1. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (hereinafter referred to as “SEBI”) had passed an ex parte interim order dated February 20, 2010, (which was later confirmed vide SEBI order dated October 6, 2010), in the matter of synchronized trading, creation of artificial volumes and price manipulation in scrips of eight companies viz. Allcargo Global Logistics Ltd. (“Allcargo”), Asian Star Company Ltd. (“Asian”), KSL & Industries Ltd. (“KSL”), Mavens Biotech Ltd. (“Mavens”), Panoramic Universal Ltd. (“Panoramic”), Rasi Electrodes Ltd.(“Rasi”), Sat Industries Ltd. (“SAT”) and Ushdev International Ltd. (Ushdev”), on the Bombay Stock Exchange (“BSE”) as well as the National Stock Exchange of India Limited (“NSE”), by sixteen connected entities during the period between March 01, 2009 to September 20, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as “Investigation Period 1”). Vide the said orders, SEBI restrained the abovesaid sixteen entities from accessing the securities market or buying, selling or dealing in securities in any manner till further directions, for prima facie violations of regulations 3 and 4 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to the Securities Market) Regulations, 2003 (hereinafter referred to as the “FUTP Regulations”). The alleged violations pertaining to the sixteen entities were brought to light on the basis of certain alerts generated by the surveillance system that a certain group of persons was involved in the execution of the structured trades. In view of this, SEBI also advised the BSE to examine the trading pattern of the said group of persons during Investigation Period 1.
2. Preliminary investigation by BSE and SEBI revealed that an additional nineteen connected entities were also involved in synchronized and circular trading resulting in the creation of artificial volumes and price manipulation in twelve scrips (hereinafter referred to as the “selected scrips”) including the eight scrips observed during Investigation Period 1. The unusual trading activity in the four additional scrips viz those of KBS Capital Management Ltd. (“KBS”), Lotus Eye Care Hospitals Ltd. (“Lotus”), MVL Limited (“MVL”) and Anil Products Ltd. (“Anil”) was observed during the period between July 01, 2009 to December 15, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as “Investigation Period 2”). It was also revealed that the structured and manipulative trading done in the accounts of most of the connected entities appeared to have been executed by one Mr. Sunil Mehta (hereinafter referred to as “Sunil Mehta”) and his associates, who opened and operated the trading accounts by promising cash benefits to the account-holders. The initial funds to start trading were also allegedly deposited by Sunil Mehta and his associates into the bank accounts of many of the account-holders.
3. On the basis of findings of preliminary investigation into the matter, SEBI passed another ex parte interim order dated May 27, 2011, restraining an additional nineteen connected entities, including Sunil Mehta, from accessing the securities market or buying, selling or dealing in securities in any manner, till further directions.
4. Therefore, a total of thirty five connected entities were restrained from accessing the securities market and also from buying, selling or dealing in securities in any manner, for the prima facie violation of regulations 3 and 4 of the FUTP Regulations when they carried out synchronized and circular trades as well as price and volume manipulation in the selected scrips during Investigation Period 1 and Investigation Period 2. Subsequent investigation revealed that the trading accounts of one Ms. Namita Khicha, who was not included in the interim orders dated February 20, 2010 and May 27, 2011 passed against the sixteen and nineteen entities respectively, were also involved in the alleged structured trades and price-volume manipulation in the selected scrips. Therefore, Ms. Namita Khicha was also issued a Shqw Cause Notice along with the thirty five entities already covered by the SEBI orders dated October 6, 2010 and March 27, 2012. These thirty six entities, namely, Sunil Mehta, Ms. Anjana Mehta (“Anjana Mehta”), Mr. Jitendra Mannalal Jain (“Jitendra Jain”), Ms. Hemlata Ramesh Harikare (“Hemlata Hankare”), Mr. Ajay Roongta (“Ajay Roongta”), Mr. Bharat Jain (“Bharat Jain”), Mr. Suresh Hanswal (“Suresh Hanswal”), Mr. Praveen Gate (“Praveen Gate”), Mr. Manish Mathur (“Manish Mathur”), Mr. Bhavesh Kothari (“Bhavesh Kothari”), Mr. Rakesh H. Jain (“Rakesh Jain”), Mr. Bhavesh Jain (“Bhavesh Jain”), Ms. Usha Mehta (“Usha Mehta”), Ms. Seema Mathur (“Seema Mathur”), Mr. Devendra Kumar Rai (“Devendra Rai”), Ms. Renu Madhusudhan Paliwal (“Renu Paliwal”), Ms. Rashmi R Gandhi (“Rashmi Gandhi”), Mr. Ramesh Gandhi (“Ramesh Gandhi”), Mr. Hasmukh Valchand Jain (“Hasmukh Jain”), Mr. Naresh V. Rajawat (“Naresh Rajawat”), Ms. Pawanben Valchand Jain (“Pawanben Jain”), Ms. Reeta Naresh Rajawat (“Reeta Rajawat”), Mr. Kunal Dileep Kothari (“Kunal Kothari”), Ms. Sweta Bharat Kothari (“Sweta Kothari”), Ms. Shobha Dilip Kothari (“Shobha Kothari”), Ms. Neela Khicha (“Neela Khicha”), Ms. Namita Khicha (“Namita Khicha”), Mr. Kamlesh P. Jain (“Kamlesh Jain”), Mr. Hitesh Mahendra Jain (“Hitesh Jain”), Mr. Vinay Kothari (“Vinay Kothari”), Mr. Pradeep Kothari (“Pradeep Kothari”), Mr. Sitanshu Nanawati (“Sitanshu Nanawati”), Mr. Shaikh Soalli Jainuddin (“Shaikh Jainuddin”), Ms. Meena Rajawat (“Meena Rajawat”), Alpesh Rajmal Shah, HUF (“Alpesh Shah”) and Anil Rajmal Shah, HUF (“Anil Shah”), are collectively referred to as the “noticees” in the ensuing paragraphs.
5. Pursuant to its interim order dated May 27, 2011, SEBI conducted a detailed investigation into the trading activities of all the noticees in the selected scrips viz. Allcargo, Asian, KSL, Mavens, Panoramic, Rasi, SAT and Ushdev (in Investigation Period 1) and KBS, Lotus, MVL and Anil (in Investigation Period 2). The investigation conducted by SEBI led to the following main findings:—
i. The noticees are related to one another and together form a group, through whose trading accounts, synchronized and circular trades were executed in the selected scrips during Investigation Period 1 and Investigation Period 2.
ii. It was also found that such trades influenced the price and volume of the scrips.
iii. Sunil Mehta with the help of his associates, namely, Manish Mathur, Suresh Hanswal, Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare and Bhavesh Kothari (who was further assisted by Hitesh Jain, Rakesh Jain and Bhavesh Jain), had created artificial volumes and also influenced the price of the scrips under investigation by executing structured and circular trades within a large group of the noticees. For the furtherance of the manipulation, Sunil Mehta deposited cash in the bank account of many entities especially Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare, Usha Mehta and Anjana Mehta. It was also found that Sunil Mehta provided initial margin/deposit needed in cash to other entities whose accounts were opened by promise of monthly cash income or profit generation.
6. In view of the above said findings of the investigation, a common Show Cause Notice (hereinafter referred to as the “SCN”) dated February 08, 2012 was issued to the noticees to show cause as to why suitable directions including directions restraining them from buying, selling or dealing in securities for a specified period should not be issued to them under Sections 11 and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992 read with Regulation 11(1) of the FUTP Regulations, for the alleged violation of the provisions of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), and regulations 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. In addition to the above alleged violations, five of the noticees, namely, Sunil Mehta, Manish Mathur, Bhavesh Kothari, Rakesh Jain and Bhavesh Jain were further required to show cause for the alleged violation of Regulation 4(2)(d) and (f) of the FUTP Regulations.
7. It is noted that Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare and Suresh Hanswal failed to appear before the Investigating Authority (hereinafter referred to as “LA”) even after the issuance of several summons to therrv.’ I further note that all the noticees except Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare, Suresh Hanswal, Bharat Jain, Hitesh Mahendra Jain and Devendra Rai, have replied to the SCN. Considering the nature of the alleged violations, all the noticees were given opportunities for personal hearing in the interest of natural justice on May 07 and 08, 2013 and June 07 and 14, 2013.
CONSIDERATION OF ISSUES
8. I have carefully perused the SCN, the written submissions filed by the noticees, statements made by the noticees, submissions made by the noticees during the personal hearing granted to them, and other material on record. The issue arising for consideration is whether the noticees have indulged in any manipulative, fraudulent or unfair trade practice under the FUTP Regulations, by carrying out structured, synchronized or circular trading activities in the selected scrips, which led to price and volume manipulation during Investigation Period 1 and 2, as alleged in the SCN.
9. The legal provisions which have allegedly been violated by the noticees are reproduced below for reference:—
“3. Prohibition of certain dealings in securities
No person shall directly or indirectly—
(a) buy, sell or otherwise deal in securities in a fraudulent manner;
(b) use or employ, in connection with issue, purchase or sale of any security listed or proposed to be listed in a recognized stock exchange, any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in contravention of the provisions of the Act or the rules or the regulations made there under;
(c) employ any device, scheme or artifice to defraud in connection with dealing in or issue of securities ivhich are listed or proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange;
(d) engage in any act, practice, course of business which operates or would operate as fraud or deceit upon any person in connection with any dealing in or issue of securities which are listed or proposed to be listed on a recognized stock exchange in contravention of the provisions of the Act or the rules and the regulations made there under.
4. Prohibition of manipulative, fraudulent and unfair trade practices
(1) Without prejudice to the provisions of regulation 3, no person shall indulge in a fraudulent or an unfair trade practice in securities.
(2) Dealing in securities shall be deemed to be a fraudulent or an unfair trade practice if it involves fraud and may include all or any of the following, namely:—
(a) indulging in an act which creates false or misleading appearance of trading in the securities market;
(b) dealing in a security not intended to effect transfer of beneficial ownership but intended to operate only as a device to inflate, depress or cause fluctuations in the price of such security for wrongful gain or avoidance of loss;
(d) paying, offering or agreeing to pay or offer, directly or indirectly, to any person any money or money's worth for inducing such person for dealing in any security with the object of inflating, depressing, maintaining or causing fluctuation in the price of such security;
(e) any act or omission amounting to manipulation of the price of a security;
(f) publishing or causing to publish or reporting or causing to report by a person dealing in securities any information which is not true or which he does not believe to be true prior to or in the course of dealing in securities;
(g) entering into a transaction in securities without intention of performing it or ivithout intention of change ofoivnership of such security;”
Section 12A (a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992 are also reproduced below for reference:—
“12A. No person shall directly or indirectly—
(a) use or employ, in connection with the issue, purchase or sale of any securities listed or proposed to be listed on a recognised stock exchange, any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in contravention of the provisions of this Act or the rules or the regulations made thereunder;
(b) employ any device, scheme or artifice to defraud in connection with issue or dealing in securities which are listed or proposed to be listed on a recognised stock exchange;
(c) engage in any act, practice, course of business ivhich operates or would operate as fraud or deceit upon any person, in connection with the issue, dealing in securities which are listed or proposed to be listed on a recognised stock exchange, in contravention of the provisions of this Act or the rules or the regulations made thereunder;”
10. I now proceed to first establish the relationship between the noticees, after which the charge vis-a-vis each of the noticees shall be dealt with separately.
The Relationships amongst the noticees
11. The SCN explains the relationship between the noticees, based on an analysis of information received from brokers, depository participants and banks, as well as submissions, statements and admissions made by the noticees. I note that admissions of relationships amongst noticees were also made during the hearings held before me in the matter. The evidence establishing the relationship between the noticees will also be useful in understanding the nature of the manipulation carried out by the noticees, which will be discussed subsequently in this order.
12. The matrix of relationships and evidence indicating connections between the noticees as noted from the SCN as well as submissions made by the noticees is reproduced below for reference:—
i. Anjana Mehta is the wife of Sunil Mehta and Usha Mehta is his mother.
ii. Manish Mathur and Seema Mathur are husband and wife. Sunil Mehta has admitted that Manish Mathur is his old friend and also that Sunil Mehta carried out trades in Seema Mathur's trading account.
iii. It is also pertinent to note that Sunil Mehta, vide his letter dated June 10, 2013, has admitted placing orders on behalf Usha Mehta, Anjana Mehta, Jitendra Jain, Seema Mathur and Hemlata Hankare.
iv. In the course of investigation, Sunil Mehta admitted to having a business relationship with Bhavesh Kothari whereby they used to share trading information in the scrips and did jobbing in the trading account of Sitanshu Nanawati.
v. Sunil Mehta also admitted knowing Praveen Gate.
vi. Hasmukh Jain is the brother of Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat is the wife of Naresh Rajawat and Pawanben Rajawat is his mother.
vii. Bhavesh Kothari, Pradeep Kothari and Vinay Kothari are brothers-in-law of Sweta Kothari. Shobha Kothari is the sister-in law of Sweta Kothari. Kunal Kothari is the son of Shobha Kothari. Hitesh Jain is the nephew of Bhavesh Kothari. Kunal Kothari and Hitesh Jain are cousins.
viii. It is pertinent to note that Bhavesh Kothari in his reply dated March 01, 2012 has admitted that he had operated the trading accounts of eleven of the noticees, namely, Hasmukh Jain, Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Pawanben Rajawat, Pradeep Kothari, Vinay Kothari, Sweta Kothari, Shobha Kothari, Kunal Kothari, Kamlesh Jain and Neela Khicha, as per the instructions of Sunil Mehta. During the course of investigation, he stated that he facilitated opening of accounts on behalf of many of the noticees, namely, Rakesh Jain, Bhavesh Jain, Shaikh Jainuddin and Sitanshu Nanavati, on the advice of Sunil Mehta, for which he used to get Rs. 3000/- per month, per person, which he used to share with those clients. He further stated that the accounts were opened with the operational help of Praveen Gate who used to visit the clients for KYC, giving cash, taking cheques in the name of the brokers etc.
ix. One Mr. Praveen Kulkarni has stated that he had introduced Ramesh Gandhi to Sunil Mehta, and that the trading account of Rashmi Gandhi was opened and operated by Sunil Mehta. Ramesh Gandhi has corroborated this statement of Praveen Kulkarni.
x. Praveen Gate opened the trading account of several of the noticees with Inventure Growth and Securities Pvt. Ltd., Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. and PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd., three of the brokers he worked with on commission basis. He has also revealed that the trading accounts of Hemlata Hankare, Jitendra Jain, Rashmi Gandhi and Usha Mehta were opened by him on the direction of Sunil Mehta while the trading accounts of Shaikh Jainuddin and some other clients was opened under the direction of Bhavesh Kothari, whose reference was provided to him by Sunil Mehta, although he had never met the clients personally. Praveen Gate also carried out in-person verification for Jitendra Jain and Hemlata Hankare.
xi. Ramesh Gandhi, husband of the client Rashmi Gandhi, admitted during investigation that Rashmi Gandhi's trading account was operated by Sunil Mehta and that the login ID/password was given to him by Rashmi Gandhi and Ramesh Gandhi through Mr. Praveen Kulkarni.
xii. Jitendra Jain is related to Sunil Mehta, as evidenced from the fact that in the KYC documents of Jitendra Jain with a broker, Kantilal Chaganlal Securities Pvt. Ltd., a friend of Sunil Mehta (one Mr. Pradesh Bandhu Nimmawat) is stated as his nominee.
xiii. Sunil Mehta, Jitendra Jain and Renu Paliwal had a common introducer viz one Mr. Amit Joshi, who introduced all of them to the broker India Capital Markets Pvt. Ltd.
xiv. Regarding the nexus between Bharat Jain, Jitendra Jain and Sunil Mehta, the bank statement details relevant that a Demand Draft for Rs. Six lakhs was issued to Bharat Jain on February 10, 2009 from the bank account of Jitendra Jain. It is further noted from the findings of the investigations that the handwriting in the vouchers used for the issuance of the DD is that of Sunil Mehta.
xv. Mr. Pradesh Bandhu Nimmawat and Suresh Hanswal, were the introducers of Usha Mehta, Sunil Mehta, Jitendra Jain and Renu Paliwal to the broker Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd.
xvi. Statements given by Sunil Mehta during investigation brought to light the fact that Renu Paliwal's husband (one Mr. Madhusudan Paliwal) was a friend of Sunil Mehta. The mobile number (9322123256) mentioned on the KYC details of Renu Paliwal with India Capital belonged to Sunil Mehta. The demat account of Renu Paliwal with ISJ Securities Pvt. Ltd. was introduced by Sunil Mehta and witnessed by Jitendra Jain and Suresh Hanswal (a friend and associate of Sunil Mehta). Renu Paliwal in her reply stated that her trading accounts were opened and operated by her husband's friend, Sunil Mehta.
xvii. Sunil Mehta has also stated that Manish Mathur (the Chief Operating Officer of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. or “Triveni”) is his friend, and also that Sunil Mehta had introduced Madhusudan Paliwal to Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd.
xviii. Shaikh Jainuddin and Usha Mehta were introduced by Praveen Gate, and were found to have opened trading accounts with the same broker viz. Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd., on the same date i.e October 15, 2009. They were found to have started trading immediately in similar scrips which were part of the present investigation. It has also been observed that orders for Shaikh Jainuddin and Usha Mehta were being placed from the same IP address and location for many days. In this context, it is observed that Sunil Mehta admitted that he had traded on behalf of his mother, Usha Mehta. Therefore, Sunil Mehta clearly appears to have executed trades in Shaikh Jainuddin's trading account as well.
xix. Shaikh Jainuddin had admitted before the IA that his friend Rakesh Jain opened his trading account and deposited funds in his bank account in cash, for margin payment/initial deposit to be made to brokers.
xx. Rakesh Jain and Bhavesh Jain are brothers, and Bhavesh Kothari is their friend. Rakesh Jain was observed to be a client of Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. and seems to have dealt in the selected scrips through internet trading. Rakesh Jain and his brother Bhavesh Jain admitted during the course of investigation that the trading accounts were opened at the behest of Bhavesh Kothari, friend of Bhavesh Jain, and that Praveen Gate assisted Bhavesh Kothari in getting their accounts opened. They also stated that the accounts were opened in lieu of monthly cash income. They revealed that Bhavesh Kothari was using their account. It is also noted that Bhavesh Jain has stated that he paid Rs. One lakh fifty thousand for opening the account for his brother Rakesh Jain and also paid Rs. One lakh to Rakesh Jain to open account of Shaikh Jainuddin. The statements made by Shaikh Jainuddin mentioned in the preceding paragraphs further corroborate this. All these accounts were found to have been operated by Bhavesh Kothari.
xxi. Bhavesh Kothari's name was mentioned as the compulsory reference in the KYC details of Sitanshu Nanawati.
xxii. It is observed that Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah are stated to be brothers and shared a common address.
13. From the above, I note that the noticees are related to one another and together form a group. In the succeeding paragraphs of this order, evidence indicating the modus operandi of structured, synchronized and circular trades amongst the noticees, and the nature and frequency of trades executed between them will be examined.
14. The SCN provides the price-volume data for all the selected scrips during the periods of investigation. Table-1 below provides an overview—
Price (Rs.)
Volume
Scrip
Open
Close
% Change in price of selected scrips during Investigation Period 1 and Investigation Period 2.
Avg. Daily
Total
Allcargo
705.00
827.75
17.41
9868
1351918
Asian
822.00
1,529.05
86.02
24165
3286387
KSL
131.80
68.30
-48.18
28188
3833571
Mavens
62.90
105.75
68.12
61992
8430943
Panaromic
210.00
219.10
4.33
19849
2699494
Rasi
16.10
19.65
22.05
3160
398173
SAT
14.50
33.90
133.79
25068
3409253
Ushdev
44.00
145.15
229.89
52621
7156466
Anil
112.00
131.50
17.41
18293
2103729
KBS
23.00
24.40
6.09
25980
2675955
Lotus
33.45
34.60
3.44
72837
8157759
MVL#
111.25
60.00 (300)
-46.07 (209.98)
347114
39918054
# Stock split 1:5 w.e.f September 22, 2009.
15. It is observed from the SCN and the Annexures thereto, that Sunil Mehta and the noticees associated with him entered into synchronized trades within the group of noticees as a whole, with each other as counterparties, by matching the price, quantity and time of their buy and sell orders. Where the quantity of the buy and sell orders was not exactly matched in one order, it was seen to be matched over the course of successive subsequent orders. Thus, the net deliverable quantity remained either zero or negligible, while an impact was observed on the prices and volumes traded of the selected scrips, which created a false and exaggerated impression of trading in the selected scrips. The SCN states that the synchronized, structured and circular trades executed by the noticees contributed to maintenance of or increase in the price of the scrip when compared to its Last Traded Price (“LTP”). The net aggregate impact on prices is noted in Table - 2 (annexed to this order).
16. The number of shares traded through transactions structured by the noticees as a percentage of the market volumes in the selected scrips ranged from 14.02% to 56.62%. In many instances, a method of executing structured trades in smaller quantities successively appears to have been adopted by the noticees in order to avoid detection during surveillance system checks. Illustrations of such synchronized trades will be examined in detail with the violations of each noticee separately in this order.
17. In addition to the synchronized and structured trades carried out by the noticees, certain circular trades in the selected scrips have also been brought out in the SCN. These circular trades ensured that shares sold by a person belonging to the noticees' group were bought and resold by a number of persons belonging to the same group. As a result, like in the case of the alleged structured trades, there appears to have been no intention to transfer beneficial ownership of the shares and the trades seem to have been executed only to create a false impression of trades which impacted price and volumes of the scrips. Illustrations of such circular trades will be examined in detail with the violation of each notice separately in this order in the ensuing paragraph.
Role of each person in the connected group of the noticees
18. In the next few paragraphs, the charges vis-a-vis each noticee will be examined in the light of the findings of the investigation and the submissions of the noticees.
(I) SUNIL MEHTA
(i) Sunil Mehta has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e), (f) and (g) of, the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Sunil Mehta traded through Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. (“Emkay”). He has admitted to have operated the trading accounts of his wife Anjana Mehta, his mother Usha Mehta, and his friends Jitendra Jain, Seema Mathur and Hemlata Hankare. Sunil Mehta was also found to have received contract notes for all these five persons whose accounts he admittedly operated. Sunil Mehta's wife Anjana Mehta was observed to be trading through two brokers viz. BP Equities Ltd. and India Capital Ltd. When the trading of Sunil Mehta and Anjana Mehta is considered in a consolidated manner, it is seen that the number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in their trading accounts combined were as high as 31883 in the scrip of SAT alone. The details of the other structured trades executed through the trading accounts of Sunil Mehta and Anjana Mehta in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN.
(iii) An example of the structured trades executed by Sunil Mehta is mentioned in the SCN and is being reiterated here for the sake of clarity. On September 09, 2009 Jitendra Jain was observed to have placed a buy order for 300 shares in the scrip of Panoramic at Rs. 224. Sunil Mehta placed a sell order, at almost the same time, for 250 shares at price of Rs. 224. The two orders got matched immediately for 250 shares, and the buy order of Jitendra Jain for the balance 50 shares remained pending very briefly, till Sunil Mehta once again placed a sell order for 50 shares within a few seconds at the same price. This sell order got matched immediately with the pending partly executed buy order of Jitendra Jain. When studied in the context of the bank account fund flows and the nature of relationship between Sunil Mehta and Jitendra Jain, it becomes evident that there was no real intention to transfer beneficial ownership in this transaction. Rather, the intention appears to have been to create a false impression of trading in the scrip. Similarly, an observation of the trades executed in Anjana Mehta's trading account has shown structured trades were executed in her trading account. For instance, in the scrip of SAT on April 6, 2009, it was seen that Anjana Mehta placed a buy order for 525 shares at Rs. 15.20, which was matched by five successive sell orders adding up to 525 shares, at the same price, and placed within a few seconds of Anjana Mehta's buy order. This indicates that there was no intention to transfer beneficial ownership of the shares, and that the trades were merely intended to create a false impression of trading in the scrip. Examples of circular trades executed by Sunil Mehta through the trading accounts of the noticees like Jitendra Jain and Hemlata Hankare, in whose accounts Sunil Mehta has admittedly traded, have also been provided in the SCN and discussed subsequently in this order.
(iv) It is noted that Sunil Mehta, either himself or through the trading accounts of the noticees, executed several structured, synchronized or circular trades which constituted upto 56.62% of the market volume in the selected scrips. The buy and sell orders placed by Sunil Mehta and the other noticees have contributed to an increase in the price of the selected scrips, as already indicated by the data on price impact in Table - 2 annexed to this order.
(v) It is noted that Sunil Mehta and Anjana Mehta replied to the SCN vide letters dated February 28 and 27, 2012. Sunil Mehta denied the observation that the trading executed in the accounts of most of the entities viz. Rashmi Gandhi and Renu Paliwal as well as accounts of certain others were allegedly executed by him in association with entities associated with him. He admitted knowing Bhaves Kothari as a sub-broker with India Capital Market Ltd. where he had his trading account. He also stated that he had friendly relations with Ajay Roongta, Seema Mathur, Manish Mathur, Renu Paliwal and Suresh Hanswal.
(vi) During the hearing granted to Sunil Mehta on June 7, 2013, Shri. Rajesh Khandelwal, Advocate duly authorized by Sunil Mehta appeared and made submissions on behalf of Sunil Mehta that his client did not wish to contest those allegations made in the SCN which were proved beyond doubt, and also that Sunil Mehta had used the accounts of Anjana and Usha Mehta. Further, the counsel requested that a lenient view may be taken as Sunil Mehta had already undergone debarment for more than 2 years and in view of other proceedings pending against him.
(vii) However, it is noted that after availing the opportunity of hearing, Sunil Mehta, vide his reply dated June 10, 2013, stated that he admits the allegations in the SCN only in respect of the trades executed on behalf of Usha Mehta and Anjana Mehta and that he disputes all other allegations in the SCN, as there had been some miscommunication with his counsel. This retraction of the admission made during the hearing is required to be noted in the context of Sunil Mehta's conduct during the investigation, where he changed his stand several times as discussed subsequently at paragraph 18(I)(xvi) of this order. This indicates that the retraction of the admission made during the hearing may have been an afterthought. Further, Sunil Mehta vide his reply dated June 10, 2013 has admitted that on occasion he helped his friends Hemlata Hankare (in whose case he had earlier denied placing orders in her trading account), Jitendra Jain, Seema Mathur and Manish Mathur in placing orders under their instructions.
(viii) The SCN states that the bank statement details of Sunil Mehta and Anjana Mehta indicate that payments from their bank accounts were made mainly to brokers or were cash withdrawals. Similarly, receipts were either amount received from the brokers or cash deposits. Any payment to brokers were made either after the deposit of cash or after receipt from another broker of other noticees. It is noted that Sunil Mehta has failed to explain the source of such cash inflows.
(ix) The evidence gathered during the course of investigation appears to indicate that the audit trail of each noticee whose details have been mentioned and who had traded in the said scrips ultimately leads to Sunil Mehta. The statements given by Sunil Mehta and other noticees before the IA have been mentioned in the SCN. When Sunil Mehta was shown the statements of Bhavesh Kothari and details of phone calls between them, he admitted that he knew Bhavesh Kothari. Further, Sunil Mehta admitted that he had a business relationship with Bhavesh Kothari. However, Sunil Mehta denied the statements made by Bhavesh Kothari that he was paid Rs. 3000/- per month per person by Sunil Mehta for the trading accounts opened by Bhavesh Kothari for Sunil Mehta.
(x) Investigation revealed that Sunil Mehta and Bhavesh Kothari had operated the trading account of Sitanshu Nanawati. It is further found that the trading in the account of Sitanshu Nanawati was also in the same scrips and his orders were synchronized/structured with the entities associated with Sunil Mehta. On being asked as to the reasons for giving assurance to the parents of Sitanshu Nanawati regarding trading in the account of Sitanshu Nanawati, Sunil Mehta had stated before the IA that they (Sunil Mehta and Bhavesh Kothari) have done jobbing transactions in the account of Sitanshu Nanawati. It is also observed that all the transactions in the trading accounts where Bhavesh Kothari was found to have placed orders were in the same scrips where the noticees related to. Sunil Mehta (or Sunil Mehta himself) were found to have placed synchronized/structured orders. Further, it is found that the orders placed in the trading accounts which were admitted to have been operated by Bhavesh Kothari and Sunil Mehta had matched with the orders placed by the noticees directly related to Bhavesh Kothari. The aforementioned facts coupled with the statements of Bhavesh Kothari and Sunil Mehta, indicate that Sunil Mehta and Bhavesh Kothari are connected to each other and further, Sunil Mehta was aided and assisted by Bhavesh Kothari in the opening and operation of trading accounts of many of the noticees. Voice recordings analysed during investigation also indicated that Sunil Mehta placed orders for Seema Mathur and Hemlata Hankare with Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd.
(xi) Sunil Mehta's wife Anjana Mehta had stated during the course of investigation that her trading accounts were opened and operated by her husband, Sunil Mehta. Further, regarding the introduction of two of the noticees viz. Hemlata Hankare and Devendra Rai to Networth Stock Brokers Ltd. as clients, Anjana Mehta stated that she was the business associate with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd. for some time and had signed the KYC documents for the clients Hemlata Hankare and Devendra Rai on the advice of Sunil Mehta.
(xii) Sunil Mehta initially denied knowing Devendra Rai or Hemlata Hankare. However, when confronted with the fact that Anjana Mehta was the authorized representative/business associate for Devendra Rai and Hemlata Hankare, Sunil Mehta stated that the broker Networth Stock Broking Ltd. had provided him with Devendra Rai and Hemlata Hankare as clients since he had been engaged by the said broker as remisier to solicit business in securities on commission basis. He claimed that he had never met Devendra Rai or Hemlata Hankare personally nor advised them for share trading. However, it is pertinent to note that when asked to produce a copy of the remisiery agreement or evidence regarding the same, Sunil Mehta failed to do so. It is also noted that Devendra Rai has given a statement before the IA to the effect that his account was opened by Manish Mathur and Sunil Mehta in return for monthly cash income. The findings of the investigation indicate that the trades made through the trading account of Devendra Rai were with the same broker and in the same scrips as the trades admittedly executed by Sunil Mehta on behalf of Sitanshu Nanawati. This leads to the conclusion that the trades in the account of Devendra Rai were executed by Sunil Mehta. Therefore, Sunil Mehta's contention that he did not know Devendra Rai or Hemlata Hankare and did not operate their accounts cannot be accepted.
(xiii) The statements of several persons, including those of Renu Paliwal (one of the noticees), Janak Shah and Praveen Kulkarni strongly indicate that Sunil Mehta opened a trading terminal at Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd., a broker, for another of his friends, Suresh Hanswal, who then executed orders for the client Renu Paliwal (also known to Sunil Mehta) in several structured and manipulative trades in the selected scrips.
(Xiv) I also note from the findings of investigation detailed in the SCN that Sunil Mehta transferred shares in the scrip of SAT (one of the selected scrips) in off-market deals. Sunil Mehta transferred 25000, 2300, 60000 and 10000 shares on March 05, 2009, March 05, 2009, March 28, 2009 and April 02, 2009 respectively from his demat account to Suresh Hanswal's demat account. Suresh Hanswal had ultimately offloaded these shares in the market after buying and selling for a few days through the broker, Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. Fund flows to Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. have been traced to Suresh Hanswal and ultimately to Sunil Mehta.
(xv) Forensic analysis of the handwriting of Sunil Mehta by Truthlabs, Hyderabad has confirmed that the handwriting on the cheques issued by Jitendra Jain and Usha Mehta to the respective brokers, DD making form of DD issued to Bharat Jain from the bank account of Jitendra Jain and cash deposit slips in the bank accounts of Anjana Mehta, Jitendra Jain, Usha Mehta and Hemlata Hankare is that of Sunil Mehta.
(xvi) The conduct of Sunil Mehta during investigation has revealed inconsistencies and successive denials followed by admissions when confronted with evidence such as forensic analysis of handwriting or call records. For example, even though Sunil Mehta initially appeared to have been reluctant to reply to the queries regarding his alleged association with Jitendra Jain and denied any knowledge of bank account transactions with Jitendra Jain, on being confronted with cash cheque deposit slips, vouchers of making DDs favouring Bharat Jain from the bank account of Jitendra Jain and cheques issued from the bank account of Jitendra Jain, Sunil Mehta admitted that Jitendra Jain was his friend and that they held a joint bank account and jointly operated a trading account. Sunil Mehta was not only executing orders on behalf of Jitendra Jain, but also used Jitendra Jain's bank account as a conduit for fund transfers, which in turn indicate that Jitendra Jain acted as a front entity for Sunil Mehta.
(xvii) Similarly, Sunil Mehta initially denied knowing Praveen Kulkarni, Janak Shah, Dhananjay Upadhyaya (Director of broker Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd.), Rashmi Gandhi, Ramesh Gandhi, Devendra Rai, Bhavesh Kothari and Praveen Gate but later accepted the same.
(xviii) It is also noted that, contradicting his earlier statement, Sunil Mehta accepted that he knew Praveen Gate as the trading account of his mother Usha Mehta was opened in Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. through him. It is further observed that the trading accounts of Jitendra Jain and Hemlata Hankare, whose accounts were used by Sunil Mehta, were opened with brokers where Praveen Gate was an employee.
(xix) Sunil Mehta operated the trading accounts of Usha Mehta (as admitted by him) and Shaikh Jainuddin (as evidenced by the fact that Praveen Gate assisted both of them in opening trading accounts with Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. on the same day), which were then used for manipulative trades in the selected scrips. Although Sunil Mehta has denied knowing Shaikh Jainuddin or placing orders for him, it is noted that orders for Shaikh Jainuddin and Usha Mehta were being placed from the same IP address, location etc. for many days. Therefore, it is a logical inference that Sunil Mehta was involved in execution of trades for Shaikh Jainuddin as well. Sunil Mehta's admission that the trading account of Usha Mehta was opened through Praveen Gate, coupled with the statement of Praveen Gate, Ramesh Gandhi and Shaikh Jainuddin, indicates that Praveen Gate facilitated the opening of the account of Shaikh Jainuddin and other entities at the behest of Sunil Mehta.
(xx) Sunil Mehta had earlier accepted knowing Renu Paliwal but later denied it in his letter dated June 10, 2013. However, it is noted that the demat account of Renu Paliwal with ISJ Securities was introduced by Sunil Mehta himself and the mobile number mentioned on the KYC documents of Renu Paliwal with the broker India Capital Markets Pvt. Ltd. is also that of Sunil Mehta. Further, persons related to Sunil Mehta introduced Renu Paliwal to different brokers. I also note that orders for Renu Paliwal were entered at the trading terminals of the brokers Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd. and Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd., which were both managed and operated by Suresh Hanswal, who is stated to be a friend and associate of Sunil Mehta. Therefore, it is clear that Sunil Mehta knew Renu Paliwal and used her trading account to execute manipulate trades in the selected scrips.
(xxi) Sunil Mehta was found to be depositing cash in the bank accounts of Anjana Mehta, Usha Mehta, Jitendra Jain, and Hemlata Hankare, which were in turn found to have been used for executing the trades in the said scrips. Sunil Mehta admitted in his replies dated February 28, 2012 and June 10, 2013 that he deposited cash in the bank accounts of Hemlata Hankare, Jitendra Jain, Anjana Mehta and Usha Mehta and he also admitted before the IA that the cash was used for payments made to brokers. There were no other significant transactions in the bank accounts of Anjana Mehta, Usha Mehta, Jitendra Jain, and Hemlata Hankare other than cash deposits and transfers to the brokers. It is also noted that Sunil Mehta did not disclose the source of the cash inflow.
(xxii) It is observed that one Mr. Janak Shah and Praveen Kulkarni introduced Sunil Mehta to the director of Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd. Subsequently, on Sunil Mehta's assurance, Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd. had opened a trading terminal at Udaipur to be operated Sunil Mehta's friend Suresh Hanswal. It is also observed that the sole trading client from the terminals of Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd. (managed by his friend Suresh Hanswal) was Renu Paliwal (wife of the close friend of Sunil Mehta) and she was found to have traded in the said scrips by placing orders which were matched with the orders of other entities linked to Sunil Mehta. Further, I note that in one of her statements before the IA Renu Paliwal has accused Sunil Mehta of trading in her account. Therefore, it is observed that Suresh Hanswal and Sunil Mehta were executed manipulative trades on behalf of Renu Paliwal in the selected scrips.
(xxiii) I note that several of the noticees whose accounts were found to have been operated by Sunil Mehta and his associates through internet trading did not have the financial ability or the knowledge and experience to do trading. Further, cash transfers that was seen to the respective stockbrokers by such entities was beyond their financial capacity. In view of the above, a mere denial by Sunil Mehta, in respect of the transactions carried out by using the trading accounts of the noticees for the manipulation, cannot outweigh the logical inferences drawn from various facts and circumstances and the statements made by the noticees that their accounts have been operated by Sunil Mehta and his associates as mentioned above.
(xxiv) The facts and circumstances discussed above make it clear that Sunil Mehta orchestrated the whole scheme of manipulation in the selected scrips, with the aid and assistance of his associates namely, Anjana Mehta, Praveen Gate, Manish Mathur, Suresh Hanswal, Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare, Ajay Roongta, Naresh Rajawat, Bharat Jain, Hitesh Jain and Bhavesh Kothari, who was in turn was assisted and aided by Rakesh Jain and Bhavesh Jain. Together they used the trading accounts of front entities/name lenders promising them cash benefits and profit in return.
(xxv) The main contention of Sunil Mehta in his letter dated June 10, 2013 is that he carried out trades in the accounts of Anjana Mehta, Usha Mehta, and his friends Jitendra Jain, Seema Mathur and Hemlata Hankare either because they were family, or because as friends they requested him to do so on account of some difficulties. I find that this does not exonerate him from the charge of using their accounts, amongst others', to execute fraudulent and manipulate trades in the selected scrips in the relevant period as brought out in the SCN.
(xxvi) Therefore, I find that Sunil Mehta facilitated the opening of trading accounts, and also operated the trading accounts of several persons belonging to the group of the noticees, as described above. The SCN based on the investigation report reveals that these accounts were used for executing synchronized, structured or circular trades in the selected scrips. These trades impacted the price and volume of the selected scrips to generate a false impression of trading because there was no intention to change the beneficial ownership of the shares bought and sold. The relationship amongst the noticees coupled with the evidence relating to fund flows and operation of various trading accounts by Sunil Mehta further establish the prior understanding of manipulation amongst Sunil Mehta and noticees who were actively and knowingly associated with Sunil Mehta and his manipulative share transactions. Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Sunil Mehta with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that regulation 4(2)(f) of the FUTP Regulations pertaining to “publishing or causing to publish or reporting or causing to report by a person dealing in securities any information which is not true or which he does not believe to be true prior to or in the course of dealing in securities” does not apply to Sunil Mehta.
(II) ANJANA MEHTA
(i) Anjana Mehta has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. In her statement before the IA she had averred that she is a housewife and had no idea about trading. She admitted that her trading accounts were opened and operated by her husband Sunil Mehta. Further regarding the introduction of clients like Hemlata Hankare and Devendra Rai to brokers, she stated that she had signed the documents on the advice of her husband, Sunil Mehta, who might have known them.
(ii) Anjana Mehta further stated that the SCN does not bring out any substantial relationship between herself and any of the noticees. However, I note that she knowingly and admittedly permitted her trading account to be used by her husband Sunil Mehta. She also appears to have introduced some of the noticees like Devendra Rai and Hemlata Hankare to the broker Networth Stock Broking Ltd. with whom she has claimed to have worked as business associate. However, the trading accounts of these noticees on whose KYC forms she appears as compulsory reference/introducer have also been used in manipulative or structured trading executed by Sunil Mehta or his associates in the selected scrips, as seen subsequently in this order. In her own trading account as well, structured trades were noticed, for example, on April 6, 2009 in the scrip of SAT, where Anjana Mehta placed a buy order for 525 shares and the counterparty Suresh Hanswal (friend of her husband Sunil Mehta) placed sell orders for smaller numbers of shares in immediate succession after Anjana Mehta's buy order, which ultimately added up to 525 shares. This indicates a meeting of minds between known parties for execution of structured trades, with distortion of price/volumes of the scrip as the only objective.
(iii) Movement of funds from her bank accounts also appear to indicate substantial payments and receipts to and from brokers, and many payments to brokers are alleged to have been made immediately after cash deposits were made in her bank account. She also allegedly received cash deposits from Sunil Mehta and Ajay Roongta (another noticee who has been found to be known to Sunil Mehta and carried out manipulative trades in the selected scrips) and transferred funds to the bank account of Seema Mathur, in whose trading account structured and manipulative trades were then carried out by Sunil Mehta. This indicates that Anjana Mehta was a willing accomplice to the structured trades executed by Sunil Mehta and his associates amongst the noticees.
(iv) Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Anjana Mehta with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(III) USHA MEHTA
(i) Usha Mehta, mother of Sunil Mehta, has also been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) & (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. She had an online trading account with the broker Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. She has also been found to have traded through the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. She has been observed to have executed structured trades with counterparties who have been linked to Sunil Mehta. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in her trading account was 33,209 in the scrip of SAT. For instance, in the scrip of SAT on August 13, 2009, Usha Mehta placed a sell order for 2500 shares at Rs. 29.70, which was matched with successive sell orders immediately placed by Renu Paliwal (whose account was seen to have been operated by Suresh Hanswal, friend of Sunil Mehta) for 1200 shares and 1300 shares. Therefore, there appears to have been no intention to transfer the beneficial ownership of the shares. Rather, an attempt appears to have been made to generate false volumes and manipulate the price of the scrip.
(ii) Evidence regarding handwriting on cash deposit slips and cheques issued from her bank account to brokers having been identified as that of Sunil Mehta has already been examined. There is also evidence of money having been deposited in Usha Mehta's joint bank account with Sunil Mehta immediately before payment being made for that account to brokers for pay-in obligations related to trading in her demat account, and the SCN details instances illustrating the same. For instance, on June 29, 2009 and November 22, 2009, cash deposits of Rs. One lakh and two lakhs respectively were seen to have been made in her bank account, which was immediately transferred to her brokers Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. and Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. vide cheque, towards her pay-in obligations.
(iii) Sunil Mehta himself has admitted to trading in Usha Mehta's account. During the hearing before me on June 7, 2013, the Advocate Mr. Rajesh Khandelwal appearing for Usha Mehta submitted that her son Sunil Mehta had traded in her account and that she had no knowledge of misuse of her trading account. In view of the facts heretofore discussed, I find that Usha Mehta permitted her trading account to be used by her son Sunil Mehta for executing structured and manipulative trades, and that even her bank account was used as a conduit for funds traced to Sunil Mehta.
(v) Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Usha Mehta with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(IV) JITENDRA JAIN
(i) Jitendra Jain has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading accounts was 41,10,420 in the scrip of MVL, as detailed in the SCN. There are instances where trading in Jitendra Jain's account has been found to have been co-ordinated with a counterparty related to Sunil Mehta in such a way that a sell order placed by the counterparty got matched with buy orders placed by Jitendra Jain. For example, on March 6, 2009 in the scrip of KSL a sell order was found to have been placed for 1500 shares by Bharat Jain, which matched with the buy order for 2000 shares placed by Jitendra Jain at the same price at exactly the same time. The pending 500 shares in Jitendra Jain's buy order were then immediately matched with a sell order for 500 shares by Bharat Jain. Sunil Mehta had transferred funds to Bharat Jain using Jitendra Jain's bank account. The other structured trade transactions from Jitendra Jain's trading account are mentioned in the SCN.
(iii) Jitendra Jain is also observed to have executed several circular trades with various counterparties known to Sunil Mehta. For instance, the SCN provides details regarding circular trades which took place on March 6, 2009 in the scrip of KSL, wherein Jitendra Jain, Renu Paliwal and Bharat Jain were found to have bought and sold 2000 shares in such a way that there was no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. The circular trades merely served to create a false impression of trading in the said scrip.
(iv) Jitendra Jain has received funds from Sunil Mehta, Hemlata Hankare and Suresh Hanswal in his bank accounts, and the funds were used for meeting his pay-in obligations with brokers. Although his annual income was observed to be less than Rs. One lakh, an amount of more than Rs. 1 crore was credited into Jitendra Jain's bank accounts in 2009, and most of the transactions were receipts from persons connected to Sunil Mehta. The amount thus credited was used for making payments to brokers in fulfilment of pay-in obligations pertaining to transactions in the selected scrips. The handwriting on many of the deposit slips and cheques belonged to Sunil Mehta, thus establishing without doubt the direct link between Sunil Mehta and Jitendra Jain. Therefore, it becomes evident that Jitendra Jain was acting in close association with Sunil Mehta and persons amongst the noticees to execute structured and circular trades which ultimately impacted the prices and volumes of the selected scrips.
(v) Jitendra Jain did not respond to summons issued by the IA and did not avail the opportunity of the personal hearing granted to him. The facts and circular trades in the selected scrips, and permitted his bank account to be used as a conduit for transfer of funds by and to Sunil Mehta, for the purpose of executing the structured and manipulative trades indulged in by the noticees.
(vi) Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Jitendra Jain with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(V) HEMLATA HANKARE
(i) Hemlata Hankare has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) & (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in her trading account amounted to as much as 2689173 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the other structured trades executed from her trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. One of the structured trades executed in her account was in the scrip of Allcargo on March 2, 2009 where Renu Paliwal placed a buy order for 450 shares while Hemlata Hankare almost immediately placed a sell order for 500 shares at the same price, with Renu Paliwal then immediately placing a buy order for the 50 shares pending from the sell order of Hemlata Hankare.
(iii) Instances of circular trades involving Hemlata Hankare have also been illustrated in the SCN. On September 7, 2009, Hemlata Hankare sold 4150 shares of Lotus, which were then bought and sold by Sitanshu Nanawati, Rashmi Gandhi and Rakesh Jain, and ultimately bought by Hemlata Hankare, ensuring that there was no change in the beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. This contributed to price maintenance and volume inflation in the selected scrips including the scrip of Lotus.
(iv) The SCN also records evidence regarding use of Hemlata Hankare's bank accounts as conduits for transfer of funds by Sunil Mehta to various brokers like Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. and PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. to fulfil pay-in obligations of Hemlata Hankare, or to other persons from amongst the noticees, like Jitendra Jain or Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. who were related to Sunil Mehta. Funds amounting to more than Rs. Eighty lakhs were transferred to the various bank accounts of Hemlata Hankare and were mainly either transfers to persons related to Sunil Mehta or to brokers for meeting pay-in obligations. As noted during the discussion of the role of Jitendra Jain earlier in this order, Hemlata Hankare was found to have transferred money to Jitendra Jain's bank account which was then used to meet pay-in obligations of brokers.
(v) Hemlata Hankare did not reply to the SCN or attend the personal hearing.
(vi) In view of the facts discussed above, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Hemlata Hankare with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(VI) MANISH MATHUR
(i) Manish Mathur has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) & (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e), (f) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Manish Mathur executed structured trades in the scrip of Mavens on August 12, 2009, whereby he placed a sell order for 4000 shares at Rs. 103.10 Immediately thereafter, Sitanshu Nanawati placed a buy order for 3500 shares at the same price which got matched and executed. The sell order for the pending 500 shares was then matched with a corresponding buy order from Sitanshu Nanawati's trading account. The nature of the trades suggests that they were synchronized trades. Structured trades for upto 36530 shares in the scrip of Mavens alone were executed in the trading account of Manish Mathur. Details of the structured trade volumes in the other scrips are provided in the SCN.
(iii) Circular trades involving the trading account of Manish Mathur have also been mentioned in the SCN. It has been observed that Manish Mathur sold 500 shares of Allcargo on July 29, 2009, which were then immediately bought and sold by Jitendra Jain and Hemlata Hankare, and ultimately bought by Manish Mathur himself, in such a way that there was effectively no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day.
(iv) As per Sunil Mehta's own replies, Manish Mathur is his friend and he operated Manish Mathur's wife's trading account at his insistence. Manish Mathur was the Chief Operating Officer of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. The trades through the trading accounts (client and proprietary) in which Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. placed orders, were often structured/synchronised with trades in accounts of counterparties who were connected to Sunil Mehta. It was found that money amounting to more than Rs. Four lakhs was received from Sunil Mehta and Jitendra Jain (whose trading and bank accounts were being handled by Sunil Mehta, as observed earlier) in Manish Mathur's father one Shri Gopal Lal Mathur's bank account - in several unexplained transactions, which in the facts and circumstances of the case can be inferred as remuneration for assisting Sunil Mehta in the execution of the manipulative trades in the selected scrips. Manish Mathur also admitted before the IA that he operated his father Gopal Lal Mathur's trading account.
(v) Manish Mathur's name also appears in the KYC form of Hemlata Hankare with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd. As mentioned in this order, Devendra Rai and Hemlata Hankare are noticees whose trading accounts were used for executing manipulative trades in the selected scrips.
(vi) In his reply dated March 12, 2012 to the SCN, Manish Mathur has claimed that he did not know Hemlata Hankare and that he was only introduced to her husband, one Mr. Ramesh Hankare, as the latter was an employee of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. and met him once for salary. However, I note that the SCN also mention that money was transferred from Hemlata Hankare's bank account to that of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. (Rs. 4 lakhs were transferred vide cheque dated October 21, 2009). There are no records of a satisfactory explanation of this transaction by Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. or Manish Mathur. I also note that off-market transfer of shares amounting to Rs. 5 lakhs were made from the demat account of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. to that of Hemlata Hankare. These facts indicate a definite relationship between Manish Mathur and Hemlata Hankare. Therefore, I find the contentions of Manish Mathur in this regard unacceptable.
(vii) The SCN also mentions that Sunil Mehta has stated that he had introduced Renu Paliwal, another of the noticees whose trading account was used for manipulative trades in the selected scrips, to Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. as his friend Manish Mathur was the Chief Operating Officer of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd.
(viii) Manish Mathur has also denied knowing Devendra Rai or using his account for executing trades. However, the facts and circumstances mentioned in the SCN indicate that the counterparty clients with reference to the trades executed from Devendra Rai's trading account have been found to have been related to Manish Mathur and Sunil Mehta. Sunil Mehta has also admitted that he placed orders in the trading account of Seema Mathur, wife of Manish Mathur, on being requested to do so by Manish Mathur. In view of the same, Manish Mathur's averments cannot be accepted.
(ix) Manish Mathur also denied knowing Sunil Mehta closely. However, this fact is controverted by Sunil Mehta's admissions, and the fact that Sunil Mehta used to place orders in Manish Mathur's wife's trading account as well. It is pertinent to note here that Manish Mathur also stated during the hearing on May 8, 2013 that Sunil Mehta is his friend, and that the latter had misused Manish Mathur's name in the various manipulative trades alleged in the SCN.
(x) Without losing sight of the fact that the trading accounts in which Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. (of which Manish Mathur was the Chief Operating Officer) was placing orders were also found to be counterparties in a series of synchronized/structured trades in the selected scrips, I note that the structured and circular trades executed in Manish Mathur's account contributed to the manipulative trades executed in the accounts of the noticees, which led to price/volume manipulation in the selected scrips. The evidence indicates that Manish Mathur has actively and knowingly colluded with Sunil Mehta to obtain clients whose accounts were then used for manipulating trading. The trading accounts of some of the clients were even operated by him or his firm for executing manipulative trades in the selected scrips. Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Manish Mathur with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that regulation 4(2)(f) of the FUTP Regulations pertaining to “publishing or causing to publish or reporting or causing to report by a person dealing in securities any information ivhich is not true or ivhich he does not believe to be true prior to or in the course of dealing in securities” does not apply to Manish Mathur.
(VII) SEEMA MATHUR
(i) Seema Mathur has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b),
(c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) She is found to have traded through the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in her trading account was as high as 78998 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the other structured trades executed from her trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on August 6, 2009 in the scrip of Ushdev, Seema Mathur placed a sell order for 2000 shares at Rs. 130.40, which matched with two successive buy orders by Hemlata Hankare for 1800 shares and 200 shares at the same price, which indicated manipulative trading and impacted the volume and price of the scrip of Ushdev.
(iii) Instances of circular trades involving Seema Mathur have also been illustrated in the SCN. For example, on September 1, 2009, Seema Mathur was a part of a circular trade transaction where 2500 shares of KSL sold by her were bought and sold by Hemlata Hankare and Rashmi Gandhi to ultimately be bought by Seema Mathur herself, ensuring that there was no change in the beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. This contributed to price maintenance and volume inflation in the selected scrips including the scrip of KSL.
(iv) Vide his letter dated June 10, 2013, Sunil Mehta has also admitted to placing orders in Seema Mathur's account under the instructions of Manish Mathur. Further, it has been observed that Rs. 95000 were transferred to her bank account by Anjana Mehta. Vide her replies dated July 5, 2011 and March 1, 2012 Seema Mathur has claimed that she has been involved in the matter only because she is Manish Mathur's wife, and that Rs. 95000/- were given to her by Ms. “Anju Metha” as repayment of friendly loan. The various deposits in Seema Mathur's bank account were then used to make payments to the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd., and Sunil Mehta was found to have accepted contract notes of Seema Mathur, which were sent to his address.
(v) In the light of the evidence available, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Seema Mathur with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(VIII) DEVENDRA RAI
(i) Devendra Rai has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a),(b) and (c) of in his statement before the IA, Devendra Rai said that he earns a monthly income of Rs. 3000/- by fixing aluminum sliding windows for a living and is not familiar with the internet. However, he stated that he knew Mr. Dinanath Dubey, who worked in the same firm, Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd., of which Manish Mathur was the Chief Operating Officer. This is supported by the fact that Dinanath Dubey is indeed mentioned as a compulsory reference for Devendra Rai with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd. He mentioned that he had met Manish Mathur in the office of the abovesaid firm, and Manish Mathur had told him about a scheme of investment proposed by Sunil Mehta, where if a person opened a trading account with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd., and allowed Sunil Mehta or Manish Mathur to use the same, he would be given monthly cash income and margin requirements of the broker would also be met for him. He admitted receiving Rs. 1,00,000/- cash from Manish Mathur for margin money to be given to Networth Stock Brokers Ltd. Anjana Mehta is the authorised representative for Devendra Rai's trading account with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd.
(ii) It is observed from the SCN that Devendra Rai's trading account was used for structured and manipulative trades. To illustrate, a buy order for 2500 shares at Rs. 25.50 in the scrip of KBS was placed on November 18, 2009 in Devendra Rai's trading account, which matched with smaller successive orders placed at the same price by Shaikh Jainuddin (another of the noticees) which ultimately added up to 2500 shares, ensuring that there was no intention to transfer beneficial ownership, and that the trading was intended to manipulate price and volume in the scrip of KBS. A summary of trading details of Devendra Rai within group comprising the noticees is mentioned in the SCN. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading account was as high as 394892 in the scrip of MVL.
(iii) I note that Devendra Rai did not attend the personal hearing.
(iv) In view of the facts before me, I find that since Devendra Rai permitted his trading account return for monetary benefits, he cannot avoid responsibility for the misuse of his account in execution of structured trades.
(v) Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Devendra Rai with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A (a),(b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(IX) SURESH HANSWAL
(i) Suresh Hanswal has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. He is stated to have been the terminal operator and manager both at Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd. and Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. at Udaipur. Investigation had revealed that Suresh Hanswal assisted Sunil Mehta in operating the trading account of Renu Paliwal, who was the sole trading client for the trading terminal operated by Suresh Hanswal, and from whose from whose account structured and manipulative trades were executed in the selected scrips. Suresh Hanswal also placed manipulative orders through the trading terminals of both the abovementioned brokers, in the trading accounts of Renu Paliwal, Jitendra Jain and himself. Details of the structured trades thus executed by Suresh Hanswal are provided in Annexures 7 and 8 of the SCN. For instance, the number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading accounts was as high as 17332 in the scrip of SAT. In the scrip of SAT on April 6, 2009, Anjana Mehta placed a buy order for 525 shares at Rs. 15.20 Within a few seconds thereafter, Suresh Hanswal was found to have placed successive sell orders adding up to 525 shares at the same price. Similarly, circular trades involving the trading account of Suresh Hanswal were observed on May 7, 2009 in the scrip of KSL where 1000 shares were sold by Hemlata and subsequently bought and sold by Jitendra Jain, Suresh Hanswal, Renu Paliwal and Rashmi Gandhi to ultimately be bought by Hemlata Hankare herself. These trades clearly appear to have been intended to generate false volumes and manipulate the price of the scrip rather than effect a transfer of beneficial ownership of the shares.
(ii) Fund flows substantiate the connection between Jitendra Jain and Suresh Hanswal, as well as between Sunil Mehta and Suresh Hanswal. There is evidence to indicate that Suresh Hanswal knew Jitendra Jain and funded some of his transactions in the selected scrips during the Investigation Period. For instance, on May 12, 2009, Rs. 300000/- was transferred from account number 01191000085001 of Vidya Gaur and Suresh Hanswal vide cheque number 0090060 dated May 12, 2009 to the account of Jitendra Jain. This sum was immediately transferred to the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. (bank account number 00600140000168) towards his pay-in obligation on the same day vide cheque number 0043433 dated March 12, 2009. It has also been observed that payments made by Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. to the abovementioned joint bank account of Vidya Gaur and Suresh Hanswal on March 9, 12 and 21, 2009 were transferred to Sunil Mehta's bank account (HDFC Kandivali bank a/c no. 01821000057910) on March 12, 13 and 23, 2009. Funds were also received from Jitendra Jain's HDFC Kandivali bank (account number 01821000069637) to the above bank account of Vidya Gaur/Suresh Hanswal on February 21, 2009 vide cheque number 0953074. From the details mentioned in the SCN it is also clear that this same amount was then transferred to the broker Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. on February 25, 2009 vide cheque number 0042123.
(iii) Further, as mentioned earlier, Suresh Hanswal helped Sunil Mehta offload the shares of SAT.
(iv) No replies to the SCN have been received from Suresh Hanswal, and he did not attend the personal hearing.
(v) In the light of the facts discussed above, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Suresh Hanswal with respect to violation of regulation 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(X) RENU PALIWAL
(i) Renu Paliwal has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Renu Paliwal has traded through the brokers Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd. and Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in her trading account was as high as 422407 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the structured trades executed from her trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. As mentioned earlier in this order, for instance, on March 2, 2009 structured trades were executed in the scrip of Allcargo from her trading account with Hemlata Hankare as counterparty.
(iii) Instances of circular trades involving Renu Paliwal have also been illustrated in the SCN. In the scrip of KSL on March 6, 2009, Renu Paliwal was a part of a circular trade transaction where 2000 shares sold by Bharat Jain (one of the noticees associated with Sunil Mehta) were then bought and sold by Renu Paliwal and Jitendra Jain, and was ultimately bought by Bharat Jain, ensuring that there was no change in the beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day contributed to the manipulative trades executed in the accounts of the noticees, which led to price/volume manipulation in the selected scrips, including the scrip of KSL.
(iv) It has been seen from the SCN that Renu Paliwal was introduced to Arcadia Shares and Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. by Pradesh Nimawat who has been found to be a friend of Sunil Mehta. Also, Renu Paliwal and Sunil Mehta were introduced to the broker India Capital Markets Pvt. Ltd. by a common person, one Mr. Amit Joshi, and the mobile number mentioned on her KYC form with the said broker belonged to Sunil Mehta. Further, when opening a trading account with ISI Securities Pvt. Ltd., Renu Paliwal was introduced by Sunil Mehta and witnessed by Jitendra Jain and Suresh Hanswal. (two of the other noticees who were associated with Sunil Mehta).
(v) Renu Paliwal's father-in-law made a statement before the IA that his son Madhusudan Paliwal was a friend of Sunil Mehta, and that Sunil Mehta had come to him with KYC forms of Triveni Management Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. to open his trading account. This is corroborated by Renu Paliwal's own statements before the IA that Sunil Mehta, a friend of her husband Madhusudan Paliwal, had advised her to sign some forms and give him some cheques in order to earn profit in the stock market. I also note that Renu Paliwal was the sole trading client for the trading terminal operated by Suresh Hanswal (friend of Sunil Mehta) with Ramniklal Mohanlal Capital Markets Ltd.
(vi) As per the SCN, Renu Paliwal's bank account statements reveal that no payments were made to the brokers through whom Renu Paliwal traded. This fact viewed in the light of other evidence examined above clearly indicates that someone else was making payments to enable trading in Renu Paliwal's account; in other words, that her account was being used by another person.
(vii) In her replies dated May 23, 2012 and February 21, 2013 to the SCN, Renu Paliwal has stated that none of the alleged trades mentioned in the SCN were executed by her, and that she only agreed to sign the various forms as suggested by Sunil Mehta on his persistence. She has admitted that she allowed Sunil Mehta to open and operate her trading accounts on her behalf. From the charges with respect to Sunil Mehta and Suresh Hanswal as discussed earlier, it has already been observed that evidence in the matter indicates that they had operated Renu Paliwal's trading account for executing manipulative trades in the selected scrips, and Renu Paliwal was paid money in return for the use of her trading account. This indicates that Renu Paliwal permitted the use of her trading account by third parties for monetary compensation, contributing to the manipulative trading in the selected scrips. Therefore I find that there is enough evidence of the fact that Renu Paliwal's trading accounts were used by Sunil Mehta for executing manipulative trades in the selected scrips.
(viii) Thus, ssin view of the facts discussed above, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Renu Paliwal with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XI) BHARAT JAIN
(i) Bharat Jain has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Bharat Jain was found to have traded through the broker Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading account was as high as 77339 in the scrip of Ushdev alone. The SCN details the structured trades executed from his trading account in the selected scrips. For instance, in the scrip of KSL on March 6, 2009, Bharat Jain placed a sell order for 1500 shares at Rs. 129.45, which got matched with a buy order by Jitendra Jain for 2000 shares at the same price. The buy order for 500 shares remained pending briefly, till Bharat Jain again placed a sell order for 500 shares within a few seconds, at the same price. Circular trades involving the trading account of Bharat Jain have also been noticed in the scrip of KSL, for instance, on March 6, 2009, when 2000 shares sold by Bharat Jain were bought by Jitendra Jain, who then sold 1000 shares back to Bharat Jain, and the remaining 1000 shares to Renu Paliwal, who in turn sold the shares to Bharat Jain himself. These trades clearly indicated that there was no intention to transfer the beneficial ownership of the shares; rather the intention appears to have been to generate artificial volumes and manipulate prices in the scrip.
(iii) In an instance where prices in the scrip of Allcargo were seen to have been manipulated it is noted that on March 24, 2009 when several buy and sell orders were pending at different prices, Bharat Jain was found to have placed a sell order for 270 shares at Rs. 703, which was executed. Immediately thereafter, he placed a buy order for just one share at Rs. 713.95, which got matched with a pending sell order at the same price, and raised the price of the scrip by Rs. 10.95 Selling shares at a lower price and buying them at a higher price calls into question the bonafides of the transaction.
(iv) Various cash and cheque deposit slips and demand draft vouchers transferring funds from the bank account of Jitendra Jain to that of Bharat Jain and bearing the handwriting of Sunil Mehta, were found during investigation. Therefore, a link between Bharat Jain and Sunil Mehta has been established.
(v) No reply to the SCN has been received from Bharat Jain, and he did not appear during the personal hearing granted to the noticees.
(vi) In view of the foregoing, I find that Bharat Jain placed orders for trades which were circular or structured and synchronized with corresponding manipulative orders placed in the trading accounts of other persons connected to Sunil Mehta.
(vii) Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Bharat Jain with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XII) PRAVEEN GATE
(i) Praveen Gate has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) As discussed earlier, Praveen Gate worked with brokers like PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd., Inventure Growth and Securities Pvt. Ltd. and Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. on commission basis. Praveen Gate introduced and opened the trading accounts of various clients like Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare, Rashmi Gandhi and Usha Mehta at the behest of Sunil Mehta. Further, he has been found to have opened the trading account of Shaikh Jainuddin on the directions of Bhavesh Kothari, with brokers like PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd., Inventure Growth and Securities Pvt. Ltd. and Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. The clients often used to handover cheques issued in the name of the respective brokers to Praveen Gate. Further, Praveen Gate performed the in-person verification for Jitendra Jain and Hemlata Hankare.
(iii) The statements of many of the noticees corroborate the above facts in respect of the important role played by Praveen Gate, who acted as per the instructions of Sunil Mehta. For instance, Bhavesh Kothari has stated that Sunil Mehta used to send him cash through Praveen Gate, which he then used to distribute to the clients, whose trading accounts were being used by Sunil Mehta. In the course of investigation, Sunil Mehta also admitted to knowing Praveen Gate.
(iv) Vide his reply dated April 12, 2012 Praveen Gate stated that he has worked for PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. since 2008 and has assisted in account opening and has introduced many clients. He has stated that he did not manage the accounts and was not involved in any cash transactions. In the oral submissions made before me during the personal hearing on May 7, 2013, Praveen Gate reiterated his submissions made in his reply dated April 12, 2012.
(v) However, I note that the SCN also alleges that Praveen Gate helped Sunil Mehta to open trading accounts of outstation clients in Mumbai by doing fake in-person verification. His phone number has been used as contact number on many of the KYC forms, for instance, in the cases of Shaikh Jainuddin and Sitanshu Nanawati.
(vi) The facts discussed above indicate that Praveen Gate was actually assisting Sunil Mehta in obtaining the trading accounts of different persons, in return for commission, in order to allow Sunil Mehta to use these trading accounts for manipulative transactions.
(vii) In view of the foregoing, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Praveen Gate with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XIII) BHAVESH KOTHARI
(i) Bhavesh Kothari has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e), (f) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Bhavesh Kothari operated a terminal as a sub-broker (viz. Money Magnet Securities Ltd.) of India Capital Markets Pvt. Ltd. While examining the relationships amongst the noticees in paragraph 12. (xx) of this order it has been seen that Rakesh Jain and Bhavesh Jain, two of the noticees who were alleged to have indulged in manipulative trading in the selected scrips during Investigation Period 1 and 2, had stated that Bhavesh Kothari had got their trading accounts opened through Praveen Gate (another of the noticees) and had offered monthly income and cash benefits in return. Bhavesh Jain also stated that he paid Rs. 150000/- to Rakesh Jain's broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. and Rs. 100000/- to Rakesh Jain for opening the trading accounts of Rakesh Jain and Shaikh Jainuddin respectively. Bhavesh Kothari was also the compulsory reference for Sitanshu Nanawati in his KYC form with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd., and has been found to have opened and operated his trading account in return for cash benefits. Bhavesh Kothari is stated to have funded the trading which took place from the trading account of Sitanshu Nanawati.
(iii) The SCN makes it very clear that Bhavesh Kothari was the common introducer for Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain, Kunal Kothari and Sweta Kothari, and that his employee, one Mr. Sagar Mistry, had introduced Neela Khicha to brokers. Further, the statement of one Piyush Khicha and also of Naresh Rajawat serve to corroborate the above, and also to establish that Bhavesh Kothari traded in the accounts of other noticees.
(iv) Bhavesh Kothari himself has admitted in his reply dated March 01, 2012 and later during the hearing before me on June 14, 2013, that he requested some of his friends and relatives to open trading accounts with him and allowed these accounts to be used by Sunil Mehta in return for Rs. 1000/- per account per month. He has also admitted that he had carried out the trades in the accounts of eleven persons, namely, Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain, Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari, Sweta Kothari, Pawanben Jain, Neela Khicha, Kamlesh Jain, Pradeep Kothari and Vinay Kothari, as per the instructions of Sunil Mehta, and that he seeks pardon for the same. In this regard it is pertinent to note that Sunil Mehta had admitted to a business relationship with Bhavesh Kothari, though he has not admitted to the monthly payments made to Bhavesh Kothari.
(v) The facts and circumstances discussed above make it very clear that Bhavesh Kothari played a key role in assisting Sunil Mehta in executing manipulative orders from his terminal as a sub-broker, as well as with respect to soliciting and obtaining trading accounts of persons who agreed to lend their accounts for manipulative trades. In view of the foregoing, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Bhavesh Kothari with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that regulation 4(2)(f) of the FUTP Regulations pertaining to “publishing or causing to publish or reporting or causing to report by a person dealing in securities any information which is not true or which he does not believe to be true prior to or in the course of dealing in securities” does not apply to Bhavesh Kothari.
(XIV) RAKESH JAIN
(i) Rakesh Jain has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e), (f) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Rakesh Jain was observed to be trading through the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading account is stated to be 11,37,278 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the structured trades executed from his trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, in the scrip of KBS on October 28, 2009, Meena Rajawat placed a buy order for 1500 shares at Rs. 23.10 Immediately afterwards and at the same price, Rakesh Jain placed a sell order for 1666 shares, and the pending sell order for 166 shares was matched shortly afterwards with a buy order placed by Meena Rajawat. This is one of the transactions indulged in by Rakesh Jain where the intention appears to have been only to manipulate price and create a false impression of trading in the scrip.
(iii) An instance of circular trading involving Rakesh Jain has already been discussed in the context of the role of Hemlata Hankare with respect to trading in the scrip of Lotus on September 7, 2009, where Hemlata Hankare sold 4150 shares of Lotus, which were then bought and sold by Sitanshu Nanawati, Rashmi Gandhi and Rakesh Jain, and ultimately bought by Hemlata Hankare, ensuring that there was no change in the beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. The circular trades contributed to the manipulation of volume and price in the scrip of Lotus.
(iv) Rakesh Jain has been observed to have opened Shaikh Jainuddin's trading account with Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd., and he also deposited cash in Shaikh Jainuddin's bank account. The money was transferred to Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd. for margin payments and deposits. Shaikh Jainuddin has also stated before the IA that Rakesh Jain had promised him a monthly cash income on opening of the account.
(v) Cash deposits and transfers into Rakesh Jain's bank account have been observed, followed by withdrawals on the same day and deposit of funds to the account of the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. Transfer of funds from Bhavesh Jain's bank account to that of Rakesh Jain have also been observed.
(vi) Rakesh Jain's statements before the IA indicated that he was educated upto the eighth standard and was not computer literate. He also stated that his friend Bhavesh Kothari got his trading account opened in return for monthly income of Rs. 2000/- paid in cash.
(vii) Vide his reply dated March 12, 2012 Rakesh Jain has stated that he was not aware of the trades taking place in his account, but that he allowed his account to be used by Sunil Mehta who he does not know personally but was referred to by Bhavesh Kothari.
(viii) The facts discussed above make it clear that Rakesh Jain permitted his trading account to be used for trades by third parties in return for monthly cash income. Further, the evidence also indicates that Rakesh Jain played an active role in facilitating opening of the trading account of Shaikh Jainuddin by promising monthly income. Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Rakesh Jain with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that regulation 4(2)(f) of the FUTP Regulations pertaining to “publishing or causing to publish or reporting or causing to report by a person dealing in securities any information which is not true or which he does not believe to be true prior to or in the course of dealing in securities” does not apply to Rakesh Jain.
(XV) BHAVESH JAIN
(i) Bhavesh Jain has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e), (f) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. As mentioned earlier, he is the brother of Rakesh Jain.
(ii) Bhavesh Jain's statements before the IA indicated that he operates a medical shop and has a monthly income Rs. 20000/-. He stated that he provided cash to his brother's account and knew that it was to be used for trading in stocks. Although he initially claimed that deposits of cash, including giving Rs. 100000/- to his brother Rakesh Jain to deposit in the account of Shaikh Jainuddin were from the sales receipts from his shop, he could not show proof of generation of such income from his shop. Further, he admitted that he knew Bhavesh Kothari, and that he allowed Bhavesh Kothari to open and operate his trading account in return for monthly cash income. This aspect, viewed in the context of other facts like the monthly income of Bhavesh Jain, make it evident that his bank accounts were being used as conduits for fund transfers to brokers for executing manipulative trades in the selected scrips, in collusion with persons connected with Sunil Mehta.
(iii) It has been observed that cash was deposited in his bank account immediately prior to making payments to his broker Systematrix Shares and Stock India Ltd. Further, it is noted that there have been instances of transfer of funds from his account to his brother Rakesh Jain's account, followed by equivalent cash deposits in Bhavesh Jain's account. Rakesh Jain stated before the IA that Bhavesh Jain gave him Rs. 150000 and Rs. 100000 to be paid to Rakesh Jain's broker and the Shaikh Jainuddin's broker, respectively.
(iv) Vide his reply dated March 12, 2012 Bhavesh Jain has stated that he was not aware of the trades taking place in his account, but that he allowed his account to be used by Sunil Mehta who he does not know personally but was referred to by Bhavesh Kothari.
(v) The facts discussed above make it clear that Bhavesh Jain permitted his trading account to be used for trades by third parties in return for monthly income in cash. The evidence also indicates that Bhavesh Jain played an active role in facilitating the Opening of the trading account of Shaikh Jainuddin opened. Further, Bhavesh Jain transferred money to his brother Rakesh Jain's account to be paid to the brokers of Rakesh Jain and Shaikh Jainuddin. Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Bhavesh Jain with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (d), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that regulation 4(2)(f) of the FUTP Regulations pertaining to “publishing or causing to publish or reporting or causing to report by a person dealing in securities any information which is not true or which he does not believe to be true prior to or in the course of dealing in securities” does not apply to Bhavesh Jain.
(XVI) HITESH JAIN
(XVII) KUNAL KOTHARI
(XVIII) SHOBHA KOTHARI
(XIX) SWETA KOTHARI
(i) Hitesh Jain, Shobha Kothari, Sweta Kothari and Kunal Kothari have been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Hitesh Jain is the nephew of Bhavesh Kothari, and has helped the latter to obtain the trading accounts of many of his relatives, including those of Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Sweta Kothari, for use by Sunil Mehta in the execution of manipulative and structured transactions.
(iii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in the trading accounts of Hitesh Jain, Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Sweta Kothari combined was 27700 in the scrip of Ushdev alone. The details of the other structured trades executed from their trading accounts in the other selected scrips, where orders placed in the trading accounts of Hitesh Jain, Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Sweta Kothari were matched with trades placed at the same price and time by counterparty clients from amongst the noticees, are provided in the SCN. For instance, in the scrip of Mavens, on May 5, 2009, Hitesh Jain placed a buy order for 1650 shares, which was matched with successive sell orders for 1000 shares and 650 shares placed in the trading account of Rashmi Gandhi as counterparty client. Similarly, on March 25, 2009, Kunal Kothari engaged in structured trades involving 3000 shares in the scrip of KSL, with Jitendra Jain as counterparty client. Structured trading pertaining to 670 shares was also observed in Shobha Kothari's trading account in the scrip of Mavens on May 19, 2009, with Rashmi Gandhi as counterparty client. Similarly, in the scrip of Panoramic on May 12, 2009, Sweta Kothari was seen to have carried out structured trades in relation to 1000 shares, with Alpesh Shah as the counterparty client.
(iv) Kunal Kothari, Sweta Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Hitesh Jain are also seen to have been involved in circular trades with persons from amongst the noticees on May 21, 2009, May 14, 2009, May 19, 2009 and May 4, 2009 in the scrips of Allcargo, KSL, Allcargo and again Allcargo respectively, as detailed in paragraph 12.0 of the SCN.
(v) Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Sweta Kothari, who are relatives of Hitesh Jain as explained earlier in this order, have stated before the IA that Hitesh Jain used to trade in their accounts, and the same had also been accepted by Hitesh Jain during the course of the investigation. Hitesh Jain admitted that he used to call his uncle Bhavesh Kothari upto four to five times a day for trading, and that he also used to take trading advice over the phone and place orders in the accounts of Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Sweta Kothari.
(vi) Kunal Kothari, in his reply dated March 09, 2012 stated that transactions in his trading account were carried out in the normal course of trading and do not constitute material part of the volumes under scrutiny. He has also sought permission to dispose of the shares which have been lying in his demat account. Vide her reply dated March 09, 2012, Shobha Kothari made the same submissions as Kunal Kothari, and has also sought permission to sell shares lying in her demat account. Sweta Kothari stated in her reply dated March 10, 2012 that the trades in her account were carried out by her brother-in-law Bhavesh Kothari and that she had no intention to commit fraud or manipulation.
(vii) However, during the personal hearing held on June 14, 2013, Hitesh Jain admitted that all trading and market dealings were done by Bhavesh Kothari and that Hitesh Jain was not aware of the trades being carried out in his account Sweta Kothari was represented by Bhavesh Kothari during the hearing on June 14, 2013, who admitted that he traded in the accounts of eleven of the noticees including the accounts of Kunal Kothari, Shobha Kothari and Sweta Kothari.
(viii) In view of the evidence before me, I find that Hitesh Jain, Shobha Kothari, Sweta Kothari and Kunal Kothari contributed to the structured and circular trades in the selected scrips during Investigation Periods 1 and 2, which impacted on volumes/prices of the said scrips. Hitesh Jain actively solicited clients for his uncle Bhavesh Kothari so that he could operate their trading accounts. These actions facilitated the execution of manipulative trades in the selected scrips by Sunil Mehta and persons connected with him. Shobha Kothari, Sweta Kothari and Kunal Kothari, on the other hand, permitted their trading accounts to be used by their relative Hitesh Jain in return for monthly cash income. While individual contributions to the trading volumes or scrip prices in the selected scrips may not have been substantial as suggested by the abovementioned noticees in their replies, the fact that the abovesaid noticees knew each other and together contributed significantly to the overall manipulation of volumes and prices in the selected scrips as noted in Tables 1 and 2 earlier in this order, cannot be ignored.
(ix) In the light of the evidence before me I find that the charges vis-a-vis Hitesh Jain, Shobha Kothari, Sweta Kothari and Kunal Kothari with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XX) NARESH RAJAWAT
(XXI) REETA RAJAWAT
(XXII) HASMUKH JAIN
(XXIII) PAWANBEN JAIN
(i) Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain have been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) During the investigation Naresh Rajawat has admitted that he knew Bhavesh Kothari and allowed him to open and operate his own trading account as well as the trading accounts of some of his family members, with a view to earn profit. This admission has been corroborated by the statement of Pawanben Jain. The four noticees Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain are family members, clients of a common sub-broker, namely, Money Magnet Securities Ltd. (owned by Bhavesh Kothari), and had a common phone number in their KYC forms (that of Naresh Rajawat).
(iii) The SCN details the structured and circular trades executed in the trading accounts of Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain, which contributed to the distortion of volume and prices of the selected scrips. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in their trading accounts is stated to be 40501 in the scrip of Ushdev alone. The details of the structured trades executed through their trading accounts in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For example, instances of structured trades have been observed in the abovesaid trading accounts of Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain on March 3, 2009 in the scrip of Asian, on May 6, 2009 in the scrip of Panoramic, on March 6, 2009 in the scrip of KSL and on May 7, 2009 in the scrip of Asian, respectively. To illustrate, on March 3, 2009 Naresh Rajawat placed a buy order for 500 shares of Asian, which was matched by successive sell orders for 495 shares and 5 shares at the same price and almost the same time Renu Paliwal. Similar structured trades have been observed on the dates mentioned above, in the trading accounts of Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain. Additionally, instances of circular trades involving the trading accounts of Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain have been observed on May 19, 2009 and May 6, 2009 in the scrip of Allcargo for Naresh Rajawat and Reeta Rajawat respectively, and on March 6, 2009 and May 15, 2009 in the scrip of KSL for Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain respectively. To illustrate, Jitendra Jain sold 1500 shares of KSL on March 6, 2009, which were successively bought and sold by Hasmukh Jain and Renu Paliwal, and ultimately bought by Jitendra Jain himself. This ensured that there was no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. This served to create a false impression of trading the scrip of KSL.
(iv) Vide their letters dated March 10, 2012 and March 12, 2012 the abovementioned four persons replied to the SCN stating that the transactions in their trading accounts were carried out in the normal course of trading and do not constitute a material part of the volumes under scrutiny. However, during the personal hearing held on June 14, 2013, the abovementioned persons accepted the charges regarding the trades executed in their accounts, and stated that they would be more vigilant in future and will ensure non-recurrence of such incidents. They have also sought permission to sell stocks already held by them.
(v) In view of the foregoing, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Hasmukh Jain and Pawanben Jain with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XXIV) NEELA KHICHA
(XXV) NAMITA KHICHA
(i) Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha have been charged with violation of Regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4, (2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. Namita Khicha is the daughter of Neela Khicha, and Neela Khicha had stated during investigation that her son Piyush Khicha traded in her account. Piyush Khicha in turn stated before the IA that he traded in the account of his mother Neela Khicha and sister Namita Khicha, on the instructions and advice of his friend and broker, Bhavesh Kothari. According to Piyush Khicha, this was a profit sharing arrangement where 4% of the profits from the trading accounts of Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha would be shared with Bhavesh Kothari, over and above regular commission. The statements of Piyush Khicha serve to corroborate the findings of investigation that Neela Khicha's introducer, one Mr. Sagar Mistry, was an employee of Bhavesh Kothari, and had the same phone number as that of Bhavesh Kothari.
(ii) The SCN details the structured and circular trades executed in the trading accounts of Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha, which contributed to the impact on the volumes and prices of the selected scrips. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in their trading accounts is stated to be 12500 in the scrip of Ushdev alone. The details of the structured trades executed from their trading accounts in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For example, instances of structured trades have been observed in the abovesaid trading accounts of Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha on May 25, 2009 in the scrip of Asian and on March 2, 2009 in the scrip of KSL, respectively. The modus operandi in these structured trades was similar, whereby buy or sell orders placed by Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha matched with successive corresponding sell or buy orders by counterparty clients who were persons found to have been connected to Sunil Mehta. An instance of circular trades involving the trading accounts of Namita Khicha was also observed on March 2, 2009 in the scrip of Asian, wherein 500 shares sold by Namita Khicha were successively bought and then sold by Jitendra Jain and Renu Paliwal and were ultimately bought by Namita Khicha herself. All these trades served to create a false impression of trading in the selected scrips and were not genuinely intended to transfer beneficial ownership. This impacted volumes and prices of the selected scrips.
(iii) During the personal hearing on June 14, 2013, Piyush Khicha submitted that the trading in the accounts of Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha were done at the instance of Bhavesh Kothari. Bhavesh Kothari has also admitted in his replies and during the hearing that he executed trades in the account of Neela Khicha. Vide letters dated June 17, 2013, Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha have also sought permission to sell the shares lying in their respective demat accounts.
(iv) Hence, on the basis of the evidence it is established that Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha permitted their trading accounts to be used by third parties in the expectation of profit.
(v) In view of the facts discussed above and the admission of Piyush Khicha who appeared on behalf of Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha, as well as the admission of Bhavesh Kothari, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Neela Khicha and Namita Khicha with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XXVI) KAMLESH JAIN
(i) Kamlesh Jain has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d) and 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) It is noted that a number of trades in the nature of structured and circular trades have been observed to have been executed through Kamlesh Jain's trading account. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading was 10670 in the scrip of Mavens alone. The details of the structured trades executed from his trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, in the scrip of Mavens, Kamlesh Jain placed a buy order for 2000 shares at Rs. 68.15 on May 22, 2009, which was matched by two successive sell orders for 1500 shares and 500 shares placed by Rashmi Gandhi, whose account was found to have been operated by Sunil Mehta. Further, instances of circular trades involving Kamlesh Jain's trading account have also been observed on May 20, 2009 in the scrip of Allcargo, wherein 500 shares sold by Rashmi Gandhi were successively bought and sold by Renu Paliwal and Kamlesh Jain, and were ultimately bought by Rashmi Gandhi herself. The trading activity carried out by the abovementioned noticees ensured that there was no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day, and reflects an intention on the part of the persons who traded in such a manner, to manipulate volumes and prices and create a false impression of trading in the scrip.
(iii) During the course of the investigation, Kamlesh Jain has also admitted that he knew Bhavesh Kothari. The trades in Kamlesh Jain's trading account were placed through the trading terminals of Bhavesh Kothari, who has been found to have executed trades in, amongst other persons, Kamlesh Jain's trading account. Kamlesh Jain has been introduced to his broker by one Mr. Vinod Kothari, whose phone number on the KYC form with the broker is the same as that of Sweta Kothari, whose trading account was also used by Bhavesh Kothari, her brother-in-law, for executing structured and manipulative trades. These circumstances coupled with the nature of the transactions lead to the conclusion that the said trades were executed by Bhavesh Kothari. Bhavesh Kothari has himself admitted that he executed trades in the accounts of Kamlesh Jain.
(iv) During the course of the hearing on June 14, 2013, Kamlesh Jain submitted that he has made a mistake and trades in his account were executed on the advice of Bhavesh Kothari. Kamlesh Jain has also sought permission to sell the shares lying in his demat account.
(v) Kamlesh Jain has also sought permission to sell shares already held by him.
(vi) In view of the facts and evidence discussed above, I find that Kamlesh Jain allowed his trading account to be used by Bhavesh Kothari, a third party, who ultimately used Kamlesh Jain's trading account to execute manipulative trades in the selected scrips. Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Kamlesh Jain with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XXVII) VINAY KOTHARI
(XXVIII) PRADEEP KOTHARI
(i) Vinay Kothari and Pradeep Kothari have been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d) and 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Vinay Kothari and Pradeep Kothari are both stated to be relatives of Bhavesh Kothari.
(iii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in their trading accounts combined was 19980 in the scrip of KSL alone. The details of the structured trades executed from their trading accounts in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on March 23, 2009 Vinay Kothari placed a buy order for 1000 shares of Asian at Rs. 1138/-, which was matched by successive sell orders of 999 shares and 1 share by Jitendra Jain. Similarly, on March 18, 2009, Pradeep Kothari placed a buy order for 1200 shares of KSL at Rs. 122, which was immediately matched by successive sell orders for 1120 shares and 80 shares placed by Renu Paliwal, whose account has been found to have been operated by Sunil Mehta.
(iv) Similarly, the trading accounts of Vinay Kothari and Pradeep Kothari have been observed to have been involved in circular trades in the selected scrips. For instance, in the scrip of KSL on March 26, 2009, Bharat Jain sold 4000 shares which were subsequently bought and sold by Jitendra Jain and Pradeep Kothari, and ultimately bought by Bharat Jain himself. Again, on March 31, 2009 in the same scrip, Vinay Kothari was seen to have sold 3000 shares, which were successively bought and sold by Jitendra Jain, Bharat Jain and Renu Paliwal, and ultimately bought by Vinay Kothari himself. These circular trades ensured that there was no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day, and that these trades merely served to generate false volumes and manipulate prices with respect to the scrips. In this regard it is pertinent to mention that the trading accounts of Renu Paliwal, Bharat Jain and Jitendra Jain have all been found to have been operated by Sunil Mehta, as per the admission of Sunil Mehta himself, and that the trades executed through these accounts were manipulative trades which impacted the volume and prices of the selected scrips.
(v) During the personal hearing on June 14, 2013, Pradeep Kothari submitted that he seeks pardon for his actions, and any illegal transcations which have taken place in his trading account have been executed by Bhavesh Kothari. The admission made by Vinay Kothari, viewed in the light of the other circumstances of the case including the nature of the trades, indicate that the trades were a part of a larger plan executed at the behest of Sunil Mehta and his associates.
(vi) In view of the facts discussed above, I find that Vinay Kothari and Pradeep Kothari permitted their trading accounts to be used by third parties, who executed manipulative trades in the selected scrips through these accounts. Therefore, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Pradeep Kothari and Vinay Kothari with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XXIX) RASHMI GANDHI AND
(XXX) RAMESH GANDHI
(i) Rashmi Gandhi and Ramesh Gandhi have both been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Rashmi Gandhi has traded through the brokers Finquest Securities Pvt. Ltd. and PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in her trading account is stated to be 432207 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the other structured trades executed from her trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on May 7, 2009 structured trades were executed in the scrip of Asian from her trading account with Pawanben Jain as counterparty. Pawanben Jain had placed a sell order for 150 shares at Rs. 1380/-, and Rashmi Gandhi placed successive buy orders for 140 shares and 10 shares at the same price within a few seconds, so that there was no apparent intention to change the beneficial ownership of the shares and the trades were merely intended to maintain price and generate a false impression of trading in the scrip.
(iii) Instances of circular trades involving Rashmi Gandhi have also been illustrated in the SCN. One of the instances of circular trading has already been discussed in the context of the charge vis-a-vis Hemlata Hankare at paragraph 18. V. (iii), earlier in this order. As mentioned earlier, on September 7, 2009, Rashmi Gandhi was a part of a circular trade transaction with Hemlata Hankare, Sitanshu Nanawati and Rakesh Jain involving 4159 shares of Lotus ensuring that there was no change in the beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. This contributed to price/volume inflation in the selected scrips including the scrip of Lotus.
(iv) The SCN also details bank account transactions in Rashmi Gandhi's account which indicate that she received cash deposits from her husband Ramesh Gandhi and other family members like her daughter Hemali Gandhi, and that this money was used to meet pay-in obligations and margin requirements of brokers like Finquest Securities Pvt. Ltd. and PUG Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. I note that Rashmi Gandhi's bank account in Dena Bank had hardly any transactions other than the receipt of deposits and payments to brokers mentioned above.
(v) Rashmi Gandhi has already admitted before the IA that her trading accounts with both brokers was opened by Praveen Kulkarni and operated by Sunil Mehta.
(vi) Ramesh Gandhi has stated that since he was in need of money, he allowed Sunil Mehta to operate the trading account of his wife Rashmi Gandhi, on the assurance they would earn some fixed income from share transactions carried out by Sunil Mehta.
(vii) The facts on the record indicate that Rashmi Gandhi's trading accounts were used by a third party viz. Sunil Mehta, and this fact has been admitted by Rashmi Gandhi and Ramesh Gandhi. Rashmi Gandhi's trading accounts were found to have been used to execute manipulative trades which contributed to price maintenance or increase and also generated false volumes in some of the selected scrips.
(viii) Therefore, the charges vis-a-vis Rashmi Gandhi and Ramesh Gandhi with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stands established.
(XXXI) AJAY ROONGTA
(i) Ajay Roongta been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Investigation has revealed that he is a friend of Sunil Mehta, who traded through the broker Kantilal Chaganlal Securities Pvt. Ltd.
(iii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading account is stated to be 73400 in the scrip of Ushdev alone. The details of the structured trades executed from his trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on June 17, 2009 Ajay Roongta placed a sell order 500 shares of Allcargo at Rs. 812. At almost the same time and at the same price, Renu Paliwal placed a buy order 350 shares at price of Rs. 812, and immediately afterwards, a buy order for 150 shares, both of which got matched with Ajay Roongta's sell order. It was also found that on the very next day, the same quantity of shares were reversed in a similar matched trade.
(iv) Ajay Roongta has also been found to have engaged in circular trades in the selected scrips. For example, on July 2, 2009, he sold 2000 shares of KSL which were immediately bought and then sold by Jitendra Jain and then Hemlata Hankare, to ultimately be bought again by Ajay Roongta himself. This indicates a lack of intention to change the beneficial ownership of the shares. The circular trades contributed to the manipulation of volumes and price in the scrip of KSL, as mentioned in Tables 1 and 2 earlier in this order.
(v) Bank account transactions showing transfer of funds from his bank account to that of Anjana Mehta and Jitendra Jain, two of the noticees connected to Sunil Mehta, indicate a relationship between Ajay Roongta and Sunil Mehta.
(vi) Ajay Roongta did not attend the personal hearing. However, vide his reply dated April 22, 2012 Ajay Roongta has contended that while he knew Sunil Mehta, he was not an accomplice of Sunil Mehta in market manipulation. Ajay Roongta has claimed that the scrips in which he traded were liquid scrips, that he traded in shares either to fulfil certain loan obligations vis-a-vis one Mr. Narendra Sanghi or Mr. Arun Sakpal, or on account of good prospects of the companies and his trading was miniscule compared to the total trading volumes in the scrips. He also contended that all his trades were screen-based and in the natural course of business.
(vii) I find that Ajay Roongta's trading has corresponded with manipulative trades indulged in by some of the other noticees, and that Ajay Roongta knew Sunil Mehta, Anjana Mehta and Jitendra Jain, three of the persons amongst the noticees. Evidence available on record, including the nature of the trades executed from Ajay Roongta's trading account, coupled with evidence of transfer to other noticees such as Anjana Mehta and Jitendra Jain, indicate that Ajay Roongta participated in the execution of structured trades in the selected scrips.
(viii) In view of the above, I find that the charge vis-a-vis Ajay Roongta with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stands established.
(XXXII) MEENA RAJAWAT
(i) Meena Rajawat has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d) and 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) Meena Rajawat's trades were observed to have been entered at the trading terminals of the broker Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. No margin or deposits were seen to have been paid by Meena Rajawat to the broker. This was corroborated by the statement of her husband who submitted to the IA on behalf of Meena Rajawat that she allowed her trading account with the broker Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. to be opened after she received a telemarketing call from the said broker which offered to open and operate her trading account without taking any deposits, and that any income accruing from the trading in her account would be given to her. She was informed by the said broker that this was a scheme which was being offered by Manish Mathur, the Chief Operating Officer of Triveni Management Consulting Ltd.
(iii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in her trading account was 2417231 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the other structured trades executed from her trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on October 28, 2009, Meena Rajawat placed a buy order for 1500 shares of KBS at Rs. 23.10, which was matched by a sell order placed by Rakesh Jain for 1666 shares. The pending sell order for 166 shares was executed immediately thereafter when Meena Rajawat placed a buy order for 166 shares at the same price. An instance of circular trading involving the trading account of Meena Rajawat was also observed in that Scrip of MVL on November 16, 2009, when Meena Rajawat sold 5000 shares which were successively bought and sold by Shaikh Jainuddin and Jitendra Jain, two persons found to be connected with Sunil Mehta, and the shares were ultimately bought by Meena Rajawat herself. This ensured that there was no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. It also reveals an intention on the part of the persons involved to collude in order to affect the price of the scrip, and generate artificial volumes and a false impression of trading in the scrip.
(iv) Vide her reply dated April 25, 2012 Meena Rajawat submitted that a free trading account was opened in her name by Manish Mathur of Triveni Management Consultancy Ltd. She was told that trading would be done by them and any profits would be given to her. She also received Rs. 1,60,000/- by two cheques.
(v) Meena Rajawat did not attend the personal hearing.
(vi) The facts and material on record indicate that Meena Rajawat permitted her trading account to be opened and used by a third party in return for profits. Considering the nature of the structured trades as well as circular trades executed through the trading account of Meena Rajawat, the inescapable conclusion which is drawn is that the trades were executed for the purpose of creating artificial volumes and impacting the price of the selected scrips.
(vii) Therefore, I find that the charge vis-a-vis Meena Rajawat with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stands established.
(XXXIII) SHAIKH JAINUDDIN
(i) Shaikh Jainuddin has been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d) and 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) It was found during investigation that Bhavesh Jain had paid Rs. One lakh to his brother Rakesh Jain in order to facilitate opening of the trading account of Shaikh Jainuddin. Vide his reply dated March 12, 2012 Shaikh Jainuddin submitted that he was not aware of the trades executed in his account and that he allowed his account to be used by Sunil Mehta who he does not know personally but was referred to by his friend Bhavesh Kothari. This has been corroborated by the fact that the orders for Usha Mehta and Shaikh Jainuddin were placed from the same IP address location, and Sunil Mehta has already admitted having placed orders in the trading account of Usha Mehta, thereby leading to the inference that Shaikh Jainuddin's account was also operated by Sunil Mehta. Bank account statements analysed during investigation also revealed frequent cash deposits of sums ranging from Rs. 25000/- to Rs. 100000/- in the bank account of Shaikh Jainuddin, whose monthly salary was found to be around Rs. 10,000/-. These cash deposits were then utilized to meet pay-in obligations of the broker Gupta Equities Pvt. Ltd.
(iii) 2779349 shares were bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading accounts in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the structured trades executed from his trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on November 18, 2009 Shaikh Jainuddin placed a sell order for 3000 shares of KBS at Rs. 25.50, which was immediately matched by successive buy orders for 2500 shares and 500 shares at the same price by Devendra Rai. Likewise, an instance of circular trading involving the trading account of Shaikh Jainuddin was observed on November 16, 2009 in the scrip of MVL, wherein Shaikh Jainuddin bought 5000 shares from Meena Rajawat and then sold them immediately to Jitendra Jain. Subsequently, Jitendra Jain sold these shares back to Meena Rajawat, thus ensuring that there was no change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day, and that the trades were only meant to create a false impression of trading in the scrip and to contribute to manipulation of volumes and price of the scrip.
(iv) During the personal hearing on May 7, 2013 Shaikh Jainuddin reiterated the submissions made earlier in his reply dated March 12, 2012.
(v) In view of the facts heretofore discussed, I find that Shaikh Jainuddin allowed the use of his trading account by a third party in the expectation of profit, and also accepted funding of the transactions in his trading account to be routed through his bank account. This contributed to the aggregate impact on volumes and prices of the selected scrips due to the trading indulged in by the noticees.
(vi) Therefore, I find that the charge vis-a-vis Shaikh Jainuddin with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stands established.
(XXXIV) SITANSHU NAN AW ATI
(i) Sitanshu Nanawati has been charged with the violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d) and 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
(ii) The number of shares bought and sold through structured buy and sell orders in his trading accounts was 4113130 in the scrip of MVL alone. The details of the structured trades executed from his trading account in the other selected scrips are provided in the SCN. For instance, on August 12, 2009 Manish Mathur placed a sell order for 4000 shares of Mavens at Rs. 103.10, which was matched by two successive buy orders placed by Sitanshu Nanawati for 3500 and 500 shares at the same price. This indicates that there was no intention to carry out genuine trades or change beneficial ownership of shares in the scrip.
(iii) Circular trades involving the trading account of Sitanshu Nanawati were also observed in the scrip of Lotus on September 7, 2009, when Hemlata Hankare sold 4150 shares which were successively bought and sold by Sitanshu Nanawati, Rashmi Gandhi and Rakesh Jain, and were ultimately bought by Hemlata Hankare. Clearly, these trades were not intended to effect any change in beneficial ownership of the shares at the end of the day. They merely served to create a false impression of trading in the scrip, and contributed to volume and price manipulation with respect the scrip.
(iv) During the investigation Sitanshu Nanawati had stated that Bhavesh Kothari had opened his trading account with Networth Stock Brokers Ltd. as well as Monarch Projects and Finmarkets Ltd. and India Capital Markets Pvt. Ltd., Further, all trading in his accounts as well the funding of his trades was done by Bhavesh Kothari. It has been stated in the SCN that Bhavesh Kothari was also found to have deposited cash directly into the account of Sitanshu Nanawati, which was later transferred through to the concerned broker's account through cheques. During the course of investigation Sunil Mehta had admitted that he and Bhavesh Kothari had traded in the account of Sitanshu Nanawati.
(v) Vide his reply dated March 1, 2012 Sitanshu Nanawati has submitted that he realizes that he was cheated by Bhavesh Kothari and Sunil Mehta.
(vi) During the personal hearing on June 7, 2013, Sitanshu Nanawati reiterated the submissions made in his reply dated March 1, 2012.
(vii) In view of the facts on record, I find that Sitanshu Nanawati had permitted the use of his trading account by third parties for executing manipulative transactions, and accepted the funding thereof by third parties as well. This contributed to the aggregate impact on volumes and prices of the selected scrips due to the trading indulged in by the noticees.
(viii) Therefore, the charge vis-a-vis Sitanshu Nanawati with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, stand established.
(XXXV) ALPESH SHAH
(XXXVI) ANIL SHAH
(i) Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah have been charged with violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992. They are brothers residing at the same place, who traded through the broker Emkay Global Financial Services Ltd. They have been alleged to have been a part of certain structured trades and circular trades with persons related to Sunil Mehta as counterparties. The details of the alleged structured trades executed from their trading accounts in the selected scrips are provided in the SCN.
(ii) Vide their letter dated March 2, 2012, Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah have submitted that no transaction in their bank statements or other documents indicates any relationship with Sunil Mehta or persons connected to him. They have denied having indulged in synchronized trading. Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah did not appear for the personal hearing.
(iii) I note that the SCN does not mention evidence with respect to fund flows or other details linking Anil Shah and Alpesh Shah to Sunil Mehta or other noticees. In the absence of any nexus with other noticees, individual transactions of Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah, even where they happen to have matched with persons connected with Sunil Mehta, cannot conclusively establish that Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah were trading in collusion with Sunil Mehta, or that their trading accounts were being operated by Sunil Mehta or persons connected with him.
(iv) In view of the above and on the basis of the evidence available in the matter, I find that the charges vis-a-vis Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah with respect to violation of regulations 3(a), (b), (c) and (d), 4(1) and 4(2)(a), (b), (e) and (g) of the FUTP Regulations read with Section 12A(a), (b) and (c) of the SEBI Act, 1992, have not been established.
19. It is noted from information available on record such as information received from brokers, depository participants, banks, statements recorded etc. that the all the noticees except Alpesh Shah and Anil Shah were found to be linked with one another through various connecting factors such as fund flows through bank accounts, common introduces to brokers, trading accounts, common addresses and e-mail address and phone numbers in the KYC forms, nominees, compulsory references, authorized representatives, business associates mentioned in the KYC forms, family relations, as well as on the basis of the statement of the entities as explained in foregoing paragraphs. The modus operandi followed by the noticees for execution of trades in the said scrips during the investigation periods as explained in the foregoing paragraphs further substantiates the nexus amongst the noticees. The trading patterns viewed in the light of the nexus between the noticees establish that the synchronized, structured and circular trades executed by the noticees is the result of concerted effort on the part of the noticees.
20. As already stated in the foregoing paragraphs, the concentration in the synchronized trades among the group of entities was found to be significant, which suggests that concerted efforts were taken by the entities to match their orders within the group only. The noticees as a group have contributed considerable percentage of volumes in the stated scrips. It has also been found that, as a result of execution of trades in the manner mentioned above, the net deliverable quantities have remained zero or in some cases it resulted in only insignificant quantity of delivery compared to the trade volume. The repeated and continuous pattern of such synchronized trading clearly indicate the existence of a pre-determined plan of placing of orders so as to match within members of the notice group. From the facts and circumstances, it has been observed that the noticees, who are related to one other as seen earlier in this order, indulged in structured and circular trades in the selected scrips without any intention to transfer the beneficial ownership of the shares, and thus manipulated the volumes and prices of the selected scrips.
21. Though synchronized, structured or circular trades are not per se illegal, they would be illegal if executed with a view to manipulate the market in this regard, it is pertinent to note the judgment of the Hon'ble Securities Appellate Tribunal in the case of Ketan Parekh v. Securities and Exchange Board of India (Appeal No. 2 of 2004 decided on July 14, 2006), wherein Hon'ble SAT held as under—
“A synchronized transaction will, however, be illegal or violative of the Regulations if it is executed with a view to manipulate the market or if it results in circular trading or is dubious in nature and is executed with a view to avoid regulatory detection or does not involve change of beneficial ownership or is executed to create false volumes resulting in upsetting the market equilibrium. Any transaction executed with the intention to defeat the market mechanism whether negotiated or not would be illegal. Whether a transaction has been executed with the intention to manipulate the market or defeat its mechanism will depend upon the intention of the parties… In such cases the intention or collusion of the parties can be gathered and inferred from the conduct of the parties, pattern of transactions and attending circumstances, etc…….”
22. I further note that the Hon'ble Tribunal in Bhavesh Pabari v. Securities Exchange Board of India (Appeal No. 104 of 2012 dated 03.07.2012) observed that “when a large number of entities are involved and allegation is of fraud and manipulating the securities market, case of each entity is to be viewed with reference to its role in manipulating the trades and its role in executing synchronized/circular/reversal trades”.
23. Having observed the role played by each of the noticees in detail in the foregoing paragraphs, it is pertinent to mention that role and contribution by each noticee in the whole scheme of market manipulation differs depending upon whether they are directly or indirectly involved in the whole scheme of manipulation.
24. Evidence examined in this order indicates that Sunil Mehta is the main conspirator who hatched the plan of executing manipulative trades in the selected scrips in order to distort price/volumes. As detailed in the SCN as well as in the course of examination of the role of each noticee in this order, it has been found that the audit trail in terms of fund flows, relationships, voice recordings etc. led to Sunil Mehta. It is therefore evident that Sunil Mehta envisaged a scheme for manipulation of prices and volumes of the selected scrips, and enlisted the assistance of other who directly aided him in placing manipulative orders in the trading accounts of several persons, as examined in this order. By his actions, Sunil Mehta jeopardised the integrity of the markets by attempting to interfere with the smooth functioning of the securities market and acting in a manner which erodes the confidence of the investors in the securities market. Therefore, Sunil Mehta's actions warrant stringent regulatory action.
25. The noticees who are found to have been connected directly with Sunil Mehta, and who aided and assisted him and by procuring trading accounts and also by way of facilitating fund flow to the bank accounts of many of the noticees who lent their trading accounts to Sunil Mehta or persons connected to him, etc. These noticees are classified as Category 1, and comprise Anjana Mehta, Praveen Gate, Manish Mathur, Suresh Hanswal, Jitendra Jain, Hemlata Hankare, Ajay Roongta, Naresh Rajawat, Bharat Jain, Hitesh Jain as well as Bhavesh Kothari, who was in turn was assisted and aided by Rakesh Jain and Bhavesh Jain.
26. Some of the noticees, on the other hand, have been found to have only lent their names for opening trading accounts and allowed the accounts to be operated by Sunil Mehta and his associates, in return for monthly income. These noticees are classified as Category 2, and comprise Usha Mehta, Seema Mathur, Rashmi Gandhi, Ramesh Gandhi, Devendra Rai, Renu Paliwal, Hasmukh Jain, Pawanben Jain, Reeta Rajawat, Kunal Kothari, Sweta Kothari, Shobha Kothari, Neela Khicha, Namita Khicha, Kamlesh Jain, Vinay Kothari, Pradeep Kothari, Sitanshu Nanawati, Shaikh Jainuddin and Meena Rajawat.
27. The charges vis-a-vis Anil Shah and Alpesh Shah have not been found to have been established, as investigation has not revealed any evidence linking them with Sunil Mehta or any of the persons connected to him.
28. I note that the Hon'ble Securities Appellate Tribunal in Rahul H. Shah v. SEBI (Appeal No. 83 of 2012 decided on May 11, 2012) observed that name lending “is a fraudulent activity and requires to he curbed for maintaining the sanctity of the securities market”. It has been observed that the name lending by the aforementioned noticees mentioned as Category 2, has assisted Sunil Mehta and his associates to perpetrate their whole scheme involving the fraudulent and unfair trade practice of manipulation of the selected scrips by executing synchronized and circular trades through different trading accounts, which impacted the volumes and prices of the selected scrips. Such structured trades were executed without any intention to transfer beneficial ownership in securities, and impacted the price and volumes of the selected scrips, as detailed in Tables 1 and 2. As every trade establishes the price of the scrip, the execution of the trades pursuant to a preconceived manipulative scheme would disturb the price discovery system of stock exchange, as also held by the Hon'ble Securities Appellate Tribunal in the matter of Sandeep Jain v. SEBI (decided on December 20, 2012). It is also noted that artificial increases in the volumes of scrips attract innocent investors in the securities market who are lured into dealing in such shares on the basis of such false appearance of trading. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case in totality, noticees in Category 1 played an active role in execution of the manipulative trades. In this context it is pertinent to mention that noticees in Category 2 have admitted that their accounts have been opened and operated with their consent. In view of the above, I find that the persons in Category 2 also deserve appropriate penalty since they indirectly harmed the sanctity of the securities market.
29. I note that the aforementioned fraudulent, manipulative and unfair trade practices by the noticees threaten the integrity and orderly development of the securities market, and therefore call for regulatory intervention in the interest of investors. I am also of the view that the interests of investors in securities market require that such entities should not be allowed to participate in the market and unjustly enrich themselves at the cost of the investors. However, considering the degree and nature of participation in the manipulative trades by noticees in Category 1 and Category 2, it is in the interest of justice and fairness to treat the two categories differently in terms of directions to be issued in this matter.
30. It is noted that vide the Interim Orders dated February 20, 2010 and May 27, 2011 (later confirmed vide SEBI's confirmatory Orders dated October 06, 2010 and March 27, 2012 respectively), all the noticees except Namita Khicha, were restrained from accessing the securities market and prohibited from buying, selling or dealing in the securities market till further orders. In this context, I note that the noticees, except for Namita Khicha, have already undergone restraint for a period of approximately two to three years.
31. In view of the foregoing, I, in exercise of the powers conferred upon me in terms of Section 19 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 read with Sections 11, 11(4) and 11B thereof, hereby direct as follows:—
• Sunil Mehta (PAN-ACEPM8838L) is hereby restrained from accessing the capital market and is prohibited from buying, selling or otherwise dealing in the securities market, directly or indirectly, for a period of seven years from the date of this order.
• The noticees in Category 1, namely, Anjana Mehta (PAN-ACOPM6377N), Jitendra Jain (PAN-AIMPJ2936J), Hemlata Hankare (PAN-ACPPH5612Q), Ajay Roongta (PAN-AAVPR5584R), Bharat Jain (PAN-AACPJ0602M), Suresh Hanswal (PAN-ABPPH6308A), Praveen Gate (PAN-AJOPG3159M), Manish Mathur (PAN-AIVPM4384J), Bhavesh Kothari (PAN-AABPK7614H), Rakesh Jain (PAN-AEMPJ7329B), Bhavesh Jain (PAN-AGCPJ7776Q), Naresh Rajawat, HUF (PAN-AADHN8192D) and Hitesh Jain (PAN-ACXPJ9852A) are restrained from accessing the capital market and are prohibited from buying, selling or otherwise dealing in the securities market, directly or indirectly, for a period of five years from the date of this order.
• The noticees in Category 2 viz. Usha Mehta (PAN-ABQPM3248M), Seema Mathur (PAN-APRPM5075M), Devendra Rai (PAN-ALNPR6798Q), Renu Paliwal (PAN-ABHPP8821A), Rashmi Gandhi (PAN-AKHPG6563D), Ramesh Gandhi, Hasmukh Jain HUF (PAN-ABPPH6308 A), Pawanben Jain (PAN-ACUPJ1494R), Reeta Rajawat (PAN-AACPR7700A), Kunal Kothari (PAN-AWRPK0567H), Sweta Kothari (PAN-APEPK5134Q), Shobha Kothari (PAN-ALFPK0986M), Neela Khicha (PAN-AADHN8192D), Namita Khicha (ALVPK9460G), Kamlesh Jain, HUF (PAN-A AFHK8006H), Vinay Kothari (PAN-AAFHV6824A), Pradeep Kothari (PAN-AAJHP7271F), Sitanshu Nanawati (PAN- AGDPN4597Q), Shaikh [Jainuddin (PAN-BJCPS6572H) and Meena Rajawat (PAN-AFEPP9056J) are restrained from accessing the capital market and are prohibited from buying, selling or otherwise dealing in the securities market, directly or indirectly, for a period of three years from the date of this order.
• The period of debarment already undergone by the noticees in terms of the earlier Orders dated February 20, 2010 and May 27, 2011 passed by SEBI in the matter shall be taken into account while computing the said periods of debarment of ordered above.
32. I do hereby direct that the directions issued against Alpesh Rajmal Shah, HUF (PAN AAMHS6375L) and Anil Rajmal Shah, HUF (PAN AAGHA1506F) vide interim order dated February 20, 2010 and confirmatory order dated October 6, 2010 shall not continue against them.
33. I further note that some of the noticees, namely, Shobha Kothari, Rakesh Jain, Bhavesh Jain, Bhavesh Kothari, Kamlesh Jain, Kunal Kothari, Neela Kicha, Namita Khicha, Naresh Rajawat, Reeta Rajawat, Pawanben Jain and Hasmukh Jain, have sought permission to dispose of the shares which have been lying in their demat accounts since the passing of the interim orders dated February 20, 2010 and May 27, 2011. The requests received in this regard need careful consideration on a case-to-case basis. Hence, suitable directions in this regard shall be issued separately.
34. This order shall come into force with immediate effect.
35. The copies of the order shall be served to the respective stoke exchange and depositories.