Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary — High Court of Judicature at Bombay (Writ Petition No. 7939 of 2016)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, Shri Popat Kisan Mhaske and Rajubai Kisan Kapse, are co-owners of a parcel of ancestral land (Survey No. 7A (Part), Hissa No. 1+2+3/2A of Chehedi village) within the Nashik Municipal Corporation (NMC) limits. That land had been shown as reserved in the sanctioned Nashik Development Plan (1993) for the purpose of "High School and Primary School." The petitioners allege that, although more than ten years (and in the case described more than 18 years) had elapsed since the sanction of the plan, NMC did not acquire the land for the reserved public purpose.

On 3 March 2014 the petitioners served a purchase notice under Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (the Act), calling on the respondents to acquire the land within the statutory period. The petitioners say acquisition proceedings were not taken within the statutory twelve-month period; they notified respondents of deemed de-reservation on 3 March 2015 and thereafter submitted a building plan on 16 April 2015. The respondents issued a letter dated 27 May 2015 rejecting the petitioners' demand for de-reservation and an Executive Engineer refused building permission by certificates dated 28 May 2015 / 1 June 2015. The petitioners appealed to the Minister under Section 47 of the Act (appeal pending) and then filed this writ petition seeking, inter alia, an order directing publication in the Official Gazette under Section 127(2) that the reservation had lapsed, quashing of the letter dated 27 May 2015 and the refusal certificates, deletion of the land from the Draft Development Plan published May 2015, and directions to decide their building permission application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, having served a valid purchase notice under Section 127 of the Act and the respondents failing to acquire the land within 12 months, the reservation/allocation/designation of the petitioners' land is deemed to have lapsed and requires notification in the Official Gazette under Section 127(2).
  2. Whether the respondents could validly reject the petitioners' demand for de-reservation after the reservation had lapsed by efflux of the 12-month period.
  3. Whether the Refusal Certificate (dated 28 May 2015 / 1 June 2015) refusing building permission is lawful given the petitioners' contention that no discrepancy was communicated within 60 days and the building plan was submitted after deemed de-reservation.
  4. Whether the filing of an appeal under Section 47 of the Act before the Minister (pending) precludes the High Court from adjudicating the question of lapse of reservation and directing consequential action.
  5. Whether a subsequent reservation in a later Development Plan can revive a previously lapsed reservation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The purchase notice dated 3 March 2014 under Section 127 was duly served and received; respondents did not initiate acquisition within 12 months, so the reservation lapsed with effect from 3 March 2015.
  • After lapse, the land became available to the petitioners for development; respondents could not lawfully reject the de-reservation after the lapse.
  • The petitioners supplied title and other requisite documents (some after the purchase notice) and these were acted upon and acknowledged by respondents; any deficiency in initial enclosure does not invalidate the purchase notice.
  • The building plan was submitted on 16 April 2015 (after deemed de-reservation); respondents did not intimate any discrepancy within 60 days, so they were obliged to grant permission in accordance with law; the refusal certificate was back-dated and mala fide and is therefore illegal.
  • The petitioners sought judicial relief because their appeal under Section 47 before the Minister had not been heard.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The purchase notice did not enclose necessary documents of title; those documents were required to accompany the purchase notice under Section 127 and absent them the purchase notice was invalid.
  • The reservation had continued in the revised Development Plan (draft published May 2015), implying the reservation had not lapsed.
  • The petitioners had filed an appeal under Section 47 which was pending; in light of that appeal the writ petition was, according to the respondents, not maintainable and should be dismissed.
  • The respondents relied on a Supreme Court judgment (Atul Singh & Ors. v. Sunil Kumar Singh & Ors.) to support the proposition that proceedings filed without required documentary compliance can be defective — the respondents urged the analogy to invalidate the purchase notice (the court addressed this point in its reasoning).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Atul Singh & Ors. Vs. Sunil Kumar Singh & Ors. (2008) 2 SCC 602 Principle regarding requirement to file original agreement or duly certified copy with a petition under provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (i.e., compliance with documentary requirements to maintain a petition). The Court held this precedent arose in a totally different context (Arbitration Act) and was irrelevant to the issues under Section 127 of the MRTP Act. The Court rejected the respondents' reliance on the case and found the purchase notice valid despite initial non-enclosure of documents, because the documents were later submitted and acted upon by respondents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in several discrete steps, faithful to the facts and submissions recorded in the opinion:

  1. Validity of the purchase notice: The court found the purchase notice issued on 3 March 2014 was validly issued and served under Section 127 of the Act. Although some documents were provided after the notice, the respondents had acted on those documents (as evidenced by subsequent correspondence and comments), and therefore late submission did not invalidate the purchase notice.
  2. Irrelevance of the cited precedent: The court observed that the Supreme Court decision in Atul Singh (relied upon by respondents) concerned the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and the requirement to file the original agreement/duly certified copy; that decision was inapplicable to the present context and therefore of no assistance to respondents.
  3. Effect of lapse of acquisition period under Section 127: The court stated the statutory rule — when land shown as reserved is not acquired within the stipulated 12-month period from receipt of the purchase notice, the land is deemed to be de-reserved. The consequence is that there can be no valid rejection of a de-reservation application after the lapse of the reservation period.
  4. Building permission and timing: The petitioners' building plan was submitted after the land was deemed de-reserved. The respondents did not communicate any discrepancy within the statutory 60-day period; on that basis (and because the reservation had lapsed) the respondents were obliged to decide the building permission application in accordance with law.
  5. Pending appeal does not bar the Court's decision: The court held that the mere filing of an appeal under Section 47 before the Minister does not prevent the High Court from adjudicating and holding that the reservation had lapsed and from directing respondents to act on that legal position.
  6. Subsequent reservation does not revive a lapsed reservation: The court concluded that a later reservation in a revised Development Plan cannot automatically revive a reservation that has already lapsed under Section 127.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Rule is made absolute in the terms recorded in the judgment. Specifically, the court ordered that:

  • The respondents must notify by order published in the Official Gazette under Section 127(2) of the MRTP Act that the reservation/allocation/designation of the petitioners' land has lapsed.
  • The letter dated 27 May 2015 issued by Respondent No.6 and the Refusal Certificate dated 28 May 2015 / 1 June 2015 issued by Respondent No.5 are quashed and set aside.
  • The respondents are directed to delete the petitioners' land from the reservation as shown in the Draft Development Plan published in May 2015.
  • Respondent No.5 is directed to decide the petitioners' application for building permission expeditiously and in accordance with law, taking into account that the reservation has lapsed.
  • The court made the rule absolute with no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The petitioners obtain the reliefs requested — a direction to publish the de-reservation in the Official Gazette, quashing of respondents' refusal communications, deletion from the draft plan, and a mandate to determine the building permission application in lawfulness and expeditiously.
  • Procedural consequences: The court held that a pending appeal under Section 47 before the Minister did not prevent the High Court from adjudicating on the lapse of reservation and directing consequential actions by the respondents.
  • On precedent: The court found no need to create or extend legal precedent beyond applying the statutory scheme in Section 127; it explicitly treated the cited Supreme Court decision as distinguishable and not applicable, and the judgment does not state that it establishes a new broader principle beyond the application of Section 127 as described.

This summary is confined strictly to the facts, arguments, reasoning, and orders expressly contained in the provided opinion.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Popat Kisan Mhaske v. Minister For Urban Development

    23-WP-7939-2016.DOC Jsn

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    WRIT PETITION NO. 7939 OF 2016

    1. Shri Popat Kisan Mhaske

    Age 67 Yrs. Occu. Agriculture, Residing at Plot No. 48, Mhaske Mala, Samangaon Road, Chehedi (Budruk), Nashik Road, District Nashik

    2. Rajubai Kisan Kapse

    Age 69 Yrs., Occu. Housewife, Residing at Plot No.48, Mhaske Mala, Samangaon Road, Chehedi (Budruk), Nashik Road, District Nashik …Petitioners

    Versus

    1. The Hon'ble Minister for Urban Development

    State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, Mumbai

    2. The Principal Secretary

    Department of Urban Development Mantralaya, Mumbai.

    3. The Collector Nashik, Collector Office,

    Old Agra Road, Nashik.

    4. The Commissioner, Nashik Municipal Corporation, Rajiv Gandhi Bhavan,

    Sharanpur Road, Nashik

    5. Executive Engineer, Nashik Municipal

    1/14

    Corporation, Rajiv Gandhi Bhavan, Sharanpur Road, Nashik.

    6. Assistant Director of Town Planning Dept.

    Nashik Municipal Corporation, Rajiv Gandhi Bhavan, Shranpur Road, Nashik.

    7. The Municipal Secretary,

    Nashik Municipal Corporation, Rajiv Gandhi Bhavan, Sharanpur Road, Nashik. …Respondents

    Ms. Smita R. Gaidhani, for the Petitioners. Mr. Vishwajeet Sagare, AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3. Mr. Murlidhar L. Patil, for Respondent No.4.

    CORAM:

    SMT. VASANTI A NAIK AND

    RIYAZ I. CHAGLA, JJ.

    DATED :

    29TH NOVEMBER 2017

    O R A L J U D G M E N T :- (Per Riyaz I. Chagla J.)

    1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard by consent.

    2. The Petitioner by this Writ Petition is seeking an order and direction from this Court, directing the Respondent to notify by order published in Official Gazette as per Section 127(2) of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short "the said Act") that the reservation, allocation or designation of the Petitioners land viz. Survey No. 7A (Part), Hissa No. 1+2+3/2A of Chehedi village in Nashik Municipal Corporation limits (for short

    2/14

    "the said land") has lapsed. The Petitioners are further seeking the quashing and setting aside of the order / letter dated 27th May 2015 issued by Respondent No.6 and the Refusal Certificate dated 28th May 2015 / 1st June 2015 issued by Respondent No.5 thereby refusing building permission to the Petitioners. The Petitioners have also sought the deletion of the Petitioners land from reservation as shown in Draft Development Plan published in May 2015.

    The brief background of facts is necessary

    3. The Petitioners are the co-owners of the said land in village Chehedi in Nashik Municipal Corporation (for short "NMC") limits. The said land of the Petitioners is their ancestral property and has been in their possession, occupation and use since their forefathers. The said land of the Petitioners was reserved in the sanctioned development plan of Nashik city of 1993, for the purpose of "High School and Primary School". However, despite a lapse of more than 18 years, the said land of the Petitioners was not acquired by the NMC for using it for the reserved public purpose.

    3/14

    4. The Petitioners required the said land for development. As more than 10 years had lapsed from the date of sanction of the final development plan and the land had not been acquired, the Petitioners issued purchase notice dated 3rd March 2014 to the Respondents under Section 127 of the said Act. The Petitioners called upon the Respondents to acquire the said land within the period stipulated under Section 127 of the said Act. The notice was delivered on the same day to the addresses of the Respondents. By letter dated 2nd April 2014, the NMC informed the Petitioners that if the Petitioners were ready to handover the reserved plot of land to the NMC, then the Petitioners would be granted TDR after entering into an agreement to that effect. The Petitioners by their letter dated 11th April 2014 informed NMC that they were not desirous of taking the TDR and that the Respondents should initiate proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act, within the stipulated period. The Petitioners by letter dated 21st April 2014 addressed to NMC forwarded the documents as required. The Petitioners had reminded the Respondents that the time stipulated under Section 127 of the said Act run from the date of purchase notice. The Petitioners also pointed out the errors in the reservation and requested the Respondents to initiate action to correct the said mistake.

    4/14

    5. The Respondents had neither acquired nor taken any steps contemplated under Section 127 of the said Act for acquisition of the said land within the stipulated period of 12 months from the date of service of the purchase notice. Hence, the reservation deemed to have lapsed and the Government ought to have been published a notification as per Section 127(2) of the said Act, in Official Gazette de-reserving the said land. The Petitioners accordingly gave an intimation to the Respondents about the deemed de-reservation vide their letter dated 3rd March 2015 as the reservation of the said land had lapsed on 2nd March 2015. However, despite receiving the said letter, and much after the deemed de-reservation of the said land on 3rd March 2015, a letter dated 19th March 2015 was received by the Petitioners from the Estate Officer, NMC, whereby it was stated that the proposal for acquisition was forwarded by the said office to the District Collector on 22nd December 2014. The Petitioners vide their letter dated 25th March 2015 addressed to the Commissioner, NMC, reiterated that since the land was not acquired within the stipulated period of 12 months from the receipt of the notice, the reservation, allotment or designation with respect to the land has lapsed with effect from 3rd March 2015 and thereupon the said land is deemed to be released from reservation and became

    5/14

    available to the Petitioners for the purpose of development, as permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant Development Plan. The Petitioners upon not hearing from the Respondents, made an application dated 16th April 2015 by which a Building Plan was submitted for development along with relevant documents. The receipt of the said Building Plan was acknowledged by the Respondents through the Town Planning Department vide inward Number C-G/225/22 dated 16th April 2015. However, as no action was taken by the Respondents under the said Act, the Petitioners sent a reminder vide letter dated 7th May 2015 to the Principal Secretary, UDD, Mantralaya regarding publication of notification in the Government Gazette about the deletion of reservation of the said land from the sanctioned development plan of Nashik City. The Petitioners were informed by letter dated 27th May 2015 addressed by the Assistant Director, Town Planning, NMC that the proposal for acquisition had been forwarded to the District Collector on 22nd December 2015 and since the Government Gazette notification as provided under Section 127 (2) of the said Act had not been published, the Petitioners demand for de-reservation was rejected.

    6/14

    6. The Petitioners Architect was served with a Refusal Certificate dated 20th May 2015 / 1st June 2015 issued by the Executive Engineer, NMC refusing permission for the Building Plan, on the ground that the documents had not been submitted along with the Building Plan. It is the Petitioners case that the Refusal Certificate was served on the Petitioners Architect on 22nd June 2015 i.e. after a lapse of 60 days from the date of application for building permission. The Petitioners have preferred an Appeal to the Hon'ble Minister of UDD, Government of Maharashtra, under Section 47 of the said Act on 17th July 2015. The Petitioners Appeal has not been heard by Respondent. Hence this Petition.

    7. Smt. Gaidhani, the learned counsel for the Petitioners has submitted that the purchase notice under Section 127 of the said Act was duly served upon the Respondents and received by them on 3rd March 2014. There was no acquisition proceedings initiated by the Respondents within 12 months from the service of the purchase notice as stipulated under Section 127 of the said Act and hence, the said land was deemed to be released from reservation, allotment or designation with effect from 3rd March 2015. Thereafter the said land had become available to the

    7/14

    Petitioners as owners of the said land for the purpose of development. She has submitted that there is no question of Respondents rejecting the Petitioners application for de- reservation after the lapse of 12 months. Such rejection was contrary to the provisions of Section 127 of the said Act and hence the letter of rejection dated 27th May 2015 issued by Respondent No.6 ought to be quashed and set aside. She has submitted that it was incumbent upon Respondent Nos. 1 and 7 to notify in the Official Gazette as per Section 127(2) of the said Act, that the reservation, allocation or designation of the Petitioners land under reservation had lapsed. She has submitted that the purchase notice had been followed up with the submissions of all necessary documents showing the Petitioners interest / ownership in the said land and which was duly received by the Respondents and acted upon by them. She has submitted that the Building Plan had been submitted by the Petitioners on 16th April 2015 i.e. much after said land was deemed to have been de-reserved. She has submitted that the Respondents had not intimated the Petitioners about any discrepancy in the application for building permission within 60 days from the date of submission of the building permission and hence the Respondents are deemed to have granted permission to the Petitioners. She has submitted that the Respondents had

    8/14

    deliberately, intentionally and malafidely served back dated Refusal Certificate on the Petitioners Architect only on 22nd June 2015. This was much beyond the stipulated period of 60 days and hence the Refusal Certificate being dated 28th May, 2015 / 1st June 2015 is illegal, bad in law and ought to be quashed and set aside. She has submitted that the Respondents have erred in not appreciating the documents on record as well as the legal provisions in issuing the impugned order / letter and Refusal Certificate. She has submitted that the Petition filed by the Petitioners ought to be allowed.

    8. Shri Sagare, the learned Assistant Government Pleader appearing for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and Shri Patil, the learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.4 have opposed the Petition and supported the impugned action of the Respondents.

    9. Shri Patil has submitted that the purchase notice served on the NMC had not enclosed the relevant documents in respect of the Petitioners claim to be owners of the said land. The documents of title were necessary to be issued along with the purchase notice under Section 127 of the said Act and absent that the said purchase notice was illegal and hence it cannot be

    9/14

    submitted that the reservation had lapsed. He has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Atul Singh & Ors. Vs. Sunil Kumar Singh & Ors.1. The said decision related to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and it was held that under sub- section (2) of Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, it was necessary for the party to have filed the original agreement or duly certified copy along with the Petition filed, which he failed to do and hence, no order for referring the dispute to arbitration could have been passed in the Suit filed. He has submitted that the reservation has continued in the revised Development Plan. He has submitted that the Petitioners had filed an Appeal before the Hon'ble Minister, UDD, Government of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, Mumbai under Section 47 of the said Act challenging the rejection of the Petitioner's demand for de- reservation and the refusal by the Respondent - Corporation of permission for the Building Plan. He has submitted that in the light of the said Appeal which is pending, the Writ Petition is not maintainable and ought to be dismissed.

    1 0. We have considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties. We are of the view that the purchase notice has been 1 (2008) 2 Supreme Court Cases 602.

    10/14

    validly issued and served upon the Respondent Corporation under Section 127 of the said Act. We find that the documents, albeit submitted after the purchase notice was served under Section 127 of the said Act, had been acted upon by the Respondents and this is apparent from the correspondence issued thereafter as well as the Respondents comments on the various documents issued by the Petitioners evidencing their title to the said land. We are of the view that the non issuance of the requisite documents together with the purchase notice cannot invalidate the purchase notice. We find that the Petitioners had submitted the requisite documents after issuance of the purchase notice, and these documents were accepted by the Respondents. We are of the view that the judgment of the Supreme Court in Atul Singh (Supra) relied upon by the Respondents is in a totally different context as it relates to the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and is irrelevant for determining the issue in the present case. We are of the view when the said land under reservation is not acquired within the stipulated period under Section 127 of the said Act, i.e. 12 months in the present case from the date of receipt of the purchase notice then the said land is deemed to be de-reserved. We are of the view that there can be no rejection of the Petitioners application for de-reservation

    11/14

    by the Respondents after the lapsing of reservation under Section 127 of the said Act. We find that the Petitioners have submitted the Building Plan much after the said land is deemed to have been de-reserved and that no intimation had been received from the Respondents regarding any discrepancy in the Building Plan. Hence, it was obligatory for the Respondents to decide the Petitioners application for building permission in accordance with law. We are, therefore, of the view that the impugned order / letter dated 27th May 2015 issued by the Respondent No.6 rejecting the de-reservation of the said land and the impugned Refusal Certificate dated 28th May 2015 / 1st June 2015 issued by the Respondent No.5 refusing building permission to the Petitioners are illegal, bad in law and liable to be quashed and set aside. We are of the view that the mere filing of an Appeal by the Petitioners under Section 47 of the said Act before the Hon'ble Minister, UDD, Mantralaya, would not prevent this Court from holding that the reservation of the said land under Section 127 of the said Act has lapsed and that it is necessary for the Respondent No.5 to decide the Petitioners application for building permission in accordance with law by taking into consideration that the reservation of the Petitioners land has lapsed. We are also of the view that a

    12/14

    subsequent reservation in the Development Plan cannot automatically revive the lapsed reservation.

    11. We accordingly pass the following order:-

    (a) We order and direct the Respondents to notify by order published in the Official Gazette as per Section 127 (2) of the M.R.T.P. Act 1996, that the reservation, allocation or designation of the Petitioners land viz. Survey No. 7A (Part), Hissa No. 1+2+3/2A of Chehedi village in Nashik Municipal Corporation limits has lapsed.

    (b) The order / letter dated 27th May 2015 issued by Respondent No.6 and the Refusal Certificate dated 28th May 2015 and 1st June 2015 issued by Respondent No.5 are quashed and set aside.

    (c) We direct the Respondents to delete the Petitioners land from the reservation as shown in Draft Development Plan published in May 2015.

    (d) We order and direct the Respondent No.5 to decide the Petitioners application for building permission at the earliest and in accordance with law, by taking into consideration the reservation of the Petitioners land

    13/14

    has lapsed.

    (e) Rule is made absolute in the above terms with no order as to costs.

    ( RIYAZ I. CHAGLA J. ) ( SMT. VASANTI A NAIK, J. )

    14/14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Popat Kisan Mhaske v. Minister For Urban Development
    (Nov 29, 2017)