Gaggar Group (shortly called as Gaggar Group) expressed their desire to come as strategic investor, all these three groups agreed that Gaggar group shall invest INR 400 lacs to acquire 10% share holding in the Company, As on the date of execution of agreement, the position in the company is paid up capital of the company had 31,75,902 equity shares of Rs. 10/- each. Out of which, Dhanuka group had 82.34% shareholding, Tulsian group had 13.85% shareholding, and Jain group had 3.81% shareholding in the Company. However, this MoU would revise shareholding as 80.24% to Dhanuka, 15.50% to Tulsian, 4.26% to Jain group. To give effect to this revised arrangement, Dhanuka would direct Diagram Tricom (P) Ltd. to transfer its entire 41,666 shares to Tulsian at a price of INR 60/- per share, which Diagram had earlier acquired from the Company on 30-10-2010. Slmllariy Dhanuka would direct Active Suppliers (P) Ltd. to transfer its 10,599 shares to Tulsian at the rate of Rs. 60/-, which Active had earlier acquired from the company on 30-10-2010, remaining 1,067 shares held by Active would be transferred to Dhanuka at the same rate. Likewise New Age Import (P) Ltd., would transfer its 14,364 shares to Jain group at Rs. 60/- at which New Age had earlier purchased. As said above, Gaggar group would invest INR 400 lakhs to acquire 10% shareholding, similarly, Dhanuka group either in the name of them or through their men (referred as New Investor) shall have an option to invest upto INR 400 lakhs for an effective stake of 10% at the rate proposed to be issued to Gaggar group. Apart from these, there are other terms and conditions in relation to Jaipur Metal and Electrical Limited. For having the parties arrived to these arrangements, Tulsian Group agreed for withdrawal, of the CP No. 92/2011. The main thrust of the MoU to set right the allotments-made to themselves or to the companies of the answering respondents, having these Respondents made the petitioners believe earlier allotments would not remain in force, the petitioner withdrew the earlier CP. In view of the MOU arrived between the parties, the changes in the shareholding of the company shall be completed on or before 15 June 2012. After which, the parties shall enter into a binding Shareholders Agreement, on execution of the Shareholders Agreement, Tufsian Group and Gaggar Group, each shall have the right to nominate and appoint one Director on the Board of the Company. Therefore, the constitution of the Board of Directors of the company will be, with four Directors from Dhanuka Group, one Director each from Tulsian Group and Gaggar Group. These three groups also agreed that Tulsian Group and Gaggar Group would acquire all the rights, title, interests, benefits of tangible and Intangible nature, held by R1 Company, and to pursue its claims and rights as held by the company, They also agreed that the land of about 45 bighas, owned by the company, at Gram Bai Ka Bas, Khasra No. 243 & 244 Teh. Chomu, District Jaipur shall be used by the company for its expansion, details, and project matrix of which shall be mutually decided by all the three groups. It is agreed between Dhanuka Group and Tulsian Group that Jain Group would continue to remain as a minority shareholders/Group, without any Director on the Board, it is also said that Jain Group will be presented and protected by Tulsian Group. It is also agreed that all the strategic matters like, equity dilution by the company, expansion, shall be made only after obtaining the prior written approval of the three groups in respect to the price and number of shares to be issued, as also to the quantum and capacity of expansion. It is further agreed that Tulsian Group and Gaggar Group shall be entitled to receive monthly production and sales report, product wise, from the company by seventh of every following month. It is said that Tulsian Group and Gaggar Group shall be entitled to receive quarterly profit and loss account and financial statements within 30 days by the end of respective quarter. It is agreed that the affairs of the company shall be carried out and managed with high standards of integrity, performance in conformity to best Corporate Governance. The important Clause upon which this application hinges is Arbitration Clause-24, which says as follows;

    “Any disputes or differences, if any arising between the Groups shall be settled between the parties by the sole mediation of a single Arbitrator, as may be mutually appointed by all the three Groups, or as per the provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.”

    6. On the back drop of this MoU, the case of the petitioners is that Dhanuka group unilaterally terminated this MoU soon after CP 92/2011 was disposed of in terms of the MoU. For having Tulsian Group and Dhanuka Group got CP No. 92/2011 disposed of in terms of this MOU, any non-compliance of this MOU by any of the parties in CP No. 92/2011 will amount to conte of court. The petitioners submit that fair value of me share has been stated as Rs. 113 par share (premium of Rs. 103 per share) in Cause 2 of the MOU. The petitioners submit that the respondents have not performed any of the obligations, pera-wise Causes of the MOU, apart from this, R1 company allotted 3,77,173 equity shares on 18.10.2012 to a company called Umang Boards (Mumbai) Pvt. Ltd., an associate and shell company of R2 and R3, at a price of Rs. 46 per share (at a premium of Rs. 36 per share) which is in gross violation to me terms of MOU, as also to section 2(220) of Income Tax Act as allotment made at much lower value than its fair price giving undue gain of Rs. 252 lacs to me said associate company of R2&3, it should be included as deemed Income in the hands of the said shareholders u/s. 56(2)(vii)(a)(ii) of Income Tax Act. Hence, this allotment is prejudicial to me interests of the petitioners and needs to be annulled.

    7. R1 company also issued 83,695 equity shares on 08.10.2012, at Rs. 46 per share (premium of Rs. 36 per share) to me shareholders of Jain Group by unlawfully showing the loan given by me Jain Group as share application money in its audited annual accounts in the previous years. The petitioners state that Jain Group has not given money towards share application or consent letter or confirmation to make allotment to it; therefore, this allotment is Invalid.

    8. The petitioners submit that R1 on five occasions made allotment of shares at a premium of Rs. 50 per share between 30.01.2010 to 04.07.2011, to the Respondents and their family members, three shell companies of Respondents family; and to four benami/shell, companies, now forming part of the Respondents, at issue price of Rs. 60 per share (premium of Rs. 50 per share) totalling to 11, 14, 996 shares for Rs. 699 lakhs. The petitioners say that two companies of Respondents No. 2 and 3, being Uman, Business Venture Pvt. Ltd. and Umang Corporate Park Pvt. Ltd. have availed the funds from such multi layered shell/benami companies, involved in round tripping of me funds of over Rs. 12,000 crores. In addition to this, 4 bodies corporate, now forming part of Dhanuka Group are in addition to these 231 multi layered/benami/hawala companies, having involved in round tripping of black money, foreign funds, as also hawala money of over Rs. 12,000 crores. The said 231 companies and its multi-layered companies have made investments in various companies directly or indirectly belonging to various groups or industrial houses, including part amount in R1, as well as through process of money laundering and converse of black money into white thereby playing fraud on the Government exchequer. He further says, of these 231 companies, some have also figured in the Purti Group, belonging to Mr. Nitin Gadkari, used for round tripping/conversion of black money, thereafter making investments in Purtl Group.

    9. The petitioners further submit that R1 had availed Buyers' Credit from overseas branches of 4 banks, of Rs. 354 lakhs, as at 31.03.2012 this was shown as money come on import of raw material and other components used in the normal business and operations of the company but whereas the company showing imported raw-material of Rs. 144.27 lakhs only, which is in contravention to the provision of FEMA, as foreign exchange has been used/diverted by the respondents for other unlawful purposes. In view of the same, the petitioners seek reliefs:

    1) To direct the respondents to comply with the various clauses of the MOU dated 11.02.2012;

    2) To initiate contempt proceedings against the respondents for willful termination of MOU dated 11.02.2012;

    3) To declare the allotment of 3,77,173 equity shares made on 08.10.2012 to an associate of R2 and R3, at a price of Rs. 46 per share by R1 company, as to null and void;

    4) To declare the allotment of 83,692 equity shares made on 08.10.2012 at Rs. 46 per share to the shareholders of Jam Group by unlawfully and coercively converting the loan given by some members of the Jain Group to the R1 company as null and void, accordingly to rectify the shares register;

    5) To direct the respondents to complete the requirements for transfer of 66,629 shares acquired by Tulsian Group and Jain Group from Dhanuka Group in accordance with MOU dated 11.02.2012;

    6) To order the accounts of R1 company for the financial years 2010-2011, 2011-2012 and 2012-2013, to be re-audited by an independent auditor with particular reference to validity the legality of Buyers' Credit availed by R1 from four overseas banks, violations to FEMA provisions in the matter of import of raw material by R1 company, in the matter of credit facilities sanctioned by SBBJ to R1 Company and its periodical verification by SBBJ and the various irregularities (mentioned in the CP);

    7) To order investigation into the beneficial ownership of 231 and 1,500 multi layered benami/shell/hawala companies;

    8) To order investigation into the source of funds of the shareholders of Dhanuka Group;

    9) To direct appointment one director of petitioners on the Board of R1 company;

    10) To direct appointment of independent auditors for R1 company, for financial year 2013-2014;

    11 To direct appointment of two independent directors and one nominee director of SBBJ on the Board of R1 company;

    10. R2 and R3 filed this CA submitting that Company Law Board did not pass any interim relief in CP 92/2011; the Company Petition was disposed of on the MoU entered between the parties. It has not mentioned anything in the order except holding that the CP is disposed of in terms of the MOU entered between the parties. The respondents submit that compliance of the MoU, the petitioners seeking is covered by Arbitration Clause, it shall be referred to Arbitration as envisaged in it. The counsel says this has to be referred to the Arbitration as agreed in between them because, as per MoU, they agreed for Arbitration u/s B of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as and when any of the parties want to dispute the acts covered under the MOU dated 11.02.2012, Since the petitioners allegations are based on non-compliance of terms of MOU, the counsel says, the same has to be referred to Arbitration in terms of Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    11. The counsel without prejudice to the contention above mentioned submits that the Letter of Termination of the MOU was sent by the respondents to the petitioners, which was received on 27.06.2012, but whereas this petition was filed in September 2013, therefore, it also suffers from delay and laches because there is no explanation as to why delay took place in filing this CP.

    12. The Respondent counsel also submits this petition suffers from the vice of acquiescence because the money has come from Jain Group had been shown as application money in the audited annual accounts of the respondents company for the previous years. The counsel submits that the petitioners have not attended to any of the general meetings of previous years. The respondents also raised another contention stating that since the petitioners are seeking a relief of investigation into the ownership of 231 fit 1500 multi-layered Benami/Shell/Hawala companies referred in para 6.23 of the present CP without showing any of them as parties to the parties to the present CP, the petition suffers from non-joinder of necessary parties because no decree can be granted for non-joinder of a necessary parties as envisaged under Order 1 Rule 9 of CPC.

    13. In support of the application, the respondent counsel relied upon Order 1 Rule 9 of the CPC to say that when plaintiff fails to add necessary parties in the suit, the court shall dismiss the suit for non-joinder of necessary parties. The respondents counsel relied upon Jalpaiguri Cinema Co. Ltd. v. Promotha Nath Mukherjee [(1971 41 Comp Cas 141 Delhi)] to support the proposition placed above. For having the petitioner in this case sought investigation into the ownership of as many as 1731 companies without adding them as parties to the petition, the respondent counsel submits that this Bench shall dismiss it at threshold.

    14. Having the petitioners sought for an enforcement of MOU dated 11.02.2012 there being an arbitration clause in the said MOU, the respondents counsel submits that this petition, in the light of section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, shall be referred to arbitration. Though the company is not a party to the MOU, having 100% shareholders of the company being parties to the MOU, it makes no difference whether company is a party or not. The lis in the CP being covered by MoU embodied with Arbitration clause, this matter has to be referred to arbitration under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act. In support of this proposition, the respondents counsel relied upon Vijay Sekhri v. Union of India delivered by High Court of Delhi in W.P (C) No. 7559 of 2010 CM No. 19672 of 2010 and Everest Holding Ltd. v. Shyam kumar Shrivastava [(2008) 16 SCC 774)] to say ratio in the cases supra covers the facts in the present case.

    15. The respondents counsel also relied upon Pinaki Das Gupta v. Maadhyam Advertising Pvt. Ltd., [(2003) 114 CC 346)] to say when Arbitrator could grant an appropriate relief which is sought before CLB, then such dispute could be referred to the Arbitration.

    16. The respondents counsel relied upon P. Anand Gajapathi Raju v. P.V.G Raju [(2000) 4 SCC 539] to say that it is obligatory for the court to refer to the Arbitration any matter that falls within the ambit of section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Since the parties in this Company Petition and subject matter in the Company Petition are covered by MoU dated 11.02.2012, it shall be referred to Arbitration.

    17. The respondents counsel relied upon Reva Electric Car Company Pvt. Ltd. v. Green Mobil [(2012) 2 SCC 93 : AIR (2012) SC 739] to say that even on termination of an agreement, the Arbitration clause of that agreement would still survive. Basing on this proposition, the respondents counsel says the Arbitration Clause in MoU dated 11.02.2012 would remain binding on the parties notwithstanding the fact of termination of MoU dated 11.02.2012

    13. The respondents counsel further relied upon observation made by Lord Macmillan in Heyman v. Darwins [(1942) AC 356], which is as follows:

    “I venture to think that not enough attention has been directed to the true nature and function of an arbitration clause in a contract. It is quite distinct from the other clauses. The other clauses set out the obligations, which the parties undertake towards each other hinc inde (from different directions), but the arbitration clause does not impose on one of the parties an obligation in favour of the other. It embodies the agreement of both parties that if any dispute arises with regard to the obligations, which one party has undertaken to the other, such dispute shall be settled by a tribunal of their own constitution. And there is this very material difference, that whereas in an ordinary contract the obligations of the parties to each other cannot in general be specifically enforced and breach of them results only in damages, the arbitration clause can be specifically enforced by the machinery of the Arbitration Acts. The appropriate remedy for breach of the agreement to arbitrate is not damages, but its enforcement. Moreover, there is further significant difference that the courts in England have a discretionary power of dispensation as regards arbitration clauses, which they do not possess as regards the other clauses of contracts. The contract is not put out of existence, though all further performance of the obligations undertaken by each party in favour of the other may cease. It survives for measuring the claims arising out of the breach, and the arbitration clause survives for determining the mode of their settlement. The purposes of the contract have failed, but the arbitration clause is not one of the purposes of the contract.”

    19. The respondents counsel also relied upon the judgment in between Today Homes and infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Ludhiana Improvement Trust [(2014) 5 SCC 68], Swiss Timing limited v. Organising Committee, Commonwealth games 2010 Delhi [(2014) 6 SCC 677 : (AIR 2014) SC 3723] to say when the subject matter and parties are covered by Arbitration Clause, this case has to be referred to Arbitration.

    20. The petitioner counsel submits that parties settled the matter involved in CP 92/2011 in terms of MoU dated 11.02.2012, since the company petition being disposed of in terms of the said MoU, the issue present before this bench cannot be said as covered by Arbitration Clause.

    21. The petitioner counsel submits that respondents unilaterally terminated MoU though there is no provision in the MoU for terminating the same unilaterally. For having this Bench disposed of earlier CP in terms of this MoU, such unilateral termination of MoU by the respondents amounts to contempt of court.

    22. The petitioner counsel relied upon Bhushan Power & Steel Ltd. v. Rajesh Verma [(2014) 5 SCC 551] to say that non compliance of a court order amounts to contempt. The petitioner counsel submits that the present CP is for enforcement of order dated 01.03.2012 passed by CLB in CP No. 92/2011 and also for investigation into the affairs of R1 company under section 237 and to bring oppressive acts being committed in relation to affairs of R1 company. The petitioner counsel submits that the present CP ambit as such is wider than the subject matter in the MoU and wider than averments in earlier CP, therefore, the petitioner counsel submits this CA is liable to be dismissed.

    23. On hearing the submissions of either side, I do agree that all the propositions placed by the respondents saying that when 100% shareholders of the company are signatories to an agreement conceived with arbitration clause, though company is not a party, the parties are at liberty to invoke arbitration clause, provided subject matter is covered by arbitration clause. I do also agree that the principle of Doctrine of Severability is applicable to arbitration clause though the remaining clauses of the Memorandum of Understanding ceased to operate.

    24. Now the point for determination is whether the MoU dated, 11.02.2012 has given any effect at all or not.

    25. If the agreement itself is not given effect, is it necessary to bind the parties to arbitration or agreement, which has not seen the day of light?

    26. Whether the petitioner who elected 397 & 398 proceedings could seek enforcement of some clause of the MoU annexed with Arbitration Clause.

    27. The case of the respondents in the application is that this agreement has not come into effect because Gaggar Group has not invested funds Into the company as agreed by them.

    28. On seeing the agreement, it appears that the terms and clause of MoU will become shareholders agreement when the clauses of MoU in para 1 to 8 have been compiled with on or before 15.06.2012 The parties will get a right for becoming directors of the company only after shareholders agreement has come into existence, Here no changes took place as stated in para 1 to 8 of MOU dated 11.02.2012 and no shareholders agreement was executed after 15.06.2015 Apart from this, the very applicants who are respondents in this case - Dhanuka Group unilaterally terminated this agreement saying it is not binding upon the parties. In a situation like this, had the Respondents implemented or enforced the MoU, it could be understood an occasion arose for invoking Arbitration Clause in the MoU. Here, Dhanuka group unilaterally terminated the agreement, thereafter made allotment to themselves. Having made allotment to themselves not covered under MoU, it cannot be said that the issue of allotment made to themselves has to be referred to Arbitration as conceived in the MoU just by seeing that there is an arbitration clause in an MoU that has not seen the light of the day. In cases supra, the agreement entered between the parties remained in force for some time, both the parties acted upon, here nothing happened except the respondents using this MoU as a device for the withdrawal of earlier CP.

    29. This Doctrine of Severability will come into operation when the agreement has come into effect. Here the respondents filed this application saying though this agreement entered Into has not been given effect, it has to be referred to arbitration for the reason that MoU has arbitration clause notwithstanding the fact whether it is given effect or not.

    30. When Dhanuka group made allotment to their group, Tulsian group filed this CP saying that earlier CP was disposed of taking MoU into consideration, the petitioner also agreed for withdrawal of earlier CP because the MoU proposed a solution to earlier allotments arbitrarily made to the Respondents apart from a proposal for investment from Gaggar group. But whereas these Respondents after disposal of earlier CP, turned around and made further allotments without giving any opportunity to the petitioners to participate in right issue. Looking at this scenario Dhanuka group causing Tulsa in group withdraw earlier CP on the MoU with a proposal to set right earlier allotment, thereafter turning around and making allotment to their group at a price far lower than the price at which the shares were allotted to Tuisain group, I am of the view if it is not oppression, what else would become oppression? in view of the same, I am of the view that the acts of the respondents prima fide amount to prejudice to the rights of the petitioners, hence this arbitration clause is not binding upon the petitioners. The remedy available under section 397 & 398 is statutory remedy, unless the lis is strictly within the Arbitration Clause, the court is under no obligation to refer the matter to Arbitration.

    31. Since the petitioner elected remedy u/s. 397 & 398 proceedings, the Respondents cannot ask for implementation of clause under MOU dated 11.02.2012

    32. It is true that the petitioner made serious allegation against somebody who are not a party to the proceedings saying huge money embezzlement by the company through round tripping without any details, without even making them as parties. Nobody knows who they are. Therefore, the petitioner is not entitled to seek reliefs 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8 & 9, thereby those reliefs are hereby stuck off from the prayers of the petition.

    33. For the reasons mentioned above, I hereby hold,

    - that the grievances of the petitioners are not covered by either MoU or Arbitration clause of MoU, because the alleged acts cannot be coined as mere violation of the clauses of the MoU, they are, I believe, beyond the ambit of MoU and arbitration clause amounting to oppression against the petitioners, hence I dismiss the relief sought under section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996.

    - that having the petitioners failed to make the parties against whom serious aspersions are made and sought reliefs - they are not even named anywhere in the petition, hence the reliefs sought against non parties are here by dismissed as envisaged under Order 1 Rule 9 of CPC.

    Accordingly, CA 143/2014 is partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narmada E Learning Pvt. Ltd. v. Umang Boards Pvt. Ltd.
    (Mar 10, 2015)