AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 88, 92 and 370 of the Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 88, 92 and 370 of the Indian Penal Code
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Pankaj Singh Chouhan v. Dr. Sushila Tiwari Memorial Forest Hospital

    NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION

    NEW DELHI

    REVISION PETITION NO. 1332 OF 2016

    (Against the Order dated 29/02/2016 in Appeal No. 421/2007 of the State Commission Uttaranchal)

    1. PANKAJ SINGH CHOUHAN

    S/O SH. SURAJ SINGH CHAUHAN, R/O DEVNATH

    LODGE, ASHADAIE, COMPOUND, MALLITAL,

    NAINITAL

    UTTARAKHAND ...........Petitioner(s) Versus

    1. DR. SUSHILA TIWARI MEMORIAL FOREST

    HOSPITAL & 2 ORS.

    THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, HALDWANI,

    DISTRICT-NANITAL

    UTTARAKHAND

    2. DR. ASHOK KUMAR MD(MEDICINE)

    DR. SUSHILA TIWARI MEMORIAL FOREST HOSPITAL,

    HALDWANI,

    DISTRICT-NANITAL

    UTTARAKHAND

    3. NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.

    THROUGH ITS BRANCH MANAGER, NANITAL ROAD,

    HALDWANI

    DISTRICT-NANITAL UTTARAKHAND ...........Respondent(s)

    BEFORE:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J.M. MALIK, PRESIDING MEMBER HON'BLE DR. S.M. KANTIKAR, MEMBER

    For the Petitioner : Mr. Anil K. Sharma, Advocate For the Respondent :

    Dated : 18 May 2016

    ORDER

    DR. S.M. KANTIKAR, MEMBER

    1. The complainant, Pankaj Singh Chauhan's mother, Bhagwati Devi (hereinafter referred to as "patient" since deceased), was admitted on 04-02-2006, in Dr. Sushila Tiwari Memorial Forest Hospital (in short, STMFH) i.e. OP1. She was discharged on 07-02-2006 at the request of complainant. Thereafter, she was treated by Dr. Ram Sharma, a Neurophysician at Shri Ram Murti Smarak Institute of Medical Sciences, Bareilly, from 08-02-2006, till she breathed her last, on 24-02-2006. Therefore, alleging medical negligence on the part of the OPs 1&2, the complainant filed a consumer complaint before the Nainital District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum (in short, the District Forum) and prayed for compensation of Rs.15,00,000/-.

    1

    2. The District Forum allowed the complaint and directed the OPs to pay compensation of Rs.2,00,000/- with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of this complaint and Rs.1,500/- towards litigation charges, however, dismissed the complaint against the insurance company.

    3. Aggrieved by the order of the District Forum the OPs 1&2 filed first appeal before the Uttarakhand State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (in short the State Commission). The State Commission allowed the first appeal and dismissed the complaint.

    4. Hence, this revision petition.

    5. We have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner/complainant at the admission stage. He vehemently argued that, the doctor-OP1 was not a neurologist. It was a case of neurology; OP2 failed to diagnose the neurological condition and had not treated the patient properly. The patient was kept unnecessarily in the OP-1 hospital from 04-02-2006 to 07-02-2006, without proper treatment. Hence, it was negligence on the part of the OPs.

    6. We have perused the evidence adduced before the District Forum and the State Commission. The State Commission observed that, the OP-2 was on emergency duty. The patient was admitted on 04-02-2006 at 4:27 P.M. as an emergency. At the time of admission, patient had high blood pressure of 220/110 mm of Hg. She was diabetic, type II. OP-2 advised ECG and CT scan. After examination of the patient, it was found that there was blood clotting in various places of the brain of the patient. Therefore, treatment was started accordingly with higher antibiotic, anti-convulsant drugs. The BP and Blood sugar levels improved. Therefore, after improvement in the condition of the patient, she was discharged from the hospital, on 07- 02-2006 at the request of complainant. Thereafter, the patient was taken to SRMS Medical Institute, Bareilly by the complainant himself and the death of the patient occurred, on 24-02- 2006 i.e. after 16 days.

    7. It is pertinent to note that, at SRMS Medical Institute, it was diagnosed as Herpes Simplex Encephalitis. As per medical text, the condition is clinically difficult to diagnose. In the instant case, it was diagnosed by (Polymerase Chain Reaction) PCR study. OP-2, Dr Ashok Kumar is a Physician, qualified as M.D. Medicine, he can treat the medical conditions. He attended, the said patient in 'emergency', as per standard norms. On the basis of ECG, CT scan and other tests, it was clear that due to uncontrolled blood pressure and diabetes of the patient, the possibility of brain fever was expressed and advised CSF study also. On 5.2.2006, the patient gave permission to conduct CSF study. CSF report suggested possibility of viral encephalitis and it was discussed with the relatives of patient and advised them to take the patient to a higher neurology centre. Therefore, with the consent of relatives of patient, the patient was discharged on 7.2.2006.The complainant failed to prove his case, not produced any expert opinion to show that the treatment given by the OP-2 was wrong or it further deteriorated the condition of patient. Therefore, we do not find any deliration in the duty of care or negligence on the part of OP-2.

    8. Also in this case, the complainant has not produced any cogent and reliable evidence to substantiate his claim of medical negligence. The counsel relied upon the Jacob Mathews Case (2005) 6 SCC 1 and quoted reference from paras No. 19 and 20 of the judgment, but we are not convinced with his argument. It is settled principle that, "No Cure is Not a

    2

    Negligence". The doctor should not be punished for, if anything goes wrong. In a catena of judgments, Hon'ble Supreme Court discussed about what constitutes medical negligence? In

    Martin D'souza VS. Mohd. Isfaq (2009) 3 SCC 1, Hon'ble Apex Court held that; The standard of care has to be judged in the light of knowledge available at the time of the incident and not at the date of the trial. Also, where the charge of negligence is of failure to use some particular equipment, the charge would fail if the equipment was not generally available at that point of time.

    When a patient dies or suffers some mishap, there is a tendency to blame the doctor for this. Things have gone wrong and, therefore, somebody must be punished for it. However, it is well known that even the best professionals, what to say of the average professional, sometimes have failures. A lawyer cannot win every case in his professional career but surely he cannot be penalized for losing a case provided he appeared in it and made his submissions.

    Similar view was taken in the case of Kusum Sharma & Others vs Batra Hospital & Medical Research Centre and others, AIR 2010 SC 1050, wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as;

    81. It is a matter of common knowledge that after happening of some unfortunate event, there is a marked tendency to look for a human factor to blame for an untoward event, a tendency which is closely linked with the desire to punish. Things have gone wrong and, therefore, somebody must be found to answer for it. A professional deserves total protection. The Indian Penal Code has taken care to ensure that people who act in good faith should not be punished. Sections 88, 92 and 370 of the Indian Penal Code give adequate protection to the professional and particularly medical professionals.

    9. Therefore, on the basis of forgoing discussion, we do not find any merit in this revision, it is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    ......................J

    J.M. MALIK

    PRESIDING MEMBER

    ......................

    DR. S.M. KANTIKAR

    MEMBER

    3

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pankaj Singh Chouhan v. Dr. Sushila Tiwari Memorial Forest Hospital
    (May 18, 2016)