Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — Land Acquisition Appeal (Wardha)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 02.04.2005 in Land Acquisition Case No.45/1995 delivered by the 4th Adhoc Additional District Judge, Wardha. The appellant was aggrieved that the Reference Court enhanced compensation by Rs.2,64,390 as against the appellant's claim for enhancement of Rs.1,26,199.

Procedurally: land bearing Survey No.495 (3.0 hectares) in Mouza Deoli was acquired following a Section 4 notification dated 14.12.1989. The Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) awarded compensation valuing the land at Rs.28,000 per hectare, Rs.51,799 for a well, and Rs.2,10,262 for fruit and other trees, with a total award of Rs.3,48,391 (with solatium and interest) in the award dated 13.07.1997. The appellant filed a reference petition seeking enhancement; the Reference Court partly allowed the petition and enhanced compensation by Rs.2,64,390. The appellant appealed from that order.

The appellant led oral evidence including himself and two witnesses to prove comparable sale instances and other factual contentions; the Reference Court excluded a 1995 sale as post-notification and found the 1983 sale instance inapplicable for reasons of non-comparability and lack of proximity as shown on maps. The appellate court reviewed these findings and the legal principles invoked by the parties and modified the Reference Court's award as to the per-hectare rates for irrigated and non-irrigated portions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the market value of the acquired land (Survey No.495) should be enhanced on the basis of comparable sale instances relied upon by the appellant.
  2. Whether comparable sale instances relied upon (a 1983 sale and a 1995 sale) are admissible and comparable for valuation purposes given proximity, timing (proximate to Section 4 notification), similarity of land and plot size.
  3. Whether compensation for a pipeline laid in the acquired land should be awarded separately in addition to land compensation, or whether it is covered as part of 'land' or benefits arising out of land.
  4. Whether the compensation fixed for fruit trees (orange trees, teak, hybrid trees) requires enhancement in the absence of evidence about yield, age or income from those trees.
  5. Whether the potentiality or future development of surrounding area requires awarding compensation at commercial rates rather than agricultural rates.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The LAO's valuation of land at Rs.28,000 per hectare was nominal; the market value in 1989 should be Rs.1,125,000 per hectare.
  • The compensation for the well (awarded Rs.51,799) should be increased to Rs.1,50,000.
  • There were 277 orange trees; at Rs.2,500 per tree the appellant claimed Rs.6,92,500 (as opposed to Rs.2,10,262 awarded).
  • A cement pipeline of 1900 sq.ft. (claimed at Rs.150 per foot for Rs.2,85,000) had been laid and compensation should be awarded for it separately.
  • Claimed compensation of Rs.32,000 for 8 teak trees (Rs.4,000 each) and Rs.7,500 for 5 hybrid bor trees.
  • The land had non-agricultural potential and was near municipal limits and several non-agricultural uses; therefore, future development and commercial potential should be considered in assessing market value (relied on Digamber and State of Orissa authorities).

Respondent(s)' Arguments

  • Contended that the pipeline, being attached to the earth or permanently fastened, falls within the definition of "land" under Section 3(a), thus its price constitutes benefits arising out of land and is not payable separately.
  • Asserted that there was no admissible evidence that a pipeline had been laid (no supporting material), so separate compensation could not be awarded.
  • Maintained that comparable sale instances must satisfy criteria (genuineness, proximity in time to Section 4 notification, vicinity, similarity, comparable plot size), and the appellant failed to prove these—reliance placed on Shaji Kuriakose.
  • Relied on Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Karigowda (and State of Orissa v. Brij Lal Misra) to argue that award of enhanced compensation on mere potentiality or future development would be contrary to the statutory scheme (Section 24 clauses referenced in the reasoning).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shaji Kuriakose & another vs. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. and others, (2001) 7 SCC 650 Sets out the preferred use of comparable sales method for market valuation and enumerates factors for considering a sale comparable: (1) genuineness, (2) temporal proximity to Section 4 notification, (3) vicinity to the acquired land, (4) similarity of land, and (5) comparable plot size; permits adjustments when dissimilarity exists. The court applied these criteria to reject the appellant's sale instances: the 1995 sale was post-notification and therefore not considered; the 1983 sale was found non-comparable due to lack of demonstrated vicinity, dissimilar size and description, and absence of the survey number on the map; hence the sale could not be used to award compensation at the rate shown in that sale deed.
Digamber & Ors. vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors., AIR 2013 SC 3532 Invoked by appellant to support the proposition that future development and potentiality of nearby area should be considered when assessing market value. The court noted the appellant's reliance on this authority but balanced it against statutory constraints and other precedents; ultimately it did not award commercial rates solely on claimed potentiality because relevant statutory conditions and evidence were not met.
State of Orissa vs. Brij Lal Misra and others, (1995) 5 SCC 203 Used in discussions about the limits on enhancing compensation based on future potentiality; referenced both by appellant and by later authority relied upon by respondents. The court recognized this authority as part of the jurisprudential background on potentiality, and—through reliance on later authority (Karigowda)—concluded that mere potentiality or surrounding non-agricultural use does not justify awarding commercial rates absent statutory justification and evidence.
Special Land Acquisition Officer vs. Karigowda and others, (2010) 5 SCC 708 Held (relying on State of Orissa v. Brij Lal Misra) that increasing compensation on account of potentiality or future potential use would be contrary to certain provisions (noted as clauses of Section 24) unless statutory conditions are met. The respondents relied on this decision; the court accepted the principle that compensation should not be enhanced merely because nearby lands are in non-agricultural use or because the acquired land might be used non-agriculturally later, especially where the claimant had not sought non-agricultural classification or provided supporting evidence.
Earlier judgments in L.A.C. Nos.51/1995, 54/1995, 55/1995 and 63/1995 (local reference judgments) Used as comparative reference awards for lands in the same area; those references had fixed rates at Rs.30,000 per hectare for dry crop land and Rs.45,000 per hectare for irrigated land. The Reference Court had relied on these earlier awards for similarly situated plots (as reflected on map Exh.50). The appellate court agreed that those reference awards were applicable and directed compensation in the instant case be calculated at the same per-hectare rates (Rs.30,000 non-irrigated; Rs.45,000 irrigated).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by testing the appellant's evidence and claims against statutory definitions and established principles of valuation, applying precedents cited by the parties.

  1. Comparable Sales Analysis:

    The court applied the factors from Shaji Kuriakose for admissibility of comparable sales.

    The 1995 sale instance was excluded because it was post-notification and therefore not proximate in time to the Section 4 date. The 1983 sale (purchase of 2340 sq. mt. for Rs.7,55,334) was examined and rejected as comparable because: (a) the plot was much smaller than the acquired land; (b) the map (Exh.50) and the sale deed description did not establish that the bank's plot was adjacent to or in the immediate vicinity of the acquired Survey No.495; and (c) the surveyed plot number appearing in the saledeed (Survey No.125) was not shown as adjacent or near the appellant's land on the record map. Given these dissimilarities, the court concluded the sale instance could not be relied upon to fix compensation at the higher rate claimed.

  2. Reliance on Earlier Local Awards:

    In the absence of cogent, comparable sale instances, the Reference Court rightly relied on earlier judgments in L.A.C. Nos.51/1995, 54/1995, 55/1995 and 63/1995 relating to lands in the same area and reflected on the same map (Exh.50). Those judgments had assessed market price at Rs.30,000 per hectare for dry crop land and Rs.45,000 per hectare for irrigated land. The Reference Court had applied those rates to the present case in part, but modified as to irrigation treatment; on appeal the court concluded that the compensation awarded in those references should be adopted here as well.

  3. Irrigation and Extent of Irrigated Area:

    The Reference Court observed, and the appellate court accepted, that there was no evidence to show the entire field (3 H 8 R) was irrigated: the presence of 277 orange trees indicated only a portion appeared under irrigated cultivation. Thus the court declined to treat the whole land as irrigated for the higher rate; it directed compensation to be computed distinguishing between non-irrigated and irrigated portions at the said rates.

  4. Pipeline Claim:

    Respondents relied on Section 3(a)'s definition of "land" (including benefits arising out of land and things attached to the earth) to submit that a pipeline, if permanently fastened to the earth, is part of the land and not separately compensable. The court found that no sufficient evidence was produced to prove the pipeline's existence or extent; the Reference Court had noted absence of evidence that a pipeline had been laid to supply water from the well. Given lack of supporting material and the statutory framing, the court refused to award separate compensation for the pipeline.

  5. Compensation for Trees:

    The appellant failed to produce evidence regarding yield, income, age or other particulars of the orange trees; absent such evidence the court declined to disturb the valuation made by the LAO and confirmed by the Reference Court for trees. Thus tree compensation was left intact.

  6. Potentiality and Commercial Rate Argument:

    Although the appellant contended that surrounding non-agricultural uses and potential warranted commercial valuation, the court noted precedents (including Karigowda and Brij Lal Misra) indicating that enhancement purely on potentiality or future development is not permissible absent statutory basis and proper factual foundation. Because the appellant had not applied for non-agricultural use nor produced adequate evidence demonstrating entitlement to commercial rates, compensation at agricultural rates (with differentiation for irrigated portion) was held appropriate.

  7. Overall Disposition:

    The appellate court concluded that the Reference Court should not have reduced the amount of compensation relative to those earlier local awards and therefore directed that compensation be calculated at Rs.30,000 per hectare for non-irrigated land and Rs.45,000 per hectare for irrigated land. Other claims (pipeline, higher tree awards, well amount) failed for lack of admissible evidence or on legal grounds discussed above.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is partly allowed: the court modified the impugned Reference Court judgment only to the extent of directing that compensation for the acquired land be calculated at Rs.30,000 per hectare for non-irrigated (dry crop) land and Rs.45,000 per hectare for irrigated land.

Direct Consequences for the Parties:

  • The appellant obtains enhancement limited to recalculation of land compensation using the specified per-hectare rates (distinguishing irrigated and non-irrigated portions).
  • No separate compensation was awarded for the alleged pipeline due to lack of evidence and because such fixtures fall within the statutory concept of "land" or benefits arising out of land.
  • The LAO's valuations for trees and the award for the well were not disturbed for lack of sufficient supporting evidence by the appellant.

Broader Implications:

The decision modifies the monetary award in this case only and does not purport to lay down new legal principles beyond reaffirming established precedent on comparable sales, admissibility of evidence, and the limits of awarding compensation on the basis of potentiality. No new precedent was set.

Final Disposition: The appeal is disposed of in the terms stated above.

Source: Extracted and summarized strictly from the provided opinion text. No information has been added beyond that text.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Abdul Hamid v. State Of Maharashtra

    fa79.06.J.odt 1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR

    FIRST APPEAL NO.79 OF 2006

    Abdul Hamid s/o Abdul Majid Aged about 47 years, Occ: Cultivator, R/o Deoli, District Wardha. ....... APPELLANT

    ...V E R S U S...

    1] State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Wardha,

    Tah. & Dist. Wardha.

    2] The Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation having its Head Office at Bombay and Branch Office at Udyog Bhavan, Civil Lines, Nagpur, through its Area Manager, Wardha. ....... RESPONDENTS

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Shri A.Z. Jibhkate, Advocate for Appellant.

    Ms. Shamsi Haider, AGP for Respondent No.1.

    Shri M.M. Agnihotri, Advocate for Respondent No.2.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    CORAM: SMT. DR. SHALINI PHANSALKAR-JOSHI, J.

    DATE: 12 th JUNE, 2017.

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    1] Being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 02.04.2005 passed in Land Acquisition Case No.45/1995 by

    1

    the 4thAdhoc Additional District Judge, Wardha, whereby the additional compensation of Rs.2,64,390/- as against the claim for enhancement of Rs.1,26,199/- was granted, the appellant has preferred this appeal.

    2] Facts of the appeal can be stated as follows:

    In pursuance of the notification issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act on 14.12.1989, the land bearing S.No.495 admeasuring 3.0 hectare of Mouza Deoli situated on Deoli-Wardha and Deolin-Pulgaon road came to be acquired. The Land Acquisition Officer assessed the market value of the land at the rate of Rs.28,000/- per hectare. He also allowed the amount of Rs.51,799/- for the well situated in the land and Rs.2,10,262/- towards the fruit bearing and other trees. The total claim of Rs.3,48,391/- was allowed with solatium and interest by the award dated

    13.07.1997.

    3] Being not satisfied with the same, the appellant/claimant approached the learned Reference Court contending inter alia that the amount of compensation

    2

    granted towards the price of the land was nominal only and it should be increased to the rate of Rs.1,125,000/- per hectare. Even as regards the compensation for well, it was claimed that the proper amount of compensation will be of Rs.1,50,000/- and not Rs.51,799/-, as awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer. It was further submitted that there were totally 277 orange trees in the land and hence, the compensation at the rate of Rs.2500/- per tree comes to Rs.6,92,500/-, whereas the learned Reference Court has awarded the amount of Rs.2,10,262/- only in totality. It was further submitted that the Land Acquisition Officer has not awarded any amount towards the compensation of the cement pipeline laid in the acquired land. The said pipeline is running 1900 sq.ft. and at the rate of Rs.150/- per feet the compensation of Rs.2,85,000/- should be awarded, which was not awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer. The appellant has also claimed compensation of Rs.32,000/- towards 8 teak wood trees at the rate of Rs.4000/- per tree and Rs.7500/- for 5 hybrid bor trees. According to the learned counsel for appellant, without considering the situation, location and potentiality of the acquired Land

    3

    Acquisition Officer has awarded the compensation, hence it needs to be enhanced. Reference Court allowed the petition partly enhancing the compensation amount by Rs.2,64,390/- as against the claim of Rs.1,26,199/-.

    4] Before the Reference Court, in support of his case, the appellant has examined himself and two more witnesses to bring on record the evidence relating to sale instances. According to him, in the year 1989 the market price of the land was Rs.1,25,000/- per hectare. His field was just near to the limit of the Municipal Council and it was on Deoli-Wardha road and Deoli-Pulgaon road. Moreover, it had non-agricultural potential. The area nearby was occupied by the offices of Agricultural Produce Market Committee, Ginning and Pressing Factory, Tahsil Office, Government Rest House. The weekly bazaar of Deoli town was just at a distance of 1 km. Further, the quality of the land was fertile and the field was irrigated with water from the well. The appellant also examined witness No.2-Ravindrakumar to prove the sale-deed executed in the year 1983. He has further examined witness No.3 to prove another sale transaction of

    4

    the year 1995.

    5] The learned Reference Court did not consider the second sale transaction, it being of the year 1995, and therefore, post notification.

    6] As regards the sale instance produced and proved through the evidence of witness No.2-Ravindrakumar, learned Reference Court found that it was of the year 1983 and the plot purchased was admeasuring 2340 sq.mt. for the amount of Rs.7,55,334/-. The learned Reference Court therefore held that this sale instance is of a much smaller portion of the land than the acquired land. Secondly though it was stated by this witness that the land purchased by the Bank is near the land acquired, the map (Exh.50) produced on the record, nowhere showed that this land purchased by the Bank was adjacent to the acquired land. The Reference Court has considered this aspect in para 8 of its judgment. It has also considered that the description of this plot, as given in the sale-deed made it clear that the said plot was near the residential area and Survey No.125 of that plot

    5

    must be far away from the acquired land of the appellant, which was bearing Survey No.495. The Reference Court also found that in the map Exh.50, the said survey number of the land purchased by the Bank was not appearing. In this appeal also on perusal of the map (Exh.50) it is noticed that the Survey No.125 of the plot acquired by Bank, is not at all appearing either adjacent or near the field of the appellant. In such a situation, the said sale instance is rightly not relied upon by the Reference Court as comparable sale instance.

    7] Learned counsel for the respondent has in this respect rightly placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in Shaji Kuriakose and another vs. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. and others reported in (2001) 7 SCC 650, in para 3 of this judgment which is reproduced below:

    3. It is no doubt true that courts adopt comparable sales method of valuation of land while fixing the market value of the acquired land. While fixing the market value of the acquired land, comparable sales method of valuation is preferred than other methods of valuation of land such as capitalization of net income method or expert opinion method. Comparable sales method of

    6

    valuation is preferred because it furnishes the evidence for determination of the market value of the acquired land at which a willing purchaser would pay for the acquired land if it had been sold in the open market at the time of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act. However, comparable sales method of valuation of land for fixing the market value of the acquired land is not always conclusive. There are certain factors which are required to be fulfilled and on fulfillment of those factors the compensation can be awarded, according to the value of the land reflected in the sales. The factors laid down inter alia are: (1) the sale must be a genuine transaction, (2) that the sale deed must have been executed at the time proximate to the date of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act, (3) that the land covered by the sale must be in the vicinity of the acquired land,

    (4) that the land covered by the sales must be similar to the acquired land, and (5) that the size of plot of the land covered by the sales be comparable to the land acquired. If all these factors are satisfied, then there is no reason why the sale value of the land covered by the sales be not given for the acquired land. However, if there is a dissimilarity in regard to locality, shape, site or nature of land between land covered by sales and land acquired, it is open to the court to proportionately reduce the compensation for acquired land than what is reflected in the sales depending upon the disadvantages attached with the acquired land.

    8] In the present case, if the above criteria as laid down by the Apex Court are applied, it can be seen that the appellant has failed to bring sufficient evidence on record to

    7

    show that the land under the sale-deed of the Bank was in the vicinity of the acquired land. Moreover, there is also no evidence to show that the land covered by the said sale-deed is similar to the acquired land. The said land was also comparatively of much smaller size. In such a situation, the sale instance proved through the evidence of witness No.2 by the appellant cannot be used for awarding the compensation, at the rate mentioned in the said sale-deed.

    9] The learned Reference Court has thus in the absence of any cogent evidence regarding the sale instances, rightly relied upon the earlier judgment in L.A.C. Nos.51/1995, 54/1995, 55/1995 and 63/1995. The said judgment pertains to the lands acquired from the same area and the survey numbers of those lands are found reflected in the map Exh.50. The Reference Court therefore, held that those plots are similarly situated and hence the market price of the said lands as assessed by the Reference Court for those lands at the rate of Rs.30,000/- for dry crop land and Rs.45,000/- for irrigated land can be made applicable to the instant case also. In para 10 of its judgment the learned

    8

    Reference Court held that there was no evidence to show that entire acquired land was irrigated because the field is big one admeasuring 3 H 8 R and the total orange trees cultivated therein were only 277. Therefore, it reflects that only portion of the field was under irrigated crop of orange trees. In the absence of any evidence relating to laying down pipeline in the field, the Reference Court found it would not be proper to grant compensation at the rate of Rs.45,000/- per hectare, as was granted in the reference in one of the case and hence, granted the compensation at the rate of Rs.30,000/- per hectare.

    10] In my considered opinion the Reference Court should not have reduced the amount of compensation in this case, which was awarded to the other lands acquired under L.A.C. Nos.51/1995, 54/1995, 55/1995 and 63/1995. The compensation awarded in those references at the rate of Rs.30,000/- for dry crop land and Rs.45,000/- for irrigated land should be awarded in this case also and to that extent the modification is required in the impugned judgment and order of the Reference Court. Accordingly, it is directed that

    9

    the compensation for the acquired land be calculated at the rate of Rs.30,000/- for non-irrigated land and Rs.45,000/- for irrigated land.

    11] As regards the claim, made by the appellant towards the cost of pipeline, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 and 2 has relied upon the definition of the 'land' as given in Section 3 sub-clause (a) which states that "the expression 'land' includes benefits arising out of land, and things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth." Herein in the case it is submitted by learned counsel for the respondent Nos.1 and 2 that the pipeline being attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth, price of the said pipeline is included in the benefits arising out of the land. Therefore, no separate amount of compensation can be awarded towards the construction of pipeline. Learned counsel for respondents has also pointed out that absolutely no evidence is produced on record by the appellant to prove the construction of the pipeline. This Court also finds that Reference Court has considered this aspect in para 10 of

    10

    its judgment, and has specifically observed that there is no evidence that pipeline was laid down in the field to supply water from the well. In such a situation, in the absence of any sufficient material produced on record merely on the vague statement of the appellant that he has laid the pipeline, the amount of compensation cannot be awarded towards the construction of the pipeline.

    12] As regards the compensation for orange trees, though according to appellant, the amount awarded is not sufficient, again no evidence was produced on record by the appellant as regards the yield of the orange trees or the approximate income which he was getting from those trees or even as to the age of those trees. In the absence thereof, the valuation arrived at by the Land Acquisition Officer and confirmed by Reference Court cannot be disturbed with.

    13] Learned counsel for appellant has placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in Digamber & Ors. vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors. reported in AIR 2013 SC 3532

    11

    and State of Orissa vs. Brij Lal Misra and others reported in (1995) 5 SCC 203 to submit that while assessing the market value of the land, future development in the nearby area is required to be considered. It is submitted that in the instant case, as the land was acquired for the non-residential purpose and the surrounding lands were also being used for non- residential purpose, the market price of the land has to be calculated at commercial rate.

    14] However, in this respect learned counsel for respondents has relied upon the judgment of Apex Court in Special Land Acquisition Officer vs. Karigowda and others reported in (2010) 5 SCC 708, wherein reliance is placed on its own decision in the case of State of Orisa vs. Brij Lal Misra and others reported in (1995) 5 SCC 203 and it was held in para 48 "that the increase in the amount awarded by way of compensation keeping in view the potentiality of the land and further increase on future potentiality would be contrary to the provisions of Clauses "fifthly and sixthly" of Section 24 of the Act. The provisions of the Act require the Court to take into consideration various other factors including increase in

    12

    the value of the acquired land likely to accrue from the use for which it was acquired may be put to on a subsequent stage in regard to layout or important scheme etc."

    Admittedly, in the instant case, the appellant's land was used for agriculture purpose and he has not applied for non-agricultural use or for laying out plots. In such circumstances, merely because other nearby lands are used non-agricultural purposes or after acquisition, appellant's land was to be used for non-agricultural purposes, the compensation cannot be granted at the commercial rate.

    15] As a result, the appeal is allowed partly to the extent that the compensation is awarded at the rate of Rs.30,000/- per hectare for non-irrigated land and Rs.45,000/- per hectare for irrigated land. To this limited extent only, the impugned judgment and order of the Reference Court is modified.

    16] The appeal stands disposed of in above term.

    JUDGE

    NSN

    13

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Abdul Hamid v. State Of Maharashtra
    (Jun 12, 2017)