Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short 'the CPC')
  • SECTION 35 COURT FEES ACT 1870
  • Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC
  • Order 44 Rule 1 of the CPC,
  • Order 33 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • Order 2 Rule 4 of the Code,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short 'the CPC')
  • SECTION 35 COURT FEES ACT 1870
  • Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC
  • Order 44 Rule 1 of the CPC,
  • Order 33 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • Order 2 Rule 4 of the Code,
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — FA No. 134 of 2017 (High Court of Chhattisgarh, Bilaspur)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs (appellants) filed a suit which was dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) because they failed to pay the requisite court fees. Their application under Section 35 of the Court Fees Act, 1870, for exemption or relief had been refused. The plaintiffs appealed to the High Court (First Appeal FA No.134 of 2017) but again did not deposit the required court fees and instead filed I.A. No.1 under Section 149 CPC seeking exemption from payment of court fees for the appeal.

On hearing, the Court questioned the legal basis for granting such exemption in appeal proceedings — observing that Section 35 of the Court Fees Act does not, in terms, apply to appeals and noting provisions such as Order 44 Rule 1 CPC. The appellants' counsel submitted that the application sought relief in the peculiar facts so that a poor litigant would not suffer. The appellants' counsel subsequently sought permission for the plaintiffs to file a fresh suit along with an application under Order 33 Rule 1 CPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellate Court has power or discretion under the CPC or the Court Fees Act, 1870, to grant exemption from payment of court fees in appeal proceedings beyond the provision of Section 35 of the Court Fees Act.
  2. Whether the plaintiffs require leave or liberty from the appellate Court to file a fresh suit (in light of the counsel's request to be permitted to file a fresh suit with an application under Order 33 Rule 1 CPC).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The application under Section 149 CPC was moved because of the appellants' poor financial condition; they sought exemption so that the poor litigant does not suffer for want of funds to pay court fees.
  • Alternatively, the appellants requested liberty to file a fresh suit along with an application under Order 33 Rule 1 CPC.

The opinion does not detail any argument advanced on behalf of the respondent in the text provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari Kumari1 Held that if a second suit was maintainable in terms of Order 2 Rule 4 of the Code, no leave was required to be granted; a civil court does not grant leave to file another suit; if the law permits, the plaintiff may file another suit but not on the basis of observations made by a superior court. The Court relied on this authority to observe that if law permits the plaintiffs may file another suit and that no liberty/leave from this Court is required for that purpose.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded stepwise:

  1. The Court noted that the plaintiffs' original suit was dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC for non-payment of court fees and that the application under Section 35 of the Court Fees Act had already been refused.
  2. On the appellants' application under Section 149 CPC for exemption in the appeal, the Court queried the legal basis for such exemption because Section 35 of the Court Fees Act, 1870, does not, in terms, apply to appeal proceedings and no provision under the CPC was shown that conferred a discretion on the appellate Court to grant exemption from payment of court fees in appeal proceedings.
  3. The Court concluded that neither the CPC nor the Court Fees Act, 1870, confers such a discretion on the appellate Court to exempt payment of court fees; if the appellants were unable to pay, they should have sought appropriate relief in the trial Court.
  4. When counsel sought liberty to file a fresh suit with an application under Order 33 Rule 1 CPC, the Court referred to the Supreme Court decision in Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari and accepted the principle that if the law permits a second suit in terms of Order 2 Rule 4, no leave is required from the court to file that suit. The Court therefore observed that plaintiffs may file another suit if maintainable without needing liberty from the appellate Court.
  5. The Court dismissed I.A. No.1 as not maintainable. Although appellate practice often permits time to pay court fees after rejection of such an application, the Court declined to grant further time because counsel had stated plaintiffs were not in a position to pay and preferred to file a fresh suit.

Holding and Implications

I.A. No.1 seeking exemption from payment of court fees is dismissed as not maintainable; the First Appeal (FA No.134 of 2017) is also dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The appellants' application for exemption and their appeal are dismissed. The plaintiffs were not granted further time to deposit the appellate court fees.
  • The Court observed that, consistent with the cited Supreme Court decision, if the law permits a fresh/second suit (for example under Order 2 Rule 4), the plaintiffs are free to file such a suit and do not require leave from the court to do so.
  • No broader precedent was created by this order beyond application of existing provisions and the cited authority; the decision is confined to the dismissal of the application and the appeal on the basis stated in the opinion.

    Kalawati v. Gopal Prasad Shrivastava

    1NAFR HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR FA No. 134 of 2017

    1. Smt. Kalawati W/o Shri Shivcharan, Aged About 48 Years

    2. Hemant Puri S/o Shri Shivcharan Ram, Aged About 31 Years

    3. Smt. Sushila Puri @ Babli W/o Shri Hemant Puri, Aged About

    26 Years

    4. Ku. Kritanjali Puri D/o Shri Hemant Puri, Aged About 6 Years

    5. Sheryas Puri S/o Shri Hemant Puri, Aged About 1 Year Appellants No.4 & 5 are Minor Through their Father And Natural Guardian Appellant No.2, Hemant Puri S/o Shri Shivcharan Ram All are R/o Ward No.6, Ramanujganj, Post, P.S. And Tahsil Ramanujganj, District Balrampur, Chhattisgarh ---- Petitioner Versus

    1. Gopal Prasad Shrivastava S/o Late Kuldeep Sahay, Aged About 65 Years R/o Ward No.6, Ramanujganj, Post, P.S. And Tahsil Ramanujganj, District Balrampur, Chhattisgarh ---- Respondent For Appellants Shri A.K. Prasad, Advocate Hon'ble Shri Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra Hon'ble Shri Justice Arvind Singh Chandel Order On Board By Prashant Kumar Mishra, J. 226/07/2017

    I.A.No.1

    1. This is an application under Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short 'the CPC') for exemption from payment of Court fee.

    2. This first appeal has been preferred by the plaintiffs whose suit has been dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC when they failed to pay the requisite Court fees, despite having refused the application under Section 35 of the Court Fees Act, 1870 (for short 'the Act, 1870').

    3. In this appeal also the plaintiffs have not paid the requisite Court fees and have rather moved an application seeking exemption from payment of Court fees.

    4. When we confronted the learned counsel for the appellants as to under which provision of law, over and above the provision contained in Section 35 of the Act, 1870, which in terms does not apply to the appeal proceedings and the proceeding under Order 44 Rule 1 of the CPC, such exemption can be allowed by the appellate Court, learned counsel would fairly submit that the subject application is moved in the peculiar facts and 3circumstances of the case so that the poor litigant does not suffer for want of sufficient funds to pay the Court fees.

    5. We are afraid, under the CPC or under the Act, 1870, we have no such discretion to grant exemption from payment of Court fees. If the appellants had no fund to pay the Court fees it was for them to have moved the required application before the trial Court.

    6. At this stage, Shri Prasad, learned counsel appearing for the appellants, would submit that the appellants may be permitted to file a fresh suit along with an application under Order 33 Rule 1 of the CPC .

    7. For the above liberty prayed for by Shri Prasad, we may profitably refer the decision of the Supreme Court in Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari Kumari1, wherein it has been held that in any event, if a second suit was maintainable in terms of Order 2 Rule 4 of the Code, as was submitted by Ms. Luthra, no leave was required to be granted therefor. A civil court does not grant leave to file another suit. If the law permits, the plaintiff may file another suit but not on the basis of observations made by a superior court.

    1 (2007) 8 SCC 600

    48. In view of the above, we observe that if law permits, the plaintiffs may file another suit and for that no liberty is needed to them.

    9. Accordingly, I.A.No.1 seeking exemption from payment of Court fees is dismissed, being not maintainable.

    10. Ordinarily, if such application is rejected the appellate Court allows some time to the appellant to pay Court fees, however, in view of the statement made by Shri Prasad that the plaintiffs are not in a position to pay the Court fee, rather they would prefer to file a fresh suit along with an application under Order

    33 Rule 1 of the CPC, if such suit is maintainable, we are not allowing further time to the plaintiffs for payment of Court fees.

    11. As a consequence of dismissal of I.A.No.1, the First Appeal (FA No.134 of 2017) is also dismissed with the observation as stated supra. Sd/- Sd/- Judge Judge Prashant Kumar Mishra Arvind Singh Chandel Gowri 5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kalawati v. Gopal Prasad Shrivastava
    (Jul 26, 2017)