AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 12 of C.P. Act 1986.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 12 of C.P. Act 1986.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    P.MallaReddy S/o Maraiah, Rebbena. v. Agricultural Insurance Co.of India Ltd.

    Order Pronounced by Sri.D.Chiranjeevi Babu, President :- This complaint is filed under section 12 of C.P. Act 1986. The brief facts of complaint are as follows:

    1. The complainant is the owner, possessor and Pattadar of the land in Sy.No.27/A, to an extent Acres 7.30 guntas (paddy crop) situated at Kistapur village Mandal Rebbena, Dist.Adilabad. The complainant has taken Agricultural Insurance Policy for paddy from the Op.No.1/company for the above said crop land and paid premium Rs.2,125/- for value of Rs.85,000/- for Karif Season, 2009 and Op/company issued Policy receipt no.102165, dt.22.09.2009. During Kariff Season 2009 due to non fallen of rains that crop was dried, the complainant lost his entire crop. The Mandal Agricultural Officer, has assessed loss of crop and issued a certificate by showing loss of crop during Kariff Season 2009, the complainant issued notice to Op.No.1 along with all relevant documents claiming Rs.85,000/-, on that the Op.no.1 given reply stating that claim settlement is under process in the month of January 2010 but till today the Op.no.1 has not settled claim. The Op has insured the above said crop for Kareef Season 2009, hence Op.no.1/company is liable to pay compensation to the complainant for an amount of Rs.85,000/-. The complainant issued a legal notice to Op.1/company to pay an amount of Rs.85,000/- loss caused to him, but the Op.no.1 has not settled claim. The Opp.Party no.2 is the Mandal Agricultural Officer and Opp.Party no.3 to 5 are District Authority to send the particulars of crops data to Opp.Party no.1/company, but till today that process was not completed. That the Opp.Party no.1 depending on the yield data of District Collector Office and dispatching authority District Departments, hence all the Ops are liable to pay compensation for deficiency in service. The complainant prayed this forum to direct the Opp.Parties as below:

    a). To pay an amount of Rs.85,000/- towards loss caused to complainant.

    b). To pay interest @ 18% p.a. from the date of loss caused to complainant on Rs.85,000/-.

    c). To direct the Opp.Party no.1 to pay an amount of Rs.25,000/- towards mental agony, pain and suffering to complainant.

    d). To direct the Ops no.2 to 5 to pay Rs.25,000/- towards compensation to complainant.

    e). To pass any other order or orders in favour of complainant as the Honble forum deems fir and proper under the circumstances of the case.

    2. The Opp.Party no.1 contested the petition and filed counter. The contents of counter is as follows:- The Opp.Party no.1 in his counter submitted that they have issued reply to the legal notice stating the claims under NAIS are calculated basing on the yield data conducted by Director of Economics and Statistics and not on the declaration of insured farmers or any other such thing. The complainant seeks compensation for the loss based on the certificate issued by MAO, Rebbena. The complainant further submits that the insurance scheme of the complainant is country wide crop insurance formulated by Government of India and with active co ordination of State Government department and Financial Institutions. As per the scheme State level Coordination Committee is constituted which notifies crops, areas and also over sees the implementation of the scheme. The Opp.Party also submits that the National Agricultural Insurance Scheme operates an Area Approach basis. The Central Government in the said insurance scheme has dealt with the farmers adopted the broad principle of equity of group basis to provide compensation on the basis of average production in defined area. The Opp.Party further submits that under the scheme for particular notified crop and notified area guarantee yield is fixed on the basis of past three to five years average yield data complied by Directorate of Economics and statistics through crop cutting experiments multiplied by applicable level of indemnity for the crop. If the actual yield for the notified crop is less than the guarantee yield fixed for the area then all the concerned farmers insured for the eligible for compensation. The compensation is calculated as per the below formula. CLAIMS PAYABLE = Short fall in Yield

    ------------------------ X Sum Insured Threshold yield (Where the Shortfall in yield = Threshold yield Actual yield) In the year 2009 for Kareef season the Opp.Party received two proposals from Non Loanee farmers for paddy crop from Rebbena Mandal. The guarantee yield for paddy crop in Rebbena Mandal for kareef 2009 is 1467 kgs per hectares and the actual yield is 1346 kgs per hectares and accordingly the Opp.Parties settled the claim of the two farmers in the above mentioned formula. Thus the claim on the sum insured also has been settled to complainant for Rs.9,335/- and Rs.7013/- to the other farmers. It is submitted that the compensation sought by the complainant is highly illogical, inflated, exaggerated and fanciful. The Government notification G.O., Rt.No.655, dt.12th June 2009 issued with respect to NAIS during Kareef season 2009 also clearly stipulated on the front page no.1 that the claims under National Agricultural Insurance Scheme (NAIS) shall be settled on the basis of yield furnished by the Director Economics and Statistics for the notified crops and Districts and not on the basis of Annavari Certificate/Gazette notification declaring the areas as drought/flood/cyclone affected etc., by the District Collectors and it is already stated in the scheme and Guidelines for implementation of NAIS booklet in page no.22 para 21 that except for Directorate of Economics and Statistics yield data no other yield data is accepted for finalization of crop insurance claims. The Opp.Party no.1 prayed this forum to dismiss the complaint. The Opp.Parties no. 2 to 5 contested the petition and filed counter. The contents of counter are as follows: It is true that as per the Pahanies the complainant is the owner, pattedar and possessor of the lands mentioned in the complaint. It is true that the complainant has sown paddy crop in the said lands during the year 2009-2010. That regarding the payment of premium paid to the Opp.Party no.1 for coverage of the crops sown by the complainant it is the Op.No.1 to reply about this contents. It is true that the Op.No.2 has issued a certificate that due to drought the paddy crop of the complainant in the said lands as dried up. That these Ops are not aware about the complainant claiming the insurance amount from the Op.No.1. The Opp.Parties are not concerned with the contents of Para no.2&3 and it is the Op.No.1 who has reply about the contents. Regarding the contents of para no.4 these Opp.Parties submit that the Joint Director, Director of Economics and Statistics, Govt. of A.P. has submitted the average yield of Adilabad and basing on this and basing on the notification by Government dt.12.06.2009 the Op.no.1 has calculated the sum which the complainant is entitled as per the average yield and threshold yield gave the amount of the shortfall yield to the complainant. The contention of the complainant that these Ops are liable to pay the compensation is without any basis and they are in no way concerned with the insurance claim by the complainant. The issue is between the complainant and Op.no.1 as such these Ops are not necessary parties for this complaint. As such the complainant is not maintainable against these Ops and the complainant is liable to pay compensation to these Ops for making them parties to this complainant. The Opp.Parties no.2 to 5 prayed this forum to dismiss the complaint.

    3. The Opp.Party no.1 filed memo to treat the contents of counter as Proof Affidavit. The Opp.Party no.2 to 5 filed memo to treat the contents of counter as Proof Affidavit.

    4. On behalf of complainant Ex.A1 to A9 are marked. Ex.B1 to Ex.B7 are marked on behalf of Opp.Parties.

    5. Now the point for consideration is whether there is any deficiency on the part of the Ops, if so, whether the complainant is entitled to get an amount of Rs.85,000/-, interest @ 18% p.a. from the date of loss caused to Rs.85,000/- and directed the Op.1 to pay an amount of Rs.25,000/- towards mental agony, pain and suffering and further an amount of Rs.25,000/- compensation by Opp.Party no.2 to 5 and with cost.

    6. After arguments of the both side counsels our reasons are like this: The case of the complainant is that he is owner of the land Sy.No.27/A, at Kistapur village. He has obtained agricultural insurance policy for paddy and paid premium of Rs.2,125/- for value of Rs.85,000/-. The Opp.Party issued policy receipt no.102165, dt.22.09.2009 during the Kareef season 2009 due to sufficient rains the crop was dried up and the Mandal Agricultural Officer, Rebbena has issued the certificate for the loss. Thereafter the complainant issued legal notice to the Opp.Parties, but the Opp.Party issued reply notice but they have not paid require amount by the complainant, then he filed this case before this forum for the above prayer.

    7. The counter filed by the Opp.Party no.1 as well as Opp.Party no. 2 to 5 that they denied allegations of the complaint and further Opp.Party no.1 stated that there is a long process for estimation of the crop sustained loss by the complainant and for that Government as passed G.Os on that and they have calculated and they will pay the amount. Mere certificate issued by the M.A.O., Rebbena, the complainant is not entitled to get anything. The Opp.Party no.2 to

    5 they also submitted that the complainant is not entitled to get anything and it is in between complaint and Opp.Party no.1 and they requested this forum to dismiss the case.

    8. Now this forum has to see, whether the complainant is entitled as prayed for and the certificate issued by the MAO, is valid one?

    9. In this case as per Ex.A8 this is certificate issued by the Mandal Agricultural Officer, Rebbena stating that this is to certify that Sri.Puppi Reddy Malla Reddy, S/o.Maraiah, R/o.Kistapur having 7.30 Acres in 27/A Sy.No. in which paddy crop is transplanted due to the drought the crop is dried up. Hence certified. This certificate is valid one or not? For this our answer is that the certificate is Ex.A8 is not at all valid. For estimation and calculating of the loss of crop there is a big procedure. The calculation calculated by the Government i.e., claims under NAIS are calculated passed on final yield data has obtained on the basis of crop cutting experiments conducted by Director of Economics and Statistics of A.P. and not on the basis of Annawari certificate are insured farmers declaration/intimation of loss or Gazette Notification declaring certain areas as drought fund etc. In this case the National Agricultural Insurance Scheme conducted the entire thing i.e. as per Ex.B1 and as well as Ex.B2 the Government passed G.O., dt.12.06.2000. As per Government orders only the government has to calculated the loss estimated the crop of the complainant and there is one method is there for calculation of the crop CLAIMS PAYABLE = Short fall in Yield

    ------------------------ X Sum Insured Threshold yield (Where the Shortfall in yield = Threshold yield Actual yield) So the Government has to calculate the loss the estimation of the crop like this only. If anybody gives certificate is not at all valid and further as Ex.B6 the claims under National Agricultural Insurance Scheme was to be settled on the basis of the yield data furnished by the Directors of Economics and Statistics for the notified crop and district and not on the basis of Annawari certificate/Gazette notification declaring area/flood/cyclone affected etc by the District Collector. Mere on the basis of the certificated issued by the M.A.O., the complainant is not entitled to get anything.

    10. Ex.B7 letter issued by the MAO, Rebbena, who issued the certificate i.e., Ex.A8 he stated that he addressed a letter to the D.G.M. National Agricultural Insurance Company Ltd, Hyderabad stating that this certificate is given on the request of the farmer and it has no relevant for payment of crop insurance compensation. The NAIS is area basis scheme and the claim will be settled based on the results of CC experiments conducted by Director of Economics and Statistics and the yield data provide mandal wise by said department Government of A.P. No further methodology will be considered for payment of crop insurance scheme. The certificate issued for Kareef 2009 on the request of the farmer. So this Ex.B7 clearly goes to show that at the request of the farmer Ex.A8 is granted in filing of complaint. But the certificate Ex.A8 is not at all valid for the complainant. On the basis of Ex.A8 the complainant is not entitled to get anything, because we already stated supra the Government given so many G.O.s i.e., Ex.B1,B2, B3 and Ex.B6, they clearly goes to show how to assess and how to calculate the crop of the Kareef season during the year 2009. On the basis of Ex.A6 the complainant is not entitled to get anything. We accept Ex.B7, Ex.B1 to B6 and come to conclusion that how to calculate the crop estimation for the loss of the yield the Government has to do and they will calculate the same and give loss to the complainant. In this case already the government calculated loss assessment of the crop and gave it to the complainant. Mere on the basis of Ex.A6 the complainant is not entitled to get anything.

    11. For the foregoing reasons given by us we see no grounds to allow the petition and there is no deficiency on the part of the Ops 1 to 5. The first point is decided in favour of Opp.Parties against complainant. Point no.2: the first point is decided in favour of Ops against complainant, this point is also decided in favour of Ops against the complainant.

    12. In the result the complaint is dismissed without costs. Dictated to Steno, transcribed by her, corrected by us and pronounced in the Open Forum on the 3 day of September 2012. MEMBER PRESIDENT Appendix of Evidence Witnesses Examined -None- -None- Exhibits Marked ON BEHALF OF COMPLAINANT ON BEHALF OF OPP. PARTY Ex.A1: Original copy of NAIS receipt no.102165, dt.22.09.2009. Ex.B1: Photo copy of National Agricultural Insurance Scheme and Guidelines. Ex.A2: Original Pahani for the year 2009-2010. Ex.B2: Copy of G.O.Ms.No.142, dt.12.06.2000 of NAIS. Ex.A3: Photo copy of Letter dt.25.01.2010 issued by Opp.Party no.1. Ex.B3: Copy of letter dt.13.01.2011 issued by Agricultural Insurance Company of India Ltd along with Postal receipt, DD and Statement of Agricultural Insurance Co.Hyd. Ex.A4: Postal Receipt along with Acknowledgement card. Ex.B4: Copy of Yield Data issued by Agricultural Insurance Company of ltd. Ex.A5: Copy of National Agricultural Insurance Scheme. Ex.B5: Copy of Letter dt.31.03.2010 to Op.No.1. Ex.A6: Copy of Crop and area sown confirmation certificate. Ex.B6: Copy of Andhra Pradesh Gazette, dt. June 16 2009 of Agriculture & Co-Operation Department. Ex.A7: Photo copy of Demand Draft dt.12.09.2009 for Rs.2125/-. Ex.B7: Attested copy of letter to National Agricultural Insurance Co. Ltd, Hyderabad from MAO, Rebbena. Ex.A8: Copy of Certificate dt.14.12.2009. Ex.A9: Copy of Notification by the District Collector dt.05.10.2009. MEMBER PRESIDENT

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P.MallaReddy S/o Maraiah, Rebbena. v. Agricultural Insurance Co.of India Ltd.
    (Sep 3, 2012)