Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (hereinafter referred to as the Contract Act). Section 27 of the Contract Act
  • SECTION 27 CONTRACT ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (hereinafter referred to as the Contract Act). Section 27 of the Contract Act
  • SECTION 27 CONTRACT ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present suit was filed seeking permanent and mandatory injunction against infringement or breach of a contract dated 29th September, 2014. The plaintiff alleged misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of trust, delivery up, and claimed damages and rendition of accounts of profits. An ex parte injunction was granted on 23rd December, 2015 restraining defendant no. 1 from breaching the contract or misusing the plaintiff's trade secrets. Subsequently, on 20th October, 2016, defendant no. 1 stated on oath that he had no connection with Skill Educators and had not disobeyed the injunction. Defendant no. 1 later filed an application to vacate the injunction, challenging the validity of Clauses 19 and 22 of the Non-Competition, Confidentiality and Non-Solicitation Agreement dated 29th September, 2014.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Clauses 19 and 22 of the Non-Competition, Confidentiality and Non-Solicitation Agreement are valid and enforceable under Indian law, particularly in light of Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
  2. Whether the injunction restraining defendant no. 1 from competing and soliciting employees post-termination should be maintained or vacated.
  3. The extent to which a negative covenant in an employment contract is enforceable during and after the period of employment.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant no. 1's Arguments

  • Clauses 19 and 22 of the Agreement are void as they violate Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, which renders agreements in restraint of trade void.
  • The defendant has a constitutional right to earn a livelihood using his knowledge and skills, and the injunction causes irreparable harm to his career.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The defendant received special training and was employed in a special capacity, making the impugned clauses legal and valid.
  • Defendant no. 1 is restrained for 24 months post-termination from engaging in similar services as performed during employment.
  • Even if Clause 19 is void, Clause 22 and the defendant's own undertaking not to poach employees or induce third parties remain binding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Niranjan Shankar Golikari v. Century Spinning and Manufacturing Co. Ltd. (1967) 2 S.C.R 378 Negative covenants during employment are not restraint of trade; post-termination restrictive covenants are void under Section 27 of the Contract Act. The Court applied this principle to hold that restrictions during employment are valid but those extending beyond termination are void.
Superintendence Company Of India (P) Ltd. v. Krishan Murgai; (1981) 2 SCC 246 Restrictions during employment are generally valid; post-termination restrictions may be refused if too wide. The Court recognized the difficulty in drafting negative covenants and affirmed that post-termination restrictions may be unenforceable.
Percept D'Mark (India) (P) Ltd. v. Zaheer Khan; (2006) 4 SCC 227 Restrictive covenants extending beyond contract term are void; restraint of trade doctrine applies only post-termination. The Court reiterated that post-termination restrictive covenants violate Section 27 of the Contract Act and are not enforceable.
Gujarat Bottling v. Coca Cola Doctrine of restraint of trade applies to all contracts, not only employment contracts. Used to support the principle that restrictive covenants post-termination are void across contract types.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Clauses 19 and 22 of the Agreement in light of Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, which invalidates agreements restraining lawful trade or profession. It relied on established Supreme Court precedents clarifying that negative covenants during the period of employment are valid as they do not amount to restraint of trade, given the employee's duty of fidelity and receipt of remuneration. However, restrictive covenants extending beyond employment termination are void and unenforceable. Applying these principles, the Court held Clause 19, which restricts the defendant’s post-termination employment activities for 24 months, as void. Conversely, Clause 22, which restricts solicitation of employees and inducement of third parties, was upheld as binding due to the defendant’s personal undertakings and its reasonable scope. The Court balanced the defendant’s right to livelihood with protection of the plaintiff’s legitimate business interests, ensuring only the enforceable restrictions remain effective.

Holding and Implications

The Court vacated the injunction order dated 23rd December, 2015 and disposed of the present interlocutory applications. Clause 19 of the Agreement was declared void as it violates Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act by imposing an unenforceable post-termination restraint on trade. However, the defendant remains bound by Clause 22 and his undertakings not to poach employees or induce third parties to sever or modify their relationship with the plaintiff.

The decision directly affects the parties by lifting the broad post-termination employment restrictions on defendant no. 1 while preserving reasonable restrictive covenants related to solicitation. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling aligns with established Supreme Court jurisprudence on restraint of trade in employment contracts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Eli Research India Pvt. Ltd. v. Deepak Gupta

    Manmohan, J. (Oral)

    I.A Nos. 25684/2015 & 4691/2016

    1. Present suit has been filed for permanent and mandatory injunction against infringement or breach of contract dated 29th September, 2014, misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of trust, delivery up, seeking damages and rendition of accounts of profits.

    2. On 23rd December, 2015, the learned predecessor of this Court by way of an ex parte order in I.A No. 25684/2014 had restrained the defendant no. 1 from breaching the contract/reproducing/incorporating/misappropriating or misusing the trade secret or confidential information/data of the plaintiff company and making the same available in any manner to the members of the public by offering to sell, sale or any other form of communication/issuing to the public thereby amounting to infringement of the plaintiff's rights in any manner.

    3. Subsequently, on 20 October, 2016, learned predecessor of this Court recorded the statement of defendant no. 1 on oath to the effect that he had no concern whatsoever with Skill Educators and that he had not disobeyed the order of injunction dated 23 December, 2015. The statement made by defendant no. 1 on 20 October, 2016 is reproduced hereinbelow:—

    “I am defendant no. 1 in this case. I state that I have no concern whatsoever with Skill Educators. I am neither employed, nor in any manner even remotely concerned with Skill Educators. I further state that I have not disobeyed the order of injunction dated 23.12.2015”

    4. The defendant no. 1 filed an application being I.A No. 4691/2016 for vacating the aforesaid injunction order on the ground that Clauses 19 and 22 of the Non-Competition, Confidentiality and Non-Solicitation Agreement (hereinafter referred to as “the Agreement”) dated 29 September, 2014 are void.

    5. Clauses 19 and 22 of the Agreement are reproduced hereinbelow:—

    “19. Employee agrees and promises that for twenty four (24) months following the termination (whether voluntarily or involuntarily) of Employees employment relationship with Eli Research, the Employee shall not, in India, the Philippines or North America (whether directly or indirectly) own, operate or perform services that are the same or substantially similar to those performed by Employees while employed by Eli Research for any person or entity engaged in a business that a produces, markets, distributes or sells products or services of a similar nature to those developed or commercialized by Eli Research at the time of the termination of Employee's employment.

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    22. Employee agrees and promises that during Employee's employment with Eli Research and for a period of twenty-four (24) months thereafter, Employee shall not directly or indirectly solicit, lure or hire any employee of Eli Research or induce any third party or individual to cease to modify its relationship with the Company or assist or aid in any such activity even if such solicitations are undertaken without the use (which would be impressible) of the Eli Materials.”

    6. Learned senior counsel for defendant no. 1 submits that defendant no. 1 has a constitutional right to earn his livelihood by using his knowledge and skills and if the said injunction is not vacated, it would cause irreparable loss to the career and life of the said defendant. He further submits that Clauses 19 and 22 of the Agreement are null and void being violative of Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (hereinafter referred to as “the Contract Act”). Section 27 of the Contract Act reads as under:—

    “27. Agreement in restraint of trade, void. - Every agreement by which any one is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind, is to that extent void.

    Exception - Saving of agreement not to carry on business of which goodwill is sold. - One who sells the goodwill of a business may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business, within specified local limits, so long as the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill from him, carried on a like business therein, provided that such limits appear to the Court reasonable, regard being had to the nature of the business.”

    7. On the other hand learned counsel for the plaintiff contends that as defendant no. 1 had been given special training and his nature of employment was special, the impugned clauses of the Agreement are legal and valid. Consequently, according to him, the defendant no. 1 for a period of 24 months post-termination can neither own, operate or perform services that are the same or substantially similar to those performed by the employees while employed by the plaintiff.

    8. He further submits that even if it is assumed that Clause 19 of the Agreement is violative of Section 27 of the Contract Act, yet the defendant no. 1 would have to comply with Clause 22 of the said Agreement as well as the defendant no. 1's own undertaking dated 20 October, 2016.

    9. In rejoinder, learned senior counsel for defendant no. 1, on instructions of the said defendant who is personally present in Court, states that he will neither poach any employee of the plaintiff nor induce any third party or individual to cease or modify its relationship with the plaintiff.

    10. The law with regard to negative covenant in employer-employee contract is well-settled. The Supreme Court in Niranjan Shankar Golikari v. Century Spinning and Manufacturing Co. Ltd.; (1967) 2 S.C.R 378 has held that the negative covenant operative during the period of employment when the employee is bound to serve his employer exclusively is not to be regarded as restraint of trade and therefore not violative of Section 27 of the Contract Act. The Supreme Court, however, held that a restrictive covenant extending beyond the term of the contract is void and not enforceable. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced hereinbelow:—

    “The result of the above discussion is that considerations against restrictive covenants are different in cases where the restriction is to apply during the period after the termination of the contract than those in cases where it is to operate during the period of the contract. Negative covenants operative during the period of the contract of employment when the employee is bound to serve his employer exclusively are generally not regarded as restraint of trade and therefore do not fall under Section 27 of the Contract Act. A negative covenant that the employee would not engage himself in a trade or business or would not get himself employed by any other master for whom he would perform similar or substantially similar duties is not therefore a restraint of trade unless the contract as aforesaid is unconscionable or excessively harsh or unreasonable or one sided as in the case of W.H Milsted and Son Ltd., 1927 WN 233 (Supra). Both the Trial Court and the High Court have found, and in our view, rightly, that the negative covenant in the present case restricted as it is to the period of employment and to work similar or substantially similar to the one carried on by the appellant when he was in the employ of the respondent company was reasonable and necessary for the protection of the company's interests and not such as the court would refuse to enforce. There is therefore no validity in the contention that the negative covenant contained in clause 17 amounted to a restraint of trade and was therefore against public policy.”

    11. The Supreme Court in Superintendence Company Of India (P) Ltd. v. Krishan Murgai.; (1981) 2 SCC 246 has also held as under:—

    “58. The drafting of a negative covenant in a contract of employment is often a matter of great difficulty. In the employment cases so far discussed, the issue has been as to the validity of the covenant operating after the end of the period of service. Restrictions on competition during that period are normally valid, and indeed may be implied by law by virtue of the servant's duty of fidelity. In such cases the restriction is generally reasonable, having regard to the interest of the employer, and does not cause any undue hardship to the employee, who will receive a wage or salary for the period in question. But if the covenant is to operate after the termination of services, or is too widely worded, the Court may refuse to enforce it”.

    12. Subsequently, the Supreme Court in Percept D'Mark (India) (P) Ltd. v. Zaheer Khan; (2006) 4 SCC 227 has held as under:—

    “63. Under Section 27 of the Contract Act (a) a restrictive covenant extending beyond the term of the contract is void and not enforceable. (b) The doctrine of restraint of trade does not apply during the continuance of the contract for employment and it applied only when the contract comes to an end. (c) As held by this Court in Gujarat Bottling v. Coca Cola (supra), this doctrine is not confined only to contracts of employment, but is also applicable to all other contracts.”

    13. Consequently, a negative covenant, which bars the employees from doing certain activities during the period of contract is valid but the said restriction post-termination is violative of Section 27 of the Contract Act.

    14. Accordingly, Clause 19 of the Agreement, as it operates in the post-termination phase, is void being violative of Section 27 of the Contract Act. However, the defendant no. 1 is held bound by the undertaking/statement given on 20 October, 2016 as well as the undertaking given today that he would not poach any employee of the plaintiff nor induce any third party or individual to cease or modify its relationship with the plaintiff in accordance with Clause 22 of the Agreement.

    15. With the aforesaid directions and observations, the order dated 23 December, 2015 is vacated and the present I.As stand disposed of.

    CS (OS) 3447/2015 & I.A Nos. 4485/2016, 13603/2016, 422/2017

    16. List the matter before the Joint Registrar on 23 May, 2017, the date already fixed.

    17. List the matter before Court on 07 November, 2017.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Eli Research India Pvt. Ltd. v. Deepak Gupta
    (May 17, 2017)