AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 INSC 829
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act, 1956 (Section/Subsection not specified)
  • Section 9 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereafter referred to as ARBITRATION ACT)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 11 of the said Act
  • Section 11 of the ARBITRATION ACT
  • Section 9 of the said Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 INSC 829
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Companies Act, 1956 (Section/Subsection not specified)
  • Section 9 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereafter referred to as ARBITRATION ACT)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 11 of the said Act
  • Section 11 of the ARBITRATION ACT
  • Section 9 of the said Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a 95-year-old landowner, owns 2,412 sq. yards at Pali Hill, Mumbai. On 23 June 2006 he executed a Development Agreement (“AGREEMENT”) with two companies—M/s. Sharyans Resources Pvt. Ltd. and Goldbeam Construction Pvt. Ltd. (collectively “DEVELOPERS”)—granting them the right to develop the property in return for staged consideration of Rs 10 crores and a 50-50 split of the “development potential.” Key contractual provisions included:

  • Developers to obtain all regulatory permissions and commence construction within 30 days of the final building plan; completion was to occur within 24 months of the commencement certificate.
  • Clause 32 empowered the appellant, on Developers’ default, to complete construction at their cost or terminate the AGREEMENT.
  • Clause 33 mandated arbitration for most disputes but excluded disputes arising from termination under Clause 32(A).

On 20 April 2010 Sharyans assigned its 25 % share to M/s. Prajita Developers Pvt. Ltd. (“PRAJITA”), the first respondent. Despite approvals obtained in 2008, virtually no construction occurred. A succession of proceedings followed:

  • Section 9 Arbitration Petition No. 829/2015 (PRAJITA) was dismissed on 14 Jan 2016; the intra-court appeal No. 74/2016 was dismissed on 4 Mar 2016; SLP(C) Nos. 7483-7484/2016 were dismissed on 16 Mar 2016.
  • PRAJITA’s Section 11 Arbitration Application No. 292/2015 was withdrawn on 25 Jul 2016 with liberty to sue.
  • On 8 Oct 2015 the appellant formally terminated the AGREEMENT.
  • PRAJITA filed Suit No. 295/2016 on 28 Sep 2016 in the Bombay High Court seeking declarations that the AGREEMENT subsists and the termination is invalid, together with specific performance.
  • Parallel Section 9 Petition No. 697/2016 and Section 11 Application No. 234/2016 remained pending in the High Court.

The present civil appeal challenges the High Court order permitting withdrawal of the arbitration application and addresses the broader dispute between the parties.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s termination of the Development Agreement dated 23 June 2006 is valid and enforceable.
  2. Whether PRAJITA is entitled to specific performance of the Development Agreement despite prolonged non-performance.
  3. What equitable relief, if any, should be granted to resolve the parties’ competing claims and secure possession of the property.
  4. Whether the question of damages owed to PRAJITA should be referred to arbitration.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Landowner)

  • Has already received approximately Rs 8.5 crores from PRAJITA/Sharyans.
  • Offers to pay Rs 20 crores to PRAJITA to obtain peaceful, undisturbed possession.
  • Alleges that PRAJITA has stationed armed guards preventing the appellant from accessing his own property.
  • Contends that continued pursuit of specific performance is unjust given decade-long inaction and the appellant’s 75 % stake in development potential.

Respondent – PRAJITA

  • Rejects the appellant’s settlement offer of Rs 20 crores.
  • Claims legitimate rights under the 2010 Deed of Assignment and maintains guards only to protect, not to exclude the appellant.
  • Seeks enforcement of contractual rights via suit for declarations and specific performance.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted undisputed facts: (1) PRAJITA’s entitlement derives solely from Sharyans’ 25 % share; (2) twelve years after the AGREEMENT, virtually no construction has occurred; (3) time was of the essence and repeated extensions failed. Against this backdrop, the Court reasoned as follows:

  1. Termination justified. Given the Developers’ total non-performance, Clause 32 permitted termination, and the appellant exercised that right in October 2015.
  2. Specific performance inappropriate. Allowing PRAJITA’s suit would prolong litigation and be inequitable, as PRAJITA could secure only 25 % of development potential while the 95-year-old appellant remains deprived of 75 %.
  3. Equitable solution. To balance interests, the Court fashioned a monetary settlement: the appellant must deposit Rs 20 crores; in exchange, PRAJITA must vacate and deliver possession under police supervision.
  4. Residual dispute on damages. Whether PRAJITA deserves additional compensation beyond Rs 20 crores is a separable question best resolved by arbitration. The Court therefore appointed Hon’ble Shri Justice P. Venkatarama Reddy (retired) as sole arbitrator.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF.

Key directives:

  • The appellant shall deposit Rs 20 crores with the Supreme Court Registry within four weeks.
  • Upon notice of deposit, PRAJITA must withdraw all security personnel and hand over possession within seven days, witnessed by the Commissioner of Police, Mumbai (or delegate), who shall file a Panchnama with the Court.
  • After filing the Panchnama, PRAJITA may withdraw the Rs 20 crores.
  • The question of further damages is referred to arbitration before Justice P. Venkatarama Reddy.

Implications are confined to the parties: the order secures immediate possession for the elderly appellant, compensates the developer-assignee, and channels any remaining monetary dispute to arbitration. No new legal precedent is announced for broader application.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Yusuf Khan Dilip Kumar Through Power Of Attorney v. Prajita Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Another S

    Chelameswar, J.:— Leave granted in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 18912 of 2017.

    2. The appellant aged about 95 years is also the applicant in Interlocutory Application No. 75003 of 2017 in Miscellaneous Application No. 629 of 2017 filed in SLP(C) Nos. 7483-7484/2016 filed by the 1 respondent herein, which stood dismissed by an order of this court dated 16.03.2016 For the sake of convenience, he is referred to hereafter as the appellant.

    3. The appellant owns landed property admeasuring 2412 sq. yards in Plot No. 16 of Pali Hill in the village of Dand, Bandra in the city of Bombay, now called Mumbai.

    4. The appellant entered into an agreement dated 23.6.2006 (hereafter referred to as AGREEMENT) with two companies namely M/s. Sharyans Resources Private Limited (hereinafter referred to as “SHARYANS”) and the 2 respondent herein, Goldbeam Construction Private Limited, both companies incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 (hereafter collectively referred to as DEVELOPERS).

    5. The substance of the AGREEMENT is that the appellant agreed to “grant to the DEVELOPERS the right to develop the said property” and the DEVELOPERS agreed to develop the property on various terms and conditions specified under the AGREEMENT. It appears from the record that there is some single venture partnership agreement between the two companies (DEVELOPERS). From the huge mass of documents filed in these appeals, it appears that there are two documents witnessing such partnership agreement. They are dated 16.6.2006 and 10.12.2008 The language and content of both the documents is substantially similar and an interesting fact which is required to be taken note of is that the 16 June 2006 document refers to the AGREEMENT dated 23.6.2006 The complete details of the terms and conditions of the AGREEMENT are not necessary for the purpose of this appeal.

    6. For the present, it must be noted that under the AGREEMENT, the DEVELOPERS agreed to an amount of Rs. 10 crores in three installments as detailed in the AGREEMENT. It is agreed under clause 4 of the AGREEMENT that “the owner shall permit the DEVELOPERS to enter upon the said property and to commence the development thereof….” It is agreed under clause 6 that all the necessary permissions/NOCs/orders which are required to be obtained shall be obtained by the DEVELOPERS. The appellant is obliged to cooperate by executing appropriate documents for the said purpose. Under Clause 17 of the AGREEMENT, it is stipulated that the “DEVELOPERS shall have the license to enter upon the said property”.

    7. Under Clause 31 of the AGREEMENT, it is provided that the DEVELOPERS shall commence development of the said property and the construction of the building thereof within 30 days from the date of the final amended building plan and complete the construction within a period of 24 months from the date of issue of the commencement certificate.

    8. The various legal consequences that would flow from the failure on the part of the DEVELOPERS to discharge the obligations under the AGREEMENT are provided under Clause 32 of the AGREEMENT. The crux of the Clause 32 is that in the event of the DEVELOPERS not performing their part of the obligations of completing the construction within the period stipulated in the AGREEMENT, the appellant is entitled to get the construction completed at the cost of the DEVELOPERS. Parties also agreed that such cost be determined by an independent architect of the appellant's choice. Once the cost is determined the appellant is entitled to call upon the DEVELOPERS to deposit such cost with the appellant's advocates and solicitors within a period of three months from the date of receipt of intimation of the cost. If the DEVELOPERS make such a deposit, the appellant is entitled to have the construction completed through “independent contractors” “at the risk and cost of the DEVELOPERS”. In the event of the DEVELOPERS failing to make such a deposit, the owner is entitled to terminate the AGREEMENT.

    9. By clause 33 of the AGREEMENT, the parties agreed that any dispute arising out of the breach of any one of the various clauses enumerated thereunder shall be resolved by arbitration. It is further provided that any dispute arising out of the termination of the AGREEMENT invoking Clause 32(A), shall not be the subject matter of any arbitration.

    10. M/s. Prajita Developers Private Limited, the petitioner in the disposed of SLP(C) Nos. 7483-7484/2016 and the 1 respondent in the present appeal (hereafter PRAJITA) claims to be the assignee of M/s. Sharyans Resources Private Limited. The terms of the assignment are said to be evidenced by the document “Deed of Assignment” dated 20.4.2010 confirmed by the appellant and the 2 respondent.

    11. A number of complicated arrangements were entered into in different combinations at different points of time between the appellant, the DEVELOPERS and some third parties to the AGREEMENT, who are otherwise said to be related to the appellant, the details of which we do not propose to mention in this order.

    12. The first respondent filed an application (No. 829 of 2015) under Section 9 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereafter referred to as ARBITRATION ACT) for an injunction restraining appellant from dispossessing respondent no. 1 and also an injunction restraining the appellant from creating any third party right, title or interest in the said property. Initially some ad-interim orders were passed in the said application, but the application itself was eventually dismissed on 14.01.2016

    13. PRAJITA carried the matter in an intra-court appeal (No. 74/2016) which also came to be dismissed by a judgment dated 04.03.2016 It is recorded therein;

    “Para 7 … Admittedly, as per the agreement, the development was supposed to commence within 30 days and should be completed within a time period of 12 months from the date of IOD/Commencement Certificate. The plans were approved on 2 January 2008 and CC was obtained 22 September 2008. No steps to initiate even construction were taken. Admittedly the development of the remaining was not completed before September 2011 - even the foundation was not laid, except some piling work with two columns. The position remained same till the year 2013-2014. The said position of 2013 and 2014 still remained same till this date. In the background, such construction/development contract so entered into by Respondent No. 1.owner to develop his property as a owner within his lifetime considering his age. The agreement clause itself shows that time was an essence of the contract to complete the development so that all the parties including the Appellants/Petitioners would get his 25% share after completion of the construction at this costs. The Appellants/Petitioners entitlement was only after completion of the development. The remaining 25% was admittedly of Gold Beam. In the remaining 50% area, the Appellants and/or Gold Beam and/or Sharyans had no right whatsoever. Their rights/interest/entitlement was also subject to the development and construction for the development potential area. The Developers could not even obtain permission, NOC, though obtain re-validation of CC till the year 2013. The Sharyans and his assignee/Petitioner/Prajita, therefore, failed to develop the property further as per the agreement.”6

    14. Aggrieved thereby, PRAJITA carried the matter in SLP (No. 7483-7484 of 2016) to this Court which was dismissed on 16.03.2016

    15. During the pendency of the abovementioned proceedings, on 14.09.2015, PRAJITA filed an application (No. 292 of 2015) under Section 11 of the ARBITRATION ACT praying that the dispute between the parties be referred to a Sole Arbitrator to be appointed by the High Court.

    16. The Arbitration Application No. 292 of 2015 was disposed of as withdrawn by an order of the Bombay High Court dated 25 July, 2016. Subsequently, another order dated 5 August, 2016 came to be passed in the said matter. The relevant portion of the order reads as follows:

    “The learned Advocate appearing for the Applicant on instructions seeks to withdraw the above Arbitration Application as the Applicant is desirous of filing a Suit. The Arbitration Application is disposed of as withdrawn with liberty as sought. However, it is clarified that if the Applicant files a Suit, the same shall be decided on its own merits and all contentions of the Respondents including their contention that the Suit would not be maintainable, are kept open”.

    17. Aggrieved by the order, the instant Civil Appeal (arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 18912 of 2017) is filed.

    18. On 8.10.2015, the appellant terminated the AGREEMENT and informed the same to PRAJITA by issuing a notice through his lawyer. Relevant part of the notice is as follows:

    “In view of the above, we hereby terminate the development agreement dated 23 June 2006. And we call upon you to remove yourself from the said property, with immediate effect, otherwise, our client will be taking appropriate action against you.

    Our client reserves his right to claim damages for not carrying out the activity of the construction on the said property and/or completing the work of construction within the stipulated time and causing severe hardship to our client.”

    19. We are informed that subsequently PRAJITA filed a Suit bearing No. 295 of 2016 on 28 September 2016 in the Bombay High Court on its Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction praying inter alia:—

    “a) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to declare that the Development Agreement dated 23 June 2006 (being Exhibit “C” hereto) is valid subsisting and binding upon the Defendant No. 1;

    b) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to declare that the purported termination notice dated 8 October 2015 issued by the Defendant No. 1 (being Exhibit “HH” hereto) is bad in law and contrary to and precluded by the specific terms of the Development Agreement dated 23 June 2006;

    c) That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to pass a Decree directing the Defendant No. 1 to specifically perform his obligations under the Development Agreement dated 23 June 2006.:

    20. It is not necessary to mention the various other prayers made in this Suit except to note that there are some more prayers.

    21. It appears that another two arbitration petitions are pending before the Bombay High Court. It is stated in Para 17 of the Interlocutory Application No. 75003/2017:

    “As on date, the Petition (under Section 9 of the said Act) filed by the Respondent No. 1.Applicant, before the Bombay High Court, being Arbitration Petition No. 697 of 2016, and the Application (under Section 11 of the said Act), filed by the Respondent No. 1.Applicant, before the Bombay High Court, being Arbitration Application No. 234 of 2016, are pending hearing and final disposal.”

    22. The details of those petitions are not readily available from the record placed before us.

    23. The following undisputed facts emerge:

    1. The appellant granted to the DEVELOPERS under the AGREMEENT of 23 June 2006 the “right to develop” the property in question;

    2. Under the AGREEMENT, the appellant is entitled to 50% of the “Development potential” and the DEVELOPERS jointly are entitled to the balance 50% of the “development potential”.

    3. Between the two companies which jointly constituted the DEVELOPERS, each company is entitled to 50% of that portion of the “development potential” which falls to the share of the DEVELOPERS;

    In other words, the share of SHARYANS is only 25% of the “development potential”;

    4. It is agreed between the parties that the construction must be completed within 24 months from the date of the issue of the commencement certificate of development, subject to some exceptions;

    5. M/s. PRAJITA is not the original party to the AGREEMENT but stepped into the shoes of M/s. SHARYANS on 20.04.2010 under a deed of assignment.

    6. As on date, no construction worth mentioning at all is made, not to mention about completing the construction;

    24. The background of the above-mentioned facts; When these matters were initially listed before us on 31 July, 2017 while adjourning the matter to 21 August, 2017, we called upon the learned senior counsel appearing on either side Shri Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for the appellant and Shri P. Chidambaram, appearing for PRAJITA to explore the possibility of an out of court settlement to give a quietus to the entire litigation. When the matter was listed on 21 August, 2017, on behalf of the appellant, it is stated by Shri Rohatgi that the appellant has in fact received so far an amount of Rs. 8.5 crores approximately from PRAJITA and its predecessor in interest. The appellant is willing to pay an amount of Rs. 20 crores to PRAJITA in order to have an undisturbed possession and peaceful enjoyment of the property in question. According to the appellant, PRAJITA has posted armed guards around the property in question preventing the appellant from entering the property.

    25. On the other hand, Shri Chidambaram appearing for PRAJITA submitted that PRAJITA is not agreeable for the settlement of the dispute on the terms offered by the appellant and since PRAJITA has rights acquired by the deed of assignment etc. referred to earlier in the property in question, it posted guards to protect the property in question from encroachment but not to prevent the appellant in any manner from visiting the property.

    26. Having regard to the totality of the circumstances, we are of the opinion that the ends of justice would be met in this case by directing as follows:—

    The appellant shall deposit an amount of Rs. 20 crores by demand draft to the Registry of this Court within a period of four weeks from today and intimate the same to PRAJITA. Upon the receipt of such intimation, PRAJITA shall withdraw all the security personnel deployed by it and hand over possession of the property in question within a period of seven days from the date of the receipt of the above-mentioned intimation to the appellant in the presence of the Commissioner of Police, Mumbai or any other senior police officer subordinate to the Commissioner of Police, Mumbai to be nominated by the Commissioner of Police.

    The Commissioner of Police or his nominee shall draw a Panchnama of the fact of the handing over of the property by PRAJITA to the appellant and file the same in the Registry of this Court within a week from the date of the handing over of the possession.

    Upon the filing of the Panchnama with the Registry of this Court, PRAJITA shall be at liberty to withdraw the amount of Rs. 20 crores deposited by the appellant pursuant to this order.

    27. We do not also see any justification for the demand of the PRAJITA for the specific performance of the agreement dated 23.6.2006 In the circumstances of the case, we are of the opinion that permitting the continuance of the suit for specific performance of the AGREEMENT which is more than a decade old against a person from whom PRAJITA secured the development rights of the property in dispute which ultimately would enable PRAJITA to 25 per cent of the monetary value of the development potential as against the right of the appellant who is entitled for 75 per cent of the monetary value of the development potential would be unjust.

    28. The background of the facts and circumstances of the case whether PRAJITA would be entitled for any damages apart from receiving the above-mentioned amount of Rs. 20 crores from the appellant is a matter which requires some examination. We therefore, deem it appropriate to refer the said question for resolution by arbitration between the appellant and PRAJITA. We, therefore, direct that the parties shall submit the above-mentioned dispute for arbitration by Hon'ble Shri Justice P. Venkatarama Reddy, former Judge of this Court in accordance with law. Registry is directed to communicate this Order to Hon'ble Shri Justice P. Venkatarama Reddy.

    29. Civil Appeal and Miscellaneous Application are disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Yusuf Khan Dilip Kumar Through Power Of Attorney v. Prajita Developers Pvt. Ltd. & Another S
    (Aug 30, 2017)