Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act and the relevant provisions of the Indian Succession Act,
  • Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act as also unamended Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act
  • Act 48 of 2001 Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT 1882
  • Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)
  • SECTION 54 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT 1882
  • Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
  • Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act
  • SECTION 202 CONTRACT ACT 1872
  • Section 202 of the Contract Act21.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act and the relevant provisions of the Indian Succession Act,
  • Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act as also unamended Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act
  • Act 48 of 2001 Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT 1882
  • Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)
  • SECTION 54 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT 1882
  • Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
  • Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act
  • SECTION 202 CONTRACT ACT 1872
  • Section 202 of the Contract Act21.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant/plaintiff claimed ownership of 200 sq. yards of property located in khasra no. 419, Village Saboli, Gali No. 10, Shahdara, Delhi. Out of this, 70 sq. yards were sold to respondent no. 1/defendant no. 1 on 11.2.1998 for Rs. 1,75,000/-. On the same date, various documents including an agreement to sell, general power of attorney (GPA), and a Will were executed in favor of the respondent no. 1. Possession of the 70 sq. yards, comprising two rooms, a latrine, and a bathroom, was taken by the respondents on 11.2.1998. The defendant no. 1 passed away during the litigation and is now represented by legal heirs. The appellant/plaintiff alleged non-payment of the full consideration and purportedly cancelled the documents on 6.4.1998, sending a legal notice to the respondents. Despite cancellation, the respondents did not vacate the property, leading to the filing of the suit for possession, permanent injunction, and mandatory injunction. The respondents contested the suit, asserting full payment was made and the cancellation was invalid and dishonest. They also claimed possession of the adjoining 130 sq. yards, making the total possession 200 sq. yards. The trial court and first appellate court dismissed the suit, holding the cancellation ineffective and that the respondents had rights and possession over the 70 sq. yards.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant/plaintiff could validly cancel the documents executed on 11.2.1998, including the general power of attorney and agreement to sell, on the ground of non-payment of full consideration.
  2. Whether the cancellation document dated 6.4.1998 had legal effect given the provisions of Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
  3. Whether the appellant/plaintiff was entitled to possession and injunction relief over the 70 sq. yards or the entire 200 sq. yards of the suit property.
  4. Whether a second appeal under Section 100 CPC was maintainable on the facts and legal questions raised.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Claimed ownership of 200 sq. yards and sale of 70 sq. yards to respondent no. 1.
  • Asserted non-payment of the entire sale consideration, justifying cancellation of the documents dated 11.2.1998 by the cancellation document dated 6.4.1998.
  • Filed suit seeking possession, permanent injunction, and mandatory injunction.
  • Later argued for possession of the entire 200 sq. yards, though this was not pleaded or supported by evidence in the courts below.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Asserted full payment of Rs. 1,75,000/- was made at the time of executing the documents on 11.2.1998.
  • Denied validity of the cancellation document, alleging it was executed with dishonest intentions and without authority.
  • Claimed possession of the entire 200 sq. yards, including adjoining 130 sq. yards owned and possessed by them.
  • Prayed for dismissal of the suit filed by the appellant/plaintiff.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hardik Kaur v. Kailash (2012) DLT 168 Interpretation of Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 - irrevocability of general power of attorney given for consideration. Used to hold that the general power of attorney dated 11.2.1998 was irrevocable and the appellant/plaintiff had no right to cancel it.
Ramesh Chand v. Suresh Chand, 188 (2012) DLT 538 Validity of documents executed prior to amendment of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and rights created by such documents. Relied upon to affirm that documents executed before 24.9.2001 were valid and that the respondents had rights and possession over the property.
Suraj Lamps and Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana, 183 (2011) DLT 1 (SC) Validity of agreements to sell, power of attorneys and Wills executed in accordance with Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act and Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act prior to statutory amendments. Applied to confirm that pre-amendment documents remain valid and enforceable, supporting the courts' conclusions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the bilateral nature of contracts transferring immovable property rights, emphasizing that such contracts cannot be unilaterally cancelled. It relied heavily on Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, which renders a general power of attorney given for consideration irrevocable. The courts below found that the appellant/plaintiff failed to prove the cancellation deeds properly, as only photocopies were produced and no valid cause for cancellation was mentioned in the documents or legal notice. The agreement to sell was not cancelled and showed receipt of full consideration and delivery of possession, undermining the appellant's claim of non-payment. The courts also noted that possession was with the respondents and that the cancellation was ineffective. The appellant's attempt to claim possession of the entire 200 sq. yards was rejected as it was neither pleaded nor supported by evidence. The court further held that no substantial question of law arose to maintain the second appeal under Section 100 CPC, as the findings were based on facts and proper application of law. The appeal was dismissed as meritless and an abuse of process.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The court upheld the concurrent findings of the trial and first appellate courts that the cancellation of the documents dated 11.2.1998 was legally ineffective and that the respondents have valid rights and possession over the 70 sq. yards sold. The appellant/plaintiff was not entitled to possession or injunction relief either over the 70 sq. yards or the entire 200 sq. yards. The dismissal includes a cost order of Rs. 25,000/- payable by the appellant/plaintiff, reinforcing the decision as a deterrent against abuse of process. No new legal precedent was established; the decision affirms established principles regarding irrevocability of power of attorney given for consideration and the non-unilateral cancellability of bilateral contracts in immovable property transactions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Vimla Devi v. Pushpa Devi And Anr. S

    Valmiki J. Mehta, J. (Oral)

    C.M Appl. Nos. 20929-30/2017 (for exemptions)

    1. Exemptions allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

    2. C.Ms stand disposed of.

    RSA No. 157/2017 and C.M Appl. No. 20928/2017 (for stay)

    3. This Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) impugns the concurrent judgments of the courts below; of the Trial Court dated 28.3.2016 and the First Appellate Court dated 4.3.2017; by which the suit filed by the appellant/plaintiff for possession, permanent injunction and mandatory injunction, has been dismissed.

    4. The facts of the case are that appellant/plaintiff claimed that she was the owner of 200 sq. yards of the property situated in khasra no. 419, Village Saboli, Gali No. 10, Shahdara, Delhi. Out of the area of 200 sq. yards, the appellant/plaintiff sold 70 sq. yards to the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1 on 11.2.1998 for a sale consideration of Rs. 1,75,000/-. On 11.2.1998, appellant/plaintiff executed the usual set of documentation being the agreement to sell, general power of attorney, Will, receipt, etc. in favour of the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1. I may note that the defendant no. 1 in the suit expired pendente lite and therefore she is now represented by her legal heirs. The area of 70 sq. yards consists of two rooms, a latrine and a bath room, and possession of which was taken by the respondents/defendants on 11.2.1998 It was further pleaded in the plaint that since there was non-payment of the entire consideration hence the appellant/plaintiff cancelled the documentation dated 11.2.1998 by the cancellation document dated 6.4.1998, and appellant/plaintiff also sent a legal notice of the same date to the respondents/defendants. It was further pleaded that inspite of cancellation of the documents on 6.4.1998 the respondents/defendants did not vacate the suit property, and hence the subject suit was filed. For the sake of completion of narration it may be stated that defendant no. 1 in the suit was the wife of defendant no. 2, and respondents in this appeal are the defendant no. 2 and the legal heirs of the deceased defendant no. 1.

    5. The suit was contested by the respondents/defendants. It was pleaded by the respondents/defendants that complete consideration of Rs. 1,75,000/- was paid when the documents dated 11.2.1998 were executed in favour of the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1. It was also pleaded that the appellant/plaintiff with dishonest intentions cancelled the documents on 6.4.1998 It was pleaded by the respondents/defendants that appellant/plaintiff had no authority to cancel the documents and hence the cancellation has no significance to the purchase of the suit property by the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1. The respondents/defendants pleaded that the adjoining 130 sq. yards to the plot of 70 sq. yards was already owned and was in possession of the respondents/defendants, and hence the respondents/defendants are in possession of the whole 200 sq. yards. The suit was accordingly prayed to be dismissed.

    6. The main issue which was argued before the courts below, and also before this Court on behalf of the appellant/plaintiff, was that since the complete consideration was not paid hence the documents dated 11.2.1998 executed by the appellant/plaintiff in favour of the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1 were validly cancelled by the cancellation document dated 6.4.1998 and which was duly registered before the Sub-Registrar.

    7. The courts below have held that the documents dated 11.2.1998 executed by the appellant/plaintiff in favour of the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1 could not have been legally cancelled. For the disentitlement of the appellant/plaintiff to cancel the general power of attorney reliance is placed by the courts below to Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 which provides that the general power of attorney given for consideration is irrevocable. The courts below have also held that the cancelled documents do not mention that consideration was not received as was the case of the appellant/plaintiff and nor is any other cause mentioned for cancellation of the documents dated 6.4.1998 Also, the courts below have held that the cancellation is only of the general power of attorney and there is no cancellation of the agreement to sell. Trial court has in this regard made the following salient observations in paras 20 to 25 of its judgment, and which paras read as under:—

    “20. In the matter of Hardik Kaur v. Kailash (S.B) 193 (2012) DLT 168 it was stated “the words” and interest in property which forms the subject matter of the agency” in Section 202 of the Contract Act, 1872 are of wider amplitude than the words “an interest in or charge on such property” in Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Where the seller has received the sale consideration in pursuance of the agreement to sell and has delivered the possession to the purchaser, the purchaser would have interest in the property within the meaning of Section 202 of the Contract Act”

    21. Thus the GPA dated 11.02.1998 is irrevocable in view of Section 202 of the Contract Act, 1872. The plaintiff, therefore, had no right to terminate the said GPA. The revocation of the GPA by plaintiff is, therefore, of no consequence.

    22. Moreover the plaintiff has shown only the photocopies of the cancellation deeds Ex.PW 1/7 and Ex PW 1/8 dated 06.04.1998 The cancellation deeds are thus not proved on record. The documents can be looked at, at the instance of the opposite party. The cancellation deed neither mentions that consideration was not received nor has any other cause of cancellation been specified. The non-disclosure of any reason in the cancellation deed clearly suggests that there was in fact no dispute about consideration, as being claimed by the plaintiff in his suit. In addition, the legal notice sent makes no mention of the fact that the consideration amount had not been received. Moreover, the legal notice also does not state as to whether upon cancellation the consideration amount paid was being returned to the defendant by the plaintiff.

    23. Even if it is assumed for the sake of argument that the cancellation deeds are genuine, the agreement tot sell of which the plaintiff has placed on record a certified copy Ex.PW 1/2 was never cancelled by the plaintiff. As per the agreement to sell, it is on record that the possession was handed over by the plaintiff to defendant no. 1 while executing the documents. It is also clearly stated in the agreement to sell which is a document admitted by both parties that the consideration of Rs. 1,75,000/- has been paid by the defendants to the plaintiff. The plaintiff has also executed a receipt of the same amount. Hence the plaintiff has no right to cancel or revoke documents dated 11.02.1998 which were executed by the plaintiff in favour of defendant no. 1 for sale of 70 sq. yards of the suit property.

    24. Placing reliance on judgments of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in Ramesh Chand v. Suresh Chand, 188 (2012) DLT 538 and Hardip Kaur v. Kailash & Anr…. S Supra, it is held that Defendant no. 1 in the matter at hand thus may not be a classical owner as would be in case of a registered sale deed, however, they would have certain rights and entitlement over the property. Furthermore this coupled with the fact that the defendants also have actual physical possession, builds a strong case in their favour. Thus, the interest created by the agreement entered into between the parties still lies with the defendant.

    25. On basis of the discussion above, it is held that plaintiff is not entitled to the relief of possession or injunction in regard 70 sq. yards of the suit property as claimed for. Furthermore the plaintiff has asked for the relief of permanent injunction in relation to the whole 200 sq. yards. When the relief of 70 sq. yards out of 200 sq. yards cannot be granted, there is no question of granting a relief in relation to whole 200 sq. yards.”

    (underlining added)

    8. The first appellate court has upheld the findings and conclusions of the trial court by similarly observing that the general power of attorney given for consideration could not be cancelled under Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act with the fact that no reasons have been given in the cancellation document dated 6.4.1998 for cancellation of documents dated 11.2.1998 The first appellate court also mentions that the amount of sale consideration is duly mentioned as received in the receipt dated 11.2.1998 executed by the appellant/plaintiff in favour of the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1.

    9. In my opinion, the courts below have rightly held that the cancellation of the documents dated 11.2.1998 by the appellant/plaintiff by the documentation dated 6.4.1998 is of no legal effect. It is required to be noted that transfer of rights in an immovable property is by a contract i.e the same is a bilateral act, and such bilateral contract cannot be cancelled unilaterally i.e by unilateral cancellation of documents by which rights in immovable property are transferred by the transferor to the transferee. The courts below have also rightly placed reliance upon the Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act as also the judgment delivered by this Court in the case of Shri Ramesh Chand v. Suresh Chand, 188 (2012) DLT 538 and which holds that documents which are in accordance with the amended Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and executed prior to 24.9.2001 when by Act 48 of 2001 Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act was amended to require compulsory stamping and registration of an agreement to sell, then such documents prior to 24.9.2001 are valid documents because the amendment to Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act is prospective in nature. Also, this aspect is clearly stated by the Supreme Court in the judgment in the case of Suraj Lamps and Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana, 183 (2011) DLT 1 (SC) wherein the Supreme Court has held that those agreements to sell, power of attorneys and Wills, which are in accordance with Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act and the relevant provisions of the Indian Succession Act, the same will continue to be valid i.e documents executed prior to 24.9.2001 being in accordance with the then existing Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act which did not require stamping and registration of the agreement to sell would be valid documents. The courts below, in my opinion, have also rightly held that the fact that possession was given to the respondent no. 1.defendant no. 1 by the appellant/plaintiff in terms of the documents dated 11.2.1998 shows that the appellant/plaintiff had received the entire sale consideration. I also adopt the other reasoning as given by the courts below showing that complete sale consideration has been duly received by the appellant/plaintiff.

    10. Learned counsel for the appellant/plaintiff during the course of arguments sought to argue a completely new ground, and which does not form part of the pleadings of the appellant/plaintiff in the courts below, and nor was any such issue got framed and hence not decided, that the subject suit was for the entire 200 sq. yards and not for 70 sq. yards only. I asked counsel for the appellant/plaintiff to show me anything in the plaint or any issue framed by the courts below and such an issue is decided that the subject suit is for entire 200 sq. yards and not only for 70 sq. yards, however, no cause of action is found to have been pleaded in the main body of the plaint, and no evidence led on behalf of the appellant/plaintiff, that, the appellant/plaintiff seeks possession not only of 70 sq. yards but of the entire 200 sq. yards. Merely some language in the prayer clause in the plaint will not mean that the cause of action in the plaint could not be read as it is, and which is only with respect to 70 sq. yards and not 200 sq. yards.

    11. A second appeal under Section 100 CPC lies only if there arises a substantial question of law. Arriving at conclusions on the basis of the evidence on record falls in the realm of the jurisdiction of the trial court and the first appellate court, and the same has been validly done by the courts below by rightly holding that bilateral documentation dated 11.2.1998 could not have been unilaterally cancelled by the appellant/plaintiff, more so in view of Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act as also unamended Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act read with the judgment of this Court in the case of Shri Ramesh Chand (supra).

    12. Not only no substantial question of law arises, even a question of law does not arise, and therefore this regular second appeal being devoid of merits, is accordingly dismissed.

    13. The present appeal being clearly an abuse of process of law as the appellant/plaintiff had sold 70 sq. yards to the respondents/defendants, the same is dismissed with costs of Rs. 25,000/- and which costs will be deposited by the appellant/plaintiff to the government website www.bharatkeveer.gov.in within a period of four weeks from today and proof/receipt be filed in this Court within four weeks, failing which appropriate action will be taken by the Court against the appellant/plaintiff and the Registry will list the matter in the Court after four weeks in case the receipt of deposit of costs is not filed in this Court by the appellant/plaintiff.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vimla Devi v. Pushpa Devi And Anr. S
    (May 29, 2017)